Against a background of perceptions of women's low participation in entrepreneurship in the United Kingdom, this paper critically reviews recent policy developments in the provision of public sector support for women in enterprise. The available statistical evidence for women's participation in business ownership in the United Kingdom is reviewed against comparative data from the USA that is promoted by the UK government as a potential benchmark. We argue that programming and resource-issue problems are evidenced in new policies that are a direct consequence of lack of data. Next, policy is tested against various paradigmatic stances in women's enterprise support, and problematic areas in poverty alleviation, social inclusion, advocacy, access to finance, and gender mainstreaming are discussed. Selected literature that addresses barriers identified to women's enterprise is reviewed, and issues of confidence, risk, motivation to business start-up, and childcare are discussed in terms of programming. We conclude that, although the Department of Trade and Industry/Small Business Service Strategic Framework for Women's Enterprise in England is flawed, the framework has assembled a broad church of opinions and approaches to women's enterprise support in a democratic, participative, and cross-cutting fashion.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AjzenI, 1991, “The theory of planned behaviour”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes50179–211
2.
AlvarezS AMeyerDale G, 1998, “Why do women become entrepreneurs?”Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research (Arthur M Blank Center for Entrepreneurship, Babson College, Babson Park, MA) pp 165–166
3.
Barclays Bank, 2003, “Barclays small business survey, start-ups and closures”, Barclays Bank, London
4.
BelleALa ValleI, 2003, “Combining self-employment and family life”, Findings Series, Joseph Rowntree Foundation, The Homestead, 40 Water End, York YO30 6WP
5.
BirdBBrushC, 2002, “A gendered perspective on organizational creation”Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice2641–65
6.
BirleyS, 1989, “Female entrepreneurs: Are they really any different?”Journal of Small Business Management277–31
BodenR, 1999a, “Gender inequality in wage earnings and female self-employment selection”The Journal of Social Economics28351–364
9.
BodenR, 1999b, “Flexible working hours, family responsibilities and female self-employment, gender differences in self-employment selection”American Journal of Economics and Sociology5871–83
10.
BondMKerseyD, 2002, “Expanding childminding provision in areas of deprivation”Local Economy17303–312
11.
BothamR, 2004, “Women's enterprise: A review of the literature and available Scottish data”, unpublished report to Scottish Enterprise, Training and Employment Research Unit, University of Glasgow, Glasgow
12.
CarterS, 1993, “Female business ownership: Current research and possibilities for the future”, in Women in Business, Perspectives on Women Entrepreneurs Eds AlanSTrumanC (Routledge, London) pp 148–160
ChellE, 2002, “Women in science enterprise: An exploration of the issues, some policy implications and research agenda”, paper presented at the Gender Research Forum, November, Women and Equality Unit, Cabinet Office, London
17.
ChellEBainesS, 1998, “Does gender affect business performance? A study of micro-businesses in business services in the UK”Entrepreneurship and Regional Development10117–136
18.
CRE, 2002, “Towards racial equality: An evaluation of the public duty to promote race equality and good race relations in England and Wales”, Commission for Racial Equality, St Dunstan's House, 201–211 Borough High Street, London SE1 1GZ
19.
DawsonARosaP, 2003, “Gender and commercialisation of university science, academic founders of spin-out companies”, paper presented at the 2003 International Entrepreneurship and New Venture Creation Conference, University of Durham, September; copy available from Alison Dawson, Centre for Entrepreneurship, University of Stirling, Stirling FK9 4LA
20.
DeakinsDWilsonLWhittamG, 2002, “National centre for women's enterprise: Feasibility study, final research report”, Scottish Executive, Glasgow
21.
DexS, 2003, “Families and work in the twenty-first century”, Joseph Rowntree Foundation, The Homestead, 40 Water End, York YO30 6WP
22.
DexSJoshiH, 1999, “Careers and motherhood: Policies for compatibility”Cambridge Journal of Economics23641–659
23.
DTI, 2000, “Work and parents: Competitiveness and choice”, green paper, Department of Trade and Industry, 1 Victoria Street, London SW1H 0ET
24.
FalkenbergJ, 2003, “Decreasing numbers at increasing levels: An investigation of the gender imbalance at NHH”Gender, Work and Organization10175–193
25.
FieldenS LDavidsonM JDaweA JMakinP J, 2003, “Factors inhibiting the economic growth of female owned small businesses in North West England”Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development10152–166
26.
FSB, 2002, “Lifting the barriers to growth in UK small businesses”, Federation of Small Businesses, Sir Frank Whittle Way, Blackpool Business Park, Blackpool, Lanes FY4 2FE
27.
FSB, 2004, “Lifting barriers to growth in UK small businesses, the FSB biennial survey 2004”, Federation of Small Businesses, Sir Frank Whittle Way, Blackpool Business Park, Blackpool, Lanes FY4 2FE
28.
GallowayLBrownWAreniusP, 2002, “Gender-based differences in entrepreneurial behaviour: A comparative examination of Scotland and Finland”International Journal of Enterprise and Innovation3109–119
29.
GEM, 2001, “Executive report”, Global Entrepreneurship Monitor, Kauffman Center for Entrepreneurial Leadership, Babson College, Boston, MA
30.
HallidayJLittleJ, 2001, “Amongst women, exploring the reality of rural childcare”Sociologia Ruralis41423–437
31.
HardingR, 2002, “Global Entrepreneurship Monitor”, London Business School, London
32.
HartogJFerrer-i-CarbonellAJonkerN, 2002, “Linking measured risk aversion to individual characteristics”Kyklos553–26
33.
HughesK D, 2003, “Pushed or pulled, women's entry in self-employment and small business ownership”Gender, Work and Organization10433–454
34.
HundleyG, 2000, “Male/female earnings differences in self-employment: The effects of marriage, children, and the household division of labor”Industrial and Labor Relations Review October, 95–114
35.
HundleyG, 2001, “Why women earn less than men in self-employment”Journal of Labor Research22817–829
36.
JRF, 2001, “Monitoring poverty and social exclusion”, Joseph Rowntree Foundation, The Homestead, 40 Water End, York YO30 6WP
37.
KellardKMiddletonS, 1998, “Helping unemployed people into self-employment”, Centre for Research in Social Policy, Department for Education and Skills, Caxton House, Tothill Street, London SW1H 9FN
38.
KellardKLeggeKAshworthK, 2002, “Self-employment as a route off benefits”, RR 177, Department of Work and Pensions, Government Buildings, Otley Road, Lawnswood, Leeds LS16 5PU
39.
KirtonGGreeneA-M, 2000The Dynamics of Managing Diversity: A Critical Approach (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford)
40.
KnightsDRichardsW, 2003, “Sex discrimination in UK academia”Gender, Work and Organization10213–238
41.
KourilskyM LWalstadW B, 1998, “Entrepreneurship and female youth: Knowledge, attitudes, gender differences and educational practices”Journal of Business Venturing1377–88
42.
MallonMCohenL, 2001, “Time for a change? Women's accounts of the move from organisational careers to self-employment”British Journal of Management12217–230
43.
MarlowS, 2002, “Women and self-employment: A part of or apart from theoretical construct?”International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation383–91
44.
MarlowSWestallAWatsonE, 2003, “Who benefits?”, New Economics Foundation, 3 Jonathan Street, London SE11 5NH, and Prowess Ltd, Lion House, 20–28 Muspole Street, Norwich NR3 1DJ
45.
MattisM, 2005, “I'm out of here: Women leaving companies in the USA to start their own businesses”, in International Handbook of Women and Small Business Entrepreneurship Eds FieldenSDavidsonM J (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) (forthcoming)
46.
MauthnerNMcKeeLStrellM, 2001, “Work and family life in rural communities”, Joseph Rowntree Foundation, The Homestead, 40 Water End, York YO30 6WP
47.
MayouxL, 2001, “Jobs, gender and small enterprises: Getting the policy environment right”, SEED WP 15, International Labour Organization, Geneva
48.
MetcalfHBensonR, 2000, “From unemployment to self-employment: Developing an effective structure of microfinance support”, DP 170, National Institute of Economic and Social Research, London
49.
NielsenB, 2002, “Statistics on new enterprises and survival of start-ups: The Danish experience”, ST1 WP 2002/7, Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris
50.
ONS, 2001, “Labour force survey data”, Office for National Statistics, London
51.
OrhanMScottD, 2001, “Why women enter entrepreneurship: An explanatory model”Women in Management Review16232–243
RichardsonPHartshornC, 1995, “The issues faced by women in Scotland considering enterpreneurship and their attitudes towards support provision”, paper presented at the 18th National Institute of Small Business Affairs Conference, University of Paisley; copy available from PERC, University of Paisley, 1 High Street, Paisley, PA1 2BE
54.
SBS, Small Business Service, Kingsgate House, 66–74 Victoria Street, London SW1E 6SW
55.
2003a, “Women's Enterprise Strategic Framework: Consultative document”, Ethnic Minority and Women's Enterprise Unit
56.
2003b, “A Strategic Framework for Women's Enterprise: Sharing the vision: A collaborative approach to increasing female entrepreneurship”
57.
2004, “A government action plan for small business: The evidence base”
58.
ScottGCampbellJBrownU, 2001, “The contribution of childcare to local employment: Poor work or work for the poor”Local Economy16187–197
59.
Scottish Executive, 1999, “Social justice: A Scotland where everyone matters”, Scottish Executive, Edinburgh
60.
Scottish Executive, 2001, “Survey of SMEs”, Scottish Executive, Glasgow
61.
Scottish Executive, 2003, “National Unit for Women's Enterprise”, press release, March, Scottish Executive, Edinburgh
62.
SlovicP, 1999, “Trust, emotion, sex, politics and science: Assessing the risk assessment battlefield”Risk Analysis19689–701
ThieleB, 1992, “Vanishing acts in social and political thought: Tricks of the trade”, in Defining Women, Social Institutions and Gender Divisions Eds McDowellLPringleR (Open University Press, Milton Keynes) pp 26–35
65.
WatsonJ, 2003, “Failure rates for female-controlled businesses, are they any different?”Journal of Small Business Management41262–277
