A methodology is developed which enables intraurban spatial variations in local government service provision to be measured. The methodology is sufficiently general to be applied to any service delivered by British local government. The allocation of expenditure to different geographical areas of the authority and contributions in the form of taxation from these zones are each identified in order to estimate net fiscal incidence. A brief review of existing studies is presented, which shows that although increasing attention has been given to the geographical distribution of local government spending, there have been few systematic studies examining expenditure and revenue flows. The problems associated with measuring expenditure incidence are discussed and reviewed. It is suggested that ‘participation’ forms a basis for estimating expenditure distribution to the household sector. Revenue is contributed by households in various roles. Here, contributions through income are used as a surrogate. Household incomes can in turn be estimated by category analysis techniques. In addition, contributions through the rating system are assessed. Finally, a systematic statement of the methodology is outlined and its possible contribution to important policy areas suggested.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BassettKHauserD, 1975, “Public policy and spatial structure: Housing improvement in Bristol” in Bristol Geography Ed. PeelR, (Heinemann Educational Books, London) pp 20–66
2.
BennettR J, 1980The Geography of Public Finance. Welfare Under Fiscal Federation and Local Government Finance (Methuen, Andover, Hants)
3.
BensonCLundP B, 1969Neighbourhood Distribution of Local Public ServicesInstitute of Government Studies, University of California, Berkeley, CA
4.
BoadenN, 1971Urban Policy-Making (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
5.
BradshawJ, 1972, “The concept of social need”New Society496640–643
6.
BroomanF J, 1970Macro-Economics (George Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
7.
CoxK R, 1972Conflict, Power and Politics in the City: A Geographic View (McGraw-Hill, Maidenhead, Berks)
8.
CoxK R, 1979Location and Public Problems (Basil Blackwell, Oxford)
9.
CulyerA JLaversR JWilliamsA, 1972, “Health indicators” in Social Indicators and Social Policy Eds ShonfieldAShawS, (Heinemann Educational Books, London) pp 94–118
10.
DaviesB, 1968Social Needs and Resources in Local Services (Michael Joseph, London)
11.
DoE, 1973Rate Rebates in England and WalesDepartment of the Environment (HMSO, London)
12.
DoE, 1974Liverpool Inner Area Study—Area Resource Analysis: MethodologyDepartment of the Environment, 2 Marsham Street, London SW1P 3EB
13.
DoE, 1977The Development of an Income SurrogateDepartment of the Environment
14.
DunleavyP, 1980Urban Political Analysis (Macmillan, London)
15.
EddisonT, 1973Local Government: Management and Corporate Planning (Leonard Hill Books, London)
16.
FosterC DOsborneM, 1976, “Minimum standards” in Government Grants to Local Authorities: Evidence and Commissioned Work, Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Local Government Finance, Appendix 7, Chairman Frank Lay field (QC), Cmnd 6453 (HMSO, London) pp 54–60
17.
GoodmanP, 1973, “Trip generation: A review of the category analysis and regression models” WP-36, School of Geography, University of Leeds, Leeds, England
18.
GoodmanP, 1974, “A category analysis trip generation model for West Yorkshire” WP-33, Institute of Transport Studies, University of Leeds, Leeds, England
19.
GreeneK VNeenanW GScottC D, 1976, “Fiscal incidence in the Washington metropolitan area”Land Economics5213–31
20.
HallF L, 1973, “Location criteria for high schools” research paper 150, Department of Geography, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL
21.
HambletonR, 1978Policy Planning and Local Government (Hutchinson, London)
22.
HarveyD, 1973Social Justice in the City (Edward Arnold, London)
23.
HoughJ R, 1981A Study of School Costs (NFER, Slough, Berks)
24.
JohnstonR J, 1979Political, Electoral and Spatial Systems (Clarendon Press, London)
25.
Layfield, 1976Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Local Government Finance, Chairman Frank Layfield (QC), Cmnd 6453 (HMSO, London)
26.
LewisR J, 1970, “The use of census data in obtaining household income contributions”Traffic Engineering and Control11416–418
27.
McAllisterD, 1976, “Equity and efficiency in public facility location”Geographical Analysis847–63
28.
MassamB, 1975Location and Space in Social Administration (Edward Arnold, London)
29.
MishanE J, 1969, “A survey of welfare economics 1939–1959” in Welfare Economics: Ten Introductory Essays Ed. MishanE J, (Randon House, New York) pp 11–86
30.
NevittDRobertiP, 1974, “In search of the determinants of rents and gross values”Policy and Politics2(3) 205–217
31.
OxleyM, 1976, “The future of rating”Estates Gazette240529–535
32.
RandallG WLomasK WNewtonT, 1973, “Area distribution of resources in Coventry”Local Government Finance77(11) 396–400
RobertsonI M L, 1972, “Population distribution and location problems: An approach by grid squares in central Scotland”Regional Studies6237–245
35.
RowleyC KPeacockA T, 1975Welfare Economics: A Liberal Restatement (Martin Robertson, Oxford)
36.
ScitovskyT, 1968Welfare and Competition (George Allen and Unwin, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
37.
SeniorM L, 1975, “A category analysis trip end model: Base year results and performance for the West Yorkshire area” WP-128, School of Geography, University of Leeds, Leeds, England
38.
SmithD, 1977Human Geography: A Welfare Approach (Edward Arnold, Maidenhead, Berks)
39.
SmolenskyEBurtonRTidemanN, 1970, “The efficient provision of a local non-private good”Geographical Analysis2330–342
40.
South Glamorgan County Council, 1978, “Area analysis of resources” presented to the INLOGOV Research and Intelligence Annual Conference, University of York, York, England; copy available from Forward Planning Unit, South Glamorgan County Council, Wales
41.
StewartJSpencerKWebsterB, 1975, “Local government approaches to urban deprivation” OP-1, Urban Deprivation Unit, Home Office, London
42.
TunleyPTraversTPrattJ, 1979Depriving the Deprived (Kogan Page, London)
43.
WebsterBHornC JMasonTSpencerK MVielbaC, 1977Area Management: Objectives and Structures first interim report, Area Management Monitoring Project, INLOGOV, Birmingham
44.
WebsterBStewartJ, 1974, “The area analysis of resources”Policy and Politics3(1) 4–16
45.
WhiteJ ACaseK E, 1974, “On covering problems and the central facilities location problem”Geographical Analysis6(4) 281–293
46.
WhiteheadP J, 1981The Development and Application of a Framework to Investigate Intra-Urban Spatial Variations in Local Government Service Provision PhD thesis, School of Geography, University of Leeds, Leeds, England
47.
WhiteheadP J, 1983, “Intraurban spatial variations in local government service provision: 2. Application and results”Environment and Planning C1(2) forthcoming
48.
WilsonAG, 1971, “A family of spatial interaction models and associated developments”Environment and Planning31–32
49.
WolpertJ, 1965, “Behavioural aspects of the decision to migrate”Papers of the Regional Science Association15159–169
50.
WoottonH JPickG W, 1967, “A model for trips generated by households”Journal of Transport Economics and Policy1137–153
