In six experiments we demonstrate that the vertical–horizontal illusion that is evoked when viewing photographs and line drawings is relatively small, whereas the magnitude of this illusion when large objects are viewed is at least twice as great. Furthermore, we show that the illusion is due more to vertical overestimation than horizontal underestimation. The lack of a difference in vertical overestimation between pictures and line drawings suggests that vertical overestimation in pictures depends solely on the perceived physical size of the projection on the picture surface, rather than on what is apparent about an object's represented size. The vertical–horizontal illusion is influenced by perceived physical size. It is greater when viewing large objects than small pictures of these same objects, even when visual angles are equated.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersonJ M, 1970“A television aid to design presentation”Architectural Research and Teaching1(2) 20–24
2.
AndersonJ M, 1972“Simulating architecture”The Architects' Journal61325–1329
3.
AveryG CDayR H, 1969“Basis of the horizontal–vertical illusion”Journal of Experimental Psychology81376–380
4.
BegelmanD ASteinfeldG, 1967“An investigation of several parameters of the horizontal – vertical illusion”Perception & Psychophysics2539–543
5.
BhallaMProffittD R, 1999“Visual-motor recalibration in geographical slant”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance (in press)
6.
BoringE G, 1942Sensation and Perception in the History of Vision (New York: E P Dutton)
7.
ChapanisAMankinD A, 1967“The vertical – horizontal illusion in a visually-rich environment”Perception & Psychophysics2249–255
8.
ChingF, 1996Architectural Graphics (New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold)
9.
CorenSGirgusJ S, 1978Seeing is Deceiving: The Psychology of Visual Illusions (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates)
10.
DixonM WWragaMProffittD RWilliamsG C, in press “Eye height scaling of absolute size in immersive and nonimmersive environments”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance
11.
FingerF WSpeltD K, 1947“The illustration of the horizontal – vertical illusion”Journal of Experimental Psychology37243–250
12.
GibsonJ J, 1971“The information available in pictures”Leonardo427–35
13.
HigashiyamaA, 1996“Horizontal and vertical distance perception: The discorded-orientation theory”Perception & Psychophysics58259–270
14.
HigashiyamaAUeyamaE, 1988“The perception of vertical and horizontal distances in outdoor settings”Perception & Psychophysics44151–156
15.
HouckR LMefferdR BJrGreensteinG J, 1972“Influence of a visual frame and vertical–horizontal illusion on shape and size perception”Journal of Experimental Psychology96273–279
16.
HowardI PTempletonW B, 1966Human Spatial Orientation (New York: John Wiley)
17.
KünnapasT M, 1955“An analysis of the ‘vertical–horizontal illusion’”Journal of Experimental Psychology49134–139
18.
KünnapasT M, 1957a“Vertical – horizontal illusion and surrounding field”Acta Psychologica1335–42
19.
KünnapasT M, 1957b“The vertical – horizontal illusion and the visual field”Journal of Experimental Psychology53405–407
20.
KünnapasT M, 1958“Influence of head inclination on the vertical – horizontal illusion”Journal of Psychology46179–185
21.
KünnapasT M, 1959“The vertical – horizontal illusion in artificial visual fields”Journal of Psychology4741–48
22.
LiangJShawCGreenM, 1991“On temporal – spatial realism in the virtual reality environment”, in Proceedings of the ACM SIGGRAPH Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology (Hilton Head, SC: Association for Computing) pp 19–25
23.
PearceDMatinL, 1969“Variation of the magnitude of the horizontal – vertical illusion with retinal eccentricity”Perception & Psychophysics6241–243
24.
PirenneM H, 1970Optics, Painting and Photography (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
25.
PorterT, 1979How Architects Visualize (New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold)
26.
PrinzmetalWGettlemanL, 1993“Vertical – horizontal illusion: One eye is better than two”Perception & Psychophysics5381–88
27.
SchiffmanH RThompsonJ G, 1975“The role of figure orientation and apparent depth in the perception of the horizontal – vertical illusion”Perception479–83
28.
ThompsonJ GSchiffmanH R, 1974“The influence of figure size and orientation on the magnitude of the horizontal – vertical illusion”Acta Psychologica38413–420
29.
ToyeR C, 1986“The effect of viewing position on the perceived layout of space”Perception & Psychophysics4085–92
30.
Von CollaniG, 1985a“The horizontal–vertical illusion in photographs of concrete scenes with and without depth information”Perceptual and Motor Skills61523–531
31.
Von CollaniG, 1985b“Retinal projection or size constancy as determinants of the horizontal–vertical illusion”Perceptual and Motor Skills61547–557
32.
WagnerM, 1985“The metric of visual space”Perception & Psychophysics38483–495
