Recalling Tony Bennett's plea for a more ‘prosaic’ cultural studies, this paper proposes a redefinition of the concept ‘third space’ as a prosaic space of policy and governmentality. Based on field research in rural China, where cultural heritage has become a central resource in economic development, the paper argues that cultural development cannot be relied upon to produce spaces of resistance, empowerment, or ‘sustainability’. This is, in part, because cultural development tends to conceive of cultural spaces as ‘rooted’ rather than as spaces of translocality. While third space offers an attractive alternative to such a conceptualization, it remains vulnerable to the same alienating spatial abstractions as found in the practices of cultural development. The paper seeks to maintain the critical focus of third space while redefining it in more prosaic terms to better reflect the everyday governmentalized spaces of culture within which people live.
BakkenB, 2000The Exemplary Society: Human Improvement, Social Control, and the Dangers of Modernity in China (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
3.
BarnettC, 2001, “Culture, geography, and the arts of government”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space197–24
4.
BenhabibS, 2002The Claims of Culture: Equality and Diversity in the Global Era (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
5.
BennettT, 1998Culture: A Reformer's Science (Sage, London)
6.
BhabhaH, 1994The Location of Culture (Routledge, London)
7.
BollierD, 2002Silent Theft: The Private Plunder of our Common Wealth (Routledge, London)
8.
ChenJHuB Eds, 1996Dangdai Zhongguo de Cunzhuang Jingji yu Cunluo Wenhua [Village economy and culture in contemporary China]8 volumes (Shanxi Jingji Chubanshe, Taiyuan)
9.
CliffordJ, 1988The Predicament of Culture: 20th Century Ethnography, Literature, and Art (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
10.
CliffordJ, 1997Routes: Travel and Translation in the Late 20th Century (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
11.
DuaraP, 2000, “Local worlds: the poetics and politics of the native place in modern China”South Atlantic Quarterly99(1) 13–45
12.
FengC, 1999, “Jiangxi in reform: the fear of exclusion and the search for a new identity”, in The Political Economy of China's Provinces Eds HendrischkeHFengC (Routledge, London) pp 249–276
13.
GoodmanD S G, 2002, “Structuring local identity: nation, province, and county in Shanxi during the 1990s”The China Quarterlynumber 172, 837–862
14.
GuoY, 2004Cultural Nationalism in Contemporary China: The Search for National Identity Under Reform (Routledge, London)
15.
GuptaAFergusonJ, Eds, 1997Culture, Power, Place: Explorations in Critical Anthropology (Duke University Press, Durham, NC)
16.
HoffmanL, 2006, “Urban transformation and professionalization: translocality and rationalities of enterprise in post-Mao China”, in Translocal China: Linkages, Identities, and the Reimagining of Space Eds OakesTScheinL (Routledge, London) pp 109–137
17.
HolmD, 2003, “The death of Tiaoxi (the ‘leaping play’): ritual theater in the northwest of China”Modern Asian Studies37863–884
18.
JunkaL, 2006, “Camping in the third space: agency, representation, and the politics of Gaza Beach”Public Culture18349–359
19.
KeaneM, 2004, “Bringing culture back in”, in Governance in China Ed. HowellJ. (Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, MD) pp 77–96
20.
KeaneM, 2007, Created in China: The New Great Leap Forward (Routledge, London)
21.
LessigL, 2004Free Culture: How Big Media Uses Technology and the Law to Lock Down Culture and Control Creativity (Penguin, London)
22.
LinMGalikowskiM, 1999The Search for Modernity: Chinese Intellectuals and Cultural Discourse in the Post-Mao Era (St Martin's Press, New York)
23.
MaH, 2004Xiuxian: Renlei Meili de Jingshen Jiayuan [Leisure: the beautiful spiritual garden for humanity] (Zhongguo Jingji Chubanshe, Beijing)
24.
MatarassoF, (Ed.), 2001ecognizing Culture: A Series of Briefing Papers on Culture and Development (Comedia and UNESCO, London)
25.
MitchellK, 1997, “Different diasporas and the hype of hybridity”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space15533–553
26.
OakesT, 2000, “China's provincial identities: reviving regionalism and reinventing ‘Chineseness’”The Journal of Asian Studies59667–692
27.
OakesT, 2005, “The story of secretary Wang—hero, savior, liar, scoundrel”, in Narratives of the Chinese Economic Reform: Individual Pathways from Plan to Market Ed. SolingerD (Mellen, Lewiston, NY) pp 49–68
28.
OakesT, 2006, “Cultural strategies of development: implications for village governance in China”Pacific Review19(1) 13–37
29.
OakesTScheinL, (Eds), 2006Translocal China: Linkages, Identities, and the Reimagining of Space (Routledge, London)
30.
OakesTWuX, (Eds), 2007Tunpu Chongsu: Guizhou Wenhua Luyou yu Shehui Bianqian [Reinventing Tunpu: cultural tourism and social change in Guizhou] (Guizhou Minzu Chubanshe, Guiyang)
31.
PunN, 2003, “Subsumption or consumption? The phantom of consumer revolution in ‘globalizing’ China”Cultural Anthropology18469–492
32.
RadcliffeSLaurieN, 2006, “Culture and development: taking culture seriously in development for Andean indigenous people”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space24231–248
33.
RohterL, 2007, “Brazilian government invests in culture of hip-hop”The New York Times 14 March
ShenS, 2002, “Kaifa de Tunpu Guzhen” [A developed ancient tunpu village]Guizhou Ribao [Guizhou Daily] 7 April
36.
SojaE, 1996Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-imagined Places (Blackwell, Oxford)
37.
The Ecologist1993Whose Common Future? Reclaiming the Commons (Earthscan, London)
38.
ThogersenS, 2002, “Village economy and culture in contemporary China”Modern China28(2) 253–274
39.
TongE, 1989, “Morgan's model and the study of ancient Chinese society”Social Sciences in China Summer, 182–205
40.
TönniesF, 1957Community and Society [Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft] translated by LoomisC P (Michigan State University Press, East Lansing, MI)
41.
TsingA, 2005Friction: An Ethnography of Global Connection (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
42.
UrryJ, 2000Sociology Beyond Societies: Mobilities for the Twenty-first Century (Routledge, London)
43.
WangD, 2003Street Culture in Chengdu: Public Space, Urban Commoners, and Local Politics, 1870 – 1930 (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
44.
WangH, 1998, “Contemporary Chinese thought and the question of Chinese modernity”Social Text16(2) 9–44
45.
WangJ, 2001, “Culture as leisure and culture as capital”positions9(1) 69–104
46.
WangJ, 2003, “Framing policy research on Chinese ‘culture industry’: cultural goods, market-state relations, and the international free trade regime”, paper presented at the Workshop on Critical Policy Studies, Cambridge, MA, 15 – 16 November
WengJ no date, “Tunpuren jiqi jingshen wenming” [Tunpu people and spiritual civilization]”, unpublished manuscript, Guizhou Minzu Yanjiusuo, Guiyang
49.
XuB, 1998, “‘From modernity to Chineseness’: the rise of nativist cultural theory in post-1989 China”positions6(1) 203–237
50.
YanH, 2003, “Neoliberal governmentality and neohumanism: organizing suzhi /value flow through labor recruitment networks”Cultural Anthropology18493–523
51.
YanR, 1989, “A living fossil of the family—a study of the family structure of the Naxi nationality in the Lugu Lake region”Social Sciences in China3(4) 60–83
52.
YiL, 2002Yelang Shenmi: Gu Yelang, Jin Guizhou [The mystery of Yelang: ancient Yelang, modern Guizhou] (Guizhou Minzu Chubanshe, Guiyang)
53.
YúdiceG, 2003The Expediency of Culture: Uses of Culture in the Global Era (Duke University Press, Durham, NC)
ZhangX, (Ed.), 1998, “Intellectual politics in post-Tiananmen China”Social Text16(2) 1–140
56.
ZhangZ, 1996Hunan Sheng Yongshun Xian Heping Shuangfeng Cun Tujiazu Maogusi Yishi (Minsu Chuyi Congshu 47) [Maogusi rituals in Heping Shuangfeng, Yongshun, Hunan (Customs and Folk Arts Series 47)] (Shih Ho-cheng Folk Culture Foundation, Taibei)
ZhouZ, 1996, “Dixi qiyuan yice” [Conjecture on the origin of dixi], in Sui Wu Ya zhi Lu [Journeys beyond the horizon] (Sanlian Shudian, Shanghai) pp 335–340
