Helmholtz is usually credited with demonstrating the relationship between the perception of visual direction and eye muscle activity: he said that directional judgements resulted from the effort of will involved in altering the position of the eyes. However, Bell reached the same conclusion many years earlier, primarily on the basis of experiments with afterimages: an afterimage appeared to move with voluntary movement of the eye, but it appeared stationary when the eye was moved passively.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BeareJ I, 1931Parva Naturalia. De Somniis in The Works of Aristotle Translated into Englishvolume III Ed. RossW D (London: Oxford University Press) pp 461b–462a
2.
BellC, 1803The Anatomy of the Human Bodyvolume III (London: Longman, Rees, Cadell and Davies)
3.
BellC, 1811Idea of a New Anatomy of the Brain reprinted in Gordon-TaylorGSirWallsE W, 1958Sir Charles Bell. His Life and Times (Edinburgh: Livingstone) pp 218–231
4.
BellC, 1823a“On the motions of the eye, in illustration of the uses of the muscles and of the orbit”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society113166–186
5.
BellC, 1823b“Second part of the paper on the nerves of the orbit”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society113289–307
6.
BoringE G, 1942Sensation and Perception in the History of Experimental Psychology (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts)
7.
BrewsterD, 1821“Optics”Edinburgh Encyclopaedia volume XV (Edinburgh: Blackwood)
8.
BrewsterD, 1825“Observations on the vision of impressions on the retina, in reference to certain supposed discoveries respecting vision announced by Mr. Charles Bell”Edinburgh Journal of Science21–9
9.
CarmichaelL, 1926“Sir Charles Bell: A contribution to the history of physiological psychology”Psychological Review33188–217
10.
DarwinR W, 1786“New experiments on the ocular spectra of light and colours”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society76313–348
11.
FlugelJ C, 1933A Hundred Years of Psychology 1833–1933 (London: Duckworth)
12.
HansenR MSkavenskiA A, 1977“Accuracy of eye position information for motor control”Vision Research17919–926
13.
HelmholtzH, 1866Handbuch der Physiologischen Optik Dritter Band (Leipzig: Voss)
14.
HelmholtzH, 1925Physiological Opticsvolume III, English translation by SouthallJ P C for The Optical Society of America (Menasha, Wis.: Banta)
15.
HowardI PTempletonW B, 1966Human Spatial Orientation (Chichester, Sussex: John Wiley)
16.
MatinL, 1972“Eye movements and perceived visual direction” in Handbook of Sensory Physiology volume VII/4 Visual Psychophysics Eds JamesonDHurvichL M (Berlin: Springer) pp 331–380
17.
MatinL, 1976“A possible hybrid mechanism for modification of visual direction associated with eye movements—the paralyzed-eye experiment reconsidered”Perception5233–239
18.
MüllerJ, 1826aZur vergleichenden Physiologie des Gesichtssinnes des Menschen und der Thiere, nebst einen Versuch über die Bewegungen der Augen und über den menschlichen Blick (Leipzig: Cnobloch)
19.
MüllerJ, 1826bÜber die phantastischen Gesichtserscheinungen (Coblenz: Hölscher), reprinted in EbbeckeU, 1951Johannes Müller der grosse rheinsche Physiologe (Hannover: Schmorl and von Seefeld)
20.
MüllerJ, 1839Elements of Physiologyvolume I, English translation by BalyW (London: Taylor and Walton)
21.
MüllerJ, 1842Elements of Physiologyvolume II, English translation by BalyW (London: Taylor and Walton)
22.
PorterfieldW, 1759A Treatise on the Eye, the Manner and Phaenomena of Vision (Edinburgh: Hamilton and Balfour)
23.
SmithR, 1738A Compleat System of Opticks in Four Books (Cambridge: published by the author).
