Recent debates around urban encounter, integration cosmopolitanism, and renewed engagement with contact theory have raised questions about the spaces of interaction that may enable meaningful encounters between different social groups. Reflecting on a participatory art project with young people of African and British heritage in northeast England, we argue that discussion and practice around participatory action research, including the deployment of contact zones as theory and method, can cast some light on what fosters transformative spaces. Through analysis of two different approaches to community art used in the project, we show how elements of each enabled and disabled meaningful interaction between young people. We draw attention to the materiality of art (the tools) within participatory practices (the doing of it) in contributing to a space where interactions might take place, emphasising a complex interplay across/between actors, materials, and space that frames encounters as emergent, transitory, fragile, and yet hopeful. We examine the potential of a focus on the material in thinking beyond moments of encounter to how transformative social relations may be ‘scaled up’ before considering the implications for research and policy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllportG W, 1954The Nature of Prejudice (Perseus Books, New York).
2.
AmasNCroslandB, 2006Understanding the Stranger: Building Bridges Community Handbook (Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation, London).
3.
AminA, 2002, “Ethnicity and the multicultural city: Living with diversity”Environment and Planning A34959–980.
4.
AndersonBTolia-KellyD, 2004, “Matter(s) in social and cultural geography”Geoforum35669–674.
5.
AppaduraiA, (Ed.), 1986The Social Life of Things (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
6.
AskinsK, 2006, “New countryside? New country: Visible communities in the English national parks”, in The New Countryside?: Ethnicity, Nation and Exclusion in Contemporary Rural Britain Eds AgyemanJNealS, (Policy Press, Bristol) pp 149–172.
7.
AskinsK, 2008a, “Renegotiations: Towards a transformative geopolitics of fear and otherness”, in Fear: Critical Geopolitics and Everyday Life Eds PainRSmithS J, (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 235–248.
8.
AskinsK, 2008b, “In and beyond the classroom: Research ethics and participatory pedagogies”Area40500–509.
9.
BakkerKBridgeG, 2006, “Material worlds? Resource geographies and the matter of nature”Progress in Human Geography305–27.
10.
BondiL, 2002Subjectivities, Knowledges and Feminist Geographies: The Subjects and Ethics of Social Research (Rowman and Littlefield, Oxford).
11.
ButlerJ, (Ed.), 1993Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limits of ‘Sex’ (Routledge, London).
12.
CahillC, 2007, “The personal is political: Developing new subjectives through participatory action research”Gender, Place and Culture14267–292.
13.
CahillCBradleyMCasteñedaDEsquivelLMohamedNOrganistaJSandbergJValerioMWinstonK, 2008, “‘Represent’: Reframing risk through participatory video research”, in Video Vision: Changing the Culture of Social Science Research Eds DowningMJrTenneyL, (Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne) pp 207–228.
14.
CameronJGibsonK, 2005, “Participatory action research in a poststructuralist vein”Geoforum36315–331.
15.
CantS GMorrisN J, 2006, “Geographies of art and the environment”Social and Cultural Geography7857–861.
16.
ChambersR, 1998, “Beyond ‘whose reality counts?’ New methods we now need”, in People's Participation: Challenges Ahead Ed. BordaO F, (Intermediate Technology Publications, London) pp 105–127.
17.
CieriM, 2004, “Irresolvable geographies”, unpublished paper available from author, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, RI.
18.
CieriM, 2007, “Geography infected by the arts and activism”, paper presented at Geography and the Humanities SymposiumUniversity of Virginia, Charlottesville; copy available from author.
19.
CollsR, 2007, “Materialising bodily matter: Intra-action and the embodiment of ‘Fat’”Geoforum28353–365.
20.
CookI, 2006, “Geographies of food: Following”Progress in Human Geography30655–666.
21.
CookeBKothariU, (Eds), 2001Participation: The New Tyranny? (Zed Books, London).
22.
CornwallA, 2004, “Spaces for transformation? Reflections on issues of power and difference in participation in development”, in Participation from Tyranny to Transformation Eds HickeySMohanG, (Zed Books, London) pp 75–91.
23.
CRE, 2007Promoting Interaction between People from Different Ethnic BackgroundsCommission for Racial Equality, London.
24.
DCLG, Department for Communities and Local Government, London.
DrummondL, 2007, “Hanoi 5000 Hoan Kiem Lakes: Using art to involve young people in urban futures”Children's Geographies5479–488.
28.
DwyerCBresseyC, (Eds), 2008New Geographies of Race and Racism (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants).
29.
FineMTuckJ EZeller-BerkmanS, 2008, “Do you believe in Geneva?”, in Handbook of Critical and Indigenous Knowledges Eds DenzinNSmithL TLincolnY, (Sage, Beverley Hills, CA) pp 157–180.
30.
GregsonNBealeV, 2004, “Wardrobe matter: The sorting, displacement and circulation of women's clothing”Geoforum35689–700.
31.
GroszE, 1994Volatile Bodies: Toward a Corporeal Feminism (Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN).
32.
GuijtIShahM, 1998The Myth of Community: Gender Issues in Participatory Development (IT Publications, London).
33.
HickeySMohanG, (Eds), 2004Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation? (Zed Books, London).
34.
HinchliffeS, 2007Geographies of Nature: Societies, Environments, Ecologies (Sage, London).
35.
HopkinsP ESmithS J, 2008, “Scaling segregation: Racialising fear”, in Fear: Critical Geopolitics and Everyday Life Eds PainRSmithS, (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 103–116.
36.
Hume-CookGCurtisTPotakaJWagnerA TangaroaWoodsKKindonS, 2007, “Uniting people with place through participatory video: A Ngaati Hauiti journey”, in Participatory Action Research: Connecting People, Participation and Place Eds KindonSPainRKesbyM, (Routledge, London) pp 160–169.
37.
JacksonP, 2000, “Rematerializing social and cultural geography”Social and Cultural Geography19–14.
38.
KayA, 2000, “Art and community development: The role the arts have in regenerating communities”Community Development Journal35414–424.
39.
KesbyM, 2007, “Spatialising participatory approaches: Geography's contribution to a mature debate”Environment and Planning A392813–2831.
40.
KesbyMKindonSPainR, 2005, “Participatory research”, in Methods in Human Geography Eds FlowerdewRMartinM, (Prentice-Hall, Harlow, Essex) pp 144–166.
41.
KindonS, 2003, “Participatory video in geographic research: A feminist practice of looking”Area35142–153.
42.
KindonSPainRKesbyM, 2007Connecting People, Participation and Place: Participatory Action Research Approaches and Methods (Routledge, London).
43.
KundnaniA, 2007The End of Tolerance: Racism in 21st Century Britain (Pluto Press, London).
44.
LatourB, 2004Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-network Theory (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
45.
LaurierEPhiloC, 2006, “Cold shoulders and napkins handed: Gestures of responsibility”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series31193–207.
46.
LawJ, 2004After Method: Mess in Social Science Research (Routledge, London).
47.
LonghurstR, 2005, “Situating bodies”, in A Companion to Feminist Geography Eds NelsonLSeagerJ, (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 337–349.
48.
LorimerH, 2007, “Cultural geography: Wordly shapes, different arranged”Progress in Human Geography3189–100.
49.
McDowellL, 1997, “Women/gender/feminisms: Doing feminist geography”Journal of Geography in Higher Education21(3) 381–400.
50.
MacphersonH, 2009, “The inter-corporeal emergence of landscape: Negotiating sight, blindness and ideas of landscape in the British Countryside”Environment and Planning A411042–1054.
51.
MaddernJ, 2004, “The isle of home is always on your mind: Subjectivity and space at Ellis Island Immigration Museum”, in Tourism, Diasporas and Space: Travels to Promised Lands Eds ColesTTimothyD, (Routledge, London) pp 153–171.
52.
MatarassoF, 1996Use or Ornament? The Social Impact of Participation in the Arts (Comedia, Stroud, Glos).
53.
MorrisseyJ, 2005, “Cultural geographies of the contact zone: Gaels, galls and overlapping territories in late medieval Ireland”Social and Cultural Geography6551–566.
54.
MossPFalconer Al-HindiK, 2007Feminisms in Geography: Rethinking Space, Place and Knowledge (Rowman and Littlefield, Oxford).
55.
MulliganMHumphreyKJamesPScanlonCSmithPWelchN, 2006Creating Community: Celebrations, Arts and Wellbeing Within and across Local CommunitiesGlobalism Institute, RMIT University, Melbourne.
56.
NashCPrendergastKDriverFSwensonI, 2002Landings: Eight Collaborative Projects Between Artists and Geographers (Royal Holloway University of London, London).
57.
NealSAgyemanJ, (Eds), 2006The New Countryside?: Ethnicity, Nation and Exclusion in Contemporary Rural Britain (Policy Press, Bristol).
58.
O'NeillM, 2008, “Transnational refugees: The transformative role of art”Forum: Qualitative Sozialforschung/Forum: Qualitative Social Research9(2) Art. 59.
59.
O'NeillMHarindranathR, 2006, “Theorising narratives of exile and belonging: The importance of biography and ethno-mimesis in ‘understanding’ asylum”Qualitative Sociology ReviewII39–53.
60.
O'NeillMHubbardP, (forthcoming), “Asylum, destitution and the social role of arts and culture”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies.
61.
PainR, 2004, “Social geography: Participatory research”Progress in Human Geography28652–663.
62.
PainR, 2009, “Globalized fear: Towards an emotional geopolitics?”Progress in Human Geography33466–487.
63.
PainRFrancisP, 2003, “Reflections on participatory research”Area3546–54.
64.
PainRAskinsKKitokoG, 2007Connected Places, Connecting Lives: An Anti-bullying Art Project final report, Durham University.
65.
PainRPanelliRKindonSLittleJ, 2010, “Moments in everyday/distant geopolitics: Young people's fears and hopes”Geoforum41272–282.
66.
PhillipsD, 2007, “Ethnic and racial segregation: A critical perspective”Geography Compass11138–1159.
67.
PhillipsR, 2006Sex, Politics and Empire: A Postcolonial Geography (Manchester University Press, Manchester).
68.
PinkS, 2007Visual Interventions: Applied Visual Anthropology (Berghahn Books, New York).
69.
PrattG, 2007, “Working with migrant communities: Collaborating with the Kalayaan Centre in Vancouver, Canada”, in Participatory Action Research: Connecting People, Participation and Place Eds KindonSPainRKesbyM, (Routledge, London) pp 95–103.
70.
PrattGJohnstonC, 2007, “Putting play to work”, in Politics and Practice in Economic Geography Eds TickellASheppardEPeckJBarnesT, (Sage, London) pp 70–81.
71.
PrattM L, 1992Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation (Routledge, London).
72.
PunchS, 2002, “Research with children: The same or different from research with adults?”Childhood9321–341.
73.
RoseG, 2007Visual Methodologies: An Introduction to the Interpretation of Visual Methods (Sage, London).
Savin-BadenMWimpennyK, 2007, “Exploring and implementing participatory action research”Journal of Geography in Higher Education31331–343.
76.
SchwanenT, 2007, “Matter(s) of interest: Artefacts, spacing and timing”Geografiska Annaler, Series B899–22.
77.
SharpJ, 2009, “Geography and gender: What belongs to feminist geography?”Progress in Human Geography3374–80.
78.
SomervilleMPerkinsT, 2003, “Border-work in the contact zone: Thinking ndigenous/non-indigenous collaboration spatially”Journal of Intercultural Studies24253–266.
79.
Tolia-KellyD, 2007, “Participatory art”, in Participatory Action Research Approaches and Method: Connecting People, Participation and Place Eds KindonSKesbyMPainR, (Routledge, London) pp 132–140.
80.
TorreM EFineMwith AlexanderNBillupsA BBlandingYGenaoEMarboeESalahTUrdangK, 2008, “Participatory action research in the contact Zone”, in Revolutionizing Education Youth Participatory Action Research in Motion Eds CammarotaJFineM, (Routledge, New York) pp 23–44.
81.
TownsendJwith ArrevillagaUBainJCancinoSFrenkS FPachecoSPerezE, 1995Women's Voices from the Rainforest (Routledge, London).
82.
TravisA, 2007, “£50m aimed at defusing community tensions”The Guardian 6 October, page 4.
83.
ValentineG, 2008, “Living with difference: Reflections on geographies of encounter”Progress in Human Geography32323–337.
84.
WhiteM, 2009Arts Development in Community Health: A Social Tonic (Radcliffe Publishing, Abingdon, Oxon).
85.
WhyteW, (Ed.), 1991Participatory Action Research (Sage, London).
86.
WilliamsG, 2004, “Evaluating participatory development: Tyranny, power and (re)politicisation”Third World Quarterly25557–578.
WylieJ, 2005, “A single day's walking: Narrating self and landscape on the South West Coast Path”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series30234–247.
89.
YeohBSAWillisK, 2005, “Singaporean and British transmigrants in China and the cultural politics of ‘contact zones’”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies31269–285.
