The Zöllner illusion has been accounted for in terms of local interactions between the vertical lines and the crossing segments. Recently, however, some evidence supporting the importance of global figural characteristics—ie of figural elements that are not directly interacting with the test lines—in the occurrence of orientation illusions has been reported. Three experiments have been conducted with parts of the Zöllner figure to test whether this illusion is affected by the global figural characteristics. The results indicate that, similarly to what has been observed for other orientation illusions, the Zöllner illusion depends on both local and global characteristics of the stimulus configuration. In addition, results suggest a similar weight for both these figural characteristics in determining the occurrence of the illusory effect. Finally, relations among different orientation illusions are also discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BlakemoreC BCarpenterR H SGeorgesonM A, 1970“Lateral inhibition between orientation detectors in human vision”Nature (London)22837–39
2.
GilbertC DWieselT N, 1979“Morphology and intracortical projections of functionally identified neurons in cat visual cortex”Nature (London)280120–125
3.
GilbertC DWieselT N, 1983“Clustered intrinsic connections in cat visual cortex”Journal of Neuroscience31116–1133
4.
GilbertC DWieselT N, 1990“The influence of contextual stimuli on the orientation selectivity of cells in primary visual cortex of the cat”Vision Research111689–1701
5.
GlassL, 1970“Effect of blurring on perception of a simple geometric pattern”Nature (London)2281341–1342
6.
GoodenoughD ROltmanP KRossoJMertzH, 1979“Orientation contrast effect in the rod-and-frame test”Perception & Psychophysics25419–424
7.
HowardI P, 1986“The perception of posture, self motion and the visual vertical”, in Handbook of Perception and Human Performance Eds BoffR KKaufmanLThomasJ P (New York: John Wiley) pp 1–30
8.
HubelD HWieselT N, 1959“Receptive fields of single neurones in the cat's striate cortex”Journal of Physiology (London)148474–591
9.
HubelD HWieselT N, 1968“Receptive fields and functional architecture of monkey striate cortex”Journal of Physiology (London)195215–243
10.
JastrowJ, 1893“On the judgement of angles and position of lines”American Journal of Psychology5214–223
11.
JuddC H, 1899“A study of geometrical illusions”Psychological Review6241–261
MagnussenSKurtenbachW, 1979“Linear summation of tilt illusion and tilt aftereffect”Vision Research2039–42
14.
MarrD, 1982Vision: A Computational Investigation into the Human Representation and Processing of Visual Information (San Francisco, CA: W H Freeman)
15.
MorganM JCascoC, 1990“Spatial filtering and spatial primitives in early vision: an explanation of the Zöllner-Judd class of geometrical illusion”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B2421–10
16.
MorinagaS, 1933“Untersuchungen über die Zöllnersche Täuschung”Japanese Journal of Psychology8195–242 (German summary 23–25)
17.
OyamaT, 1975“Determinants of the Zöllner illusion”Psychological Research37261–280
18.
OyamaT, 1977“Feature analysers, optical illusions, and figural aftereffects”Perception6401–406
19.
RobinsonJ O, 1972The Psychology of Visual Illusion (London: Hutchinson Education)
20.
RocklandK SLundJ S, 1983“Intrinsic laminar lattice connections in primate visual cortex”Journal of Comparative Neurology216303–318
21.
T'soDGilbertCWieselT N, 1986“Relationships between horizontal connections and functional architecture in cat striate cortex as revealed by cross-correlation analysis”Journal of Neuroscience61160–1170
22.
WallaceG K, 1969“The critical distance of interaction in the Zöllner illusion”Perception & Psychophysics5261–264
23.
WenderothPO'ConnorTJohnsonM, 1986“The tilt illusion as a function of the relative and absolute lengths of test and inducing lines”Perception & Psychophysics39339–345
24.
WenderothPvan der ZwanRWilliamsM, 1993“Direct evidence for competition between local and global mechanisms of two-dimensional orientation illusions”Perception22273–286
25.
WestheimerG, 1979“The spatial sense of the eye”Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science17893–912
26.
WestheimerG, 1981“Visual hyperacuity”Progress in Sensory Physiology11–30
27.
WestheimerG, 1990“Simultaneous orientation contrast for lines in the human fovea”Vision Research301913–1921
28.
WestheimerGShimamuraKMcKeeS P, 1976“Interference with line-orientation sensitivity”Journal of the Optical Society of America66332–338
29.
WhiteK G, 1971“Zöllner illusion as perceptual enlargement of acute angles”Psychonomic Science2473–75
30.
WhiteK G, 1975“Orientation effects on contour interaction in the Zöllner illusion”Perception & Psychophysics4387–392
31.
WitkinH AGoodenoughD R, 1981Cognitive Styles: Essence and Origins (New York: International)
