The Welsh Assembly updated their planning policy for renewables in the form of Technical Advice Note 8 (TAN 8) on renewable energy in 2005. The policy-making process was in line with the Assembly's commitment to participative and stakeholder policy-led development. I explore the policymaking process through a Foucauldian understanding of power, discourses, and policy rationalities, identifing four primary rationalities within the TAN 8 policy: spatial planning, energy targets, reliance on large-scale wind power, and the rationale that the traditional planning paradigm can resolve deep-seated conflicts over renewable energy. I explore how these rationalities emerged and were reinforced through the powerful discourse coalitions that emerged within the TAN 8 stakeholder group. As a result, I suggest that ‘consensus' should not necessarily be the aim of participative policy making and that the participatory process should not be relied upon to deliver ‘rational’ planning policies, leading to sustainable development. Instead, we must embrace the notion of pluralism with an understanding of the discursive powers at work within the policy-making process.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlmendingerPBarkerA, 2001, “Attitudes towards planning in a devolved Scotland”Regional Studies35759–763
2.
AndersonM SMassaI, 2000, “Ecological modernization: origins, dilemmas and future directions”Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning2337–345
3.
BeddoeM, 2002, “Seeking an energy balance” Planning number 1470, 15
4.
BellDGrayTHaggetC, 2005, “The ‘social gap’ in wind farm siting decisions: explanations and policy responses”Environmental Politics14460–477
5.
BrittanG G, 2001, “Wind, energy, landscape: reconciling nature and technology”Philosophy and Geography4169–184
6.
BulkeleyHMolA P J, 2003, “Participation and environmental governance: consensus, ambivalence and debate”Environmental Values12143–154
7.
BWEA, 2008, “Disappointment at mixed messages on wind energy in Wales”, press release, 26 February, British Wind Energy Association, http://www.bwea.com/media/news/080226.html
8.
CowellR, 2007, “Wind power and ‘the planning problem’: the experience of Wales”European Environment17291–306
9.
DarierE, 1996, “Environmental governmentality: the case of Canada's green plan”Environmental Politics5585–606
Devine-WrightP, 2005, “Local aspects of UK renewable energy development: exploring public beliefs and policy implications”Local Environment1057–69
12.
Devine-WrightPMcAlpineGBatley-WhiteS, 2001, “Wind turbines in the landscape: an evaluation of local community involvement and other considerations in UK wind farm development”, in Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Conference of the Environmental Design Research AssociationEdinburgh, Scotland, pp 133–137
13.
DobsonA, 1995Green Political Thought (Routledge, London)
14.
DouglasNSalujaG, 1995, “Planning's role in wind energy development”Town and Country Planning (February) 50–53
15.
FlyvbjergB, 1998Rationality and Power (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
16.
ForesterJ, 1989Planning in the Face of Power (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
FoucaultM, 1979Discipline and Punish: The Birth of a Prison (Vintage, New York)
19.
FoucaultM, 1990The History of Sexuality Volume 1: An Introduction (Penguin, London)
20.
FoucaultM, 2003Society Must be Defended: Lectures at the College De France, 1975–76 (Penguin, London)
21.
HabermasJ, 1987Theory of Communicative Action. Volume 2: Lifeworld and System: A Critique of Functionalist Reason (Polity Press, Cambridge)
22.
HaggetC, 2008, “Over the sea and far away? A consideration of planning, politics and public perception of offshore wind farms”Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning10289–306
23.
HajerM A, 1995The Politics of Environmental Discourse, Ecological Modernization and the Policy Press (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
HealeyP, 2003, “Collaborative planning in perspective”Planning and Theory2101–124
27.
HullA, 1995, “Local strategies for renewable energy: policy approaches in England and Wales”Land Use Policy127–16
28.
JensenORichardsonT, 2001, “Nested visions: new rationalities of space in European spatial planning”Regional Studies35703–717
29.
KanerSLindLToldiCFiskSBergerD, 1996Facilitators Guide to Participatory Decision-making (New Society, Gabriola Island, BC)
30.
KellettJ, 2004, “Renewable energy and the UK planning system”Planning Practice and Research18307–315
31.
MallonK (Ed.), 2006Renewable Energy Policy and Politics (Earthscan, London)
32.
ManderS, 2008, “The role of discourse coalitions in planning for renewable energy: a case study of wind-energy deployment”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy26583–600
33.
MitchellCConnerP, 2004, “Renewable energy policy in the UK, 1990–2003”Energy Policy321887–1889
34.
NAW, 2000, “A sustainable Wales: learning to live differently”, consultation document, National Assembly for Wales, Cardiff
35.
NAW, 2001, “Assembly ministers look to the future of renewable energy in Wales”, press release, 5 October, National Assembly for Wales, Cardiff
O'RiordanT, 1989, “The challenge for environmentalism”, New Models in Geography: The Political-economy Perspective Eds PeetR, ThriftN (Unwin Hyman, London) pp 82–110
39.
OstromE R, 1995, “Constituting capital and collective action”, Local Commons and Global Independence Eds KeohanneR O, OstromE (Sage, London) pp 125–160
40.
PaddisonR, 1999, “Decoding decentralisation: the marketing of urban local power”Urban Studies36107–119
41.
PepperD, 1996Modern Environmentalism: An Introduction (Routledge, London)
42.
PhelpsN ATewdwr-JonesM, 2000, “Scratching the surface of collaborative and associative governance: identifying the diversity of social action in institutional capacity building”Environment and Planning A32111–130
43.
RydinY, 2003Conflict, Consensus, and Rationality in Environmental Planning: An Institutional Discourse Approach (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
SharpLRichardsonT, 2001, “Reflections on Foucauldian discourse analysis in planning and environmental policy research”Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning3193–209
47.
SlocumR, 2004, “Polar bears and energy-efficient lightbulbs: strategies to bring climate change home”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space22413–438
48.
SpaargarenGMolA P J, 1990, “Sociology, environment, and modernity: ecological modernization as a theory of social change”Society and Natural Resources5323–344
49.
StevensonR, 2000, “Realising the potential for the protection of the environment by developing small hydropower”, paper presented at ALTENER 2000, Toulouse; copy available from the author
50.
StevensonRRichardsonT, 2003, “Policy integration for sustainable development: exploring barriers to renewable energy developments in post-devolution Wales”Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning595–118
51.
SzarkaJ, 2004, “Wind power, discourse coalitions and climate change: breaking the stalemate?”European Environment14317–330
52.
Tewdwr-JonesMAlmendingerP, 1998, “Deconstructing communicative rationality: a critique of Habermasian collaborative planning”Environment and Planning A301975–1989
53.
TokeD, 2002, “Wind power in UK and Denmark: can rational choice help explain different outcomes?”Environmental Policy1183–99
54.
UpretiB R, 2004, “Conflict over biomass energy development in the United Kingdom: some observations and lessons for England and Wales”Energy Policy32785–800
WAG, 2005b, “Ministerial interim planning policy statement 01/2005: planning for renewable energy”, Welsh Assembly Government, Cathays Park, Cardiff
57.
WAG, 2005c, “Planning policy Wales, Technical Advice Note 8: planning for renewable energy”, Welsh Assembly Government, Planning Environment and Transport Division, Cathays Park, Cardiff
58.
WAG, 2008, “Renewable energy route map for Wales: consultation on way forward to a leaner, greener and cleaner Wales”, Welsh Assembly Government, Cathays Park, Cardiff
59.
WhileALittlewoodSWhitneyD, 2000, “A new space for sustainable development? Regional environmental governance in the North West and the West Midlands of England”Town Planning Review71395–413
60.
WilliamsP, 2006, “The governance of sustainable development in Wales”Local Environment11253–267
61.
WoodsM, 2003, “Conflicting environmental visions of the rural: windfarm development in Mid Wales”Sociologica Ruralis43271–288
