This paper examines how rural communities on a clandestine road crossing the
Mexico—Guatemala border stake claim over this route while delegitimizing state control.
Each community delimits its control by erecting a cadena, or chain,
across its section of the road, from which it levies tolls on cross-border contraband. The
cadenas shape political, economic, and cultural geography by instituting a local sovereign
system of morality, economy, and legality. As border residents reimagine and rematerialize
the border by displacing it from the geopolitical line to their cadenas, they mark their
claims to this space. In a region where the majority of border flows occur through
clandestine routes, residents contest the power of the nation-state to determine the
border, sovereignty, belonging, and transregional development. Simultaneously, however,
residents' border practices mimetically reproduce the relation between territory, power,
and identity. I argue that the margins of the state can be critical junctures for
examining how everyday people and state actors continuously negotiate and reconfigure the
shifting materializations and meanings of territory, state power, and (trans)national
space.
ÁlvarezR
R, 1995, “The
Mexican—U.S. border: The making of the anthropology of borderlands”Annual Review of Anthropology24447–470
2.
AndreasP,
1999, “Smuggling wars: Law enforcement and law evasion in a
changing world”, in Transnational Crime in the Americas
Ed. FarerT
(Routledge, New York) pp
85–98
ÁngelesCruz
H, 2006, “La frontera sur de
México como region de destino, tránsito, y origen de migraciones
internacionales”, 2 December, presented at Convocatoria X Congreso
Internacional sobre Integración Regional, Fronteras, y Globalización en el Continente
Americano y VI Seminario Internacional de Análisís sobra la Frontera Sur de Mexico, 30
November–2 December, San Cristóbal de las Casas, Chiapas
5.
AppaduraiA,
1988, “Putting hierarchy in its place”Cultural Anthropology3(1) 36–49
6.
CastilloM
Á, 2003,
“Mexico—Guatemala border: New controls on transborder migration in view
of recent integration schemes?”Frontera Norte15(29)
35–65
7.
CohenJ H,
1999Cooperation and Community: Economy and Society in Oaxaca
(University of Texas Press, Austin,
TX)
8.
BurgueteCruz J
L, 1998_Identidades en
Fronteras, Fronteras en Identidades: Elogio a la Intensidad de los Tiempos en los
Pueblos de la Frontera Sur (El Colegio de
Mexico, Mexico City,
DF)
9.
De VosJ,
2002, “La frontera sur y sus fronteras: Unia visión
histórica”, in Identidades, Migraciones, y Género en la Frontera
Sur de México Eds KaufferMEdithF
(El Colegio de la Frontera Sur, San Cristóbal de las
Casas, Chiapas) pp
49–67
10.
DasVPooleD (Eds),
2004Anthropology in the Margins of the State (School of
American Research Press, Santa Fe,
NM)
11.
DonnanHWilsonT M,
1999Borders: Frontiers of Identity, Nation and State
(Berg,
Oxford)
12.
DonnanHWilsonT M
(Eds), 2010Ethnographic Approaches to Security, Power, and Identity
(University Press of America, Lanham,
MD)
13.
FergusonJGuptaA,
2002, “Spatializing states: Toward an ethnography of
neoliberal governmentality”American Ethnologist29981–1002
14.
FlynnD,
1997, “We are the border: Identity, exchange, and the state
along the Bénin—Nigeria boder”American Ethnologist24311–330
15.
GalembaR,
2012a, “Corn is food not contraband: The right to free trade
at the Mexico—Guatemala border”American Ethnologist39(4)
16.
GalembaR,
2012b, “Taking contraband seriously: Practicing ‘legitimate
business’ at the Mexico—Guatemala border”The Anthropology of Work Review33(1) 3–14
17.
GallantT
W, 1999, “Brigandage,
piracy, capitalism, and state-formation: Transnational crime from a historical
world-systems perspective”, in States and Illegal
Practices Ed. HeymanJ
McC (Berg,
Oxford) pp
25–62
18.
Hernández-CastilloR
A, 1992, “Los refugiados
guatemaltecos y la dinámica fronteriza en Chiapas”, in Una
Década de Refugio en México: Los Refugiados Guatemaltecos y los Derechos
Humanos (CIESAS, Tlalpan,
DF) pp 93–105
19.
Hernández-CastilloR
A, 2001Histories and Stories from Chiapas: Border Identities in Southern Mexico
(University of Texas Press, Austin,
TX)
20.
HeymanJ
McC, 1994, “The
Mexico—United States border in anthropology: A critique and
reformulation”Journal of Political Ecology143–64
21.
HeymanJ
McC (Ed.), 1999States and Illegal Practices (Berg,
Oxford)
22.
HolstonJ,
2008Insurgent Citizenship: Disjunctions of Democracy and Modernity in Brazil
(Princeton University Press, Princeton,
NJ)
23.
JosephG MNugentD (Eds),
1994Everyday Forms of State Formation: Revolution and Negotiation of Rule in Modern
Mexico (Duke University Press,
Durham, NC)
24.
KaufferEVelascoJ C
(Eds) 2002En el Camino de la Integración: Exrefugiados y Mexicanos en Chiapas
(El Colegio de la Frontera Sur, San Cristóbal de Las
Casas, Chiapas)
25.
LaneF,
1975Venice: A Maritime Republic (Johns Hopkins University
Press, Baltimore, MD)
26.
LevittP,
2001The Transnational Villagers (University of California
Press, Berkeley, CA)
27.
MalkkiL
H, 1995, “Refugees and
exile: From ‘refugee studies’ to the national order of things”Annual Review of Anthropology24495–523
ManzB,
2004Paradise in Ashes: A Guatemalan Journey of Courage, Terror, and Hope
(University of California Press,
Berkeley, CA)
30.
MasseyD,
1993, “Power-geometry and a progressive sense of
place”, in Mapping the Futures: Local Cultures, Global
Change Eds BirdJCurtisBPutnamTRobertsonGTicknerL
(Routledge, New York) pp
60–70
31.
MontejoV,
1999Voices from Exile: Violence and Survival in Modern Maya History
(University of Oklahoma Press, Norman,
OK)
32.
NevinsJ,
2002Operation Gatekeeper: The Rise of the ‘Illegal Alien’ and the Making of the
U.S.–Mexico Boundary (Routledge,
New York)
33.
RoitmanJ,
2004, “Productivity in the margins: The reconstitution of
state power in the Chad Basin”, in Anthropology in the Margins
of the State Eds DasVPooleD
(School of American Research Press,
Santa Fe, NM) pp
191–224
34.
RoitmanJ,
2005Fiscal Disobedience: An Anthropology of Economic Regulation in Central
Africa (Princeton University Press,
Princeton, NJ)
35.
RusJVigilD,
2007, “Rapid urbanization and migrant indigenous youth in
San Cristóbal, Chiapas, Mexico”, in Gangs in the Global City:
Alternatives to Traditional Criminology Ed. HagedornJ
M (University of Illinois
Press, Champaign, IL) pp
152–184
36.
SackR D,
1986Human Territoriality: Its Theory and History (Cambridge
University Press,
Cambridge)
37.
SahlinsP,
1989Boundaries: The Making of France and Spain in the Pyrenees
(University of California Press,
Berkeley, CA)
38.
ScottJ C,
2009The Art of Not Being Governed: An Anarchist History of Upland Southeast
Asia (Yale University Press,
New Haven, CT)
39.
SmartASmartJ,
2008, “Time-space punctuation: Hong Kong's border regime and
limits on mobility”Pacific Affairs81175–193
40.
TaussigM,
1993Mimesis and Alterity (Routledge,
New York)
41.
TillyC,
1985, “War making and state making as organized
crime”, in Bringing the State Back In Eds EvansPRueschemeyerDSkocpolT
(Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge) pp
169–191
42.
TrouillotM-R,
2001, “The anthropology of the state in the age of
globalization: Closed encounters of the deceptive kind”Current Anthropology42125–138
43.
Van SchendelWAbrahamI
(Eds), 2005Illicit Flows and Criminal Things: States, Borders, and the Other Sides of
Globalization (Indiana University Press,
Bloomington, IN)
44.
SolisVillafuerte DSolanoLeyva X
(Eds), 2006Geoeconomía y geopolitica en el área del Plan Puebla-Panamá
(CIESAS, Mexico City,
DF)
45.
WilkieWallace JMeyerM Cde WilkieMonzón
E, 1976Contemporary Mexico: Papers of the 4th International Congress of Mexican
History (University of California Press,
Berkeley, CA)
46.
WilsonT MDonnanH (Eds),
1998Border Identities: Nation and State at International Frontiers
(Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge)
