The relationship between mean control scores and mean experimental scores in 23 experiments on alignment illusions has been examined. Evidence is presented to show that, through the operation of the range effect, control scores are biased to a significant degree in the direction of experimental scores. The implications of this are considered, not only as regards the value of control scores in psychophysical studies, but also as further evidence of the dangers of within-subjects experimental designs when issues depend upon the values of extreme points in a range of values.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CorenSGirgusJ S, 1978Seeing Is Deceiving: The Psychology of Visual Illusions (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates)
2.
CornsweetT, 1962“The staircase method in psychophysics”American Journal of Psychology75485–491
3.
FellowsB J, 1967“Reversal of the Müller-Lyer illusion with changes in the length of the inter-fins line”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology19208–214
4.
HelsonH, 1964Adaptation Level Theory (New York: Harper and Row)
5.
HollingworthH L, 1909“The inaccuracy of movement”Archives of Psychology the whole of 2, No.13
6.
HollingworthH L, 1910“The central tendency”Journal of Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Methods7461–469
7.
HotopfW H N, 1981“‘Mistracking in alignment illusions”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance71211–1246
8.
HotopfW H NBrownS, 1988“Constant errors in judgements of collinearity due to the presence of neighbouring objects”Perception17523–534
IpsenG, 1926b“Zur Theorie des Erkennens”Neue Psychologische Studien1279–471
11.
MorganM JHoleG JGlennersterA, 1990“Biases and sensitivities in geometrical illusions”Vision Research301793–1810
12.
PoultonE C, 1973“Unwanted range effects from using within-subject experimental designs”Psychological Bulletin80113–121
13.
PoultonE C, 1974Tracking Skill and Manual Control (London: Academic Press)
14.
PoultonE C, 1975“Range effects in experiments on people”American Journal of Psychology883–32
15.
PoultonE C, 1985“Geometric illusions in reading graphs”Perception & Psychophysics37543–548
16.
SearleL VTaylorF V, 1948“Studies of tracking behaviour. I. Rate and time characteristics of simple corrective movements”Journal of Experimental Psychology38615–631
