Gradually, then, it has become clear to me what I am trying to do. I want to provide a body of work which values creative praxis. This will not be easy as—with a few exceptions—most academics nowadays still tend towards impoverished views of praxis which leave remarkably little room for creative exorbitance. Thus, for example, many modern social and cultural theorists would find it difficult to understand the import of Wittgenstein's famous question, “what remains over from the fact that I raise my arm when I subtract the fact that my arm goes up?” In effect, what I attempt to provide is the beginnings of an answer to this question. In the first part of the paper I am therefore concerned with an account of a style of thinking which I call nonrepresentationalist. In the second part of the paper I then broaden the discourse by considering the ways in which this style of work might be linked to other developments in the social sciences and humanities grouped around the notion and the motion of performance. In the third part I consider one particular mode of performance—dance—as illustration of some of the steps I have traced out. Some tentative conclusions follow.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AaltenK, 1997, “Performing the body, creating culture”, in Embodied Practices, Feminist Perspectives on the Body Ed. DavisK (Sage, London) pp 41–58
2.
AbercrombieNLonghurstB, 1998Audiences: A Sociological Theory of Performance and ImaginationSage, London)
3.
AlbrightA C, 1989, “Mining the dance field: spectacle, moving subjects and feminist theory”'Contact Quarterly1223–47
4.
AlbrightA C, 1997Choreographing Difference: The Body and Identity in Contemporary DanceWesleyan University Press, Hanover, NH)
5.
Ansell-PearsonK, 1997Viroid Life: Perspectives on Nietzsche and the Transhuman ConditionRoutledge, London)
6.
AuslanderP, 1999LivenessRoutledge, London)
7.
BatesonG, 1973Steps to an Ecology of MindPaladin Books, London)
8.
BarryA, 2000, “Air”, in City A-Z Eds PileSThriftN J (Routledge, London)
9.
BayerB, 1998, “Between apparatus and apparitions: phantoms of the laboratory”, in Reconstructing the Psychological Subject: Bodies, Practices and Technologies Eds BayerBShotterJ (Sage, London) pp 187–213
10.
BernsteinM A, 1994Foregone Conclusions: Against Apocalyptic HistoryUniversity of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
11.
BilligM, 1999Freudian Repression: Conversation Creating the UnconsciousCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
12.
BoalF, 1998Legislative TheatreRoutledge, London)
13.
BourdieuP, 1991The Logic of PracticePolity Press, Cambridge)
14.
BradleyB, 1998, “Two ways to talk about change”, in Reconstructing the Psychological Subject: Bodies, Practices and Technologies Eds BayerBShotterJ (Sage, London) pp 68–93
15.
BrentanoA, 1994PerformanceDuke University Press, Durham, NC)
16.
BurnsT, 1992Erving GoffmanRoutledge, London)
17.
ButlerJ, 1990aGender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of IdentityRoutledge, New York)
18.
ButlerJ, 1990b, “Performative acts and gender constitution: an essay in phenomenology and feminist theory”, in Performing Feminisms: Feminist Critical Theory and Theatre Ed. CaseS (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 26–35
CaseS, 1998, “Tracking the vampire”Differences31–17
22.
CastoriadisC, 1997World in Fragments: Writings on Politics, Society, Psychoanalysis and the ImaginationStamford University Press, Stamford, CA)
23.
CaygillH, 1998Walter Benjamin: The Colour of ExperienceRoutledge, London)
24.
ChadwickWde CourtivronI, 1993Significant Others: Creativity and Intimate PartnershipThames and Hudson, London)
25.
Cohen-CruzJ (Ed.), 1998Radical Street PerformanceRoutledge, London)
26.
ConnorS, 1996, “Postmodern performance”, in Analysing Performance: A Critical Reader Ed. CampbellP (Manchester University Press, Manchester) pp 107–124
27.
CrangP, 1997, “Performing the tourist product”, in Touring Cultures Eds RojekCUrryJ (Routledge, London) pp 137–154
28.
DeleuzeG, 1986The Movement ImageUniversity of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
29.
DeleuzeG, 1994Difference and RepetitionAthlone Press, London)
30.
DeleuzeG, 1995Negotiations, 1972–1990Columbia University Press, New York)
31.
DeleuzeG, 1997aEssays Critical and ClinicalUniversity of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
32.
DeleuzeG, 1997b, “One less manifesto”, in Mimesis, Masochism, Mime. The Politics of Theatricality in Contemporary French Thought Ed. MurrayT (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI) pp 239–258
33.
DeningG, 1996PerformancesUniversity of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
34.
DesmondJ C (Ed.), 1997Meaning in Motion: New Cultural Studies of DanceDuke University Press, Durham, NC)
35.
DolanJ (Ed.), 1993Presence and Desire: Essays on Gender, Sexuality and PerformanceUniversity of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI)
36.
EcoU, 1989The Aesthetics of ChaosmosHarvard University Press, Cambridge, M A)
37.
EdwardsJ, 1995Discursive PsychologySage, London)
38.
EldridgeJ, 1998Transforming Experience: John Dewey's Cultural InstrumentalismVanderbilt University Press, Nashville, TN)
39.
EmersonR W, 1942, “Experience”, in Essays (Everyman, London) pp 26–43
40.
EnglemannP, 1967Letters from Ludwig Wittgenstein, with a MemoirBlackwell, Oxford)
41.
FarnellB, 1994, “Ethnographics and the moving body”Man, New Series29929–974
42.
FosterS L (Ed.), 1995Choreographing HistoryIndiana University Press, Bloomington, IN)
43.
FoucaultM, 1984, Collège de France lecture, 14 March 1984, cited in Practising Philosophy. Pragmatism and the Philosophical LifeShustermanR (Routledge, New York) pp 176–177
44.
FoucaultM, 1986The Care of the Self: The History of Sexuality, Volume 3Pantheon Books, New York)
45.
FraleighS H, 1987Dance and the Lived Body: A Descriptive AestheticsUniversity of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PA)
46.
FrankoM, 1993Dance as Text: Ideologies of the Baroque BodyCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
47.
FrithS, 1997Performing RitesOxford University Press, Oxford)
GaneM, 1993Harmless Lovers? Gender Theory and Personal RelationshipsRoutledge, London)
50.
GellA, 1998Art and AgencyBlackwell, Oxford)
51.
GeorgeL, 1998, “Artists incorporating: business savvy meets creative experimentation”, in Corporate Futures: The Diffusion of the Culturally Sensitive Corporate Form Ed. MarcusG E (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 311–336
52.
GibsonA, 1996Towards a Postmodern Theory of NarrativeEdinburgh University Press, Edinburgh)
53.
GilJ, 1998Metamorphoses of the BodyUniversity of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
54.
GlendinningS, 1998On Being with Others, Heidegger, Derrida, WittgensteinRoutledge, London)
55.
GoffmanA, 1971The Production of Self in Everyday LifePenguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
GordonA, 1997Ghostly Matters: Haunting and the Sociological ImaginationUniversity of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
58.
GregoryD, 1997, “Lacan and geography: the Production of Space revisited”, in Space and Social Theory: Interpreting Modernity and Postmodernity Eds BenkoGStrohmayerU (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 203–234
HetheringtonK, 1997, “In place of geometry: the materiality of place”, in Ideas of Difference: Social Spaces and The Labour of Division Eds HetheringtonKMunroR (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 183–199
61.
HolzmanFNewmanL, 1997The End of Knowing: A New Developmental Way of LearningRoutledge, New York)
62.
JanikAToulminS, 1973Wittgenstein's ViennaTouchstone, New York)
63.
JoasH, 1996The Creativity of ActionPolity Press, Cambridge)
64.
KempS, 1996, “Reading difficulties”, in Analysing Performance: A Critical Reader Ed. CampbellP (Manchester University Press, Manchester) pp 153–174
65.
KershawB, 1994, “Framing the audience for theatre”, in The Authority of the Consumer Eds KeatRWhiteleyNAbercrombieN (Routledge, London) pp 120–136
66.
KirbyV, 1997Forgetting FleshRoutledge, London)
67.
KofmanELebasE, 1995, “Lost in transposition—time, space and the city”, in Writings on CitiesLefebvreH (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 3–100
68.
KroghGRoosJ, 1995Managing KnowledgeSage, London)
69.
KuchlerS, 1988, “Malangan: objects, sacrifice and the production of memory”American Ethnologist15625–637
70.
KuchlerS, 1992, “Making skins: Malangan and the idiom of kinship in Northern New Ireland”, in Anthropology, Art and Aesthetics Eds CooteJSheltonA (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp 94–112
71.
LangerS K, 1953Feeling and Form: A Theory of Art Developed from Philosophy in a New KeyRoutledge and Kegan Paul, London)
72.
LatourB, 1997, “Trains of thought: Piaget, formalism and the fifth dimension”Common Knowledge6170–191
73.
LawJ, 1998, “After ANT: complexity, naming and technology”, in Actor Network Theory and After Eds LawJHassardJ (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 1–14
74.
LawJBenschopR, 1997, “Resisting pictures: representation, distribution and autological politics”, in Ideas of Difference Eds HetheringtonKMunroR (Blackwell, Oxford)
75.
LecercleJ J, 1990Philosophy Through the Looking Glass: Language, Nonsense, DesireOpen Court, La Salle, IL)
76.
LefebvreH, 1934Morceaux Choisis de MarxNRF, Paris)
77.
LefebvreH, 1991The Production of SpaceBlackwell, Oxford)
78.
LefebvreH, 1995Writings on CitiesBlackwell, Oxford)
79.
McAloonJ J, 1995, “Interval training”, in Choreographing History Ed. FosterS L (Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IL) pp 32–53
80.
McClureB, 1998, “Machinic philosophy”Theory, Culture and Society15175–185
81.
McKenzieJ, 1997, “Genre trouble: (the) Butler did it”, in The Ends of Performance Eds PhelanPLaneJ (New York University Press, New York) pp 217–235
McRobbieA, 1991Feminism and Youth CultureMacmillan, London)
84.
MarksJ, 1998Gilles Deleuze: Vitalism and MultiplicityPluto Press, London)
85.
MartinR, 1997, “Staging crisis: twin tales in moving performance”, in the Ends of Performance Eds PhelanPLaneJ (New York University Press, New York) pp 186–196
86.
MassumiB, 1997a, “The political economy of belonging and the logic of relation”, in Anybody Ed. DavidsonC (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 224–238
87.
MassumiB, 1997b, “The autonomy of affect”, in Deleuze: A Critical Reader Ed. PattonP (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 217–239
88.
MaussM, 1992Techniques of the BodyCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
89.
Merleau-PontyM, 1962The Phenomenology of PerceptionRoutledge and Kegan Paul, London)
90.
MorsonG S, 1994Narrative and Freedom: The Shadows of TimeYale University Press, New Haven, CT)
91.
NewmanFHolzmanL, 1997The End of Knowing: A New Developmental Way of LearningRoutledge, New York)
92.
NovackC J, 1990Sharing the Dance: Contact Improvisation and American CultureUniversity of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI)
93.
PerloffM, 1996Wittgenstein's LadderChicago University Press, Chicago, IL)
94.
PhelanP, 1993Unmarked: The Politics of PerformanceRoutledge, New York)
95.
PhelanP, 1998, “Introduction: the ends of performance”, in The Ends of Performance (New York University Press, New York) pp 1–19
96.
PiniM, 1996, “Dance classes—dancing between classifications”Feminism and Psychology6411–426
97.
PollockG (Ed.), 1998Exceptional Spaces: Essays in Performance and HistoryUniversity of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill, NC)
98.
RabinowP, 1995Making PC: A Study of BiotechnologyUniversity of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
99.
RabinowP, 1996Essays on the Anthropology of ReasonPrinceton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
100.
RadleyA, 1996, “Displays and fragments: embodiment and the configuration of social worlds”Theory and Psychology6559–576
101.
RoachJ, 1995, “Culture and performance in the circum-Atlantic world”, in Performativity and Performance Eds ParkerASedgwickE K (Routledge, London) pp 63–78
102.
RoachJ, 1996Cities of the Dead: Circum-Atlantic PerformanceColumbia University Press, New York)
103.
RodowickD N, 1997Gilles Deleuze's Time MachineDuke University Press, Durham, NC)
104.
RubinJ, 1970Do It!Simon and Schuster, New York)
105.
RyanA, 1995John Dewey and the High Tide of American LiberalismCornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)
106.
SandfordM R (Ed.), 1995Happenings and Other ActsRoutledge, London)
107.
SchechnerR, 1993The Future of Ritual: Writings on Culture and PerformanceRoutledge, London)
108.
SchechnerR, 1998, “What is performance studies anyway?”, in The Ends of Performance Eds PhelanPLaneJ (New York University Press, New York) pp 357–362
109.
SchieffelinE L, 1998, “Problematising performance”, in Ritual, Performance, Media Ed. Hughes-FreelandR (Routledge, London) pp 194–207
110.
SchwartzmanB, 1978Transformations: The Anthropology of Children's PlayPlenum, New York)
111.
Sheets-JohnsonM, 1966The Phenomenology of DanceUniversity of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI)
112.
SheringhamM, 1996, “City space, mental space, poetic space: Paris in Breton, Benjamin and Réda”, in Parisian Fields Ed. SheringhamM. (Reaktion, London) pp 85–114
113.
ShotterJ, 1993Cultural Politics of Everyday LifeOpen University Press, Milton Keynes)
ShotterJ, 1998, “Social construction as social politics: Oliver Sacks and the case of Dr P”, in Reconstructing the Psychological Subject: Bodies, Practices and Technologies Eds BayerBShotterJ (Sage, London) pp 33–51
116.
ShustermanR, 1997Practising Philosophy: Pragmatism and the Philosophical LifeRoutledge, New York)
117.
SmithD W, 1997, “A life of pure immanence: Deleuze's ‘Critique et Clinique’ project”, in Essays Critical and ClinicalDeleuzeG (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN) pp xi–liii
118.
SmithN, 1982, “Dance in translation: the hieroglyphs”Contact Quarterly743–46
119.
SpinosaCFloresFDreyfusH, 1997Disclosing New Worlds: Entrepreneurship, Democratic Action and the Culturalisation of SolidarityMIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
120.
SteedmanC, 1998, “What a rag rug means”Journal of Material Culture323–64
121.
StewartN, 1998, “Relanguaging the body; phenomenological description and the dance image”Performance Research392–53
122.
StrathernM, 1996, “Cutting the network”Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute2517–535
123.
Sutton-SmithB, 1997The Ambiguity of PlayHarvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
124.
TaussigM, 1992The Nervous SystemRoutledge, New York)
125.
TaussigM, 1993Mimesis and Alterity: A Particular History of the SensesRoutledge, New York)
126.
TaussigM, 1997The Magic of the StateRoutledge, London)
127.
ThomasH (Ed.), 1998Dance in the CityMacmillan, London)
ThriftN J, 1983, “On the determination of social action in space and time”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space122–57
130.
ThriftN J, 1996Spatial FormationsSage, London)
131.
ThriftN J, 1997, “The still point: resistance, expressive embodiment and dance”, in Geographies of Resistance Eds PileSKeithM (Routledge, London) pp 124–151
132.
ThriftN J, 1998, “Steps to an ecology of place”, in Human Geography Today (Eds MasseyDAllenJSarreP) (Policy, Cambridge) pp 220–243
133.
ThriftN J, 1999, “Entanglements of power: shadows?”, in Geographies of Domination/Resistance Eds SharpJRoutledgePPhiloCPaddisonR (Routledge, London) pp 269–277
134.
TufnellMCrickmayC, 1990Body Space Image. Notes Towards Improvisation and PerformanceDance Books, London)
135.
van GennepA, 1961The Rites of PassageUniversity of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
136.
WilliamsR, 1972Marxism and LiteratureOxford University Press, New York)
137.
WilliamsS T, 1998, “Bodily dys-order: desire, excess and the transgression of corporeal boundaries”Body and Society459–82
