In this paper I seek to unfold the place of landed property within Japan's postwar uneven development and the way in which this found expression in the 1980s real-estate ‘bubble’ and subsequent 1990s banking crisis. I argue that landed property was both internal to and constitutive of the social relations that marked the specificity of Japan's postwar capitalism. As a national state within the accumulation of global capital, however, Japan's specificity only existed as ‘difference-in-unity’. Furthermore, I suggest that the 1980s real-estate ‘bubble’ and 1990s banking crisis were specific and culminating expressions of changes within the form of those social relations, as mediated by Japan's changing position within the process of global uneven development. Important in this respect was the way in which credit, fictitious capital, and spatial restructuring became precarious expressions of attempts to achieve a temporal and spatial displacement of crisis.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenJMasseyDCochraneA, 1998Rethinking the Region (Routledge, London).
2.
AnchordoguyM, 1992, “Land policy: A public policy failure”, in Land Issues in Japan: A Policy Failure? Eds HaleyJ OYamamuraK (Society for Japanese Studies, Seattle, WA) pp 77–111.
3.
AsaiHTazakiSFukunagaH, 1995, “The end of the post-war banking system?”Tokyo Business Today634–9.
4.
AsherD L, 1995, “Why Japan needs a collapse”International Economy July/August, 23–27, 61–66.
5.
AsherD L, 1996, “What became of the Japanese ‘miracle’”Orbis Spring, 215–234.
6.
BabbJ, 1995, “Japan's Ministry of Finance and the politics of complicity”Review of International Political Economy2536–560.
7.
BacowL S, 1990, “The Tokyo land market: An essay”, WP26, Center for Real Estate Development, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA.
8.
BeaverstockJ VDoelM A, 2001, “Unfolding the spatial architecture of the East Asian financial crisis: The organizational response of global investment banks”Geoforum3215–32.
9.
BernardMRavenhillJ, 1995, “Beyond product cycles and flying geese: Regionalisation, hierarchy and the industrialisation of East Asia”World Politics47171–209.
10.
BonefeldW, 1995, “Monetarism and crisis”, in Global Capital, National State and the Politics of Money Eds BonefeldWHollowayJ (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 35–68.
11.
BonefeldW, 2000, “The spectre of globalisation: On the form and content of the world market”, in The Politics of Change: Globalisation, Ideology and Critique Eds BonefeldWPsychopedisK (Palgrave, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 31–68.
12.
BrennerN, 1998, “Between fixity and motion: Accumulation, territorial organization and the historical geography of spatial scales”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space16459–481.
13.
BuddL, 1999, “Globalisation and the crisis of territorial embeddedness of international financial markets”, in Money and the Space Economy Ed. MartinR (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 115–137.
14.
BurkettPHart-LandsbergM, 2000Development, Crisis and Class Struggle: Learning from Japan and East Asia (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants).
15.
BurnhamP, 1997, “Globalisation: States, markets and class relations”Historical Materialismnumber 1, 150–160.
16.
CallinicosA, 1998, “World capitalism at the abyss”International Socialism813–43.
17.
ClarkeS, 1990, “Crisis of socialism or crisis of the state”Capital and Classnumber 42, 19–29.
18.
ClarkeS, 1992, “The global accumulation of capital and the periodisation of the capitalist state form”, in Open Marxism, Volume 1 Eds BonefeldWGunnRPsychopedisK (Pluto, London) pp 133–150.
19.
CoakleyJ, 1994, “The integration of property and financial markets”Environment and Planning A26697–713.
20.
ColhngeC, 1999, “Self-organisation of society by scale: A spatial reworking of regulation theory”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17557–574.
21.
CuttsR L, 1990, “Power from the ground up: Japan's land bubble”Harvard Business Review May—June,164–172.
DeheshAPughC, 1999, “The internationalisation of post-1980 property cycles and the Japanese ‘bubble’ economy 1986–96”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research23147–164.
24.
DoelM, 1999Poststructuralist Geographies (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh).
25.
DouglasM, 1988, “The transnationalisation of urbanisation in Japan”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research12425–454.
26.
DouglasM, 1993, “The ‘new’ Tokyo story: Restructuring space and the struggle for place in a world city”, in Japanese Cities in the World Economy Eds FujitaKHillR C (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA) pp 85–115.
27.
FarrellR S, 2000A Yen for Real Estate: Japanese Real Estate Investment Abroad-From Boom to Bust (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos).
28.
Focus Japan1998, “Overseas companies bullish on Japanese real estate”25 part 5, pp 1–5.
29.
FukaiS, 1990, “Japan's land policy and its global impact”, OP90–01 US-Japan Relations Programme, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
30.
FukuokaS, 1997, “The structure of urban land administration during the bubble economy: Control systems and their operations”Comprehensive Urban Studiesnumber 62, 165–179.
31.
GunnR, 1987, “Practical reflexivity in Marx”Common Sense139–51.
32.
HalhdayJ, 1978A Political History of Japanese Capitalism (Monthly Review Press, New York).
33.
HarveyD, 1989aThe Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change (Blackwell, Oxford).
HayakawaKHirayamaY, 1991, “The impact of the minkatsu policy on Japanese housing and land use”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space9151–164.
36.
HillCFujitaK, 1993, “Japanese cities in the world economy”, in Japanese Cities in the World Economy Eds FujitaKHillR C (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA).
HollowayJ, 2000, “Zapata in Wall Street”, in The Politics of Change: Globalisation, Ideology and Critique Eds BonefeldWPsychopedisK (Palgrave, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 173–195.
39.
IkedaS, 1994, “Japanese accumulation structure and the postwar world-system”Social Justice2124–49.
40.
IMF, International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC.
41.
IMF, International Monetary Fund, 1977International Financial Statistics, Volume 30.
42.
IMF, International Monetary Fund, 1980International Financial Statistics, Volume 33.
43.
IMF, International Monetary Fund, 1985International Financial Statistics, Volume 38.
44.
IMF, International Monetary Fund, 1986International Financial Statistics, Volume 39.
45.
IMF, International Monetary Fund, 1990International Financial Statistics, Volume 43.
46.
IMF, International Monetary Fund, 1995International Financial Statistics, Volume 48.
47.
IMF, International Monetary Fund, 2001International Financial Statistics, Volume 54.
48.
IshibashiI, 1999, “Sudden land value decrease and land assessment in Tokyo”, paper presented to the 1999 International Conference on Assessment Administrators, Las Vegas, September 1999http://www.reinet.or.jp/study/eng/6-lecture/6B-Iaao1999.pdf.
49.
ItoTHironoK N, 1993, “Efficiency of the Tokyo housing market”Bank of Japan Economic Studies111–32.
50.
ItoTIwaisakoT, 1996, “Expanding asset bubbles in Japan”Bank of Japan Monetary and Economic Studies14143–193.
51.
ItohM, 1990The World Economic Crisis and Japanese Capitalism (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants).
52.
ItohM, 1994, “Is the Japanese economy in crisis?”Review of International Political Economy129–51.
53.
JenkinsK, 1995On What is History: From Carr and Elton to Rorty and White (Routledge, London).
54.
WoottenJones Lang, 1985, International Property Review 1985Jones Lang Wootten Vizuäl, Inc., Crossroads of Dulles, 1041 Sterling Road, Suite 206, Herndon, VA 20170.
55.
WoottenJones Lang, 1996Asia Pacific Property Digest, April 1996Jones Lang Wootten Vizuäl, Inc., Crossroads of Dulles, 1041 Sterling Road, Suite 206, Herndon, VA 20170.
56.
JujitaK, 1991, “A world city and flexible specialisation: Restructuring of the Tokyo metropolis”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research15269–284.
57.
KanemotoY, 1997, “The housing question in Japan”Regional Science and Urban Economics27613–641.
58.
KatzR, 1998Japan: The System that Soured (M E Sharpe, New York).
59.
KennedyDMatsuoM, 1996, “The key issues behind Japanese disinvestment of US real estate in the 1990s”The Real Estate Finance Journal116–16.
60.
KirwanR M, 1987, “Fiscal policy and the price of land and housing in Japan”Urban Studies24345–360.
61.
Knight Frank Baillieu International, 1989Pacific Property Report 1989Knight Frank Baillieu International, 20 Hanover Square, London W1F S1HZ.
62.
KolkoG, 1968The Politics of War: The World and United States Foreign Policy, 1943–1945 (Random House, New York).
63.
KolkoJKolkoG, 1972The Limits of Power: The World and United States Foreign Policy 1945 – 1954 (Harper and Row, New York).
64.
KudoY, 1995, “No bottom in sight”Tokyo Business Today63 (11) 10–15.
65.
LapavitsasC, 1997, “Transition and crisis in the Japanese financial system: An analytical overview”Capital and Classnumber 62, 21–47.
66.
LeeJ, 1997, “The ‘crisis’ of non-performing loans: A crisis for the Japanese financial system?The Pacific Review10 (1) 57–83.
67.
LewisM K, 1994, “The Japanese financial system after liberalisation”, Discussion Papers in Economics number 94/11, University of Nottingham, Nottingham.
68.
LeyshonA, 1994, “Under pressure: Finance, geo-economic competition and the rise and fall of Japan's postwar growth economy”, in Money Power and Space Eds CorbridgeSThriftNMartinR (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 116–145.
69.
LidaM, 1994, “The fall of the 1955 system in Japanese politics and the current crisis of hegemony”Social Justice21 (2) 50–61.
70.
MachimuraT, 1992, “The urban restructuring process in Tokyo in the 1980s: Transforming Tokyo into a world city”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16114–128.
71.
McKinnonR IOhnoK, 1997Dollar and Yen: Resolving Economic Conflict Between the United States and Japan (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
72.
MarxK, 1959Capital: Volume 3 (Lawrence and Wishart, London).
73.
MasahiroK, 1998, “Japan as a creditor nation: What is happening to its net external assets?, in The Political Economy of Japanese Society: Volume 2–International and Domestic Issues Ed. BannoJ (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 8–37.
74.
MasseyD, 1999, “Imagining globalisations: Power-geometries of time-space”, in Global Futures: Migration, Environment and Globalisation Eds BrahAHickmanM JMacAnghailM (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 27–44.
75.
MerrifieldA, 1993a, “Place and space: A Lefebvrian reconciliation”Transactions of the British Institute of Geographers, New Series18516–531.
76.
MerrifieldA, 1993b, “The Canary Wharf debacle: From ‘TINA’—there is no alternative-to ‘THEMBA’—there must be an alternative”Environment and Planning A251247–1265.
77.
MerrifieldA, 2000, “Phantoms and spectres: Capital and labour at the millennium”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1815–36.
78.
MincaC (Ed.), 2001Postmodern Geography: Theory and Praxis (Blackwell, Oxford).
79.
MiyamotoK, 1993, “Japan's world cities: Osaka and Tokyo compared”, in Japanese Cities in the World Economy Eds FujitaKHillR C (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA).
80.
MurphyR T, 1996The Real Price of Japanese Money (Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London).
81.
NakajimaZTaguchiH, 1995, “Toward a more stable financial framework: Long-term alternatives-an overview of recent bank disruption worldwide”, in Financial Stability in a Changing Environment Eds SawamotoKNakajimaZTaguchiH (St Martin's Press, New York) pp 41–98.
82.
NoguchiT, 1992, “Land problems and policies in Japan: Structural aspects”, in Land Issues in Japan: A Policy Failure? Eds HaleyJ OYamamuraK (Society for Japanese Studies, Washington, DC) pp 11–32.
83.
NoguchiY, 1994, “The ‘bubble’ and economic policies in the 1980s”Journal of Japanese Studies20291–329.
84.
OizumiE, 1994, “Property finance in Japan: Expansion and collapse of the bubble economy”Environment and Planning A26199–213.
85.
OkumuraH, 1999, “Japan's corporate capitalism in peril”, in The Transformation of the Japanese Economy Ed. SatoK (M E Sharpe, New York) pp 115–135.
86.
Ould-MeyM, 1999, “The new global command economy”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17155–180.
87.
PempelT J, 1996/97, “Gulliver in Lilliput: Japan and Asian economic regionalism”World Policy Journal12(4)13–26.
RowleyA, 1998b, “Japan's banks lift the veil to show a 26% rise in NPLS”The Banker August, page 4.
93.
RowleyA, 1998c, “Obuchi criticised over bank plan compromise”The Banker October, pages 14–16.
94.
RowleyA, 1998d“Obuchi wraps up a package to help banks”The Banker November, page 8.
95.
RowleyA, 1998e, “Bridge plan to nowhere”The Banker August, pages 26–29.
96.
RyttingJ, 1989, “Class struggle in Japan”Against the Current4 (1) 26–29.
97.
SakaiyaT, 1999a, “The Japan of tomorrow, different from today”, speech at Center for Strategic and International Studies, Washington, DC, April, http://www.epa.go.jp/99b/19990430b-daijin-e.html.
98.
SakaiyaT, 1999b, “The present and future of the Japanese economy”, speech by Minister of State, Economic Planning Agency, Government of Japan given in Singapore, 1 September, http://wwwepa.go.jp/99b/19990903b-daijinkouen-e.html.
99.
Sankyo Estates, 1998Tokyo Building and Office Rent Data 1998Sankyo Estate Co Ltd, Tokyo.
100.
SassenS, 1991The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
101.
SeguchiTMaloneP, 1996, “Tokyo: Waterfront development and social needs”, in City, Capital and Water Ed. MaloneP (Routledge, London).
102.
ShibataY, 1995, “Coming soon: A whole new bank credit system for Japan”Global Finance9 part 8, 58–59.
103.
SmithN, 1984Uneven Development: Nature, Capital and the Production of Space (Blackwell, Oxford).
104.
SojaE W, 2001a, “Afterword”, in Postmodern Geography: Theory and Praxis Ed. MincaC (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 282–294.
105.
SojaE W, 2001b, “Exploring the postmetropolis”, in Postmodern Geography: Theory and Praxis Ed. MincaC (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 37–56.
106.
SorensenA, 1999, “Land readjustment, urban planning and urban sprawl in the Tokyo Metropolitan Area”Urban Studies362333–2360.
107.
StevenR, 1988, “The high yen crisis in Japan”Capital and Classnumber 34, 76–118.
108.
StoneDZiembaW T, 1993, “Land and stock prices in Japan”Journal of Economic Perspectives7(3)149–165.
109.
StrangeS, 1998Mad Money (Manchester University Press, Manchester).
110.
SwyngedouwE, 1997, “Neither global nor local: ‘globalization’ and the politics of scale”, in Spaces of Globalization: Reasserting the Power of the Local Ed. CoxK R (Guilford Press, New York) pp 137–166.
111.
SwyngedouwE, 2000, “Authoritarian governance, power, and the politics of rescaling”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1863–76.
112.
TaniguchiT, 1993, Japan's Banks and the Bubble Economy' of the Late 1980s Center of International Studies Program on US — Japan Relations monograph series number 4, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ.
113.
TanterR, 1998, “Japan incorporated: Drowning, waving or considering its options?”Arena Journalnumber 10, 15–26.
114.
The Bank of Japan, 1990, “The recent rise in Japan's land prices: Its background and implications”, special paper number 193, Research and Statistics Department, The Bank of Japan, Tokyo.
115.
The Banker1994a, “The suits have it”, July, pages 116–119.
116.
The Banker1994b, “A real mess”, September, pages 61–62.
117.
The Banker1995a, “Tokyo's panic button”, July, pages 109–112.
118.
The Banker1995b, “Pain in store”, January, pages 44–47.
119.
The Banker1997, “Japanese system looks to throw off bad debts”, October, page 13.
120.
The Economist1994, “Why America's levers will not shift leverage Japan”330 (7849) 73.
121.
ThriftN, 1998, “Distance is not a safety zone but a field of tension: Mobile geographies and world cities”, in Timing Global Cities Eds GranesteijnS G Evan GriensvenSde SmidtM C (Vereniging van Utrechtse Geografie Studenten, Koninklijk Nederlands Aardrijkskundig Genootschapl) pp 54–66.
122.
TsuruS, 1993Japan's Capitalism: Creative Defeat and Beyond (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
123.
WarfB, 1988, “Japanese investments in the New York metropolitan region”Geographical Review78257–271.
124.
WernerR A, 1994, “Japanese foreign investment and the ‘land bubble’”Review of International Economics2 (2) 166–178.
125.
WhittakerD HKurosawaY, 1998, “Japan's crisis: Evolution and implications”Cambridge Journal of Economics22761–771.
126.
WilsonD, 1991, “Urban change, circuits of capital, and uneven development”The Professional Geographer43403–415.
127.
WoodC, 1992The Bubble Economy: The Japanese Economic Collapse (Sidgwick and Jackson, London).
128.
WoodC, 1994The End of Japan Inc.: And How the New Japan Will Look (Simon and Schuster, New York).
129.
WoodallB, 1992, “Land policy: A public policy failure”, in Land Issues in Japan: A Policy Failure? Eds HaleyJ OYamamuraK Y (Society for Japanese Studies, Washington, DC) pp 113–148.
130.
WoodallB, 1996Japan Under Construction: Corruption, Politics, and Public Works (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
131.
YaginumaH, 1999, “The keiretsu issue: A theoretical approach”, in The Transformation of the Japanese Economy Ed. SatoK (M E Sharpe, New York).
132.
YamamuraK, 1992, “LDP dominance and high land price in Japan: A study in positive political economy”, in Land Issues in Japan: A Policy Failure? Eds HaleyJ OYamamuraK (Society for Japanese Studies, Washington, DC) pp 33–75.
133.
YonosukeI, 1998, “The problem of land use and land prices”, in The Political Economy of Japanese Society: Volume 2—International and Domestic Issues Ed. JunjiB (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 231–244.
