We propose an empirical analysis of the clustering phenomenon in the Eastern part of Romania as a relevant example to support the idea that the question of clusters in lagging regions, usually with economic structures dominated by mid-tech and low-tech industries, could become an interesting niche for cluster-devoted research in forthcoming years. The specific features in two lagging Romanian regions have been investigated by means of geographic information systems, followed by an interview-based qualitative inquiry. The findings indicate that, despite its great potential, the clustering process has not yet reached an upper-level stage; it is still in a ‘start-up’ phase with a series of ‘economic agglomerations’ that could be mostly considered of a static-cluster type. Subsequent reflections on support policies suggest that local production systems of industrial-district type are an appropriate organisational form for cluster development in the two analysed regions, with a special emphasis on ‘soft’ measures that are able to strengthen the local networks and to ensure cluster identity.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AydalotPKeebleD, 1988High Technology Industry and Innovative Environments (Routledge, New York)
2.
BecattiniG, 1990, “The Marshallian industrial district as a socio-economic notion”, inIndustrial Districts and Inter-firm Co-operation in Italy Eds PykeFBecattiniGSengerbergerW, (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva) pp 123–135
BojarE, 2007, “Clusters: The concepts and types. Examples of clusters in Poland”, inThe Emergence and Development of Clusters in Poland Eds BojarEOlesinskiZ, (Difin, Warsaw) pp 11–30
5.
BojarW, 2007, “The role of groups of agricultural producers in the process of cluster-formation in the Lublin region”, inThe Emergence and Development of Clusters in Poland Eds BojarEOlesinskiZ, (Difin, Warsaw) pp 149–157
6.
BorrásSTsagdisD, 2008Cluster Policies in Europe: Firms, Institutions, and Governance (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos)
7.
BresnahanTGambardellaASaxenianA, 2001, “‘Old economy’ inputs for ‘new economy’ outcomes: Cluster formation in the New Silicon Valleys”Industrial and Corporate Change10835–860
8.
CamagniR, 1995, “The concept of innovative milieu and its relevance for public policies in European lagging regions”Papers in Regional Science74317–340
9.
CombesP PMayerTThisseJ F, 2008Economic Geography: The Integration of Regions and Nations (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
10.
ConstantinD L, 2006, “SMEs and territorial networks: The emerging framework in Romania”, inEntrepreneurship, Investment and Spatial Dynamics Eds NijkampP NMoomawR LTraistaru-SiedschlagI, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 165–181
11.
ConstantinD LGoschinZIleanuB, 2009, “Clusters and regional policy: A case study in Romania”, inClusters: Policy, Management, Good Clustering Practices in the World Ed. BojarE, (Dom Organizatora, Torun) pp 241–261
12.
CrouchCVoelzkowH, 2004, “Introduction”, inChanging Governance of Local Economies: Responses of European Local Production Systems Eds CrouchCTrigiliaCVoelzskowHLe GalèsP, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 1–10
13.
CruzS C STeixeiraA A C, 2010, “The evolution of cluster literature: Shedding light on the regional studies – regional science debate”Regional Studies441263–1288
14.
DoloreuxDPartoS, 2005, “Regional innovation systems: Current discourse and unresolved issues”Technology in Society27133–153
15.
Dziembowska-KowalskaJFunckR H, 2000, “Cultural activities as a location factor in European competition between regions: Concepts and some evidence”Annals of Regional Science341–12
16.
EickelpaschALejprasAStephanA, 2007, “Hard and soft locational factors, innovativeness and firm performance”, WP 109, Centre of Excellence for Science and Innovation Studies, Berlin, http://www.infra.kth.se/cesis/documents/WP109.pdf
17.
EnrightM J, 1998, “Regional clusters and firm strategy”, inThe Dynamic Firm Eds ChandlerAHagstromPSolvellO, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 315–342
18.
EnrightM J, 2000, “The globalisation of competition and the localization of competition: Policies toward regional clustering”, inThe Globalisation of Multinational Enterprise Activity and Economic Development Eds HoodNYoungS, (Macmillan, London) pp 303–331
19.
EnrightM J, 2001, “Local partnerships, clusters and SME globalisation”, in Enhancing SME Competitiveness (OECD, Paris) pp 115–150
European Commission, 2008, “The concept of clusters and cluster policies and their role for competitiveness and innovation: Main statistical results and lessons learned”, Commission Staff Working Document, SEC 2637 (European Commission, Brussels)
22.
Europe INNOVA, 2007, “Innovation clusters in Europe: A statistical analysis and overview of current policy support”, DG Enterprise and Industry Report: PRO INNO Europe papers 5, http://www.proinno-europe.eu/publications Europe Cluster Observatory, “Methodology”, http://www.clusterobservatory.eu
23.
FeserE JSweeneyS H, 2002, “Theory, methods and cross-metropolitan comparison of business clustering”, inIndustrial Location Economics Ed. McCannP, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 222–262
24.
FIN MEDIA, 2008, “Top of the 19,000 Romanian business firms in 2007” (FIN MEDIA, Bucharest)
FunckR HKowalskiJ S, 1996, “Management policies for Central European countries: How to induce research and development activities and innovative behaviour”, inUrban and Regional Management in Countries in Transition Eds ChatterjiMDomanskiR, (Polish Academy of Sciences, Warsaw) pp 201–220
27.
FunckR HKowalskiJ S, 1997, “Innovative behaviour, R&D development activities and technology policies in countries in transition: The case of Central Europe”, inInnovative Behaviour in Space and Time Eds BertugliaC SLombardoSNijkampP, (Springer, Berlin) pp 408–430
GoschinZConstantinD LRomanMIleanuB, 2009a, “Regional specialisation and geographic concentration of industries in Romania”South-Eastern Europe Journal of Economics761–76
30.
GoschinZConstantinD LRomanMIleanuB, 2009b, “Specialisation and concentration patterns in the Romanian economy”Journal of Applied Quantitative Methods495–111
31.
HendreyCBrownJ, 2006, “Dynamics of clustering and performance in the UK opto-electronics industry”Regional Studies40707–726
32.
GasconJ M HernandezFrancoliJ FontrodonaPezziA, 2005, “Map of industrial production systems in Catalonia”, Department of Industry, Ministry of Employment and Industry of the Autonomous Government of Catalonia, Barcelona
33.
HilberC A IVoicuI, 2010, “Agglomeration economies and the location of foreign direct investment: Empirical evidence from Romania”Regional Studies44355–372
34.
Hirsch-KreinsenH, 2008, “Low-technology: A forgotten sector in innovation policy”Journal of Technology Management Innovation311–20
35.
HooverE M, 1948The Location of Economic Activity (McGraw-Hill, New York)
36.
HooverE M, 1937Location Theory and the Shoe and Leather Industries (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
37.
HospersG JBeugelsdijkS, 2002, “Regional cluster policies: Learning by comparing?”Kyklos55381–402
38.
IammarinoS, 2005, “An evolutionary integrated view of regional systems of innovation: Concepts, measures and historical perspectives”European Planning Studies13497–519
IsbasoiuG M, 2007, “Industrial clusters and regional development: The case of Timisoara and Montebelluna”, paper 5057, http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/5037/
KetelsCLindqvistGSölvellÖ, 2006Cluster Initiatives in Developing and Transition EconomiesCentre for Strategy and Competitiveness, Stockholm
43.
KowalskiJRothengatterW, 1998, “Introduction to soft factors in spatial dynamics”Scientific Seminar in Honour of Rolf FunckInstitute for Economic Policy Research, University of Karlsruhe,
44.
KrugmanP, 1991Geography and Trade (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
45.
LaestadiusS, 1995, “Tacit knowledge in a low tech firm”European Journal of Vocational Training627–33
46.
LEED, 2004, “Clusters of enterprises and the internationalisation of SMEs: The case of the Romanian region of Timisoara”, OECD—Local Economic and Employment Development Programme seminar, Timisoara, 24 May, OECD, Paris
47.
Le GalèsPVoelzkowH, 2001, “The governance of local economies”, inLocal Production Systems in Europe: Rise or Demise? Eds CrouchCLe GalèsPTrigiliaCVoelzkowH, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 1–24
MariottiI, 2008, “Italian investments in the agglomeration of Timisoara in Romania: Threat of opportunity for economic development?”Romanian Journal of Regional Science253–79
55.
MarshallA, 1920Principles of Economics8th edition (Macmillan, London)
56.
MaskellP, 1998, “Low-tech competitive advantages and the role of proximity: The Danish wooden furniture industry”European Urban and Regional Studies599–118
57.
MolnarT, 2001, “Regional characteristics of social and economic structures in Western Transdanubia”Journal of Central European Agriculture217–26
58.
National Institute of Statistics, 2010Statistical Yearbook of Romania 2009National Institute of Statistics, Bucharest
59.
NijkampP, 1997, “Northern Poland regional development initiative and project: Some theoretical and policy perspectives”, Department of Spatial Economics, Free University of Amsterdam,
60.
PhelpsN A, 2009, “From branch plant economies to knowledge economies? Manufacturing industry, government policy, and economic development in Britain's old industrial regions”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy27574–592
61.
PILOT, 2006, “Peculiarities and relevance of non-research-intensive industries in knowledge-based economy”, final report of the project ‘Policy and Innovation in Low-tech: Knowledge Formation, Employment and Growth Contributions of the ‘Old Economy’ Industries in Europ—PILOT, http://www.pilot-project.org/publications/finalreport.pdf
62.
PislaruDAristideO, 2004, “Identifying emerging clusters in Romania”, http://www.gea.ro
63.
PorterM E, 1990The Competitive Advantage of Nations (Free Press, New York)
64.
PorterM E, 1998, “Clusters and the new economies of competition”Harvard Business Review7677–90
65.
PorterM E, 2003, “The economic performance of regions”Regional Studies37549–678
66.
PusterlaF, 2002, “Foreign direct investment profitability: EU firms in Romania”, inEntrepreneurship, Investment and Spatial Dynamics Eds NijkampPMoomawR LTraistaru-SiedschlagI, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 68–86
Rodríguez-PoseA, 2001, “Local production systems and economic performance in France, Germany, Italy and the United Kingdom”, inLocal Production Systems in Europe: Rise or Demise? Eds CrouchCLe GalèsPTrigiliaCVoelzkowH, (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 25–45
69.
Rodríguez-PoseAComptourF, 2011, “Do clusters generate greater innovation and growth? An analysis of European regions”The Professional Geographer forthcoming
70.
Romanian Ministry of Economy, 2010, “Clusters and potential clusters in Romania: A mapping exercise”, Romanian Ministry of Economy, Bucharest
SkokanK, 2009, “Regional cluster and transformation of old industrial regions”, Proceedings of the 3rd Central European Conference in Regional Science, Ostrava, October, pp 770–783, http://www.cers.tuke.sk/cers2009/PDF/O2_55_Skokan.pdf
73.
SmithK, 2003, “Innovation, growth and employment in Europe: The role of low-tech industries”, paper presented at the Conference ‘Policy and Innovation in Low-tech industries’”, University of Dortmund, 14 February
74.
SohnD WLeeJ H, 2009, “Policy-driven university - industry linkages and regional innovation networks in Korea”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy27647–664
TorreA, 2008, “First steps towards a critical appraisal of clusters”, inThe Economics of Regional Clusters: Networks, Technology and Policy Eds BleinUMaierG, (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) pp 29–40
82.
TripplM, 2010, “Low-tech innovation in a high-tech environment: The case of the food industry in the Vienna metropolitan region”, inAbstracts of the Annual Conference of the Regional Studies Association ‘Regional Responses and Global Shifts: Actors, Institutions and Organisations’, Pecs, May, pp 193–194
83.
Van der LindeC, 2003, “The demography of clusters: Findings from the cluster meta-study”, inInnovation Clusters and Interregional Competition Eds BrockerJDohseDDoltwedelR, (Springer, Berlin) pp 130–149
84.
VICLI, 2001, “Virtual clustering identification and dissemination of strategic territorial planning best practices for certain countries of Danubian and Southern Europe, Interreg II C, http://www.inforest.it/vicli/
85.
WeberA, 1909Über den Standort der Industrien, translated by C J Freidrich, 1929 Alfred Weber's Theory of Location of Industries (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
