The author reports the results of a survey of more than five hundred local planners in the United States. The purpose of the survey was to measure the extent to which an ecological definition of sustainable development is reflected in planners' views and opinions. Through statistical and other quantitative analyses of the results of the survey, it was found that the conceptual integration of sustainability is most related to the planners' academic background, the state public policy context in which they work, and their general level of support for the concept. Although there is much consistency between planners' views and sustainability there remain several areas of conceptual conflict, primarily in relation to nonurban issues (that is, agriculture and natural open space) and private market forces that affect the use of land.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AhernJBoughtonJ, 1994, “Wildflower meadows as sustainable landscapes”, in The Ecological City: Preserving and Restoring Urban Diversity Eds PlattR HRowntreeR AMuickP C, (University of Massachusetts Press, Amherst, MA) pp 172–187
2.
AlexanderE R, 2000, “Rationality revisited: Planning paradigms in a post-postmodernist perspective”Journal of Planning Education and Research19242–256
3.
AllenT F HStarrT, 1988Hierarchy: Perspectives for Ecological Complexity (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
4.
BaumH S, 1983, “Planning and professions”, in Planners and Public Expectations (Schenkman, Cambridge, MA) pp 3–40
5.
BeatleyT, 1995a, “The many meanings of sustainability”Journal of Planning Literature9339–342
6.
BeatleyT, 1995b, “Planning and sustainability: The elements of a new (improved?) paradigm”Journal of Planning Literature9383–395
7.
BeatleyTBrowerD J, 1993, “Sustainability comes to Main Street”Planning59(5) 16–19
8.
BeatleyTManningK, 1997The Ecology of Place: Planning for Environment, Economy, and Community (Island Press, Washington, DC)
9.
BeauregardR E, 1990, “Intellectual journeys and political destinations”Planning Theory Newsletter47–11
10.
BeauregardR E, 1991, “Without a net: Modernist planning and the postmodern abyss”Journal of Planning Education and Research10(3) 189–195
11.
BerkeP R, 1995, “Natural-hazard reduction and sustainable development: A global assessment”Journal of Planning Literature9371–395
12.
BerkeP RConroyM M, 2000, “Are we planning for sustainable development?”Journal of the American Planning Association6621–33
13.
BlowersA, 1993, “The time for change”, in Planning for a Sustainable Environment Ed. BlowersA, (Earthscan Publications, London) pp 1–18
14.
BolanR S, 1980, “The practitioner as theorist”Journal of the American Planning Association46261–274
15.
BrehenyM, 1993, “Planning the sustainable city region”Town and Country Planning April, pages 71–75
16.
BrownL R, 1981Building a Sustainable Society (W W Norton, New York)
17.
BruffG EWoodA P, 2000, “Making sense of sustainable development: Politicians, professionals, and policies in local planning”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy18593–607
18.
CampbellS, 1996, “Green cities, growing cities, just cities?”Journal of the American Planning Association62296–312
19.
CarleyMChristieI, 1993Managing Sustainable Development (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
20.
ChristensenN LJr, 1996, “Science and the sustainable use of land”, in Land Use in America Eds DiamondH LNoonanP F, (Island Press, Washington, DC) pp 273–294
21.
CullingworthB, 1997Planning in the USA (Routledge, New York)
22.
DaltonL C, 2000, “Introduction: Planning for people and places”, in The Practice of Local Government Planning Eds HochC JDaltonL CSoF S, International City/County Management Association, 777 North Capitol Street NE, Suite 500, Washington, DC 20002–4201
23.
DalyH E, 1989, “Steady-state and growth concepts for the next century”, in Economy and Ecology: Towards Sustainable Development Eds ArchibugiFNijkampP, (Kluwer, Boston, MA) pp 73–88
24.
DalyH ECobbJ BJr, 1989For the Common Good (Beacon Press, Boston, MA)
25.
DavelaarE-JNijkampP, 1990, “Structural transformation of cities: A Dutch example”, in Sustainability of Urban Systems Ed. NijkampP, (Avebury, Brookfield, VT) pp 111–136
26.
DavidoffPReinerT A, 1962, “A choice theory of planning”Journal of the American Institute of Planners28103–115
27.
di CastriFHadleyM, 1986, “Enhancing the credibility of ecology: Is interdisciplinary research for land use planning useful?”Geo Journal13299–325
28.
DubosR, 1981Celebrations of Life (McGraw-Hill, New York)
29.
DyckmanJ W, 1967, “City planning and the treasury of science”, in Environment for Man Ed. EwaldW R, (Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN) pp 27–59
30.
EhrenreichBEhrenreichJ, 1978, “The professional-managerial class”, in Between Labor and Capital Ed. WalkerP, (Black Rose Books, Montreal) pp 5–45
31.
EkinsP, 1993, “‘Limits to growth’ and ‘sustainable development’: Grappling with ecological realities”Ecological Economics8269–288
32.
FriedmannJ, 1989, “Planning, politics, and the environment”Journal of the American Planning Association55334–338
33.
FriedmannJ, 1993, “Toward a non-euclidian mode of planning”Journal of the American Planning Association59482–485
GiaoutziM, 1990, “Complexity in urban dynamics: A Greek example”, in Sustainability of Urban Systems Ed. NijkampP, (Gower, Brookfield, VT) pp 183–218
36.
GirardetH, 1992The Gaia Atlas of Cities (Doubleday, New York)
37.
GrantJManuelPJoudreyD, 1996, “A framework for planning sustainable residential landscapes”Journal of the American Planning Association62331–344
38.
HarperT LSteinS M, 1992, “The centrality of normative ethical theory to contemporary planning theory”Journal of Planning Education and Research11(2) 105–116
39.
HarrisJ MGoodwinN R, 2001, “Introduction”, in A Survey of Sustainable Development Eds HarrisJ MWiseT AGallagherK PGoodwinN R, (Island Press, Washington, DC)
HealeyPShawT, 1993, “Planners, plans and sustainable development”Regional Studies27769–776
42.
HerspergerA M, 1994, “Landscape ecology and its potential application to planning”Journal of Planning Literature914–29
43.
HochC, 1984, “Doing good and being right”Journal of the American Planning Association50335–344
44.
HoweE, 1994, “Planners' roles”, in Acting on Ethics in City Planning (Center for Urban Policy Research, New Brunswick, NJ) pp 112–147
45.
InnesJ E, 1996, “Planning through consensus: A new view of the comprehensive planning ideal”Journal of the American Planning Association62460–472
46.
JacobsM, 1991The Green Economy: Environment, Sustainable Development and the Politics of the Future (Pluto Press, London)
47.
JepsonE J, 2001, “Sustainability and planning: Diverse concepts and close associations”Journal of Planning Literature15499–510
48.
JonesA, 1996, “The psychology of sustainability: What planners can learn from attitude research”Journal of Planning Education and Research1656–65
49.
KatzD, 1986, “Metropolitan food systems and the sustainable city”, in Sustainable Communities Eds Van der RynSCalthorpeP, (Sierra Club Books, San Francisco, CA) pp 148–166
50.
KayJ J, 1991, “The concept of ecological integrity, alternative theories of ecology, and implications for decision-support indicators”, in Economic, Ecological, and Decision Theories: Indicators of Ecologically Sustainable Development Eds VictorP AKayJ JRuitenbeckH J, The Canadian Environmental Advisory Council, c/o Environment Canada, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0H3, pp 23–58
51.
KingJSlesserM, 1994, “The natural philosophy of natural capital: Can solar energy substitute?”, in Toward Sustainable Development Eds van den BerghJ C J Mvan der StraatenJ, (Island Press, Washington, DC) pp 139–163
52.
KrizekK JPowerJ, 1996A Planners Guide to Sustainable Development Planning Advisory Service Report 467 (American Planning Association, Chicago, IL)
53.
LangJ, 1983, “Teaching planning to city planning students. An argument for the studio/workshop approach”Journal of Planning Education and Research2122–129
54.
LyleJ T, 1994Regenerative Design for Sustainable Development (John Wiley, New York)
55.
LynchK, 1981Good City Form (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
56.
McDonaldG T, 1996, “Planning as sustainable development”Journal of Planning Education and Research15225–236
57.
MacNeillJ, 1989, “Strategies for sustainable development”Scientific American261(3) 155–165
58.
ManningE W, 1986Towards Sustainable Land Use: A StrategyMinister of Supply and Services, Ottawa, Canada
59.
MaserC, 1997Sustainable Community Development (St. Lucie Press, Delray Beach, FL)
60.
MeadowsD HMeadowsD LRandersJ, 1992Beyond the Limits (Chelsea Green Publishing Company, Post Mills, VT)
61.
MintzbergH, 1994, “The fall and rise of strategic planning”Harvard Business Review January–February, pages 107–115
62.
MollisonB, 1990Permaculture: A Practical Guide for a Sustainable Future (Island Press, Washington, DC)
63.
MyersDKitsuseA, 2000, “Constructing the future in planning: A survey of theories and tools”Journal of Planning Education and Research19221–232
64.
PatteeH H, 1973, “The physical basis and origin of hierarchical control”, in Hierarchy Theory: The Challenge of Complex Systems Ed. PatteeH H, (Braziller, New York) pp 72–108
65.
PoracskyJHouckM C, 1994, “The metropolitan Portland Urban Natural Resource Program”, in The Ecological City Eds PlattR HRowntreeR AMuickP C, (University of Massachusetts Press, Amherst, MA)
66.
ReesW E, 1989Defining “Sustainable Development”CHS Research Bulletin, Centre for Human Settlements, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada
67.
ReesW E, 1990, “Planning for sustainable development: A resource book”, proceedings of a symposium organized by the School of Community and Regional Planning, the University of British Columbia, 25–27 November, 1988; Centre for Human Settlements, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada
68.
ReesW E, 1992, “Ecological footprints and appropriated carrying capacity; what urban economics leaves out”Environment and Urbanization4(2) 121–130
69.
ReesW E, 1995, “Achieving sustainability: Reform or transformation?”Journal of Planning Literature9343–361
70.
ReesW ERoselandM, 1991, “Sustainable communities: Planning for the 21st century”Plan Canada31(3) 15–26
71.
RolstonHIII, 1988Environmental Ethics (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA)
72.
RoselandM, 1998Toward Sustainable Communities (New Society Publishers, Gabriola Island, Canada)
SchonD A, 1983The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action (Basic Books, New York)
75.
ScruggsP, 1993, “Definitions and principles”, in Guidelines for State Level Sustainable Development Ed. ParkS, Center for Policy Alternatives and Environmental Resource Program, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, pp 3–8
76.
ShawDKiddS, 1996, “Planning sustainable development: Principles and implementation”Journal of Planning Education and Research15237–241
77.
ShortJ R, 1982, “Urban policy and British cities”Journal of the American Planning Association4824–38
SimonH A, 1962, “The architecture of complexity”Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society106467–482
80.
SitarzD, (Ed.), 1994Agenda 21: The Earth Summit Strategy to Save Our Planet (EarthPress, Boulder, CO)
81.
SmithT W, 1996, “Sustainable communities in the urban–rural interface”Small Town and Rural Planning March, pages 8–12
82.
SpainD, 1995, “Sustainability, feminist visions, and the utopian tradition”Journal of Planning Literature9362–369
83.
StoneP A, 1973The Structure, Size and Costs of Urban Settlements (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
84.
TalenEEllisC, 2002, “Beyond relativism: Reclaiming the search for good city form”Journal of Planning Education and Research2236–49
85.
TonnB E, 1986, “500-year planning—speculative provocation”Journal of the American Planning Association52185–193
86.
Van der RynSCowanS, 1996Ecological Design (Island Press, Washington, DC)
87.
VictorP A, 1991, “Indicators of sustainable development: Some lessons from capital theory”, in Economic, Ecological, and Decision Theories: Indicators of Ecologically Sustainable Development Eds VictorP AKayJ JRuitenbeckH J, The Canadian Environmental Advisory Council, c/o Environment Canada, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0H3, pp 1–22
88.
VoiseyHBeuermannCSverdrupL AO'RiordanT, 1996, “The political significance of Local Agenda 21: The early stages of some European experience”Local Environment1(1) 33–50
89.
WackernagelMReesW, 1996Our Ecological Footprint (New Society, Gabriola Island, Canada)
90.
WCED, 1987Our Common Future The Brundtland Report, World Commission on Environment and Development (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
91.
WhiteR R, 1994Urban Environmental Management (John Wiley, New York)
92.
WitmanW E, 1985Ecology, Impact Assessment and Environmental Planning (John Wiley, New York)
