The view that excessive regulation constrains small business growth has been a persistent theme within business and policy communities, although recent studies have demonstrated the actual effects of regulation to be relatively modest. A prior small-scale study proposed four reasons why employment legislation does “not damage” small firms. We attempt to assess the robustness of these propositions in a large-scale survey of 16 779 small firms. Results provide empirical support for three propositions. Firstly, perceived dissatisfaction masks actual effects. Secondly, competitive conditions mediate regulatory effects; however, even resource-constrained firms reported few negative effects. Thirdly, informality eases regulatory impact. Results failed to confirm that older laws are ‘routinised’. Length of time as a business owner was found to be more influential than age of regulation, with owners who have been in business for many years having a longer ‘window of exposure’ increasing their likelihood of experiencing negative and positive effects.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AthaydeRBlackburnRHartMKitchingJSmallboneDWilsonN, 2006, “The impact of regulation on small business performance: Interim report from stage 1”, Small Business Research Centre, Kingston University, Kingston upon Thames, Surrey
2.
AtkinsonCCurtisS, 2004, “The impact of employment regulation on the employment relationship in SMEs”Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development11486–494
3.
BannockG, 2006The Economics and Management of Small Business (Routledge, London)
4.
BannockGPeacockA, 1989Governments and Small Business (Paul Chapman, London)
5.
BennettR, 2006, “Government and small business”, in Enterprise and Small Business: Principles, Practice and Policy Eds CarterS, Jones-EvansD (FT Prentice Hall, Harlow, Essex) pp 49–75
6.
BerneyROwensE, 1985, “A theoretical framework for small business policy”Policy Studies Journal13681–691
ChittendenFKauserSPoutziourisP, 2003, “Tax regulation and small business in the USA, UK, Australia and New Zealand”International Small Business Journal2193–115
9.
CressyR, 2000, “Tax, assistance, compliance and the performance of the smaller business”, Federation of Small Businesses, London
10.
Disability Discrimination Act, 1995Public General Acts—Elizabeth II chapter 50 (The Stationery Office, London)
11.
Disability Discrimination Act, 2005Public General Acts–Elizabeth II chapter 13 (The Stationery Office, London)
12.
DTI, 1985Burdens on BusinessDepartment of Trade and Industry (HMSO, London)
13.
EdwardsP, RamM, 2006, “Surviving on the margins of the economy: Working relationships in small, low-wage firms”Journal of Management Studies43895–916
14.
EdwardsP, RamM, BlackJ, 2004, “Why does employment legislation not damage small firms?”Journal of Law and Society31245–265
15.
ENSR, 1997, “The European Observatory for SMEs: Fifth Annual Report”, European Network on SME Research, Zoetermeer, The Netherlands
16.
European Commission, 1995European Observatory for SMEs. Third Annual Report (CEC, Brussels)
17.
European Commission, 2002Observatory for European SMEs 2002/2: SMEs in Europe (CEC, Brussels)
18.
FairmanRYappC, 2005, “Enforced self-regulation, prescription and conceptions of compliance within small businesses: The impact of enforcement”Law and Policy27491–519
GrayCBannockG, 2005, “Government regulation and the small firm”, Institute for Small Business and Enterprise Policy Report, Small Enterprise Research Team, Open University, Milton Keynes, Bucks
21.
HarrisL, 2002, “Small firm responses to employment regulation”Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development9296–306
22.
HMSO, 1986Building Businesses, Not Barriers Cmnd 9794 (HMSO, London)
HurrellS A, 2005, “Dilute to taste? The impact of the working time regulations in the hospitality industry”Employee Relations27532–546
25.
KallebergAVan BurenM, 1996, “Is bigger better? Explaining the relationship between organization size and job rewards”American Sociological Review6147–66
26.
LoaderR JHobbsJ E, 1999, “Strategic responses to food safety legislation”Food Policy24685–706
27.
MarlowS, 2006, “Labour management and the small business”, in Enterprise and Small Business: Principles, Practice and Policy Eds CarterS, Jones-EvansD (FT Prentice Hall, Harlow, Essex) pp 385–405
28.
MasonC MCarterSTaggS K, 2006, “The effect of the national minimum wage on the UK small business sector: A geographical analysis”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy2499–116
OPSI, 2006Work and Families Act 2006Office of Public Sector Information (The Stationery Office, London)
33.
O'RourkeD, 2003, “Outsourcing regulation: Analyzing nongovernmental systems of labor standards and monitoring”Policy Studies Journal311–29
34.
PoutziourisPChittendenFMichaelasN, 2001, “Modelling the impact of taxation (direct and compliance costs) on the UK small business economy”, in Tax Compliance Costs: Festschrift for Cedric Sandford. Eds EvansC, HasseldineJ, PopeJ (Prospect Media, Sydney) pp 273–296
35.
PoutziourisPChittendenFWattsTSoufaniK, 2003, “A comparative analysis of the impact of taxation on the SME economy: The case of UK and US–New York State in the year 2000”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy21493–508
36.
ReardonTFarinaE, 2001, “The rise of private food quality and safety standards: Illustrations from Brazil”International Food and Agribusiness Management Review4413–421
SchifferMWederB, 2001, “Firm size and the business environment: Worldwide survey results”, DP 43, International Finance Corporation, The World Bank Group, Washington, DC
39.
Small Business Research Centre, 2005, “Regulation and small firm performance and growth: A review of the literature”, Small Business Research Centre, Kingston University, Kingston Upon Thames, Surrey
40.
Small Business Service, 2005, “Business start-ups and closures: VAT registrations and deregistrations in 2004” Statistical Press Release URN 05/11, Small Business Service, London
41.
SommersPColeR, 1985, “Compliance costs of small and larger businesses”Policy Studies Journal13701–708
42.
StoreyD, 1994Understanding the Small Business Sector (Routledge, London)
43.
van der HorstRNijsenAGulhanS, 2000, “Regulatory policies and their impact on SMEs in Europe: The case of administrative burdens”, in Handbook of Entrepreneurship Eds SextonD L, LandstromH (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 128–149
44.
van StelAStunnenbergV, 2006, “Linking business ownership and perceived administrative complexity”Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development137–22
45.
VickersIJamesPSmallboneDBaldockR, 2005, “Understanding small firm responses to regulation”Policy Studies26149–169
46.
VieiraL, 2004The Impact of Public and Private Standards on Co-ordination and Co-operation in the Brazilian Beef Chain unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Agricultural and Food Economics, University of Reading, Reading, Berks
47.
World Bank Group, 2006Doing Business 2007: How to ReformThe International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank, Washington, DC
