The author compares the coalmining disputes of 1926 and 1984–85 and concentrates on the similarity shown by the spatial patterns of support for both actions. It is argued that the failure of the recent strike was not the result of the disappearance of a traditional solidarity but involved the reproduction of regional traditions of industrial relations. The geography of the 1926 dispute is not satisfactorily explained by economic coercion. It was also related to the coalowners' determination to end national wage bargaining and produced by varying degrees of commitment across the coalfields. In Nottinghamshire a group of internal contractors, who saw the strike as a denial of individual liberty and as a political abuse of mining unionism, organised a return to work. A sense of a violation of individual rights, which centred on the lack of a national ballot, was also fundamental to the failure of the recent strike in this coalfield. The cultural inheritance which shaped this response should be set within the context of the restructuring of the industry and of a decentralisation of wage bargaining. The conclusion drawn is that understanding economic change is not furthered by exaggerating the simplicity and homogeneity of past geographies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AshworthW, 1987The History of the British Coal Industry. Volume 5: 1946–82 The Nationalised Industry (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
2.
BaldwinG, 1953, “Structural reform in the British Miners' Union”Quarterly Journal of Economics67576–597
BassettP, 1984a, “Bonus pay changes pit attitudes”Financial Times 17 April, page 12
5.
BassettP, 1984b, “Home ownership rise may curb pit militancy”Financial Times 18 April, page 12
6.
BeynonHMcMylorP, 1985, “Decisive power: The new Tory state against the miners”, in Digging Deeper: Issues in the Miners' Strike Ed. BeynonH, (Verso, London) pp 29–45
7.
BeynonHHudsonRSadlerD, 1986, “Nationalised industry policies and the destruction of communities: Some evidence from the North East”Capital and Classnumber 29, 27–57
8.
BoothH W, 1924, “The butty system in the Notts coalfield”The Mineworker 10 May, page 2
9.
CoalBritish, 1987–88, “Report and accounts”, British Coal, Hobart House, Grosvenor Place, London SW1
10.
BulmerM, 1975, “Sociological models of the mining community”Sociological Review, New Series2361–92
11.
CliffD, 1986, “Memoir: North Staffs, a tale of two pits”, in The Enemy Within: Pit Villages and the Miners' Strike of 1984–85 Eds SamuelRBloomfieldBBoanasG, (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Andover, Hants) pp 86–92
12.
(The) Colliery Guardian1923, 23 February
13.
(The) Colliery Guardian1926a, 23 April, page 966
14.
(The) Colliery Guardian1926b, 11 June, page 1283
15.
Committee of Enquiry, 1916, “Report of a Departmental Committee Appointed to Enquire into Conditions Prevailing in the Coalmining Industry due to the War”Parliamentary Papers PP1914-16 XXVIII (HMSO, London)
16.
Court of Enquiry, 1925, “Report by a Court of Enquiry into the Dispute in the Coalmining Industry”Parliamentary Papers PP1924-5 XIII (HMSO, London)
17.
(The) Daily Herald1926, 9 October
18.
DavidsonP, 1981, “Post Keynesian economics”, in The Crisis in Economic Theory Eds BellDKristolI, (Basic Books, New York) pp 151–173
19.
DouglasR, 1972, “The National Democratic Party and the British Workers' League”Historical Journal15533–552
20.
(The) Economist1926, “The coal crisis and the government” 17 April, page 772
21.
(The) Empire Citizen1922, February issue
22.
(The) Empire Citizen1926, November issue
23.
FeickhertD, 1987, “The midwife of mining”Capital and Classnumber 37, 7–15
24.
Financial Times1984, 16 March, page 10
25.
Financial Times1986, 21 August, page 8
26.
FineBHarrisL, 1985The Peculiarities of the British Economy (Lawrence and Wishart, London)
27.
FrancisH, 1985, “NUM United: A team in disarray”Marxism Today April, pp 28–34
28.
GriffinA, 1962The Miners of Nottinghamshire 1914–44 (George Allen and Unwin, London)
29.
GriffinAGriffinC, 1977, “The non-political trade union movement”, in Essays in Labour History Eds BriggsASavilleJ, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 133–162
30.
GriffinC, 1984, “Notts miners between the wars: The Spencer Union revisited”, OP-4, Centre for Local History, Department of Adult Education, University of Nottingham, Nottingham
31.
HollandW, 1921, “The wreckers”The Empire Citizen December issue
32.
HollandW, 1926, “A few reflections”The Empire Citizen December issue
33.
House of Commons Energy Committee, 1986Coal Industry. House of Commons Papers—Session 1985–86 HC196, volumes 1 and 2 (HMSO, London)
34.
JonesJCartwrightGGuenaultP, 1939The Coal Mining Industry; An International Study in Planning (Isaac Pitman, London)
KeynesJ, 1925The Consequences of Mr Churchill (Hogarth Press, London)
37.
KriegerJ, 1983Undermining Capitalism: State Ownership and the Dialectic of Control in the British Coalmining Industry (Pluto Press, London)
38.
LittlerC, 1985, “Taylorism, Fordism and job design”, in Critical Perspectives on the Labour Process Eds KnightDWilmottH, (Gower, Aldershot, Hants) pp 10–29
39.
LloydJ, 1984, “Overture to a strike as the miners call the tune”Financial Times 21 April, page 6
40.
LloydJSamuclsonM, 1984, “MacGregor turns on the heat”Financial Times 18 March, page 22
41.
MacGregorI, 1986The Enemies Within: The Story of the 1984–85 Miners' Strike (William Collins, London)
42.
MAGB, 1926, “Minute book of the Central Committee”, Mining Association of Great Britain; copy may be consulted at National Library of Wales, Aberystwyth
43.
Mansfield and North Notts Advertiser1923a, 16 March
44.
Mansfield and North Notts Advertiser1923b, 30 March, page 7
45.
Mansfield and North Notts Advertiser1926, 9 July
46.
Marxism Today1985a, “The miners' strike”, April issue, page 22
47.
Marxism Today1985b, “The miners' strike: A round table discussion”, April issue, page 25
48.
MasseyD, 1984Spatial Divisions of Labour: Social Structures and the Geography of Production (Macmillan, London)
49.
MasseyDWainwrightH, 1985, “Beyond the coalfields”, in Digging Deeper: Issues in the Miners' Strike Ed. BeynonH, (Verso, London) pp 149–168
50.
MFGB, 1925, “The economic position of the coal industry”, Miners' Federation of Great Britain; copy may be consulted at South Wales Miners' Library, Swansea
51.
MFGB, 1926, “Minute book”, Miners' Federation of Great Britain; copy may be consulted at South Wales Miners' Library, Swansea
52.
(The) Mining Engineer1987, number 312, 14 September, page 101
53.
Monopolies and Mergers Commission, 1983, “National Coal Board: A report on the efficiency and costs in the development, production and supply of coal by the NCB”, Cmnd 8920 (HMSO, London)
54.
NCB, 1974, “Plan for coal”, National Coal Board, Hobart House, Grosvenor Place, London SW1
55.
NCB, 1983–84, “Report and accounts”, National Coal Board, Hobart House, Grosvenor Place, London SW1
56.
NCB, 1984–85, “Report and accounts”, National Coal Board, Hobart House, Grosvenor Place, London SW1
57.
NCB, 1985–86, “Report and accounts”, National Coal Board, Hobart House, Grosvenor Place, London SW1
58.
(The) New Statesman1927, 23 July
59.
Nottingham Advertiser1926, 3 June
60.
(The) Nottinghamshire Miner1985a, February issue, page 1
61.
(The) Nottinghamshire Miner1985b, October issue, page 1
62.
NUM Notts Area, 1983, “An appraisal of the British coalmining industry and an examination of the possible consequences following pit closures”, copy may be consulted at Miners' Offices, Berry Hill, Mansfield, Notts
63.
O'DonnellK, 1985, “Pit closures in the British coal industry: A comparison of the 1960s and 1980s”International Review of Applied Economics263–75
64.
OtteyR, 1985The Strike: An Insider's Story (Sidgwick and Jackson, London)
65.
PedenG, 1984, “The ‘Treasury view’ on public works and employment in the interwar period”Economic History Review Second Series37167–181
66.
PhillipsM, 1927Women and the Miners' Lockout (Labour Publishing Company, London)
67.
PioreMSabelC, 1984The Second Industrial Divide: Possibilities for Prosperity (Basic Books, New York)
68.
PRO, Public Record Office, Chancery Lane, London WC2
69.
ReesG, 1985, “Regional restructuring, class change, and political action: Preliminary comments on the 1984–1985 miners' strike in South Wales”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space3389–406
70.
ReesG, 1986, “‘Coalfield culture’ and the 1984–1985 miners' strike: A reply to Sunley”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space4469–476
71.
Report of Chief Registrar of Friendly Societies for years1926–27, Cambridge University Library
72.
Royal Commission on the Coal Industry, 1926Parliamentary Papers PP1926 XIV (HMSO, London)
73.
RyanP, 1975, “The poor law in 1926”, in The General Strike Ed. MorrisM, (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx) pp 358–378
74.
SamuelRBloomfieldBBoanasG, 1986The Enemy Within: Pit Villages and the Miners' Strike of 1984–85 (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Andover, Hants)
75.
SayerR, 1982, “Explanation in economic geography: Abstraction versus generalisation”Progress in Human Geography668–85
76.
ScottAStorperM, 1986Production, Work, Territory: The Geographical Anatomy of Industrial Capitalism (Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
77.
ShackleG, 1972Epistemics and Economics: A Critique of Economic Doctrines (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
78.
SuppleB, 1985, “Time and the miners”Times Literary Supplement 15 March, pp 279–280
79.
SuppleB, 1986, “Ideology or pragmatism? The nationalisation of coal 1916–46”, in Business Life and Public Policy Eds McKendrickNOuthwaiteR, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 228–250
80.
TaylorA, 1984The Politics of the Yorkshire Miners (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)
81.
Von HayekF, 1937, “Economics and knowledge”Economica, New Series433–54
82.
WaddingtonDWykesM, 1989, “Voting with their feet”New Statesman and Society January, pp 26–27
83.
WallerR, 1983The Dukeries Transformed: The Social and Political Development of a Twentieth Century Coalfield (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
84.
WilsherPMacIntyreDJonesM, 1986Strike: Thatcher, Scargill and the Miners (Coronet Books, London)
85.
WintertonJWintertonR, 1989Coal, Crisis and Conflict: The 1984–85 Miners' Strike in Yorkshire (Manchester University Press, Manchester)
86.
(The) Workers' Weekly1926a, “Where few pits limp along”, 2 July
87.
(The) Workers' Weekly1926b, 27 August
88.
WrigleyC, 1984, “1926: Social costs of the mining dispute”History Today34 (November) 5–10
