Prolonged observation of a stationary grating has a number of perceptual consequences. Initially the lines appear well-resolved and straight. The lines then take on a wavy and oscillating appearance, which is followed by scintillation of the pattern. The scintillations are often accompanied by cloudy disappearances of the grating. A streaming or scintillating aftereffect is visible subsequently, upon viewing a homogeneous surface. The literature concerning these effects is reviewed and several experiments are reported which examined the apparent waviness and scintillating disappearances. The basis for the apparent waviness remains unresolved. It is suggested that the scintillations are produced by small involuntary eye movements over the contours and that the associated disappearances might be due to binocular rivalry.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArnulfADupuyO, 1960“Contribution à l'étude des micro-fluctuations d'accommodation de l'oeil”Revue d'Optique, Theorique et Instrumentale39195–208
2.
AtkinsonJCampbellF WFiorentiniAMaffeiL, 1973“The dependence of monocular rivalry on spatial frequency”Perception2127–133
3.
BarlowH B, 1963“Slippage of contact lenses and other artefacts in relation to fading and regeneration of supposedly stable retinal images”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology1536–51
4.
BarrettC, 1970Op Art (London: Studio Vista)
5.
BlakeRFoxR, 1974“Binocular rivalry suppression: insensitive to spatial frequency and orientation change”Vision Research14687–692
6.
BlumA C, 1956“Photic stimulation, imagery and alpha rhythm”Journal of Mental Science102160–167
BrewsterD, 1818“Account of an affection of the eye” report of Proceedings at the Royal Society of Edinburgh in Thomson's Annals of Philosophy11151
9.
BrewsterD, 1825“On some remarkable affections of the retina, as exhibited in its insensibility to indirect impressions, and to the impressions of attenuated light”Edinburgh Journal of Science3288–293
10.
BrewsterD, 1831A Treatise on Optics (London: Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, Green and Taylor)
11.
Brewster SirD, 1832aLetters on Natural Magic Addressed to Sir Walter Scott, Bart (London: John Murray)
12.
Brewster SirD, 1832b“On the undulations excited in the retina by the action of luminous points and lines”London and Edinburgh Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science1169–174
13.
Brewster SirD, 1834“Influence of successive impulses of light upon the retina”London and Edinburgh Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science4241–245
14.
Brewster SirD, 1845“Notice of two new properties of the retina”Report of the British Association. Transactions of the Sections8–9
15.
BrownC RGebhardJ W, 1948“Visual field articulation in the absence of spatial stimulus gradients”Journal of Experimental Psychology38188–200
16.
CampbellF WHowellE R, 1972“Monocular alternation: a method for the investigation of pattern vision”Journal of Physiology22519P–21P
17.
CampbellF WRobsonJ G, 1958“Moving visual images produced by regular stationary patterns”Nature (London)181362
18.
CampbellF WWestheimerGRobsonJ G, 1959“Fluctuations in accommodation under steady viewing conditions”Journal of Physiology145579–594
19.
DvorakV, 1870“Versuche über die Nachbilder von Reizveränderungen”Sitzungsberichte der Wiener Academie der Wissenschaften61257–262
20.
ErbM BDallenbachK M, 1939““Subjective” colors from line-patterns”American Journal of Psychology52227–241
21.
EvansC RMarsdenR P, 1966“A study of the effect of perfect retinal stabilization on some well-known visual illusions, using the after-image as a method of compensating for eye movements”British Journal of Physiological Optics23242–248
22.
EvansC RPigginsD J, 1963“A comparison of the behaviour of geometrical shapes when viewed under conditions of steady fixation, and with apparatus for producing a stabilized retinal image”British Journal of Physiological Optics201–13
23.
FechnerG T, 1838“Über eine Scheibe zur Erzeugung subjectiver Farben”Poggendorffs Annalen der Physik und Chemie45227–232
24.
FerreeC E, 1906“An experimental examination of the phenomena usually attributed to fluctuation of attention”American Journal of Psychology1782–120
25.
FerreeC E, 1908a“The intermittence of minimal visual sensations”American Journal of Psychology1958–129
26.
FerreeC E, 1908b“The streaming phenomenon”American Journal of Psychology19484–503
27.
FleischlE, 1883“Physiologisch-optische Notizen. 2. Mittheilung”Sitzungsberichte der Wiener Academie der Wissenschaften868–25
28.
FordeJMacKinnonG E, 1975“Binocular stimulation and the fragmentation of after-images”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology27565–577
29.
GellhornE, 1928“Über den Wettstreit im Nachbild. VI. Über Intracorticale Erregungsvorgänge in der Sehrinde des Menschen”Pflügers Archiv für Gesamte Physiologie des Menschen und der Tiere21854–82
30.
GeorgesonM A, 1976a“Antagonism between channels for pattern and movement in human vision”Nature (London)259413–415
31.
GeorgesonM A, 1976b“Psychophysical hallucinations of orientation and spatial frequency”Perception599–111
32.
GrindleyG CWilkinsonR T, 1953“The after effect of seen movement on a plain field”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology5183–184
33.
HelmholtzH, 1856Handbuch der Physiologischen Optik Erster Band (Leipzig: Voss)
34.
HelmholtzH, 1860Handbuch der Physiologischen Optik Zweiter Band (Leipzig: Voss)
35.
HelmholtzH, 1924Physiological Optics English translation by SouthallJ P C, reprinted 1962 (New York: Dover)
36.
HensenV, 1865“Über eine Einrichtung der Fovea centralis retinae, welche bewirkt, dass feinere Distanzen als solche, die dem Durchmesser eines Zapfens entsprechen, noch unterschieden werden können”Archiv für Pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für Klinische Medizin34401–411
37.
HensenV, 1867“Über das Sehen in der Fovea centralis”Archiv für Pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für Klinische Medizin39475–492
38.
HonnisettJOldfieldR C, 1961“Movement and distortion of visual patterns during prolonged fixation”Scandinavian Journal of Psychology249–55
39.
HowardI P, 1959“Some new subjective phenomena apparently due to interocular transfer”Nature (London)1841516–1517
40.
HunterW S, 1915“Retinal factors in visual after-movement”Psychological Review22479–489
41.
KitterleF LKayeR SNixonH, 1974“Pattern alternation: effects of spatial frequency and orientation”Perception and Psychophysics16543–546
42.
KupinJ JHaddadG MSteinmanR M, 1973“Saccades in Neal's ‘Square of Three’”Perception and Psychophysics14298–300
43.
LehmkuhleS WFoxR, 1975“Effect of binocular rivalry suppression on the motion aftereffect”Vision Research15855–859
44.
LuckieshMMossF K, 1933“A demonstration test of vision”American Journal of Psychology45135–139
45.
McDougallW, 1901a“Some new observations in support of Thomas Young's theory of light- and colour-vision. I”Mind1052–97
46.
McDougallW, 1901b“Some new observations in support of Thomas Young's theory of light- and colour-vision. II”Mind10210–245
47.
McDougallW, 1901c“Some new observations in support of Thomas Young's theory of light- and colour-vision. III”Mind10347–382
48.
MacKayD M, 1957a“Moving visual images produced by regular stationary patterns”Nature (London)180849–850
49.
MacKayD M, 1957b“Some further visual phenomena associated with regular patterned stimulation”Nature (London)1801145–1146
50.
MacKayD M, 1958“Moving visual images produced by regular stationary patterns”Nature (London)181362–363
51.
MacKayD M, 1961“Interactive processes in visual perception” in Sensory Communication Ed. RosenblithW A (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press) pp 339–355
52.
MacKayD MMacKayV, 1976“Antagonism between visual channels for pattern and movement?”Nature (London)263312–314
53.
MacKinnonG EFordeJPigginsD J, 1969“Stabilized images, steadily fixated figures and prolonged after-images”Canadian Journal of Psychology23184–195
54.
MillodotM, 1968“Influence of accommodation on the viewing of an optical illusion”Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology20329–335
55.
Mundy-CastleA C, 1953“Electrical responses of the brain in relation to behaviour”British Journal of Psychology44318–329
56.
PierceA H, 1901Studies in Auditory and Visual Space Perception (New York: Longmans, Green)
57.
PirenneM H, 1958“Moving visual images produced by regular stationary patterns”Nature (London)181362
58.
PurkinjeJ, 1823Beobachtungen und Versuche zur Physiologie der Sinne. Beiträge zur Kenntniss des Sehens in subjecktiver Hinsicht Erstes Bändchen (Prague: Calve'schen Buchhandlung)
59.
PurkinjeJ, 1825Beobachtungen und Versuche zur Physiologie der Sinne. Neue Beiträge zur Kentniss des Sehens in subjecktiver Hinsicht Zweites Bändchen (Berlin: Reiner)
60.
RauscheckerJ P JCampbellF WAtkinsonJ, 1973“Colour opponent neurones in the human visual system”Nature (London)24542–43
61.
RemoleA, 1973“Subjective patterns in a flickering field: binocular vs monocular observation”Journal of the Optical Society of America63745–748
62.
RollettH, 1910“Über ein subjektives optisches Phänomen bei der Betrachtung gestreifter Flächen”Zeitschrift für Psychologie und Physiologie der Sinnesorgane. Abteilung II. Zeitschrift für Sinnesphysiologie46198–224
63.
SchilderP, 1912“Über autokinetische Empfindungen”Archiv für die Gesamte Psychologie des Menschen und der Tiere2536–77
64.
SlaughterJ W, 1901“The fluctuations of attention in some of their psychological relations”American Journal of Psychology12313–332
65.
SmythiesJ R, 1957“A preliminary analysis of the stroboscopic patterns”Nature (London)179523–524
66.
SmythiesJ R, 1959a“The stroboscopic patterns. I. The dark phase”British Journal of Psychology50106–116
67.
SmythiesJ R, 1959b“The stroboscopic patterns. II. The phenomenology of the bright phase and after-images”British Journal of Psychology50305–324
68.
SmythiesJ R, 1960“The stroboscopic patterns. III. Further experiments and discussion”British Journal of Psychology51247–255
69.
SternL W, 1894“Die Wahrnehmung von Bewegung vermittelst des Auges”Zeitschrift für Psychologie und Physiologie der Sinnesorgane7321–386
70.
SzilyA, 1905“Bewegungsnachbild und Bewegungskontrast”Zeitschrift für Psychologie und Physiologie der Sinnesorgane3881–154
71.
ThomsenE, 1919“Über Johannes Evangelista Purkinje und seine Werke”Skandanavisches Archiv für Physiologie371–116
72.
TroxlerD, 1804“Über das Verschwinden gegebener Gegenstände innerhalb unsers Gesichtskreises”Ophtalmologisches Bibliothek21–53
VierordtK, 1856“Wahrnehmung des Blutlaufs in der Netzhautgefässen”Archiv für Physiologische Heilkunde15256–268
75.
WadeN J, 1972“Orientation effects on line afterimages”Perception and Psychophysics12409–416
76.
WadeN J, 1973“Orientation and spatial frequency effects on linear afterimages”Perception and Psychophysics13446–450
77.
WadeN J, 1974“Some perceptual effects generated by rotating gratings”Perception3169–184
78.
WadeN J, 1975a“Monocular and binocular rivalry between contours”Perception485–95
79.
WadeN J, 1975b“Fragmentation of monocular afterimages in individuals with and without normal binocular vision”Perception and Psychophysics18328–330
80.
WadeN J, 1976“On interocular transfer of the movement aftereffect in individuals with and without normal binocular vision”Perception5113–118
81.
WadeN J, 1977“A note on the discovery of subjective colours”Vision Research17671–672
82.
WalterW G, 1950“The twenty-fourth Maudsley lecture: the functions of electrical rhythms in the brain”Journal of Mental Science961–31
83.
WeissteinN, 1969“What the frog's eye tells the human brain. Single cell analyzers in the human visual system”Psychological Bulletin72157–176
84.
WelpeE, 1975“Das Schachbrettmuster, ein nur binokular anregbares Flimmermuster”Vision Research151283–1287
85.
WelpeE, 1976“Über die durch ein Rechteckgitter induzierten subjecktiven Rautenmuster”Vision Research161337–1341
86.
WilsonJ P, 1960“The response of the visual system to spatially repetitive stimuli” Ph D Thesis, University of London, England
87.
WohlgemuthA, 1911“On the after-effect of seen movement”British Journal of Psychology MonographSupplement 11–117
88.
WrightM JIkedaH, 1974“Processing of spatial and temporal information in the visual system” in The Neurosciences: Third Study Program Eds SchmittF OWordenF G (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press) pp 115–122
89.
YoungR S LColeR EGambleMRaynerM D, 1975“Subjective patterns elicited by light flicker”Vision Research151291–1293
90.
ZehfussG, 1880“Über Bewegungsnachbilder”Wiedemann's Annalen der Physik und Chemie9672–676
