It is widely reported that a picture of an angry face seems to figuratively pop out of an array of happy faces, although all of these reports are based on a single experiment by Hansen and Hansen. Pop out, when it occurs, indicates that an observer has located the target by means of a preattentive, parallel search. Hansen and Hansen concluded that it was the affect displayed by the face which caused it to pop out from its surrounding distracters. However, Hansen and Hansen's angry faces contained extraneous dark areas which were introduced when they transformed Ekman and Friesen's photographs of angry and happy faces into black-on-white sketches. When the original artifact-free gray-scaled versions of angry and happy faces were used no evidence for pop out was found. All target faces were found during a serial, self-terminating search regardless of their expression. The angry face in Hansen and Hansen's experiments may have popped out from a crowd of happy faces because of a contrast artifact inadvertently introduced when they created their stimuli.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmbadyNRosenthalR, 1992“Thin slices of behavior as predictors of interpersonal consequences: A meta-analysis”Psychological Bulletin111256–274
2.
AronoffJWoikeB AHymanL M, 1992“Which are the stimuli in facial displays of anger and happiness? Configurational bases of emotion recognition”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology621050–1066
3.
BarghJ A, 1989“Conditional automaticity: Varieties of automatic influence in social perception and cognition”, in Unintended Thought Eds UlemanJ SBarghJ A, (New York: Guildford Press) pp 3–51
4.
BaronR AByrneD, 1991Psychology: Understanding Human Interaction6th edition (Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon)
5.
BoucherJ YCarlsonG E, 1980“Recognition of facial expression in three cultures”Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology11263–280
6.
BowersDBauerR MCoslettH B, 1985“Processing of faces by patients with unilateral hemisphere lesions”Brain and Cognition4258–272
7.
BrehmS SKassinS M, 1993Social Psychology2nd edition (Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin)
8.
BrunerJ, 1994“The view from the heart's eye: A commentary”, in The Heart's Eye: Emotional Influences in Perception and Attention Eds NiedenthalP MKitayamaS, (New York: Academic Press) pp 269–286
9.
ByrneAEysenckM W, 1995“Trait anxiety, anxious mood, and threat detection”Cognition and Emotion9549–562
10.
CohenJ, 1992“A power primer”Psychological Bulletin112155–159
11.
CorenSRussellJ A, 1992“The relative dominance of different facial expressions of emotion under conditions of perceptual ambiguity”Cognition and Emotion6339–356
12.
DayD VCrainE C, 1992“The role of affect and ability in initial exchange quality perceptions”Group and Organizational Management17380–397
13.
EgethH, 1994“Emotion and the eyewitness”, in The Heart's Eye: Emotional Influences in Perception and Attention Eds NiedenthalP MKitayamaS, (New York: Academic Press) pp 245–267
14.
EkmanPFriesenW V, 1976The Pictures of Facial Affect copy available from Paul Ekman, University of California, 401 Parnassus Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94143
15.
EnnsJ TOchsE PRensinkR A, 1990“VSearch: Macintosh software for experiments in visual search”Behavior Research Methods, Instruments and Computers22118–122
16.
EnnsJ TRensinkR A, 1991“VSearch Color: Full-color visual search experiments on the Macintosh II”Behavior Research Methods, Instruments and Computers23265–272
17.
EstevesFParraCDimbergUOhmanA, 1994“Nonconscious associative learning: Pavlovian conditioning of skin conductance responses to masked fear-relevant facial stimuli”Psychophysiology31375–385
18.
FazioR HRoskos-EwoldsonD RPowellM, 1994“Attitudes, perception, and attention”, in The Heart's Eye: Emotional Influences in Perception and Attention Eds NiedenthalP MKitayamaS, (New York: Academic Press) pp 197–216
19.
FiskeS TTaylorS E, 1991Social Cognition2nd edition (New York: McGraw Hill)
20.
FranzoiS L, 1996Social Psychology (Madison, WI: Brown and Benchmark)
21.
von GrünauMAnstonC, 1995“The detection of gaze direction: A stare-in-the-crowd effect”Perception241297–1313
22.
HamptonCPurcellD GBersineLHansenC HHansenR D, 1989“Probing ‘pop-out’: Another look at the face-in-the-crowd effect”Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society27563–566
23.
HansenC HHansenR D, 1988“Finding the face in the crowd: An anger superiority effect”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology54917–924
24.
HansenC HHansenR D, 1994“Automatic emotion: Attention and facial efference”, in The Heart's Eye: Emotional Influences in Perception and Attention Eds NiedenthalP MKitayamaS, (New York: Academic Press) pp 217–243
25.
HarrisonD WGorelczenkoP MCookJ, 1990“Sex differences in the functional asymmetry for facial affect perception”International Journal of Neuroscience5211–16
26.
IsenA MDiamondG A, 1989“Affect and automaticity”, in Unintended Thought Eds UlemanJ SBarghJ A, (New York: Guildford Press) pp 124–152
27.
IzardC E, 1993“Four systems for emotional activation: Cognitive and noncognitive processes”Psychological Review10068–90
28.
KenrickI, 1994“Evolutionary social psychology: From sexual selection to social cognition”Advances in Experimental Social Psychology2675–121
29.
KenrickINeubergS LZierkK LKronesJ M, 1994“Evolution and social cognition: Contrast effects as a function of sex, dominance, and physical attractiveness”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin20210–217
30.
KirouacGDoreF Y, 1984“Judgment of facial expressions of emotion as a function of exposure time”Perceptual and Motor Skills59147–150
31.
KirouacGDoreF Y, 1985“Accuracy of the judgment of facial expression of emotions as a function of sex and level of education”Journal of Nonverbal Behavior93–7
32.
KitayamaSHowardS, 1994“Affective regulation of perception and comprehension: Amplification and semantic priming”, in The Heart's Eye: Emotional Influences in Perception and Attention Eds NiedenthalP MKitayamaS, (New York: Academic Press) pp 41–65
33.
KuehnS MJolicoeurP, 1994“Impact of quality of the image, orientation, and similarity of the stimuli on visual search for faces”Perception2395–122
34.
LandauT, 1989About Faces (Garden City, NY: Anchor Books)
35.
LeyR GBrydenM P, 1979“Hemispheric differences in processing emotions and faces”Brain and Language7127–138
36.
McAndrewF T, 1986“A cross-cultural study of recognition thresholds for facial expressions of emotion”Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology17211–224
37.
MandalM KPalchoudhuryS, 1985“Perceptual skill in decoding facial affect”Perceptual and Motor Skills6096–98
38.
MyersD G, 1995Psychology4th edition (New York: Worth)
39.
NiedenthalP M, 1990“Implicit perception of affective information”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology26505–527
40.
NiedenthalP M, 1992“Affect and social perception: On the psychological validity of rose-colored glasses”, in Perception Without Awareness Eds BornsteinR FPittmanT S, (New York: Guildford Press) pp 211–235
41.
NiedenthalP MKitayamaS, (Eds), 1994The Heart's Eye: Emotional Influences in Perception and Attention (New York: Academic Press)
42.
NiedenthalP MSetterlundM B, 1994“Emotional congruence in perception”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin20401–411
43.
NothdurftH C, 1993“Faces and facial expressions do not pop out”Perception221287–1298
44.
PizzamiglioLZoccolottiPMammucariACesaroniR, 1983“The independence of face identity and facial expression recognition mechanisms: Relationship to sex and cognitive style”Brain and Cognition2176–188
45.
PrattoF, 1994“Consciousness and automatic evaluation”, in The Heart's Eye: Emotional Influences in Perception and Attention Eds NiedenthalP MKitayamaS, (New York: Academic Press) pp 116–143
46.
PrattoFJohnO P, 1991“Automatic vigilance: The attention-grabbing power of negative social stimuli”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology61380–391
47.
PurcellD GStewartA LSkovR, 1993“The face in the crowd: An effect of a confounding variable”, poster presented at the 5th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Society Chicago IL, June
48.
PurcellD GStewartA LSkovR, 1994“A stroop effect with facial expressions of affect”, poster presented at the 6th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Society, Washington, DC, June
49.
RosenthalRRosnowR L, 1984Essentials of Behavioral Research: Methods and Data Analysis (New York: McGraw-Hill)
50.
SdorowL M, 1995Psychology3rd edition (Madison, WI: Brown and Benchmark)
51.
ShimodaKArgyleMBittiP R, 1978“The intercultural recognition of emotional expressions by three national racial groups: English, Italian and Japanese”European Journal of Social Psychology8169–179
52.
SrivastavaPMandalM K, 1990“Proximal spacing to facial affect expressions in schizophrenia”Comprehensive Psychiatry31119–124
53.
StalansLWeddingD, 1985“Superiority of the left hemisphere in the recognition of emotional faces”International Journal of Neuroscience25219–223
54.
StanovichK E, 1996How to Think Straight about Psychology4th edition (New York: Harper Collins)
55.
StewartA LPurcellD GSkovR, 1993“Another look at the face in the crowd: An anger inferiority effect”, poster presented at the 5th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Society, Chicago, IL, June
56.
SuzukiSCavanaghP, 1995“Facial organization blocks access to low-level features: An object inferiority effect”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance21901–913
57.
TreismanA, 1988“Features and objects: The fourteenth Bartlett memorial lecture”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology A40201–237
58.
TreismanAGormicanS, 1988“Feature analysis in early vision: Evidence from search asymmetries”Psychological Review9515–48
59.
TreismanASoutherJ, 1985“Search asymmetry: A diagnostic for preattentive processing of separable features”Journal of Experimental Psychology: General114285–310
60.
UlemanJ SBarghJ A, (Eds), 1989Unintended Thought (New York: Guildford Press)
61.
WagnerH LMacDonaldC JMansteadA S R, 1986“Communication of individual emotions by spontaneous facial expressions”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology50737–743
