Some decisive elements of implicit or explicit technology policies have escaped policy attention in France. These elements and their relationship with patterns of regional development are highlighted in this paper. The ‘modernization’ strategy in France is examined first, and then the regional dynamics of high-technology production are explored. Subsequently, the role of military expenditure in regional development processes is evaluated. It is concluded that this implicit policy has dramatically altered the character of industrial activity bundles in selected regions and has greatly influenced their potential for future technology-intensive growth. The regional subsidies and incentive policies have proven less important, insofar as modernization and technological change is concerned, than the military expenditures. It is argued that there is little evidence that the impressive military procurement program is integrated with other aspects of regional policy and no evidence that it is playing a role in the industrial restructuring of the older industrial areas.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArcherK, 1986, “State policies and the development of high-technology industries: The United States and Japan”, report prepared for the research project “High Technology Development and Regional Space”, Association Region Nord/Pas-de-Calais-Université Johns Hopkins, Université de Lille I, 59650 Villeneuve d'Ascq, France
2.
ADEFI-GRECO, 1984Régions et Politique Industrielle (Economica, Paris)
3.
ADES, 1985, “Rhône-Alpes, les grands enjeux économiques”, Préfecture Rhône-Alpes, Grenoble
4.
BakisH, 1977, “Economic and spatial impacts of the IBM company in France”, paper presented at the Geographical Symposium, Commission on Industrial Systems, International Geographical Union, Erasmus University, Rotterdam (mimeo); copy available from E A Swyngedouw, The Johns Hopkins European Center for Regional Planning and Research, University of Lille I, 59650 Villeneuve d'Ascq, France
5.
BellonBChevalierJM, 1983L'Industrie en France (Flammarion, Paris)
6.
BoddyMLoveringJ, 1986, “High technology industry in Bristol; the defense–aerospace nexus”Regional Studies20217–231
7.
BonbrunR, 1986, “Mythes et réalités de la modernisation régionale”Économie et Politique numéro 111–112, pages 34–39
8.
CastellsM, 1985, “High technology, economic restructuring, and the urban–regional process in the United States”, in High Technology, Space and Society Ed. CastellsM, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 11–40
9.
CookeP, 1985, “Regional innovation policy: Problems and strategies in Britain and France”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy3253–267
10.
DelpierreM, 1985De l'Aménagement des Villes à l'Aménagement des Hommes: Évolution de la Division Technique, Sociale et Spatiale du Travail, Mutations Spatiales et Changement Institutional PhD dissertation, Department of Law, Political and Social Sciences, University of Lille II, 42 rue Paul Duez, 59800 Lille, France
11.
DGA, 1985, “Budget 1985”, Délégation Générale pour l'Armement, 231 Blvd Saint-Germain, 75997 Paris
12.
DGRT, 1986Recherche et Développement dans les Entreprises Direction Générale de la Recherche et de la Technologie, Ministère de l'Éducation Nationale, Ministère de la Recherche et de l'Enseignement Supérieure (La Documentation Française, Paris)
13.
DurandP, 1983, “Mutations industrielles et aménagement du territoire”, in Les Cahiers Français N° 211. Le Tissu Industriel Ed. BouchersM, (La Documentation Française, Paris) pp 31–34
14.
DussaugeP, 1985LTndustrie Française de l'Armement (Economica, Paris)
15.
DyckmanJSwyngedouwEAndersonSArcherK, 1987Les Développements de la Haute Technologie et l'Espace Régional dans le Nord/Pas-de-Calais final report, Centre Européan Johns Hopkins, Université de Lille I, 59650 Villeneuve d'Ascq, France
16.
FolmerHNijkampP, 1985, “Methodological aspects of impact analysis of regional economic policy”Papers of the Regional Science Association57165–181
17.
GlasmeierAKMarkusenARHallP, 1983, “Defining high technology industries”, WP-407, Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720
18.
INSEE, 1985Structure des Emplois en 1983 Les Collections de l'INSEE, D-108, Institut National de la Statistique et des Études Économiques, 18 Blvd Adolphe-Pinard, 75675 Paris Cedex 14
19.
INSEE-Rhône-Alpes, 1986, “Enquěte sur la situation de l'emploi dans les grands établissements”, in Point d'Appui pour l'Économie Rhône-Alpes numéro 38, Insee–Rhône–Alpes, 165 Rue Garibaldi, BP 3196, 69041 Lyon Cedex 3
20.
LacourC, 1985, “Références”Revue d'Économie Urbaine et Régionale821–824
21.
Le BrunF, 1986, “La chasse aux aides”Économie et Entreprise numéro 552, pages 38–39
22.
Le GarrecJ, 1984Demain la France: Les Choix du IXième Plan, 1984–1988 (La Découverte, Paris)
23.
LipietzA, 1977Le Capital et son Espace (Maspéro, Paris)
24.
MarkusenAR, 1984, “Defense spending and the geography of high tech industries”, WP-423, Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720
25.
MarkusenAR, 1986, “Defense spending: A successful industrial policy”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research10105–122
26.
MarkusenARBlochR, 1985, “Defensive cities: Military spending, high technology, and human settlements”, in High Technology, Space and Society Ed. CastellsM, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 106–121
27.
PottierC, 1985, “La localisation des activités de pointe en France”, Dossier numéro 45, Centre Économie Espace Environnement, Université de Paris I, 12 Place du Panthéon, 75231 Paris, France
28.
PottierCTouatiPY, 1981, “Concurrence internationale et localisation de l'industrie des semi-conducteurs en France”, Dossier numéro 24, Centre Économie Espace Environnement, Université de Paris I, 12 Place du Panthéon, 75231 Paris, France
29.
SaxenianA, 1983, “The urban contradictions of Silicon Valley—regional growth and restructuring in the semiconductor industry”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research7237–262
30.
SteinJM, 1985, “Militarism as a domestic planning issue”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research9341–351
31.
SwyngedouwE, 1987, “Integrated regional planning, models of decentralization and technological change: Prospects for regional development”, in Planning Without a Passport forthcoming
32.
SwyngedouwEAndersonS, 1986, “The regional pattern and dynamics of high-technology production in France: Some theoretical considerations and empirical evidence”, in Technologies Nouvelles et Développement RégionalGroupe de Recherche des Environnements et Milieux Innovateurs, Centre Économie Espace Environnement, Université de Paris I, 12 Place du Panthéon, 75231 Paris, France; pages 441–459
33.
SwyngedouwEArcherK, 1986, “Les leçons de l'expérience américaine”, in Technologie Nouvelle et Ruptures Régionales Eds ZollerHGFederwischJ, (Economica, Paris) pp 11–40
34.
TiberghienF, 1985, “L'effort de défense depuis 1981”Défense Nationale41 November issue, pages 31–50
35.
VictorJC, 1985Armes (Autrement, Paris)
36.
ZukinS, 1985, “The regional challenge to French industrial policy”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research9352–367
