The author aims at a comparative analysis of the development of local government systems in Britain, France, and Germany. First, he makes the point that, during the historical evolution of the local government systems of the three countries over the last century, their institutional profiles have exhibited an almost classical divergence. Against this historical background the author pursues answers to the questions of whether, to what degree, and why the local government systems of the three countries have, in their more recent development, shown institutional convergence. Among the factors possibly fostering such convergence, the following are highlighted in the paper: the internationalisation (‘globalisation’) of socioeconomic and political challenges and institutional responses to them.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndrewCGoldsmithM, 1998, “The theme of local governance”International Political Science Review19(2) 101–123
2.
AshfordD E, 1982British Dogmatism and French Pragmatism. Central – Local Policy Making in the Welfare State (Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
3.
BaldersheimHIllnerMOtterdalARoseLSwianiewicaP, (Eds), 1996Local Democracy and the Processes of Transformation in East-Central Europe (Boulder, Westview Press, CO)
4.
Becquart-LeclercqJ, 1994, “Frankreich” [France], in Kommunalpolitik in Europa [Local politics in Europe], Ed. WehlingH-G, (Kohlhammer, Stuttgart) pp 160f
5.
BennettR J, 1993a, “Local government in Europe: Common directions of change”, in Local Government in the New Europe Ed. BennettR J, (Belhaven Press, London) pp 1–27
6.
BennettR J, 1993b, “European local government systems”, in Local Government in the New Europe Ed. BennettR J, (Belhaven Press, London) pp 28–50
7.
BenzAGoetzK H, 1996, “The German public sector: National priorities and the international reform agenda”, in A New German Public Sector? Eds BenzAGoetzK H, (Dartmouth, Aldershot, Hants) pp 1–16
8.
BeyerJWielgohsJ, 1998Path-dependency Approaches and National Differences in Post-socialist Institution Building: The Case of Large Privatization Policies unpublished manuscript, Social Science Institute, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Berlin
9.
BönkerFWollmannH, 1996, “Incrementalism and reform wars: The case of social service reform in the Federal Republic of Germany”Journal of European Public Policy3441–460
10.
BrooksJ, 1998, “Labour's modernisation of local government: A critical approach”, unpublished manuscript, Department of Politics, Southampton Institute, Southampton
11.
BulpittJ, 1983Territory and Power in the United Kingdom (Dover, New York)
12.
DerlienH U, 1996, “Patterns of postwar administrative development in Germany”, in A New German Public Sector? Eds BenzAGoetzK H, (Dartmouth, Aldershot, Hants) pp 146–179
13.
DETR, 1998, “Modern local government: In touch with the people”, Cm4014, Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions (The Stationery Office, London)
14.
EngeliCHausW, 1975Quellen zum modernen Gemeindeverfassungsrecht in Deutschland [Sources of modern municipal law in Germany] (Kohlhammer, Stuttgart)
15.
GreenwoodR, 1982, “Pressure from Whitehall”, in Fiscal Stress in Cities Eds RoseRPageE, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge), pp 110–132
16.
GrémionP, 1976Le pouvoir périphérique: Bureaucrates et notables dans le système politique français [The peripheral power: Bureaucrats and notables in the French political system] (Le Seuil, Paris)
17.
GröttrupH, 1973Die kommunale Leistungsverwaltung [The administration of local services] (Kohlhammer, Stuttgart)
18.
GrunowDWollmannH, (Eds), 1998Lokale Verwaltungsmodernisierung in Aktion [Modernisation of local administration in action] (Birkhäuser, Basle)
19.
HambletonR, 1998, “Strengthening political leadership in UK local government”Public Money and Management18(1) 1–11
20.
HeffterH, 1950Die deutsche Selbstverwaltung im 19. Jahrundert [German local self-administration in the 19th century] (Kohlhammer, Stuttgart)
21.
HesseJ J, 1990, “Local government in a federal state: The case of West Germany”, in Local Government and Urban Affairs in International Perspective Ed. HesseJ J, (Nomos, Baden-Baden) pp 353–386
22.
HesseJ JSharpeL J, 1990, “Local government in international perspective: Some comparative observations”, in Local Government and Urban Affairs in International Perspective Ed. HesseJ J, (Nomos, Baden-Baden) pp 603–621
23.
HoffmannW G, 1965Das Wachstum der deutschen Wirtschaft seit der mitte des 19. Jahrhunderts [The growth of the German economy since the mid-19th century] (Kohlhammer, Stuttgart)
24.
Hoffmann-MartinotV, 1997, “Zentralisierung und Dezentralisierung” [Centralisation and decentralisation], in Fremde Freunde [Unknown friends], Ed. PichtR, (Piper, München) pp 168–174
25.
JohnsonN, 1988, “Die kommunale Selbstverwaltung in England” [Local self-government in England], in Kommunaherfassungen in Europa [Municipal charters in Europe], Ed. ErichsenU A, (Kohlhammer, Stuttgart) pp 19–37
26.
JonesG W, 1990, “Local government in Great Britain”, in Local Government and Urban Affairs in International Perspective (Nomos, Baden-Baden) pp 167–210
27.
KarlT LSchmitterP C, 1991, “Modes of transition in Latin America, Southern and Eastern Europe”International Social Science Journal43269–284
28.
KeatingM, 1996, “Regional devolution: The West European experience”Public Money and Management16(4) 35–42
29.
KeatingM, 1999, “Reforging the Union: Devolution and constitutional change in the United Kingdom”, unpublished manuscript, European University Institute, Florence
30.
KisslerLBogumilJGreifensteinRWiechmannE, 1997Moderne Zeiten im Rathaus? [Modern times in city hall?] (Sigma, Berlin)
31.
KnemeyerF-L, 1999, “Gemeindeverfassungen” [Municipal charters], in Kommunalpolitik [Local politics], Eds WollmannHRothR, (Leske and Budrich, Opladen) pp 104–122
32.
LauxE, 1999, “Erfahrungen und Perspektiven der kommunalen Gebiets- und Funktionalreform” [Practice and perspective of local territorial and functional reforms], in Kommunalpolitik [Local politics], Eds WollmanHRothR, (Leske and Budrich, Opladen) pp 168–185
33.
LeemansA R, 1970Changing Patterns of Local Government (International Union of Local Authorities, The Hague)
34.
LehmbruchG, 1993, “Institutionentransfer: Zur politischen Logik der Verwaltungsintegration in Deutschland” [Institutional transfer: The political logic of administrative integration in Germany], in Verwaltungsreform und Verwaltungspolitik im Prozess der deutschen Einigung [Administrative reform and policy in the process of German unification], Eds SeibelWBenzAMädingH, (Nomos, Baden-Baden) pp 42–66
35.
LorenzSWollmannH, 1999, “Kommunales Dienstrecht und Personal” [Local employment law and personnel], in Kommunalpolitik [Local politics], Eds WollmannHRothR, (Leske and Budrich, Opladen) pp 490–511
36.
MabileauA, 1994Le système local en France [The local system in France], 2nd edition (Montchrestien, Paris)
37.
MabileauA, 1997, “Les génies invisibles du local” [The invisible spirit of the local]Revue Française de Science Politique47340–375
38.
MarcouG, 1996, “L'administration publique en Allemagne et en France” [Public administration in Germany and France]Revue française d'administration publique78357–373
39.
MarcouGVerbelyiI, 1993New Trends in Local-government in Western and Eastern EuropeInternational Institute of Administrative Sciences, Brussels
40.
MényY, 1992, “La République des fiefs” [The republic of fiefdoms]Pouvoirsnumber 60, 55–71
41.
NorthD C, 1990Institutions, Instutional Change, and Economic Performance (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
42.
NortonA, 1994International Handbook of Local and Regional Government (Edward Elgar, Aldershot, Hants)
43.
PageE C, 1990, “Die ‘do parties make a difference’ – Diskussion in Grossbritannien” ['Do parties make a difference-discussion in Great Britain[, in Die alte Bundesrepublik [The other German Republic], Eds BlankeBWollmannH, (Westdeutscher Verlag, Opladen) pp 239–252
44.
PageE C, 1991Localism and Centralism (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
45.
PageE CGoldsmithM J, (Eds), 1987Central and Local Relations: A Comparative Analysis of West European Unitary States (Sage, London)
46.
ReichardC, 1994Umdenken im Rathaus: Neue Steuerungsmodelle in der deutschen Kommunalverwaltung [New thinking in city hall: The ‘new steering model’ in Germany's local administration] (Sigma, Berlin)
47.
ReichardCWollmannH, (Eds), 1996Kommunalverwaltung im Modernisierungsschub? [Local administration in a modernisation push?] (Birkhäuser, Basle)
48.
RoseR, 1980Do Parties Make a Difference? (Macmillan, London)
49.
RoseR, 1982Understanding the United Kingdom (Longman, Harlow, Essex)
50.
SchefoldDNeumannM, 1996Entwicklungstendenzen der Kommunaherfassungen in Deutschland: Demokratisierung und Dezentralisierung? [Trends in the municipal charters in Germany: Democratisation and decentralisation?] (Birkhäuser, Basel)
51.
SchmitzM, 1991Der Landrat: Mittler zwischen Staatsverwaltung und kommunaler Selbstverwaltung [The county head: Intermediary of state administration and local self-administration] (Nomos, Baden-Baden)
52.
SchröterE, 1998, “Ein Bürgermeister für London: Neue Plane und alte Probleme der Metropolenverwaltung” [Mayor of London: New schemes and old problems of metropolitan government]Verwaltungs-Archiv89505–525
53.
SchröterEWollmannH, 1997, “Public sector reforms in Germany: Whence and where? A case of ambivalence”Administrative Studies/Hallinnon Tutkimusnumber 3, 184–200
54.
SharpeL J, (Ed.), 1993aThe Rise of Meso Government in Europe (Sage, London)
55.
SharpeL J, 1993b, “The United Kingdom: The disjointed meso”, in The Rise of Meso Government in Europe Ed. SharpeL J, (Sage, London) pp 247–259
StewartJ, 1995The Role of Local Government in the United KingdomInstitute of Local Government Studies, Birmingham
58.
StokerG, 1998, “British Local Government. Under new management?”, in Lokale Verwaltungsmodernisierung in Aktion [Modernisation of local administration in action], Eds GrunowDWollmannH, (Birkhäuser, Basel) pp 372–385
59.
ThoenigJ-C, 1998, “Neues Politik- und Verwaltungsmanagement. Reformbilanz in Frankreich” [New political and administrative management. State of reforms in France], WP 158/1998, Konrad Adenauer Foundation, St Augustin
60.
von SaldernA, 1999, “Rückblicke: Zur Geschichte der kommunalen Selbstverwaltung in Deutschland” [Retrospective on the history of local self-administration in Germany], in Kommunalpolitik [Local politics], Eds WollmannHRothR, (Leske and Budrich, Opladen) p 23–36
61.
WollmannH, 1996, “The transformation of local government in East Germany: Between imposed and innovative institutionalization”, in A New German Public Sector? Eds BenzAGoetzK H, (Dartmouth, Aldershot, Hants) pp 137–163
62.
WollmannH, 1997a, “Institution building and decentralization in formerly socialist countries: The cases of Poland, Hungary, and East Germany”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy15463–480
63.
WollmannH, 1997b, “Modernization of the public sector and public administration in the Federal Republic of Germany. (Mostly) A story of fragmented incrementalism”, in State and Administration in Japan and Germany. A Comparative Perspective on Continuity and Change Eds MuramatsuMNascholdF, (de Gruyter, Berlin) pp 80–103
64.
WollmannH, 1997c, “Between institutional transfer and legacies: Local administrative transformation in Eastern Germany”, in Restructuring Networks in Post-socialism Eds GrabherGStarkD, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 324–351
65.
WollmannH, 1999a, “Entwicklungslinien lokaler Demokratie und kommunaler Sellstverwaltung im internationalen Vergleich” [Trends in local democracy and local self-government, internationally compared], in Kommunalpolitik [Local politics], Eds WollmannHRothR, (Leske and Budrich, Opladen) pp 186–205
66.
WollmannH, 1999b, “Kommunalvertretungen: Verwaltungsorgane oder Parlamente?” [Local councils-administrative organs or parliaments?], in Kommunalpolitik [Local politics], Eds WollmannHRothR, (Leske and Budrich, Opladen) pp 50–66
67.
WollmannH, 1999c, “Le système local en Allemagne en route vers un nouvel modèle de la démocratie locale?” translation [Local democracy: Representation, participation and public space], Eds CURAPP/CRAPS (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris)
68.
WollmannH, 1999d, “Kommunalpolitik – zu neuen (direkt)-demokratischen Ufern” [Local politics—towards new (direct) democratic shores?], in Kommunalpolitik [Local politics], Eds WollmannHRothR, (Leske and Budrich, Opladen) p 37–49
