We examine the uneven employment changes in the Italian local labour systems (LLSs) in the 1990s. Using the 1991 and 2001 economic census data, we intend to compare the performance of different types of LLS, and particularly those of the industrial districts (IDs) and the large enterprise systems (LESs). The originality of the study lies in the territorial unit of analysis chosen: the 784 Italian LLSs. The analysed data show that, in the 1990s, the Italian IDs proved to be the country's most dynamic local systems. Moreover, the shift-and-share analysis demonstrates that the local effect in the IDs was positive enough to more than compensate for the negative industry mix. Conversely, in the LESs the local effect was so negative as to determine a total negative effect, despite the positive industry mix. We conclude with an overview of the present situation and the corresponding policy implications.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BarffRAKnightPL, 1988, “Dynamic shift–share analysis”Growth and Change191–10
2.
BecattiniG (Ed.), 1987Mercato e Forze Locali: Il Distretto Industriale (Il Mulino, Bologna)
3.
BecattiniG, 1990, “The Marshallian industrial district as a socio-economic notion”, in Industrial Districts and Inter-firm Co-operation in Italy Eds PykeFBecattiniGSengenbergerW (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva) pp 37–51
4.
BecattiniG, 1996, “I sistemi locali nello sviluppo economico italiano e nella sua interpretazione”Sviluppo Locale2–35–25
5.
BecattiniG, 2004Industrial Districts: A New Approach to Industrial Change (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham)
6.
BecattiniGBellandiM, 2002, “Mighty Pygmies and feeble Watutsis. Consideration on Italian industry”Review of Economic Conditions in Italy3375–405
7.
BecattiniGColtortiF, 2006, “Areas of large enterprise and industrial districts in the development of post-war Italy: A preliminary survey”European Planning Studies141105–1138
8.
BecattiniGDei OttatiG, 2006, “The performances of Italian industrial districts and large enterprise areas in the nineties”European Planning Studies141139–1162
9.
BecattiniGMenghinelloS, 1998, “Contributo e ruolo del made in Italy distrettuale nelle esportazioni nazionali di manufatti”Sviluppo Locale95–41
10.
BecattiniGBellandiMDei OttatiGSforziF, 2003From Industrial Districts to Local Development: An Itinerary of Research (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham)
11.
BellandiM, 1999, “Terza Italia e distretti industriali dopo la seconda guerra mondiale”, in Storia dell'Itali. L'industria. Annali n. 15 Eds. AmatoriFBigazziDGiannettiRSegretoL (Einaudi, Torino) pp 841–891
12.
BrioschiFBrioschiMSCainelliG, 2004, “Ownership linkages and business groups in industrial districts”, in The Evolution of Industrial Districts. Changing Governance, Innovation and Internationalisation of Local Capitalism in Italy Eds CainelliGZoboliR (Physica, Heidelberg) pp 155–174
13.
BruscoSPabaS, 1997, “Per una storia dei distretti industriali italiani dal secondo dopoguerra agli anni novanta”, in Storia del Capitalismo Italiano dal Dopoguerra ad Oggi Ed. BarcaF (Donzelli, Roma) pp 265–333
14.
BruscoSCainelliGForniFFranchiMMalusardiARigettiR, 1996, “The evolution of industrial districts in Emilia-Romagna”, in Local and Regional Response to Global Pressure: The Case of Italy and its Districts Eds CossentinoFPykeFSengenbergerW (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva) pp 17–36
15.
BurroniL, 2001Allontanarsi Crescendo. Politica e Sviluppo Locale in Veneto e Toscana (Rosenberg and Sellier, Torino)
16.
BurroniLTrigiliaC, 2001, “Italy: Economic development through local economies”, in Local Production Systems in Europe: Rise or Demise? Eds CrouchCLe GalèsPTrigiliaCVoelzkowH (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 46–78
17.
ColtortiF, 2004, “Le medie imprese industriali italiane: Nuovi aspetti economici e finanziari”Economia e Politica Industriale1215–25
18.
ColtortiF, 2006a, “Le medie imprese italiane: Una risorsa cruciale per lo sviluppo”, in Industria e Distretti. Un Paradigma di Perdurante Competitività Italiana Eds CurzioQuadrio AFortisM (Il Mulino, Bologna) pp 315–361
19.
ColtortiF, 2006b, “European and Italian multinationals: Vices and virtues since the 1980s”Review of Economic Conditions in Italy189–134
20.
ContiGCucculelliMParadisiM, 2007, “Internazionalizzazione e strategie delle imprese nei settori tradizionali”L'industria1121–161
21.
CossentinoFPykeFSengenbergerW (Eds), 1996Local and Regional Response to Global Pressure: The Case of Italy and its Industrial Districts (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva)
22.
CrestanelloP, 1996, “The industrial districts in Veneto: Changes and tendencies”, in Local and Regional Response to Global Pressures: The Case of Italy and its Industrial Districts Eds CossentinoFPykeFSengenbergerW (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva) pp 67–96
23.
CrestanelloPTattaraG, 2005, “Connessioni e competenze nei processi di delocalizzazione delle industrie venete dell'abbigliamento e delle calzature in Romania”Economia e Società Regionale9063–99
24.
CrouchCLe GalèsPTrigiliaCVoelzkowH, 2001Local Production Systems in Europe: Rise or Demise? (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
25.
Dei OttatiG, 1996, “The remarkable resilience of the industrial districts of Tuscany”, in Local and Regional Response to Global Pressure: The Case of Italy and its Industrial Districts Eds CossentinoFPykeFSengenbergerW (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva) pp 37–66
26.
Dei OttatiG, 2002, “Social concertation and local development: The case of industrial districts”European Planning Studies4449–466
27.
Dei OttatiG, 2006, “El efecto distrito: Algunos aspectos conceptuales”Economia Industrial35973–79
28.
de NardisSTraùF, 1999, “Specializzazione settoriale e qualità dei prodotti: Misure della pressione competitiva sull'industria italiana”Rivista Italiana degli Economisti2177–212
29.
FortisM, 1998Il Made in Italy (Il Mulino, Bologna)
GarofoliG, 2003, “Distretti industriali e processo di globalizzazione: Trasformazioni e nuove traiettorie”, in Impresa e Territorio Ed. GarofoliG (Il Mulino, Bologna) pp 539–571
32.
HentonD, 2001, “Lessons from Silicon Valley: Governance in a global city-region”, in Global City-regions: Trends, Theory, Policy Ed. ScottAJ (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 391–400
33.
IacobucciD, 2004, “Groups of small and medium-sized firms in industrial districts in Italy”, in The Evolution of Industrial Districts Eds CainelliGZoboliR (Physica, Heidelberg) pp 128–154
34.
IPI, 2006I Distretti Industriali Individuati dall'Istat al Censimento 2001 (Instituto per la Promozione Industriale, Roma)
35.
ISTAT, 2005I Sistemi Locali del Lavoro 2001 (Instituto Nazionale di Statistica, Roma)
36.
ISTATSforziF, 1997I Sistemi Locali del Lavoro 1991 (Instituto Nazionale di Statistica, Roma)
37.
IuzzolinoG, 2004, “Costruzione di un algoritmo di identificazione delle realtà distrettuali sulla base di indicatori di aggregazione settoriali”, in Economie Locali, Modelli di Agglomerazione e Aperture Internazionali. Nuove Ricerche della Banca d'Italia Sullo Sviluppo Territoriale (Banca d'Italia, Roma)
38.
MaddisonA, 1995Monitoring the World Economy (OECD, Paris) pp 34–95
39.
MarshallA, 1975The Early Economic Writings of Alfred Marshall: 1867–1890 edited by WhitakerJK (Macmillan, London)
PorterM, 1990The Competitive Advantage of Nations (The Free Press, New York)
42.
PykeFSengenbergerW (Eds), 1992Industrial Districts and Local Economic Regeneration (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva)
43.
PykeFBecattiniGSengenbergerW (Eds), 1990Industrial Districts and Inter-firm Cooperation in Italy (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva)
44.
SchmitzH, 2001, 2001, “Local governance and conflict management: Reflections on a Brazilian cluster”, in Global City-Regions: Trends, Theory, Policy Ed. ScottAJ (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 401–416
45.
SengenbergerWPykeF, 1992, “Industrial districts and local economic regeneration: Research and policy issues”, in Industrial Districts and Local Economic Regeneration Eds PykeFSengenbergerW (International Institute for Labour Studies, Geneva) pp 3–29
