This paper contains a presentation of a theory and a taxonomy explaining relationships among policies in three spheres—sector, distribution, and space. Based on a juxtaposition of competing approaches of the liberal and radical schools, the theoretical analysis is seen to suggest the dominance of sectoral policies and the complementary role of others, particularly spatial policies. In order to define the interdependencies among policies in practical terms, a relational taxonomy is presented. Last, a procedure of taxonomical analysis is prescribed as a normative guideline for policymaking.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmirahmadiH, 1986, “Regional planning in Iran: A survey of problems and policies”Journal of Developing Areas20501–530
2.
BeckerCMMillsESWilliamsonJG, 1984, “The impact of unbalanced productivity advance on Indian urbanization: Some preliminary findings”, discussion paper UDD-53, The World Bank, Washington, DC
3.
BrowettJ, 1984, “On the necessity and inevitability of uneven spatial development under capitalism”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research8155–176
4.
•CarneyJHudsonRLewisJ, (Eds), 1980Regions in Crisis: New Perspectives in European Regional Theory (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent)
5.
ChoiSCSongBN, 1982, “An evaluation of industrial location policies for urban deconcentration in the Seoul region”, discussion paper UDD-7, The World Bank, Washington, DC
6.
ClarkGL, 1980, “Capitalism and regional inequality”Annals of the Association of American Geographers70226–237
7.
CoaseR, 1960, “The problem of social cost”Journal of Law and Economics31–44
8.
CoreyKE, 1984, “Deconcentrated urbanization in Sri Lanka: A case study of policy serendipity”, urban studies working paper 2, Institute for Urban Studies, University of Maryland, College Park, MD
9.
•DearM, 1981, “The state: A research agenda”Environment and Planning A131191–1196
10.
DearMScottAJ, 1981, “Toward a framework for analysis”, in Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society Eds DearMScottAJ, (Methuen, New York) pp 3–16
11.
•El-ShakhsS, 1972, “Development, primacy and systems of cities”Journal of Developing Areas711–36
12.
FainsteinNIFainsteinSS, 1982, “Restoration and struggle: Urban policy and social forces”, in Urban Policy Under Capitalism Eds FainsteinNIFainsteinSS, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 9–20
13.
•FoxK, 1978, “Uneven regional development in the United States”Review of Radical Political Economics1068–86
14.
FriedmannJ, 1966Regional Development Policy (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
15.
GarnHA, 1985, “The national urban policy study for Egypt: An introduction to national urban settlement and investment strategies”, unpublished paper, The World Bank, Washington, DC
16.
GlickmanN, 1980The Urban Impacts of Federal Policies (The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
17.
•GoldsmithWW, 1978, “Marxism and regional policy: An introduction”Review of Radical Political Economics1013–17
HamerAM, 1983, “Decentralized urban development and industrial location behavior in Sao Paulo, Brazil: A synthesis of research issues and conclusions”, discussion paper UDD-29, The World Bank, Washington, DC
20.
HicksNL, 1979, “Growth vs. basic needs: Is there a trade-off?”World Development7985–994
21.
•HirschmanAO, 1958The Strategy of Economic Development (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
KrugmanP, 1981, “Trade, accumulation, and uneven development”Journal of Development Economics8149–161
25.
•LäppleD, 1978, “Gesellschaftlicher Reproduktionsprozeß und Stadtskrukturen”, in Stadtkrise und soziale Bewegung—Texte zur internationalen Entwicklung Eds MayerMRothRBrandesV, (Europäische Verlagsanstalt, Frankfurt) pp 23–54
26.
LeeKS, 1985, “Decentralization trends of employment location and spatial policies in LDC Cities”Urban Studies22151–162
27.
•LeeR, 1977, “Regional relations and economic structure in the EEC”, in London Papers in Regional Science 7. Alternative Frameworks for Analysis Eds MasseyDBBateyPWJ, (Pion, London) pp 19–35
28.
LimG-C, 1987, “Land markets and public policy: A Korean case study”Habitat International1173–81
29.
LipietzA, 1980, “The structuration of space, the problem and land and spatial policy”, in Regions in Crises: New Perspectives in European Regional Theory Eds CarneyJHudsonRLewisJ, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) pp 60–75
30.
MandelE, 1976, “Capitalism and regional disparity”Southwest Economy and Society141–47
31.
•MarkusenAR, 1979, “Regionalism and the capitalist state: The case of the United States”Kapitalistate739–62
32.
MasseyD, 1978, “Regionalism: Some current issues”Capital and Class6106–125
33.
•MasseyDBateyPWJ, 1977, “Introduction”, in London Papers in Regional Science 7. Alternative Frameworks for Analysis Eds MasseyDBBateyPWJ, (Pion, London) pp 1–5
34.
•MuellerDC, 1979Public Choice (Cambridge University Press, New York)
35.
MyrdalG, 1958Economic Theory and Underdeveloped Regions (Vera, Bombay)
36.
O'ConnorJ, 1973The Fiscal Crisis of the State (St Martin's Press, New York)
37.
OkunAM, 1975Equality and Efficiency: The Big Trade Off (The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC)
38.
OlsonM, 1980The Logic of Collective Action (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
39.
•PerrousF, 1964La Nation de Pole de Croissance, Ueconomie du Xxeme Siecle (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris)
40.
•RawlsJA, 1971A Theory of Justice (The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
41.
RenaudB, 1981National Urbanization Policy in Developing Countries (Oxford University Press, New York)
42.
RichardsonH, 1981, “National urban development strategies in developing countries”Urban Studies18267–283
43.
•RondinelliDA, 1982, “Intermediate cities in developing countries”Third World Planning Review4357–386
44.
•SantosM, 1977, “Society and space: Social transformation as theory and method”Antipode93–13
45.
ScottI, 1982Urban and Spatial Development in Mexico (The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
46.
SojaE, 1978, “Topian Marxism and spatial praxis: A reconsideration of the political economy of space”, paper submitted to the Annual Meeting of the Association of American Geographers, New Orleans, LA; copy from Dr E Soja, Department of Urban Planning, University of California at Los Angeles, CA 90024
47.
•SundquistJ, 1975Dispersing Population (The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC)
48.
The World Bank, 1980Poverty and Basic Needs (The World Bank, Washington, DC)
49.
The World Bank, 1984, “Industrial location policies”Urban Edge8 Number 9, pages 1–6
50.
The World Bank, 1987, “Urban strategies and national development”Urban Edge11 Number 1, pages 1–3
51.
ThoumiF, 1983, “The changing pattern of economic and demographic growth and concentration in Columbian cities and regions (1960–1975)”, in Urban Planning and Spatial Strategies in Rapidly Changing Societies Ed. LimG-C, (Consortium on Urban and Regional Policies in Developing Countries, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ) pp 107–141
52.
WalkerRA, 1978, “Two sources of uneven development under advanced capitalism: Spatial differentiation and capital mobility”Review of Radical Political Economies1028–37
53.
WheatonWCShishidoM, 1981, “Urban concentration, agglomeration economies, and the level of economic development”Economic Development and Cultural Change3017–30
54.
WilliamsonJG, 1965, “Regional inequality and the process of national development: A description of the pattern”Economic Development and Cultural Change133–45
