Debates over the content of urban studies flowered in the early 1970s and died in the 1980s. The rise and fall was closely mirrored by the fashionable status of the urban theories of certain Marxists. This paper is a look at the reasons why this urban debate, like its predecessors, failed to incorporate an adequate analysis of the provision of the built environment, the physical framework of cities. The work of Castells, Lojkine, amd Harvey is examined in this respect and the concept of collective consumption questioned. An approach to studying the built environment is then suggested which hopefully will help to get Marxist urban analysis off its functionalist petard.
BallM, 1981“The development of capitalism in housing provision”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research5145–177
4.
BallM, 1983Housing Policy and Economic Power: The Political Economy of Owner Occupation (Methuen, Andover, Hants)
5.
BallM, 1985a“Land rent and the construction industry” inLand Rent, Housing and Urban Planning Eds BallMFolinFEdwardsM, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 71–86
6.
BallM, 1985b“The urban rent question”Environment and Planning A17503–525
7.
BallM, forthcoming, “Rebuilding construction” mimeograph, details from the author
8.
Bartlett International Summer Schools, 1979–85The Production of the Built EnvironmentProceedings of the Bartlett Summer School; Bartlett School of Planning and Architecture, University College, London
9.
BaumolWOatesW, 1975The Theory of Environmental Policy (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
10.
BreugelI, 1975“The Marxist Theory of rent and the contemporary city: A critique of Harvey” inPolitical Economy and the Housing Question (CSE Books, London) pp 34–46
11.
CannadineD, 1980Lords and Landlords, Aristocracy and the Towns (Leicester University Press, Leicester)
12.
CastellsM, 1976“Is there an urban sociology?” inUrban Sociology: Critical Essays Ed. PickvanceC, (Tavistock Publications, Andover, Hants) pp 33–59
CastellsM, 1978City, Class and Power (Macmillan, London)
15.
CastellsM, 1983The City and the Grassroots (Edward Arnold, London)
16.
CheckowayB, 1980“Large builders, federal housing programmes, and postwar suburbanization”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research421–45
17.
ClawsonM, 1971Suburban Land Conversion in the United States (The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
18.
FineBHarrisL, 1979Rereading Capital (Macmillan, London)
19.
FosterC, 1973“Planning and the market” inThe Future of Planning Ed. CowanP, (Heinemann Educational Books, London) pp 132–165
20.
FraserD, 1973The Evolution of the Welfare State (Macmillan, London)
21.
GravejatA, 1985“Capitalist urban rent” inLand Rent, Housing and Urban Planning: European Perspective Eds BallMBetivegnaVFolinFEdwardsM, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 156–176
22.
GrayF, 1982, “Owner occupation and social relations” inOwner Occupation in Britain S Merrett with F Gray (Routlege and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon) pp 267–291
23.
GreblerL, 1973Large Scale Housing and Real Estate Firms: An Analysis of a New Business Enterprise (Praeger, New York)
HarloeM, 1978, “Marxism, the state and the urban question: Critical notes on two recent French theories” inBritish Political Sociology Yearbook Ed. CrouchC, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 75–94
26.
HarveyD, 1973Social Justice and the City (Edward Arnold, London)
27.
HarveyD, 1974, “Class-monopoly rent, finance capital and the urban revolution”Regional Studies8239–255
28.
HarveyD, 1975, “The political economy of urbanization in advanced capitalist societies: The case of the United States” inThe Social Economy of Cities Eds GappertGRoseH, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 119–164
29.
HarveyD, 1976, “Labour, capital and class struggle around the built environment in advanced capitalist societies”Politics and Society6265–295
30.
HarveyD, 1978, “The urban process under capitalism: A framework for analysis”International Journal for Urban and Regional Research2101–131
31.
HarveyD, 1982The Limits to Capital (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
32.
HarveyDChaterjeeL, 1974, “Absolute rent and the restructuring of space by financial institutions”Antipode622–36
33.
HeadJ, 1962, “Public goods and public policy”Public Finance17197–219
34.
JessopB, 1982The Capitalist State (Martin Robertson, Oxford)
35.
JohnsonJPooleyC, 1982The Structure of Nineteenth Century Cities (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)
36.
KellettJ, 1969The Impact of Railways on Victorian Cities (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon)
37.
LebasE, 1981, “Introduction” inCity, Class and Capital Eds HarloeMLebasE, (Edward Arnold, London) pp ix–xxxiii
38.
LebasE, 1982, “Urban and regional sociology in advanced and industrial societies: A decade of Marxist and critical perspectives”Current Sociology30 Spring issue
39.
LebasE, 1983, “The state in British and French urban research, or the crisis of the urban question” inUrban Social Research: Problems and Prospects Eds PonsVFrancisR, (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon) pp 9–30
LipietzA, 1985, “Building and the crisis of Fordism: The case of France” inThe Production of the Built EnvironmentBartlett School of Planning and Architecture, University College, London; pp I-13–I-32
42.
LojkineJ, 1976, “Contribution to a Marxist theory of capitalist urbanisation” inUrban Sociology: Critical Essays Ed. PickvanceC, (Tavistock Publications, Andover, Hants) pp 119–146
43.
LojkineJ, 1977Le Marxisme, l'État et la Question Urbaine (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris)
44.
McMahonM, 1985, “The law of the land: Property rights and town planning in modern Britain” inLand Rent, Housing and Urban Planning: A European Perspective Eds BallMBentivegnaVFolinFEdwardsM, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 87–106
45.
MasseyDCatalanoA, 1978Capital and Land: Landownership by Capital in Great Britain (Edward Arnold, London)
46.
MingioneE, 1981Social Conflict and the City (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
47.
MinnsR, 1980Pension Funds and British Capitalism (Heinemann Educational Books, London)
48.
OfferA, 1977, “The origins of the Law of Property Acts, 1910–1925”Modern Law Review40505–522
49.
OfferA, 1981Property and Politics 1870–1914 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
50.
PahlR, 1977, “Collective consumption and the state in capitalist and state socialist societies” inIndustrial Society: Aspects of Class Cleavage and Control Ed. ScaseR, (George Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts) pp 23–37
PreteceilleE, 1981, “Collective consumption, the state and the crisis of capitalist society” inCity, Class and Capital Eds HarloeMLebasE, (Edward Arnold, London) pp 1–16
53.
ProctorI, 1983, “Urbanization in the framework of the spatial structuring of social institutions: A discussion of concepts with reference to British material” inUrban Social Research: Problems and Prospects Eds PonsVFrancisR, (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon) pp 87–114
54.
SamuelsonP, 1954, “A pure theory of public expenditure”Review of Economics and Statistics36387–389
55.
SaundersP, 1979Urban Politics: A Sociological Interpretation (Hutchinson, London)
56.
ScottA, 1980The Urban Land Nexus and the State (Pion, London)
57.
SteinerP O, 1974, “Public expenditure budgeting” inThe Economics of Public Finance (The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC) pp 126–140
58.
TheretB, 1982, “Collective means of consumption, capital accumulation and the urban question”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research6345–371
59.
TopalovC, 1973Capital et Propriété Foncière (Centre de Sociologie Urbaine, Paris)
60.
TopalovC, 1981Tous Propriétaires! (Centre de Sociologie Urbaine, Paris)
