We present comparative ethnographic material on volunteer biodiversity monitoring from environmental organisations in three postcommunist countries: Poland, Slovenia, and Lithuania. We chart and discuss aspects of the heritage from socialism and communist rule in terms of their effect on the present-day running and operations of four case-study organisations in these countries, focusing particularly on challenges posed by the legacy of compulsory volunteering, inherited organisational cultures, economic reorganisation, and internationalisation of the volunteering sector. In closing we indicate certain key differences between our case-study organisations, focusing on factors that influenced their ability to operate in the postcommunist nongovernmental organisation sector, and offer some observations of more general relevance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BellSMarzanoMReinertHCentJKobierskaHPodjedDVandzinskaiteDArmaitieneAGrodzińska-JurczakMMuršičR, 2008, “What counts? Volunteers and their organisations in the recording and monitoring of biodiversity”Biodiversity and Conservation1734433454
2.
BellSMarzanoMPodjedD, 2010, “Inside monitoring: A comparison of bird monitoring groups in Slovenia and the United Kingdom”, in Taking Stock of Nature Ed. LawrenceA, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 212231
3.
ChimiakG, 2006, “What are NGOs and what do they have in common with civil society? The case of post-communist countries and Poland”, in Civil Society in the Making Eds GawinDGlińskiP (IFIS Pan Press, Warsaw) pp 292330
4.
DallagoB, 1990The Irregular Economy: The Underground Economy and the Black Labour Market (Dartmouth, Aldershot, Hants)
5.
DobsonA, 2003Citizenship and the Environment (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
DuijvelaarC, 1996Beyond Borders: East — East Cooperation Among Environmental NGOs in Central and Eastern Europe (Wageningen Agricultural University, Wageningen)
8.
EllisRWatertonC, 2004, “Environmental citizenship in the making: The participation of volunteer naturalists in UK biological recording and biodiversity politics”Science and Public Policy3195105
9.
EuMon, 2007, Cross-Cultural Recommendations for Operational Approaches in Participatory Monitoring Networks to Assess the 2010 Target (University of Durham, Durham)
10.
FaganA, 2005, “Taking stock of civil-society development in post-Communist Europe: Evidence from the Czech Republic”Democratization12528547
11.
FischerJPerovšekJLazarevićZDolencEGodešaBGabričAČepičZKandusNZemljičI, 2005Slovenska novejša zgodovina: Odprograma Zedinjena Slovenija do mednarodnegapriznanja Republike Slovenije: 1848–1992 [Slovenian recent history: From the programme United Slovenia to international recognition of the Republic of Slovenia: 1848–1992] (Mladinska knjiga, Ljubljana)
GlinskiP, 1994, “Environmentalism among Polish youth: A maturing social movement?”Communist and Post-communist Studies27145159
14.
GlinskiP, 1996, Zieloni: Ruch spoleczny w okresie przemian [Polish greens] (IFiS PAN Press, Warsaw)
15.
GordonJLenhardtR, 2006, “Citizenship talk: Bridging the gap between immigration and race perspectives”Fordham Law Review7524932520
16.
GreenwoodJ, 2007, “Citizens, science and bird conservation”Journal of Ornithology148 Supplement 1, 77124
17.
Grodzińska-JurczakM, 2006, “Cultural change and environmental protection in the New Poland”, in Cultural Issues of Our Time Ed LidstoneJ (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 108119
18.
GrzelakJ, 2004, “Social motivation: Are we better now than then?”International Journal of Sociology46082
19.
HardinG, 1968, “The tragedy of the commons”Science16212431248
20.
HeinenJ, 1997, “Public/private: Gender-social and political citizenship in Eastern Europe”Theory and Society4577597
21.
HicksB, 1996Environmental Politics in Poland (Columbia University Press, New York)
22.
HowardMM, 2002, “The weakness of postcommunist civil society”Journal of Democracy13157169
23.
HowardMW, 2001, “Market socialism and political pluralism: Theoretical reflections on Yugoslavia”Studies in East European Thought53307328
24.
IgnatowG, 2007Transational Identity Politics and the Environment (Lexington Books, Lanham, MD)
25.
IsinEWoodP (Eds), 1999Citizenship and Identity (Sage, London)
26.
JančarT, 2004, “Zgodovina sodelovanja DOPPS z BirdLife od začetkov do polnopravnega partnerstva” [The history of cooperation between DOPPS and BirdLife: From its beginnings to full partnership] Svet ptic104143
27.
Jancar-WebsterB, 1998, “Environmental movement and social change in the transition countries”Environmental Politics76990
28.
JohnsonSPCorcelleG, 1995The Environmental Policy of the European Communities (Kluwer, London)
29.
JucknevičiusSSavickaA, 2003, “From restitution to innovation: Volunteering in postcommunist countries”, in The Values of Volunteering Eds DekkerPHalmanL (Kluwer, New York) pp 127142
30.
KelleyD (Ed.), 1997After Communism: Democracy in Perspective (University of Arkansas Press, Fayettville, AR)
31.
KligmanG, 1990, “Reclaiming the public: A reflection on creating civil society in Romania”East European Politics and Societies4393439
32.
KymlickaWNormanW, 1994, “Return of the citizen: A survey of recent work on citizenship theory”Ethics2352381
33.
LangI, 2003, “Sustainable development: A new challenge for the countries in Central and Eastern Europe”Environment, Development and Sustainability1–2167178
34.
LawrenceA, 2005, “Reluctant citizens? The disjuncture between participatory biological monitoring and environmental governance”, paper presented at the International Sociological Association Conference Environment, Knowledge and Democracy, Marseilles, France, July, http://www.eci.ox.ac.uk/research/humaneco/downloads/lawrence_marseille.pdf
35.
MilliganCFyfeN, 2005, “Preserving space for volunteers: Exploring the links between voluntary welfare organisations, volunteering and citizenship”Urban Studies42417433
36.
MirovitskayaNSoroosM, 1995, “Socialism and the tragedy of the commons: Reflections on environmental practice in the Soviet Union and Russia”Journal of Environmental Development477110
37.
PaleyJ, 2002, “Toward an anthropology of democracy”Annual Review of Anthropology31469496
38.
ParkerG, 2002Citizenships, Contingency and the Countryside (Routledge, London)
39.
Perez-DiazV, 2002, “From civil war to civil society”, in Democracies in Flux Ed. PutnamR (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 284285
40.
RegulskaJ, 1999, “NGOs and their vulnerabilities during the time of transition: The case of Poland”Voluntas106171
41.
RinkevičiusL, 2000, “Ecological modernisation as cultural politics: Transformations of civic environmental activism in Lithuania”, in Ecological Modernisation Around the World Eds MolPSonnenfeldD (Routledge, London) pp 171202
42.
RinkevičiusL, 2001, “Attitudes and values of the Lithuanian green movement in the period of transition”Filosofija, Sociologija17229
43.
RohrschneiderRDaltonR, 2002, “A global network? Transnational cooperation among environmental groups”Journal of Politics64510533
44.
SiegelDYanceyJ, 1992The Rebirth of Civil Society: The Development of the Nonprofit Sector in East Central Europe and the Role of Western Assistance (Rockefeller Fund, New York)
45.
SomersMR, 1993, “Citizenship and the place of the public sphere: Law, comand political culture in the transition to democracy”American Sociological Review5587620
46.
StaddonCTurnockD, 2001, “Think global act local? Negotiating sustainable development under postcommunist transformation”GeoJournal3–4477484
47.
TurnockD, 2001, “Environmental problems and policies in east central Europe: A changing agenda”GeoJournal3–4485505
48.
ValkovN, 2009, “Membership in voluntary organizations and democratic performance: European post-communist countries in comparative perspective”Communist and Post-communist Studies42121
49.
VanekM, 2004, “The development of a green opposition in Czechoslovakia: The role of international contacts”, in Transnational Moments of Change in Europe: 1945, 1968, 1989 Eds HornRKenneyP (Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, MD) pp 173188
50.
van SteenbergenB (Ed.), 1994, The Condition of Citizenship (Sage, London)
51.
VerderyMBurawoyK, 1999Uncertain Transition: Ethnographies of Change in the Postsocialist World (Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, MD)
52.
VoicuMVoicuB, 2003, “Volunteering in Eastern Europe: One of the missing links?”, paper presented at the University Lucian Blaga of Sibiu, 6–8 September
53.
VučkovićV, 1998, “Failure of socialist self-management to create a viable nation-state, and disintegration of the Yugoslav administrative state and state institutions”East European Quarterly3353376
54.
WedelJR, 1986The Private Poland (Facts on File, New York)
55.
WWF, 2006Natura 2000 in Europe: An NGO Assessment (World Wildlife Fund, Budapest)
