Batters in professional baseball are confronted with pitches that appear to curve, dip, wobble, or rise. The rising fastball is a pitch where the ball appears to hop up as much as a third of a meter with a sudden increase in speed. Physics experiments confirm that many reported trajectories are possible, but not the rising fastball. The present paper shows how the apparent rise may be explained as a perceptual illusion due to the hitter underestimating original speed of the pitch.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AldersonG J KSullyD JSullyH G, 1974“An operational analysis of a one-handed catching task using high speed photography”Journal of Motor Behavior6(4) 217–226
2.
AllenE, 1982“Pitches” in Baseball Play and Strategy (Malabar, FL: Robert E Krieger) pp 27–32
3.
BacheR M, 1904“About a baseball's curves”Scientific American91(3) 42
4.
BahillA TLaRitzT, 1984“Why can't batters keep their eyes on the ball”American Scientist72249–253
BrancazioP, 1984 in Sport Science (New York: Simon and Schuster)
7.
BriggsL J, 1959“Effect of spin and speed on the lateral deflection (curve) of a baseball; and the Magnus effect for smooth spheres”American Journal of Physics27(8) 589–596
8.
BrownS L, 1913“Bernoulli's principle and its application to explain the curving of a baseball”Popular Science Monthly83199–203
9.
ButlerB, 1989“The Brett Butler Show” (KNBR Radio, San Francisco, CA)
10.
DeLuciaP RCochranE L, 1985“Perceptual information for batting can be extracted throughout a ball's trajectory”Perceptual and Motor Skills61143–150
11.
DigglesV AGrabinerM DGarhammerJ, 1987“Skill level and efficacy of effector visual feedback in ball catching”Perceptual and Motor Skills64987–993
12.
DruryJ F, 1953“The hell it don't curve”American Mercury76101–106
13.
ErlichsonH, 1985‘Is a baseball a sand-roughened sphere?’American Journal of Physics53(6) 582–583
14.
FimriteR, 1986“The pitch of the ′80s”Sports Illustrated64(23) 66–78
15.
FischmanM GSchneiderT, 1985“Skill level, vision, and proprioception in simple one-handed catching”Journal of Motor Behavior17(2) 219–229
16.
FrohlichC, 1984“Aerodynamic drag crisis and its possible effect on the flight of baseballs”American Journal of Physics52(4) 325–334
17.
FrohlichC, 1985“Comments on ‘Is a baseball a sand-roughened sphere?’”American Journal of Physics53(6) 583
18.
HarveyL OJrMichonJ A, 1974“Detectability of relative motion as a function of exposure duration, angular separation, and background”Journal of Experimental Psychology103(2) 317–325
19.
von HofstenC, 1987“Catching” in Perspectives on Perception and Action Eds HeuerHSandersA F (Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum Associates) chapter 2, pp 33–46
20.
HollenbergJ W, 1987“Knuckleballs” (Summary of work of J W Hollenberg in “Science and the Citizen”)Scientific American257(1) 22
21.
HubbardA WSengC N, 1954“Visual movements of batters”Research Quarterly25(1) 42–57
22.
KindelS, 1983“The hardest single act in all of sports”Forbes132(7) 180–187
23.
LeeD N, 1976“A theory of visual control of braking based on information about time-to-collision”Perception5437–459
24.
LeeD NYoungD SReddishP ELoughSClaytonT M H, 1983“Visual timing in hitting an accelerating ball”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology A35333–346
25.
McBeathM KShepardR N, 1989“Apparent motion between shapes differing in location and orientation: A window technique for estimating path curvature”Perception & Psychophysics46333–337
26.
McLeodP, 1987“Visual reaction time and high-speed ball games”Perception1649–59
27.
McLeodPMcLaughlinCNimmo-SmithI, 1985“Information encapsulation and automaticity: Evidence from the visual control of finely timed actions” in Attention and Performance XI Eds PosnerM IMarinO S M (Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum Associates) chapter 21, pp 391–406
28.
McMastersJ H, 1989“The flight of the bumblebee and related myths of entomological engineering”American Scientist77164–169
29.
MagnusH G, 1853“On the deviation of projectiles; and on the remarkable phenomenon of rotating bodies” in Scientific Memoirs Eds TyndallJFrancisW (London: Taylor and Francis; reprinted in 1966, New York: Johnson Reprint Corp.)
30.
MessierS TOwenM G, 1984“Bat dynamics of female fast pitch softball batters”Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport55(2) 141–145
31.
NesslerJ, 1973“Length of time necessary to view a ball while catching it”Journal of Motor Behavior5(3) 179–185
32.
NewtonI, 1671“A letter of Mr. Isaac Newton containing his new theory of light and colours”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London6(80) 3075–3087 (see p 3078)
33.
NewtonI, 1809 .“A letter of Mr. Isaac Newton containing his new theory of light and colours” in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London (Abridged), Volume 1: 1665–1672 (Eds HuttonCShawGPearsonR) (Blackfriars, England: C and R Baldwin) pp 678–688 (see pp 680–681)
34.
PortalJ MRomanoP E, 1988“Patterns of eye-hand dominance in baseball players”New England Journal of Medicine319(10) 655–656
35.
PringleJ W S, 1957 in Insect Flight (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
36.
Rayleigh Lord, 1877“On the irregular flight of a tennis ball”Messenger of Mathematics714
37.
ReganDBeverleyKCynaderM, 1979“The visual perception of motion in depth”Scientific American24(1) 136–151
38.
RexA F, 1985“The effect of spin on the flight of batted baseballs”American Journal of Physics53(11) 1073–1075
39.
RipollHFleuranceP, 1988“What does keeping one's eye on the ball mean?”Ergonomics31(11) 1647–1654
40.
RosengrenK SPickH Lvon HofstenC, 1988“Role of visual information in ball catching”Journal of Motor Behavior20(2) 150–164
41.
RunesonS, 1974“Constant velocity—Not perceived as such”Psychological Research373–23
42.
RunesonS, 1975“Visual prediction of collision with natural and nonnatural motions”Perception & Psychophysics18(4) 261–266
43.
SavelsberghG J PWhitingH T A, 1988“The effect of skill level, external frame of reference and environmental changes on one-handed catching”Ergonomics31(11) 1655–1663
44.
SchiffWDetwilerM L, 1979“Information used in impending collision”Perception8647–658
45.
SelinC, 1959“An analysis of the aerodynamics of pitched baseballs”Research Quarterly30232–240
46.
ShankM DHaywardK M, 1987“Eye movements while viewing a baseball pitch”Perceptual and Motor Skills64(3, part 2), 1191–1197
47.
SharpR HWhitingH T A, 1974“Exposure and occluded duration effects in a ball-catching skill”Journal of Motor Behavior6(3) 139–147
48.
SharpR HWhitingH T A, 1975“Information-processing and eye movement behaviour in a ball catching skill”Journal of Human Movement Studies1124–131
SmythM M, 1986“A note: Is it a catch or a fumble”Journal of Motor Behavior18(4) 492–495
51.
SmythM MMarriottA M, 1982“Vision and proprioception in simple catching”Journal of Motor Behavior14(2) 143–152
52.
ToddJ T, 1981“Visual information about moving objects”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance7795–810
53.
VerwiebeF L, 1942“Does a baseball curve?”American Journal of Physics10119–120
54.
WattsR GBaroniS, 1989“Baseball-bat collisions and the resulting trajectories of spinning balls”American Journal of Physics57(1) 40–45
55.
WattsR GFerrerR, 1986“The lateral force on a spinning sphere: Aerodynamics of a curve-ball”American Journal of Physics55(1) 40–44
56.
WattsR GSawyerE, 1975“Aerodynamics of a knuckleball”American Journal of Physics43(11) 960–963
57.
WhitingH T A, 1970“An operational analysis of a continuous ball throwing and catching task”Ergonomics13(4) 445–454
58.
WhitingH T A, 1986“Isn't there a catch in it somewhere?”Journal of Motor Behavior18(4) 486–491
59.
WhitingH T AGillE BStephensonJ M, 1970“Critical time intervals for taking in flight information in a ball-catching task”Ergonomics13(2) 265–272
60.
WhitingH T ASavelsberghG J PFaberC M, 1988“Catch questions and incomplete answers” in Cognition and Action in Skilled Behaviour Eds ColleyA MBeechJ R (Amsterdam: Elsevier Science) pp 257–271
61.
WilliamsTUnderwoodJ, 1986 in The Science of Hitting (New York: Simon and Schuster)
62.
WinogradS, 1942“The relationship of timing and vision to baseball performance”Research Quarterly13(4) 481–493
