Fraser and Wilcox [1979 Nature (London)281 565–566] devised a series of complex stationary patterns that provoked episodes of compelling illusory motion, but only in about two-thirds of people tested. Using simplified versions of their stimuli, we have confirmed their claim of perceptual dimorphism. We show that the strength of the illusory motion depends upon stimulus duration, eccentricity, and contrast. The illusory motion does not require fluctuations in accommodation, as has been suggested for some other forms of illusory motion. Finally, we consider the relation of Fraser-type motion to other forms of illusory motion.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AnstisS MRogersB J, 1986“Illusory continuous motion from oscillating positive – negative patterns: Implications for motion perception”Perception15627–640
2.
BülthoffHGötzK G, 1979“Analogous motion illusion in man and fly”Nature (London)278636–638
3.
CharmanW NHeronG, 1988“Fluctuations in accommodation: A review”Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics8153–164
4.
DerringtonA MGoddardP A, 1989“Failure of motion discrimination at high contrasts: Evidence for saturation”Vision Research291767–1776
5.
EdwardsMBadcockD RNishidaS, 1996“Contrast sensitivity of the motion system”Vision Research362411–2422
6.
FestaE KWelchL, 1997“Recruitment mechanisms in speed and fine direction discrimination tasks”Vision Research373129–3143
7.
FraserAWilcoxK, 1979“Perception of illusory movement”Nature (London)281565–566
8.
GregoryR L, 1993“A comment: Mackay Rays shimmer due to accommodation changes”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B253123
9.
HineT JCookMRogersG T, 1995“An illusion of relative motion dependent upon spatial frequency and orientation”Vision Research353093–3102
10.
HineT JCookMRogersG T, 1997“The Ouchi illusion: An anomaly in the perception of rigid motion for limited spatial frequencies and angles”Perception & Psychophysics59448–455
11.
HolzmanP S, 1989“The use of eye movement dysfunctions in exploring the genetic transmission of schizophrenia”European Archives of Psychiatry and Neurological Science23943–48
12.
HunterW S, 1915“Regional factors in visual after-movement”Psychological Review22479–489
13.
KeckM JPalellaT DPantleA, 1976“Motion aftereffect as a function of the contrast of sinusoidal gratings”Vision Research16187–191
14.
LeguireL EBlakeR, 1982“Role of threshold in afterimage visibility”Journal of the Optical Society of America721232–1237
15.
LeviantI, 1996“Does ‘brain power’ make Enigma spin?”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B263997–1001
16.
LevyD LHolzmanP SMatthysseSMendellN R, 1994“Eye tracking and schizophrenia: A selective review”Schizophrenia Bulletin2047–62
17.
MacKayD, 1961“Interactive processes in visual perception”, in Sensory Communication Ed. RosenblithW A (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press) pp 339–355
18.
McKeeS PWelchL, 1985“Sequential recruitment in the discrimination of velocity”Journal of the Optical Society of America A2243–251
19.
MatherG, 1984“Luminance change generates apparent movement: Implications for models of directional specificity in the human visual system”Vision Research241399–1405
20.
NishidaSAshidaHSatoT, 1997“Contrast dependencies of two types of motion aftereffect”Vision Research37553–563
21.
OhtaniYIdoKEjimaY, 1995“Effects of luminance contrast and phase difference on motion assimilation for sinusoidal gratings”Vision Research352277–2286
22.
RaymondJ EDarcangeloS M, 1990“The effect of local luminance contrast on induced motion”Vision Research30751–756
23.
SalzmanC DNewsomeW T, 1994“Neural mechanisms for forming a perceptual decision”Science264231–237
24.
SekulerR, 1996“Motion perception: A modern view of Wertheimer's 1912 monograph”Perception251243–1258
25.
SnowdenR JHessR FWaughS J, 1995“The processing of temporal modulation at different levels of retinal illuminance”Vision Research35775–789
26.
ThompsonP, 1983“Discrimination of moving gratings at and above detection threshold”Vision Research231533–1538
27.
TootellR BHamiltonS LSwitkesE, 1988“Functional anatomy of macaque striate cortex. IV: Contrast and magno-parvo streams”Journal of Neuroscience81594–1609
28.
WadeN J, 1977“Distortions and disappearances of geometrical patterns”Perception6407–433
29.
WadeN J, 1995“Portraits of artists and scientists”, in The Artful Eye Eds GregoryRHarrisJHeardPRoseD (Oxford: Oxford University Press) pp 399–425
30.
WatsonA BRobsonJ G, 1981“Discrimination of moving gratings at and above detection threshold”Vision Research211115–1122
ZekiS, 1995“Phenomenal motion seen through artificial intra-ocular lenses”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B260165–166
33.
ZekiSWatsonJ D GFrackowiakR S, 1993“Going beyond the information given: The relation of illusory visual motion to brain activity”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B252215–222
