Because efforts to use the cutaneous sense for conveying speech and visual information have met with only partial success, it would be useful to understand better the pattern-sensing capabilities of touch. This paper is an account of the sensory and perceptual factors known or hypothesized to limit the tactile perception of simple two-dimensional patterns, with special attention to the limited spatial bandwidth of touch.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllesD S, 1970“Information transmission by phantom sensations”IEEE Transactions on Man-Machine Systems MMS-11 85–91.
2.
AndrewsD PButcherA KBuckleyB R, 1973“Acuities for spatial arrangement in line figures: Human and ideal observers compared”Vision Research13599–620.
3.
Apkarian-StielauPLoomisJ M, 1975“A comparison of tactile and blurred visual form perception”Perception and Psychophysics18362–368.
4.
AustinT RSleightRB, 1952“Accuracy of tactual discrimination of letters, numerals, and geometric forms”Journal of Experimental Psychology43239–247.
5.
Bach-Y-RitaP, 1972Brain Mechanisms in Sensory Substitution (New York: Academic Press).
6.
BanksW PLarsonD WPrinzmetalW, 1979“Asymmetry of visual interference”Perception and Psychophysics25447–456.
7.
BeauchampK LMathesonD WScaddenL A, 1971“Effects of stimulus-change method on tactile-image recognition”Perceptual and Motor Skills331067–1070.
8.
BeckJSchwartzT, 1979“Vernier acuity with dot test objects”Vision Research19313–320.
9.
Von BékésyG, 1955“Human skin perception of traveling waves similar to those on the cochlea”Journal of the Acoustical Society of America27830–841.
10.
Von BékésyG, 1957“Neural volleys and the similarity between some sensations produced by tones and by skin vibrations”Journal of the Acoustical Society of America291059–1069.
11.
Von BékésyG, 1958“Funneling in the nervous system and its role in loudness and sensation intensity on the skin”Journal of the Acoustical Society of America30399–412.
12.
Von BékésyG, 1963“Hearing theories and complex sounds”Journal of the Acoustical Society of America35588–601.
13.
Von BékésyG, 1967Sensory Inhibition (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
14.
BlakemoreCCampbellF W, 1969“On the existence of neurones in the human visual system selectively sensitive to the orientation and size of retinal images”Journal of Physiology (London)203237–260
15.
BledsoeW, 1972“Braille: A success story” in Evaluation of Sensory Aids for the Visually Handicapped (Washington DC: National Academy of Sciences).
16.
BlissJ C, 1969“A relatively high-resolution reading aid for the blind”IEEE Transactions on Man-Machine Systems MMS-10 1–9.
17.
BlissJ C, 1978a“Reading machines for the blind” in Active Touch—The Mechanisms of Recognition of Objects by Manipulation: A Multidisciplinary Approach Ed. GordonG (Oxford: Pergamon Press).
18.
BlissJ C, 1978b“Reading systems”paper presented at Conference on Interrelations of the Communicative Senses, Asilomar, Calif., 29 September–2 October [sponsored by the National Science Foundation].
19.
BlissJ CCraneH DLinkS WTownsendJ T, 1966a“Tactile perception of sequentially presented patterns”Perception and Psychophysics1125–130.
20.
BlissJ CCraneH DMansfieldP KTownsendJ T, 1966b“Information available in brief tactile presentations”Perception and Psychophysics1273–283.
21.
BlissJ CKatcherM HRogersC HShepardR P, 1970“Optical-to-tactile image conversion for the blind”IEEE Transactions on Man—Machine Systems MMS-11 58–65.
22.
BoringE G, 1930“The two-point limen and the error of localization”American Journal of Psychology42446–449.
23.
BoringE G, 1942Sensation and Perception in the History of Experimental Psychology (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts).
24.
BoumaH, 1970“Interaction effects in parafoveal letter recognition”Nature (London)226177–178.
25.
BracewellR N, 1978The Fourier Transform and Its Application2nd edition (New York: McGraw-Hill).
26.
BrownR LNibarberDOllieGSolomonA, 1967“A differential comparison of two types of electropulse alphabets based on locus of stimulation”Perceptual and Motor Skills241039–1044.
27.
BürklenK, 1932Touch Reading of the Blind translated by MerryF K (New York: American Foundation for the Blind).
28.
CampbellF W, 1974“The transmission of spatial information through the visual system” in The Neurosciences Third Study Program Eds SchmittF OWordenF G (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press) pp 95–103.
29.
CampbellF WGreenD G, 1965“Optical and retinal factors affecting visual resolution”Journal of Physiology (London)181576–593.
30.
CampbellF WRobsonJ G, 1968“Application of Fourier analysis to the visibility of gratings”Journal of Physiology (London)197551–566.
31.
CornsweetT N, 1970Visual Perception (New York: Academic Press).
32.
CraigJ C, 1974a“Pictorial and abstract cutaneous displays” in Conference on Vibrotactile Communication Ed. GeldardF A (Austin, Tex.: The Psychonomic Society).
33.
CraigJ C, 1974b“Vibrotactile difference thresholds for intensity and the effect of a masking stimulus”Perception and Psychophysics15123–127.
34.
CraigJ C, 1976“Vibrotactile letter recognition: The effects of a masking stimulus”Perception and Psychophysics20317–326.
CraigJ C, 1978“Vibrotactile pattern recognition and masking” in Active Touch—The Mechanisms of Recognition of Objects by Manipulation: A Multidisciplinary Approach Ed. GordonG (Oxford: Pergamon Press).
37.
CraigJ C, 1979“Modes of vibrotactile pattern generation”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance6151–166.
38.
DaleyM LSingerM, 1975“A spatial resolution measure of cutaneous vision”IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics SMC-5 124–125.
39.
DeGowinE LDimmickF L, 1928“The tactual perception of simple geometrical forms”Journal of General Psychology1114–122.
40.
DonderiDCaseB, 1970“Parallel visual processing: Constant same-different decision latency with two to fourteen shapes”Perception and Psychophysics8373–375.
41.
FoulkeEBerlaE P, 1978“Visual impairment and the development of perceptual ability” in Perception and Experience Eds WalkR DPickH LJr (New York: Plenum).
42.
FranzenOMarkowitzJSwetsJ A, 1970“Spatially-limited attention to vibrotactile stimulation”Perception and Psychophysics7193–196.
43.
GeldardF A, 1975Sensory Saltation: Metastability in the Perceptual World (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates).
44.
GeldardF A, 1976“The saltatory effect in vision”Sensory Processes177–86.
45.
GeldardF A, 1978“The cutaneous ‘rabbit’ and human dermatomes”paper presented at the annual meeting of the Psychonomic Society, San Antonio, Texas.
46.
GeldardF ASherrickC E, 1965“Multiple cutaneous stimulation: The discrimination of vibratory patterns”Journal of the Acoustical Society of America37797–801.
47.
GeldardF ASherrickC E, 1972“The cutaneous ‘rabbit’: A perceptual illusion”Science178178–179.
48.
GescheiderG A, 1970“Some comparisons between touch and hearing”IEEE Transactions on Man—Machine Systems MMS-11 28–35.
49.
GescheiderG AHermanD DPhillipsJ N, 1970“Criterion shifts in the measurement of tactile masking”Perception and Psychophysics8433–436.
50.
GescheiderG AVerrilloR T, 1979“Vibrotactile frequency characteristics as determined by adaptation and masking procedures” in Sensory Functions of the Skin of Humans Ed. KenshaloD R (New York: Plenum).
51.
GibsonJ J, 1962“Observations on active touch”Psychological Review69477–491.
52.
GibsonJ J, 1966The Senses Considered as Perceptual Systems (Boston, Mass: Houghton Mifflin)
53.
GilsonR D, 1968“Some factors affecting the spatial discrimination of vibrotactile patterns”Perception and Psychophysics3131–136.
54.
GilsonR D, 1969a“Vibrotactile masking: Some spatial and temporal aspects”Perception and Psychophysics5176–180.
55.
GilsonR D, 1969b“Vibrotactile masking: Effects of multiple maskers”Perception and Psychophysics5181–182.
56.
GilsonR D, 1974“Vibratory masking” in Conference on Vibrotactile Communication Ed GeldardF A (Austin, Tex.: The Psychonomic Society).
57.
GinsburgA P, 1978“Visual information processing based on spatial filters constrained by biological data”Doctoral dissertation, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, England.
58.
GordonG (Ed.), 1978Active Touch—The Mechanism of Recognition of Objects by Manipulation: A Multidisciplinary Approach (Oxford: Pergamon Press).
59.
GregoryR LWallaceJ G, 1963Recovery from Early Blindness: A Case Study Experimental Psychology Society Monograph number 2 (Cambridge: Heffer and Sons).
60.
HenselHKonietznyF, 1979“Problems of correlating cutaneous sensation with neural events in man” in Sensory Functions of the Skin of Humans Ed KenshaloD R (New York: Plenum).
61.
HillJ W, 1974“Limited field of view in reading lettershapes with the finger” in Conference on Vibrotactile Communication Ed. GeldardF A (Austin Tex.: The Psychonomic Society).
62.
HillJ WBlissJ C, 1968a“Perception of sequentially presented tactile point stimuli”Perception and Psychophysics4289–295.
63.
HillJ WBlissJ C, 1968b“Modeling a tactile sensory register”Perception and Psychophysics491–101.
64.
HirshI JSherrickC EJr, 1961“Perceived order in different sense modalities”Journal of Experimental Psychology62423–432.
65.
HoaglandH, 1932“A basis for cutaneous localization”Journal of General Psychology6468–470.
66.
JohanssonR, 1976“Skin mechanoreceptors in the human hand: Receptive field characteristics” in Sensory Functions of the Skin in Primates Ed. ZottermanY (New York: Pergamon Press).
67.
JonesF N, 1956“Space—time relationships in somesthetic localization”Science124484.
68.
JonesM BVierckC JJr, 1973“Length discrimination on the skin”American Journal of Psychology8649–60.
69.
KabriskyMTallmanODayC MRadoyC M, 1970“A theory of pattern perception based on human physiology”Ergonomics13129–147.
70.
KenshaloD R, 1978“Biophysics and psychophysics of feeling” in Handbook of Perception, Volume VIB: Feeling and Hurting Eds CarteretteE CFiedmanM P (New York: Academic Press).
71.
KirmanJ H, 1973“Tactile communication of speech: A review and an analysis”Psychological Bulletin8054–74.
72.
KirmanJ H, 1978“Tactile pattern perception and tactile displays”paper presented at Conference on Interrelations of the Communicative Senses, Asilomar, Calif., 29 September-2 October [sponsored by the National Science Foundation].
73.
KruegerL E, 1970“David Katz's Der Aufbau der Tastwelt (The World of Touch): A synopsis”Perception and Psychophysics7337–341.
74.
LappinJ SFoulkeE, 1973“Expanding the tactual field of view”Perception and Psychophysics14237–241.
75.
LickliderJ C R, 1951“Basic correlates of the auditory stimulus” in Handbook of Experimental Psychology Ed. StevensS S (New York: John Wiley)
76.
LinvillJ GBlissJ C, 1966“A direct translation reading aid for the blind”Proceedings of the IEEE5440–51.
77.
LoomisJ M, 1974“Tactile letter recognition under different modes of stimulus presentation”Perception and Psychophysics16401–408.
78.
LoomisJ M, 1980“Interaction of display mode and character size in vibrotactile letter recognition”Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society16385–387.
79.
LoomisJ M, 1981a“On the tangibility of letters and braille”Perception and Psychophysics2937–46.
80.
LoomisJ M, 1981b“An investigation of tactile hyperacuity”Sensory Processes in press.
81.
LoomisJ MApkarian-StielauP, 1976“A lateral masking effect in tactile and blurred visual letter recognition”Perception and Psychophysics20221–226.
82.
LoomisJ MCollinsC C, 1978“Sensitivity to shifts of a point stimulus: An instance of tactile hyperacuity”Perception and Psychophysics24487–492.
83.
LowenfeldBAbelG LHatlenP H, 1969Blind Children Learn to Read (Springfield, Ill.: Charles C Thomas).
84.
LudvighE, 1953“Direction sense of the eye”American Journal of Ophthalmology36139–142.
85.
MajorD R, 1898“Cutaneous perception of form”American Journal of Psychology10143–147.
86.
MerryR V, 1937“Fingers for eyes: The story of raised print”Scientific Monthly44273–279.
87.
MerzenichM MHarringtonT, 1969“The sense of flutter-vibration evoked by stimulation of the hairy skin of primates: Comparison of human sensory capacity with the responses of mechano-receptive afferents innervating the hairy skin of monkeys”Experimental Brain Research9236–260.
88.
MooreT J, 1970“A survey of the mechanical characteristics of skin and tissue in response to vibratory stimulation”IEEE Transactions on Man-Machine Systems MMS-11 79–84.
89.
MountcastleV B, 1961“Some functional properties of the somatic afferent system” in Sensory Communication Ed. RosenblithW A (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press).
90.
NeisserU, 1967Cognitive Psychology (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts).
91.
NolanC YKederisC J, 1969Perceptual Factors in Braille Word Recognition (New York: American Foundation for the Blind).
92.
PlompR, 1976Aspects of Tone Sensation (New York: Academic Press).
93.
PollenD ALeeJ RTaylorJ H, 1971“How does the striate cortex begin the reconstruction of the visual world?”Science17374–77.
94.
RoedererJ G, 1973Introduction to the Physics and Psychophysics of Music (New York: Springer).
95.
RosnerB S, 1961“Neural factors limiting cutaneous spatiotemporal discriminations” in Sensory Communication Ed. RosenblithW A (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press).
96.
SaidaSShimizuYWakeT, 1978“Construction of small TVSS and optimal mode of stimulus presentation”paper presented at Fourth Symposium on Sensory Substitution, Tokyo, 24–25 November [in Japanese].
97.
ScaddenL A1971Perception of Patterned Vibratory Stimulation: An Evaluation of the Tactile Vision Substitution SystemDoctoral dissertation, University of the Pacific, Stockton, Calif.
98.
ScaddenL A, 1973“Tactile pattern recognition and body loci”Perception2333–336.
99.
SchindlerUKnappA, 1976“Ursachen der gegenseitigen Verdeckung von taktil dargebotenen Buchstaben: Unterbrechung, Summation oder Verzögerung?”Psychological Research38303–318.
100.
SchmidE, 1961“Temporal aspects of cutaneous interaction with two-point stimulation”Journal of Experimental Psychology61400–409.
101.
SekulerR, 1974“Spatial vision”Annual Review of Psychology25195–232.
102.
SherrickC EJr, 1964“Effects of double simultaneous stimulation of the skin”American Journal of Psychology7742–53.
103.
SherrickC E, 1975“Auditory saltation” inPrinceton Cutaneous Research Reports268–9.
104.
SherrickC E, 1979“Cutaneous communication” in Contributions to Sensory Physiology Ed. NeffW D (New York: Academic Press).
105.
ShiffrinR MCraigJ CCohenE, 1973a“On the degree of attention and capacity limitation in tactile processing”Perception and Psychophysics13328–336.
106.
ShiffrinR MGardnerJ TAllmeyerD H, 1973b“On the degree of attention and capacity limitation in visual processing”Perception and Psychophysics14231–236.
107.
SinclairD, 1967Cutaneous Sensation (London: Oxford University Press).
108.
SnyderR E, 1977“Vibrotactile masking: A comparison of psychophysical procedures”Perception and Psychophysics22471–475.
109.
SnyderR E, 1979“Spatial masking of tactile letter identification”paper presented at the annual meeting of the Psychonomic Society, Phoenix, Arizona.
110.
SperlingGBudianskyJSpivakJ GJohnsonM C, 1971“Extremely rapid visual search: The maximum rate of scanning letters for the presence of a numeral”Science174307–311.
111.
SullivanG DOatleyKSutherlandN S, 1972“Vernier acuity as affected by target length and separation”Perception and Psychophysics12438–444.
112.
TaenzerJ C, 1970“Visual word reading”IEEE Transactions on Man-Machine Systems MMS-11 44–53.
113.
TaenzerJ C, 1972“An information processing model for visual and tactile reading”Perception1147–160.
114.
TaylorM MLedermanS J, 1975“Tactile roughness of grooved surfaces: A model and the effect of friction”Perception and Psychophysics1723–36.
115.
TaylorS GBrownD R, 1972“Lateral visual masking: Supraretinal effects when viewing linear arrays with unlimited viewing time”Perception and Psychophysics1297–99.
116.
TregearR T, 1966The Physical Functions of the Skin (New York: Academic Press).
117.
UttalW R, 1960“Inhibitory interaction of responses to electrical stimuli in the fingers”Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology5347–51.
118.
VallboA BJohanssonR S, 1978“The tactile sensory innervation of the glabrous skin of the human hand” in Active Touch—The Mechanisms of Recognition of Objects by Manipulation: A Multidisciplinary Approach Ed. GordonG (Oxford: Pergamon Press).
119.
ValvoA, 1971Sight Restoration After Long-Term Blindness: The Problems and Behavior Patterns of Visual Rehabilitation (New York: American Foundation for the Blind).
120.
VerrilloR T, 1965“Temporal summation in vibrotactile sensitivity”Journal of the Acoustical Society of America37843–846.
121.
VerrilloR T, 1968“A duplex mechanism of mechanoreception”The Skin Senses Ed. KenshaloD R (Springfield, Ill: Charles C Thomas).
122.
VerrilloR TGescheiderG A, 1979“Psychophysical measurements of enhancement, suppression, and surface gradient effects in vibrotaction” in Sensory Functions of the Skin of Humans Ed. KenshaloD R (New York: Plenum).
123.
VierckC JJrJonesM B, 1969“Size discrimination on the skin”Science63488–489.
124.
WeinsteinS, 1968“Intensive and extensive aspects of tactile sensitivity as a function of body part, sex, and laterality” in The Skin Senses Ed. KenshaloD R (Springfield, Ill.: Charles C Thomas).
125.
WernerGWhitselB L, 1973“Functional organization of the somatosensory cortex” in Handbook of Sensory Physiology volume II Somatosensory System Ed. IggoA (New York: Springer).
126.
WestheimerG, 1976“Diffraction theory and visual hyperacuity”American Journal of Optometry and Physiological Optics53362–364.
127.
WestheimerG, 1977“Spatial frequency and light-spread descriptions of visual acuity and hyperacuity”Journal of the Optical Society of America67207–212.
128.
WestheimerG, 1978“Spatial phase sensitivity for sinusoidal grating targets”Vision Research181073–1074.
129.
WestheimerG, 1979“Spatial sense of the eye (Proctor Lecture)”Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science18893–912.
130.
WestheimerGMcKeeS P, 1977a“Integration regions for visual hyperacuity”Vision Research1789–93.
131.
WestheimerGMcKeeS P, 1977b“Perception of temporal order in adjacent visual stimuli”Vision Research17887–892.
132.
WestheimerGMcKeeS P, 1977c“Spatial configurations for visual hyperacuity”Vision Research17941–947.
133.
WhiteB W, 1970“Perceptual findings with the Vision-Substitution System”IEEE Transactions on Man-Machine Systems MMS-11 54–58.
134.
WhiteB WSaundersF AScaddenLBach-Y-RitaPCollinsC C, 1970“Seeing with the skin”Perception and Psychophysics723–27.
135.
WielandB A, 1960“The interaction of space and time in cutaneous perception”American Journal of Psychology73248–255.
136.
WolfordG, 1975“Perturbation model for letter identification”Psychological Review82184–199.
137.
ZiglerM J, 1935“The experimental relation of the two-point limen to the error of localization”Journal of General Psychology13316–331.
138.
ZiglerM JBarrettR, 1927“A further contribution to the tactual perception of form”Journal of Experimental Psychology10184–192.
139.
ZiglerM JNorthrupK M, 1926“The tactual perception of form”American Journal of Psychology37391–397.
