This paper outlines a number of possible reforms of local government finance in Britain against the philosophical background of reducing the power of government in aggregate and reasserting the independence of local authorities. The reforms suggested are for a simpler central grant, a local income tax (combined with self-assessment and year-end adjustment for present PAYE payers, with eventual noncumulative PAYE and credit income tax), a land value tax at national level to replace local nondomestic rates, charges for use of local services by industry and commerce, and a new independent revenue source for parish and community councils. These proposals are proffered as a review of one aspect of the political platform for change offered by the ‘centre’ political parties in Britain.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArcherR W, 1976, “The Sydney betterment levy 1969–73: An experiment in functional funding for metropolitan development”Urban Studies13339–342
2.
BarrN AJamesS RPrestA R, 1977Self-assessment for Income Tax (Heinemann, London)
3.
BennettR J, 1981, “The local income tax in Britain: A critique of recent arguments against its use”Public Administration59295–311
4.
BennettR J, 1982Central Grants to Local Governments: The Political and Economic Impacts of the Rate Support Grant in England and Wales (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
5.
BurgessTTraversT, 1980Ten Billion Pounds: Whitehall's Takeover of the Town Halls (Grant McLntyre, London)
6.
CrawfordMDawsonD, 1982, “Are rates the right tax for local government?”Lloyds Bank Review14515–35
7.
GarlandJ M, 1934Economic Aspects of Australian Land Taxation (Melbourne University Press, Melbourne)
8.
HC Environment Committee, 1982, “Enquiry in methods of financing local government in the context of the Government's green paper (Cmnd 8449)” second report of the Environment Committee (House of Commons), session 1981–82, HC Papers 217 (3 volumes) (HMSO, London)
9.
HC Parliamentary Committee, 1952, “The rating of site values” report of the Parliamentary Committee (House of Commons) session 1951–52 (Chairman: Erskine-Simes QC) (HMSO, London)
10.
HepworthN, 1982, “Presentation to the ‘Liberal Party Working Group on Local Government Finance’” (Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy, London)
11.
HM Government, 1947Public General Acts—George VI, 1947 chapter 51, Town and Country Planning Act, 1947 (HMSO, London)
12.
HM Government, 1954, Report of the Scotland valuation and rating Committee, Cmnd 9244 (HMSO, London)
13.
HM Government, 1955, “Valuation and rating in Scotland” Cmnd 9606 (HMSO, London)
14.
HM Government, 1956Public General Acts—Elizabeth II, 1956 chapter 26, Valuation and Rating (Scotland) Act (HMSO, London)
15.
HM Government, 1971a, “The future shape of local government finance” Department of the Environment green paper, Cmnd 4741 (HMSO, London)
16.
HM Government, 1971bPublic General Acts—Elizabeth II, 1971 Chapter 78, Town and Country Planning (Amendment) Act (HMSO, London)
17.
HM Government, 1972, “Proposals for a tax-credit system” Treasury green paper, Cmnd 5116 (HMSO, London)
18.
HM Government, 1973Public General Acts—Elizabeth II, 1973 chapter 26, Land Compensation Act (HMSO, London)
19.
HM Government, 1975Public General Acts—Elizabeth II, 1975 chapter 77, Community Land Act (HMSO, London)
20.
HM Government, 1977a, “Local government finance”Department of the Environment (Welsh Office) green paper, Cmnd 6813 (HMSO, London)
HM Government, 1980Public General Acts—Elizabeth II, 1980 chapter 65, Local Government Planning and Land Act, 1980 (HMSO, London)
23.
HM Government, 1981, “Alternatives to domestic rates”Department of the Environment (Scottish Office; Welsh Office) green paper, Cmnd 8449 (HMSO, London)
24.
HM Government, 1982a, “The government's expenditure plans, 1982–83 to 1984–85”, Treasury green paper, Cmnd 8494, 2 volumes (HMSO, London)
25.
HM Government, 1982bPublic General Acts—Elizabeth II, 1982 chapter …., Local Government Finance Act, 1982 (HMSO, London)
26.
Kilbrandon, 1973Royal Commission on the Constitution 1969–1973 (Chairman: Lord Kilbrandon) Cmnd 5460, 2 volumes (HMSO, London)
27.
Layfield, 1976Committee of Inquiry into Local Government Finance (Chairman: Frank Layfield, QC) Cmnd 6453, report and 10 appendices (HMSO, London)
28.
Liberal Party, 1982, “Local finance for local government”Report of a Working Group on Local Government Finance, Liberal Party Headquarters, 1 Whitehall Place, London SW1
29.
Maud, 1969Royal Commission on Local Government in England 1966–69 (Chairman: The Rt. Hon. Lord Redcliffe-Maud) Cmnd 4040, 3 volumes (HMSO, London)
30.
MieskowskiP, 1972, “The property tax: Excise tax or profits tax?”Journal of Public Economics273–96
31.
MillsS, 1925Taxation in Australia (Macmillan, London)
32.
PrestA R, 1981The Taxation of Urban Land (Manchester University Press, Manchester)
33.
SDP, 1982, “Decentralising government” SDP green paper-3 (Social Democratic Party, 4 Cowley Street, London SW1)
34.
SharpeL J, 1981The Local Fiscal Crisis in Western Europe: Myths and Realities (Sage, Beverley Hills, CA)
35.
StewartJJonesG, 1982, “The way ahead for local government finance” response to HM Government green paper, Cmnd 8449, 1981; Institute of Local Government Studies, University of Birmingham
36.
TinsleyC H, 1976, “Rating—the way ahead”The Estates Gazette September 25, pp 962–969
37.
WilksH M, 1964Rating of Site ValuesRating and Valuation Association, 115 Ebury Street, London SW1
38.
WilksH M, 1973, “Some reflections on the second valuation of Whitstable”International Union for Land Value Taxation and Free Trade, 177 Vauxhall Bridge Road, London SW1
39.
WyattC M, 1983, “The effects of rating reform in Britain: A case study of Derby”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy157–72
