Proponents of devolution have argued that devolved governing leads to enhanced democratisation. This democratisation process is argued to be the result both of new governance structures and of new practices of governing which produce a new, more democratic, politics. The case of Scottish devolution is one example of where constitutional change was constructed as heralding a ‘new politics’. This proposition is analysed through a specific policy intervention in the devolved Scotland—the designation of a national park in the Cairngorms. This designation is traced from the instigation of national parks legislation to the formal creation of the park. The claim that devolution can bring about a more open and participatory approach to governing is critiqued. It is proposed that, although democratisation has a formed a political rationality of devolution, the actual practices of governing owe more to traditional rationalities of managerialism.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsJRobinsonP, (Eds), 2002Devolution in Practice: Public Policy Differences within the UK (Institute for Public Policy Research, London).
2.
BlairA, 1996, “Blair on the constitution”The Economist 14 September, pages 33–35.
3.
BonneyN, 2003, “The Scottish Parliament and participatory democracy: Vision and reality”Political Quarterly74459–467.
4.
Campaign for the English Regions, 2005, “Policy statement”, Campaign for the English Regions, 140–150 Pilgrim Street, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 6TH.
5.
DouglasE, 2001, “Clouds on the horizon”Guardian Society 29 August, pages 6–7.
6.
FergussonA, 2002, “Letter to Allan Wilson MSP re: Proposals for the Cairngorms National Park on behalf of the Rural Development Committee of the Scottish Parliament”, 14 October (Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh).
7.
ForsythBDownieADowS, 2001The Report of the Proposal for a National Park in the Cairngorms, Report Three: A Description of the Consultation Exercise in the Local AreaScottish Natural Heritage, 12 Hope Terrace, Edinburgh EH9 2AS.
HassanGWarhurstC, 2000The New Scottish Politics: The First Year of the Scottish Parliament and Beyond (The Stationery Office, London).
11.
HumphreyLTomaneyJ, 2002Regional Government and Democratic RenewalCentre for Democratic Policy Making, Archway Resource Centre, 1b Waterlow Road, London N19 5NJ.
12.
JessopB, 1994, “Post-Fordism and the state”, in Post-Fordism: A Reader Ed. AminA, (Blackwell, Oxford) pp ….
13.
KeatingM, 2005The Government of Scotland: Public Policy Making after Devolution (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh).
14.
LynchP, 2001Scottish Government and Politics: An Introduction (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh).
15.
MitchellJ, 2000, “New parliament, new politics in Scotland”Parliamentary Affairs53605–621.
16.
MorganJMunghamG, 2000Redesigning Democracy: The Making of the Welsh Assembly (Seren, Bridgend).
17.
MorganK, 2002, “The English question: Regional perspectives on a fractured nation”Regional Studies36797–810.
18.
ParryR, 2003, “The Scottish Executive and the challenges of complex policy making”Political Quarterly74450–458.
19.
PatersonL, 2002, “Civic democracy”, in Anatomy of the New Scotland: Power, Influence and Change Eds HassanGWarhurstC, (Mainstream, Edinburgh) pp 56–64.
20.
RettieK M, 2001The Report on the Proposal for a National Park in the Cairngorms—A Description of the Consultation Exercise in the Local AreaScottish Natural Heritage, 12 Hope Terrace, Edinburgh EH9 2AS.
21.
RhodesR, 1997Understanding Governance: Policy Networks, Reflexivity and Accountability (Open University Press, Milton Keynes, Bucks).
22.
RoseNMillerP, 1992, “Political power beyond the state: Problematics of government”British Journal of Sociology42173–201.
23.
RossJ, 2003a, “Perthshire fights for a place in park”The Scotsman 12 March, page 8.
24.
RossJ, 2003b, “Rivals hold alternative ceremony in park row”The Scotsman 28 August, page 4.
25.
RossJ, 2003c, “Britain's biggest national park is opened”The Scotsman 2 September, page 9.
26.
RoweM, 2003, “Fury over size of Cairngorms Park”The Independent on Sunday 12 January, page 13.
27.
Scottish Constitutional Convention, 1988, “A claim of right for Scotland”, in A Diverse Assembly—The Debate on a Scottish Parliament Ed. PatersonL, (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh) pp .
28.
Scottish Executive, 2002Cairngorms National Park—Consultation on Draft Designation Order (Scottish Executive, Edinburgh).
29.
Scottish Executive, 2003The Cairngorms National Park Designation, Transitional and Consequential Provisions Order (Scotland) Order 2003 Scottish statutory instrument 2003 number 1, 6 January (Scottish Executive Edinburgh).
30.
Scottish Parliament, 2000National Parks (Scotland) Act, 2000 (The Stationery Office, Edinburgh).
31.
Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee, 2002aOfficial Report 21 May (Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh).
32.
Scottish Parliament Public Petition Committee, 2002bOfficial Report 8th October (Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh).
33.
Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs Committee, 20005th Report 2000—Stage One Report on the National Parks (Scotland) Bill (Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh).
34.
Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee, 2002Transcript of Informal Committee Session of Away Day Meeting Public Session in Kingussie 11th October (Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh).
SNH, 1998National Parks for Scotland—A Consultation Paper.
37.
SNH, 1999National Parks for Scotland—Scottish Natural Heritage's Advice to Government.
38.
SNH, 2001aReport One: The Report on the Proposal for a National Park in the Cairngorms.
39.
SNH, 2001bReport Two: The Report on the Proposal for a National Park in the Cairngorms—An Account of the Information Received During the Consultation Exercise.
40.
The Scotsman2002a, “Cairngorms National Park to be halved”, 30 May, page 11.
41.
The Scotsman2002b, “Call to halt talks on Cairngorms park”, 1 June, page 9.
42.
WatsonA, 2003a, “Laughing stock”The Scotsman 1 May, page 24.
43.
WatsonA, 2003b, “Park strife in dispute over boundary lines”Scotland on Sunday 9 March, page 13.
44.
WilsonA, 2002Letter from Allan Wilson Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development to Alex Fergusson Convenor of the Rural Development Committee on Proposals for the Cairngorms National Park (Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh).
