Six general features of perceptual reversals or alternations are described, and an explanation is proposed in terms of the cyclic repetition of an optional stopping decision process. The properties of this model are found to correspond closely to the general features of perceptual alternation, and the account seems capable of explaining several related findings as well as reconciling some apparent conflict between previous results.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsP. A., 1954, “The effect of past experience on the perspective reversal of a tridimensional figure”, American Journal of Psychology, 67, 708–710
2.
AmmonsC. H.AmmonsR. B., 1963, “Perspective reversal as affected by physical characteristics of Necker cube drawings”, Proceedings of the Montana Academy of Sciences, 23, 287–302
3.
AmmonsR. B.AmmonsC. H., 1965, “Learning and performance of rotary pursuit and reversals of perspective with continuous practice and a single rest”, Paper presented to Rocky Mountain Psychological Association in Albuquerque, N. M., May
4.
AmmonsR. B.UlrichP.AmmonsC. H., 1959, “Voluntary control of perception of depth in a two-dimensional drawing”, Proceedings of the Montana Academy of Sciences, 19, 160–168
5.
AshI. E., 1914, “Fatigue and its effects upon control”, Archives of Psychology, 31, 1–61
6.
AttneaveF., 1968, “Triangles as ambiguous figures”, American Journal of Psychology, 81, 447–453
AudleyR. J., 1960, “A stochastic model for individual choice behaviour”, Psychological Review, 67, 1–15
9.
AudleyR. J., 1970, “Choosing”, Bulletin of the British Psychological Society, 23, 177–191
10.
BiaseD. V.ZuckermanM., 1967, “Sex differences in stress responses to total and partial sensory deprivation”, Psychosomatic Medicine, 29, 380–390
11.
BirrenJ. E.BotwinickJ., 1955, “Speed of response as a function of perceptual difficulty and age”, Journal of Gerontology, 10, 433–436
12.
BotwinickJ.BrinleyJ. F.RobbinJ. S., 1958, “The interaction effects of perceptual difficulty and stimulus exposure time on age differences in speed and accuracy of response”, Gerontologia, 2, 1–10
13.
BotwinickJ.RobbinJ. S.BrinleyJ. F., 1959, “Reorganization of perceptions with age”, Journal of Gerontology, 14, 85–88
14.
BrierleyH., 1961, “The speed and accuracy characteristics of neurotics”, British Journal of Psychology, 52, 273–280
15.
BrownK. T., 1955, “Rate of apparent change in a dynamic ambiguous figure as a function of observation time”, American Journal of Psychology, 68, 358–371
16.
BrunerJ. S.PostmanL.MostellerF., 1950, “A note on the measurement of reversals of perspective”, Psychometrika, 15, 63–72
17.
BuckL., 1966, “Reaction time as a measure of perceptual vigilance”, Psychological Bulletin, 65, 291–304
18.
CatlinJ.GleitmanH., 1968, “Relations between choice and latency measures in a selective learning paradigm”, Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 5, 422–441
19.
ClynesM. E., 1961, “Unidirectional rate sensitivity: A biocybernetic law of reflex and humoral systems as physiologic channels of control and communication”, Annals of the New York Academy of Science, 92, 946–969
20.
CorsoJ. F., 1967, The Experimental Psychology of Sensory Behaviour (Holt, Rinehart, & Winston, New York)
21.
CrossmanE.R.F.W.SzafranJ., 1956, “Changes with age in the speed of information intake and discrimination”, Experientia Supplementum, 4, 128–135
22.
DaviesD. R.TuneG. S., 1970, Human Vigilance Performance (Staples Press, London)
23.
DoaneB. K.MahatooW.HeronW.ScottT. H., 1959, “Changes in perceptual function after isolation”, Canadian Journal of Psychology, 13, 210–219
24.
DodwellP. C., 1961, “Coding and learning in shape discrimination”, Psychological Review, 68, 373–382
25.
DonahueW. T.GriffittsC. H., 1931, “The influence of complexity on the fluctuations of the illusions of reversible perspective”, American Journal of Psychology, 43, 613–617
26.
DuncanC. J.SheppardP. M., 1963, “Continuous and quantal theories of sensory discrimination”, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Ser. B, 158, 343–363
27.
EdwardsW., 1965, “Optimal strategies for seeking information: Models for statistics, choice reaction times, and human information processing”, Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 2, 312–329
28.
EscherM. C., 1959, Grafiek en Tekeningen (Koninklijke Uitgevereij J. J. Tijl, Zwolle)
29.
FestingerL., 1943, “Studies in decision: II. An empirical test of a quantitative theory of decision”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 32, 411–423
30.
FisherG. H., 1968, “Ambiguity of form: Old and new”, Perception and Psychophysics, 4, 189–192
31.
FittsP. M., 1966, “Cognitive aspects of information processing: III. Set for speed versus accuracy”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 71, 849–857
32.
FrederiksenN. O.GuilfordJ. P., 1934, “Personality traits and fluctuation of the outline cube”, American Journal of Psychology, 46, 470–474
33.
FreedmanS. J.GreenblattM., 1959, “Studies in human isolation”, WADC Technical Report 59-266 (Wright–Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio)
34.
FrischH. L.JuleszB., 1966, “Figure-ground perception and random geometry”, Perception and Psychophysics, 1, 389–398
35.
GardnerR. W., 1961, “Individual differences in figural after-effects and response to reversible figures”, British Journal of Psychology, 52, 269–272
36.
GoldsteinA. G., 1967, “Gestalt similarity principle, difference thresholds, and pattern discriminability”, Perception and Psychophysics, 2, 377–382
37.
GordonK., 1903, “Meaning in memory and attention”, Psychological Review, 10, 267–283
38.
GregoryR. L., 1956, “An experimental treatment of vision as an information source and noisy channel”, in Information Theory, Ed. CherryC. (Butterworth, London)
39.
GregoryR. L., 1966, Eye and Brain (McGraw-Hill, New York)
40.
HeathH. A.EhrlichD.OrbachJ., 1963, “Reversibility of the Necker cube: II. Effects of various activating conditions”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 17, 539–546
41.
HeathH. A.OrbachJ., 1963, “Reversibility of the Necker cube: IV. Responses of elderly people”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 17, 625–626
42.
HollingworthH. L., 1939, “Perceptual fluctuation as a fatigue index”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 24, 511–519
43.
HowardI. P., 1961, “An investigation of a satiation process in the reversible perspective of revolving skeletal shapes”, Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 13, 19–33
44.
HymanR., 1953, “Stimulus information as a determinant of reaction time”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 45, 188–196
45.
JacksonD. N., 1956, “Intelligence and reversals of perspective”, American Journal of Psychology, 69, 482–484
46.
JastrowJ., 1900, Fact and Fable in Psychology (Houghton Mifflin, New York)
47.
JohansonA. M., 1922, “The influence of incentive and punishment upon reaction time”, Archives of Psychology, 54, 1–53
48.
KahnemanD., 1968, “Method, findings, and theory in studies of visual masking”, Psychological Bulletin, 70, 404–425
49.
KöhlerW.WallachH., 1944, “Figural after-effects: An investigation of visual processes”, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 88, 269–357
50.
KünnapasT. M., 1957, “Experiments on figural dominance”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 53, 31–39
51.
KünnapasT. M., 1966, “Intensity of the underlying figural process”, Perception and Psychophysics, 1, 288–292
52.
KünnapasT. M., 1969, “Figural reversal rate and personal tempo”, Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 10, 27–32
53.
La BergeD., 1962, “A recruitment theory of simple behaviour”, Psychometrika, 27, 375–396
54.
LamingD. R. J., 1968, Information Theory of Choice-reaction Times (Academic Press, New York)
55.
LeidermanP. H., 1962, “Imagery and sensory deprivation, an experimental study”, WADC Technical Report MRL-TDR 62-28 (Wright–Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio)
56.
LeppmanP. K.MefferdR. B.Jr., 1968, “Validity of perceptual reports of experienced and inexperienced observers”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 26, 1167–1172
57.
LindauerM. S.LindauerJ. G., 1970, “Brightness differences and the perception of figure-ground”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 84, 291–295
58.
McDougallW., 1906, “Physiological factors of the attention process: IV”, Mind, 15, 329–359
59.
MefferdR. B.Jr., 1968a, “Perceptual fluctuations involving orientation and organization”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 27, 827–834
60.
MefferdR. B.Jr., 1968b, “Fluctuations in perceptual organization and orientation and perception of apparent movement”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 27, 368–370
61.
MefferdR. B.Jr.WielandB. A.CookT. H.SadlerT. G.BentonR. G.ReddingG. M., 1966, “Analysis of perspective reversal and associated apparent motions using a perspective-bound movement illusion”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 22, 835–858
62.
MefferdR. B.Jr.WielandB. A.GreensteinD. G.LeppmannP. K., 1968, “Effects of pretraining and instructions on validity of perceptual reports by inexperienced observers”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 27, 1003–1006
63.
OlsonR. K.AttneaveF., 1970, “What variables produce similarity grouping?”, American Journal of Psychology, 83, 1–21
64.
OrmistonD. W., 1961, “A methodological study of confinement”, WADC Technical Report 61-258 (Wright–Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio)
65.
OrneM. T., 1962, “On the social psychology of the psychological experiment, with particular reference to the demand characteristics and their implications”, American Psychologist, 17, 776–783
66.
OyamaT., 1950, “Figure–ground dominance as a function of sector angle, brightness, hue, and orientation”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 60, 299–305
67.
PachellaR. G.PewR. W., 1968, “Speed-accuracy trade-off in reaction time: Effect of discrete criterion times”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 76, 19–24
68.
PeltonL. H.SolleyC. M., 1968, “Acceleration of reversals of a Necker cube”, American Journal of Psychology, 81, 585–588
69.
PewR. W., 1969, “The speed–accuracy operating characteristic”, in Attention and Performance II, Ed. W. G. Koster, Acta Psychologica, 30, 16–26
70.
PickettR. M., 1970, “Visual analyses of texture in the detection and recognition of objects”, in Picture Processing and Psychopictorics, Eds. LipkinB. S.RosenfeldA. (Academic Press, New York)
71.
PikeA. R., 1968, “Latency and relative frequency of response in psychophysical discrimination”, British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology, 21, 161–182
72.
PikeA. R., 1971, “The latencies of correct and incorrect responses in discrimination and detection tasks: Their interpretation in terms of a model based on simple counting”, Perception and Psychophysics, 9, 455–460
73.
PorterE. K. H., 1938, “Factors in the fluctuations of fifteen ambiguous phenomena”, Psychological Record, 2, 231–253
74.
PriceJ. R., 1967a, “Two components of reversal for a rotating skeletal cube: ‘conditioned satiation’”, Australian Journal of Psychology, 19, 261–270
75.
PriceJ. R., 1967b, “Perspective duration of a plane reversible figure”, Psychonomic Science, 9, 623–624
76.
PriceJ. R., 1968, “Studies of reversible figures”, Doctoral Thesis (unpublished), University of Western Australia
77.
PriceJ. R., 1969a, “Studies of reversible perspective: A methodological review”, Behaviour Research Methods and Instrumentation, 1, 102–106
78.
PriceJ. R., 1969b, “Effect of extended observation on reversible perspective duration”, Psychonomic Science, 16, 75–76
79.
RubinE., 1958, “Figure and ground”. Translation in Readings in Perception, Eds. BeardsleeD. C.WertheimerM. (Van Nostrand, New York)
80.
SadlerT. G.MefferdR. B.Jr., 1970, “Fluctuations of perceptual organization and orientation: Stochastic (random) or steady state (satiation)?”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 31, 739–749
81.
SanfordA. J., 1971, “A periodic basis for perception and action”, in Biological Rhythms and Human Performance, Ed. ColquhounW. P. (Academic Press, London)
82.
SantosJ. F.FarrowB. J.SolleyC. M., 1962, “Exposure frequency and the perception of a reversible perspective”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 14, 199–209
83.
SaugstadP., 1965, “Effect of reward and punishment on visual perception of figure–ground”, Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 6, 225–236
84.
SchoutenJ. F.BekkerJ. A. M., 1967, “Reaction time and accuracy”, in Attention and Performance I, Ed. A. F. Sanders, Acta Psychologica, 27, 143–153
85.
ShephardMaxine, 1972, “Decision processes in perceptual organization: Effects of proximity and regularity on response frequency and latency”, in Pictorial Organization and Shape, Ed. O'CallaghanJ. F. (Division of Computing Research, C.S.I.R.O., Canberra, A.C.T.)
86.
SpitzH. H.BlackmanL. S., 1959, “A comparison of mental retardates and normals on visual figural after-effects and reversible figures”, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 58, 105–110
87.
SpitzH. H.LipmanR. S., 1962, “Some factors affecting Necker cube reversal rate”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 15, 611–625
88.
StoneM., 1960, “Models for reaction time”, Psychometrika, 25, 251–260
89.
TannerW. P.SwetsJ. A., 1954, “A decision-making theory of visual detection”, Psychological Review, 61, 401–409
90.
ThurstoneL. L., 1927a, “Psychophysical analysis”, American Journal of Psychology, 38, 368–389
91.
ThurstoneL. L., 1927b, “A law of comparative judgment”, Psychological Review, 34, 273–286
92.
ThurstoneL. L., 1944, A Factorial Study of Perception (University of Chicago Press, Chicago)
93.
ToriiS., 1960, “Figure–ground reversals under successively repeated observations”, Japanese Psychological Research, 9, 25–37
94.
TussingL., 1941, “Perceptual fluctuations of illusions as a possible fatigue index”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, 29, 85–88
95.
UlrichP.AmmonsR. B., 1959, “Voluntary control of perceived dimensionality (perspective) of three-dimensional objects”, Proceedings of the Montana Academy of Sciences, 19, 169–173
96.
UrbanF. M., 1910, “The method of constant stimuli and its generalizations”, Psychological Review, 17, 229–259
97.
VernonJ., 1963, Inside the Black Room (Clarkson N. Potter, New York)
98.
VickersD., 1970, “Evidence for an accumulator model of psychophysical discrimination”, in Current Problems in Perception, Eds. A. T. Welford, L. Houssiadas, Ergonomics, 13, 37–58
99.
VickersD., 1972a, “Decision processes in perceptual organisation”, in Pictorial Organization and Shape, Ed. O'CallaghanJ. F. (Division of Computing Research, C.S.I.R.O., Canberra, A.C.T.)
100.
VickersD., 1972b, “Some general features of perceptual organisation”, in Psychological Aspects of Driver Behaviour, Ed. AsmussenE. (Institute for Road Safety Research, S.W.O.V., Voorburg, Netherlands)
101.
VickersD.CaudreyD.WillsonR. J., 1971, “Discriminating between the frequency of occurrence of two alternative events”, Acta Psychologica, 35, 151–172
102.
VitzP. C.ToddT. C., 1971, “A model of the perception of simple geometric figures”, Psychological Review, 78, 207–228
103.
WashburnM. F.ReaganC.ThurstoneE., 1934, “The comparative controllability of the fluctuations of simple and complex ambiguous perspective figures”, American Journal of Psychology, 46, 636–638
104.
WelfordA. T., 1967, “Single-channel operation in the brain”, in Attention and Performance I, Ed. A. F. Sanders, Acta Psychologica, 27, 5–22
105.
WelfordA. T., 1968, Fundamentals of Skill (Methuen, London)
106.
WelfordA. T., 1969, “Age changes in discrimination, choice and control of movement: Nine years on”, Proceedings of the Eighth International Congress of Gerontology, Volume 1 (International Association of Gerontology, Washington, D.C.), pp. 461–464
107.
WertheimerM., 1938, “Laws of organization in perceptual forms”. Translation in A Source of Gestalt Psychology, Ed. EllisW. D. (Harcourt, Brace, New York)
108.
WertheimerM., 1955, “Figural after-effect as a measure of metabolic efficiency”, Journal of Personality, 24, 56–73
109.
WertheimerM.JacksonC. W., 1957, “Figural after-effects, ‘brain modifiability’, and schizophrenia: A further study”, Journal of General Psychology, 57, 45–54
110.
WertheimerM.WertheimerN., 1954, “A metabolic interpretation of individual differences in figural after-effects”, Psychological Review, 61, 279–280
111.
WielandB. A.MefferdR. B.Jr., 1966, “Effects of orientation, inclination, and length of diagonal on reversal rate of Necker cube”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 23, 823–826
112.
WielandB. A.MefferdR. B.Jr., 1967, “Individual differences in Necker cube reversal rates and perspective dominance”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 24, 923–930
113.
ZubekJ. P., 1969a, “Physiological and biochemical effects”, in Sensory Deprivation: Fifteen Years of Research, Ed. ZubekJ. P. (Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York)
114.
ZubekJ. P., 1969b, “Sensory and perceptual-motor processes”, in Sensory Deprivation: Fifteen Years of Research, Ed. ZubekJ. P. (Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York)
115.
ZubekJ. P.AftanasM.HasekJ.SansomW.SchludermannE.WilgoshL.WinocurG., 1962, “Intellectual and perceptual changes during prolonged perceptual deprivation: Low illumination and noise level”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 15, 171–198
116.
ZubekJ. P.AftanasM.KovachK.WilgoshL.WinocurG., 1963, “Effect of severe immobilization of the body on intellectual and perceptual processes”, Canadian Journal of Psychology, 17, 118–133
117.
ZubekJ. P.MacNeillM., 1966, “Effects of immobilization: Behavioural and EEG changes”, Canadian Journal of Psychology, 20, 316–336
118.
ZubekJ. P.PushkarD.SansomW.GowingJ., 1961, “Perceptual changes after prolonged sensory isolation (darkness and silence)”, Canadian Journal of Psychology, 15, 83–100
119.
ZubekJ. P.WilgoshL., 1963, “Prolonged immobilization of the body: Changes in performance and the electroencephalogram”, Science, 140, 306–308
120.
ZuckermanM., 1969, “Theoretical formulations: I”, in Sensory Deprivation: Fifteen Years of Research, Ed. ZubekJ. P. (Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York)
121.
ZuckermanM.PerskyH.HopkinsT. R.MurtaughT.BasuG. K.SchillingM., 1966, “Comparison of stress effects of perceptual and social isolation”, Archives of General Psychiatry, 14, 356–365
