Although promotion of the compact city is now enshrined in land-use planning policy in many countries, including the United Kingdom, there is little evidence to support the many claims in its favour. In seeking to provide empirical data to advance the debate, one of the key problems researchers face is the task of measuring urban compactness. Research on the compact city is hampered both by a lack of consensus on its meaning and by the absence of recognised indicators for measuring it. This paper describes the development of a large set of urban compactness indicators used in an investigation of social sustainability outcomes in twenty-five English towns and cities. The paper begins by identifying and defining the different aspects of urban compactness, then outlines the indicators (including sources and methods) used for measuring each of these aspects. Finally, the values of these indicators for a range of English towns and cities are presented and reviewed. The aim of the paper is to contribute methodological tools to the compact city debate and provide a model for further research, essential in this field.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlexanderE, 1993, “Density measures: a review and analysis”Journal of Architectural and Planning Research10(3) 181–202
2.
AlexanderEReedK D, 1988, “Density measures and their relation to urban form”, Center for Architecture and Urban Planning Research, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI
3.
BarlowJ, 1994Offices into Flats: Flexible Design and Flexible Planning (Policy Studies Institute, London)
4.
BarrettG, 1996, “The transport dimension”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 171–180
5.
BentleyIAlcockAMurrainPMcGlynnSSmithG, 1985Responsive Environments: A Manual for Designers (Architectural Press, London)
6.
BibbyPCoppinP, 1994Analyses of Land Use Change Statistics a report for the Department of the Environment, SERRL Occasional Monographs 1; now Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
7.
BibbyPShepherdJ, 1990Rates of Urbanisation in England 1981–2001 a report for the Department of the Environment, now Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
8.
BoyleM, 1989, “Grading the state business climate report cards”The Economic and Demographic Trends Newsletter2(1) 1–6
9.
BrehenyM J (Ed.), 1992European Research in Regional Science 2. Sustainable Development and Urban Form (Pion, London)
10.
BrehenyMGentTLockD, 1993Alternative Development Patterns: New SettlementsPlanning Research Programme, Department of the Environment (HMSO, London)
11.
BrehenyMRookwoodR, 1993, “Planning the sustainable city region”, in Planning for a Sustainable Environment Ed. BlowersA (Earthscan Publications, London) pp 150–189
12.
BrotchieJ, 1992, “The changing structure for cities”Urban Futuresspecial issue 513–23
13.
BurtonE, 1998The Compact City: Just or Just Compact? unpublished PhD thesis, School of Architecture, Oxford Brookes University, Oxford
14.
BurtonE, 2000a, “The potential of the compact city for promoting social equity”, in Achieving Sustainable Urban Forms Eds WilliamsKBurtonEJenksM (Spon, London) pp 19–29
15.
BurtonE, 2000b, “The compact city: just or just compact? A preliminary analysis”Urban Studies371969–2006
16.
BurtonTMatsonL, 1996, “Urban footprints: making best use of urban land and resources—a rural perspective”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 298–301
17.
CadmanDPayneG (Eds), 1989The Living City: Towards a Sustainable Future (Routledge, London)
18.
CalthorpeP, 1993The Next American Metropolis: Ecology, Community and the American Dream (Princeton Architectural Press, New York)
19.
CEC, 1990Green Paper on the Urban Environment EUR 12902 (Commission of European Communities, Brussels)
20.
Church of England, 1985Faith in the City: A Call for Action by Church and Nation report of the Archbishop of Canterbury's Commission on Urban Priority Areas, Church House, Great Smith Street, London SW1P 3NZ
21.
CoombesMWongC, 1994, “Methodological steps in the development of multivariate indexes for urban and regional policy analysis”Environment and Planning A261297–1316
22.
CoombesMRaybouldSWongC, 1992Developing Indicators to Assess the Potential for Urban Regeneration Inner Cities Directorate, Department of the Environment (HMSO, London)
23.
CraigJ, 1985A 1981 Socio-Economic Classification of Local and Health Authorities of Great Britain OPCS Studies on Medical and Population Subjects 48 (HMSO, London)
24.
Department of the Environment and Local Government, 1999Residential Density: Consultation Draft of Guidelines for Planning Authorities (The Stationery Office, Dublin)
25.
Department of Transport, 1993National Travel Survey 1989/91 (HMSO, London)
26.
DETR, Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions; now Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU 1998a Planning for the Communities of the Future Cm 3885 (The Stationery Office, London)
27.
DETR, 1998bThe Use of Density in Urban Planning (The Stationery Office, London)
28.
DETR, 1998cPlanning for Sustainable Development: Towards Better Practice (The Stationery Office, London)
29.
DETR, 1998dA New Deal for Transport: Better for Everyone, the Government's White Paper on the Future of Transport Cm 3950 (The Stationery Office, London)
30.
DETR, 1999A Better Quality of Life: A Strategy for Sustainable Development in the United Kingdom Cm 4345 (The Stationery Office, London)
31.
DETR, CABE2000By Design: Urban Design in the Planning System: Towards Better PracticeDepartment of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (Thomas Telford Publishing, London)
32.
DoE, Department of the Environment; now Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
33.
DoE, 1983Urban Deprivation Information Note 2, Inner Cities Directorate
34.
DoE, 1990Housebuilding in England by Local Authority Areas 1981–1989Government Statistical Service
35.
DoE, 1991Survey of Derelict Land in England 1988, Volume 2 (HMSO, London) 1994Sustainable Development: The UK Strategy Cm 2426 (HMSO, London)
DoE1995bCommercial and Industrial Floorspace Statistics 1995 Construction Sponsorship Directorate (HMSO, London)
38.
DoE1995cSurvey of Derelict Land in England 1993, Volume 2 (HMSO, London)
39.
DoE1997Planning Policy Guidance: General Policy and Principles PPG1 (The Stationery Office, London)
40.
DoE, Department of Transport, 1994Planning Policy Guidance: Transport PPG13 (HMSO, London)
41.
DoE and Welsh Office, 1992Local Housing Statistics, England and Walesnumber 103, October, Government Statistical Service
42.
DuanyAPlater-ZyberkE, 1991Towns and Town-Making Principles (Rizzoli International, New York)
43.
ECOTEC, 1993Reducing Transport Emissions Through PlanningDepartment of the Environment (HMSO, London)
44.
ElkinTMcLarenDHillmanM, 1991Reviving the City: Towards Sustainable Urban Development Friends of the Earth, 16–24 Underwood Street, London N1 7JQ
45.
GoodchildB, 1985, “The significance of density”Housing Review34(4) 126–129
46.
GoodchildB, 1994, “Housing design, urban form and sustainable development”Town Planning Review65143–157
47.
GordonDForrestR, 1995People and Places 2: Social and Economic Distinctions in England (School for Advanced Urban Studies, Bristol)
48.
GottliebP, 1995, “Residential amenities, firm location and economic development”Urban Studies321413–1436
49.
GreenA, 1994The Geography of Poverty and Wealth: Evidence on the Changing Spatial Distribution and Segregation of Poverty and Wealth from the Census of Population 1981 and 1991Institute for Employment Research, University of Coventry, Warwick
50.
GreenA EChampionA G, 1991, “Research policy and review 35. The Booming Town studies: methodological issues”Environment and Planning A231393–1408
51.
GreenR, 1996, “Not compact cities but sustainable regions”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 143–154
52.
GwilliamMBourneCSwainCPratA, 1999Sustainable Renewal of Suburban Areas report for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (York Publishing Services, York)
HayesM, 1986Urban Decline and Deprivation: Liverpool's Relative Position—A Technical ReportPlanning Department, Liverpool City Council, Millennium House, 60 Victoria Street, Liverpool L1 6JF
55.
HowardE, 1989Garden Cities of Tomorrow (Faber and Faber, London)
Llewelyn-Davies, 1994Providing More Homes in Urban Areas in association with the Joseph Rowntree Foundation and Environmental Trust Associates (SAUS Publications, University of Bristol, Bristol)
58.
Llewelyn-Davies, 1997Sustainable Residential Quality: New Approaches to Urban Living Report for the Government Office for London, Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, London Planning Advisory Committee, Artillery House, Artillery Row, London SW1P 1RT
59.
LockD, 1995, “Room for more within city limits?”Town and Country Planning64(7) 173–176
60.
LPAC, 1998Dwellings over and in Shops in LondonLondon Planning Advisory Committee, Artillery House, Artillery Row, London SW1P 1RT
61.
McLarenD, 1992, “Compact or dispersed? Dilution is no solution”Built Environment18(4) 268–284
62.
MartinLMarchL, 1972Urban Space and Structures (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
63.
MinneryJ, 1992Urban Form and Development Strategies: Equity, Environmental and Economic Implications: The National Housing Strategy (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra)
64.
MohneyDEasterlingK, 1991Seaside: Making a Town in America (Princeton Architectural Press, New York)
65.
NaessP, 1993, “Can urban development be made environmentally sound?”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management36309–333
66.
NewmanP, 1992, “The compact city—an Australian perspective”Built Environment18285–300
67.
NewmanPKenworthyJ, 1989Cities and Automobile Dependence (Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
68.
NewtonPTuckerSAmbroseM, 2000, “Housing form, energy use and greenhouse gas emissions”, in Achieving Sustainable Urban Form Eds WilliamsKBurtonEJenksM (Spon, London) pp 74–83
69.
NijkampPRienstraS, 1996, “Sustainable transport in a compact city”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 190–199
70.
Office for National Statistics, 1996Guide to Official Statistics (The Stationery Office, London)
71.
OCSD, Entec, 1998, “Urban intensification: impacts and acceptability”, a report presented to the Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, Oxford Centre for Sustainable Development, Oxford
72.
OPCS, 1984Census 1981: Key Statistics for Urban AreasOffice of Population Censuses and Surveys (HMSO, London)
73.
OPCS, 1995Population Density Change and Concentration in Great Britain 1971, 1981 and 1991 Studies on Medical and Population Subjects 58, Office of Population Censuses and Surveys (HMSO, London)
74.
OwensS, 1986Energy Planning and Urban Form (Pion, London)
75.
OwensS, 1992, “Energy, environmental sustainability and land-use planning”, in European Research in Regional Science 2. Sustainable Development and Urban Form Ed. BrehenyM J (Pion, London) pp 79–105
76.
PACEC, 1990Indicators of Comparative Regional Local Economic PerformancePA Cambridge Economic Consultants, 62-64 Hills Road, Cambridge CB2 1LA
77.
PetherickA, 1991, “Benefits of over-the-shop schemes for local authorities”, in Living Over the Shop WP 3, University of York, York
78.
PooleRDonovanK, 1991Safer Shopping: The Identification of Opportunities for Crime and Disorder in Covered Shopping CentresWest Midlands Police, Birmingham and Home Office Police Requirements Support Unit, Horseferry House, Dean Ryle Street, London SW1P 2AW
79.
PrattRLarkhamP, 1996, “Who will care for compact cities?”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 277–288
80.
RapoportA, 1975, “Toward a redefinition of density”Environment and Behaviour7133–158
81.
RavetzA, 1995The Place of Home: English Domestic Environments 1914–2000 (Spon, London)
82.
RickabyP ASteadmanJ PBarrettM, 1992, “Patterns of land use in English towns: implications for energy use and carbon dioxide emissions”, in European Research in Regional Science 2. Sustainable Development and Urban Form Ed. BrehenyM J (Pion, London) pp 182–196
83.
RogersonR JFindlayA MMorrisA SCoombesM G, 1989, “Indicators of quality of life: some methodological issues”Environment and Planning A211655–1666
84.
RudiinDFalkN, 1999Building the 21st Century Home: The Sustainable Urban Neighbourhood (Architectural Press, Oxford)
85.
RydinY, 1992, “Environmental impacts and the property market”, in European Research in Regional Science 2. Sustainable Development and Urban Form Ed. BrehenyM (Pion, London) pp 217–241
86.
SackmanH, 1974Delphi Assessment: Expert Opinion, Forecasting and Group Procedure (Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, CA)
87.
ScoffhamEValeB, 1996, “How compact is sustainable—how sustainable is compact?”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 66–73
88.
SherlockH, 1991Cities are Good for Us: The Case for High Densities, Friendly Streets, Local Shops and Public Transport (Paladin, London)
89.
SherlockH, 1996, “Repairing our much abused cities: the way to sustainable living”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 289–297
90.
SouthworthM, 1997, “Walkable suburbs? An evaluation of traditional communities at the urban edge”Journal of the American Planning Association63(1) 28–44
91.
ThomasLCousinsW, 1996, “The compact city: a successful, desirable and achievable urban form?”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 53–65
92.
ThompsonM J, 1977Great Cities and Their Traffic (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
93.
TownsendPPhillimorePBeattieA, 1986Inequalities in Health in the Northern Region: An Interim ReportNorthern Regional Health Authority and Department of Social Policy and Social Planning, University of Bristol, Bristol
94.
TroyP, 1996, “Urban consolidation and the family”, in The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form? Eds JenksMBurtonEWilliamsK (Spon, London) pp 155–165
95.
UK Round Table on Sustainable Development, 1997Housing and Urban CapacityDepartment of the Environment; now Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU
96.
United Nations, 1993Earth Summit Agenda 21: The UN Programme of Action from Rio (United Nations, New York)
97.
University of Warwick Business Information Service, 1990Sources of Unofficial UK Statistics2nd edition (Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
98.
UnwinR, 1912Nothing Gained by Overcrowding (P S King, London)
99.
Urban Initiatives and Chestertons, 1995Hertfordshire: Dwelling Provision through Planned RegenerationHertfordshire County Council, County Hall, Pegs Lane, Hertford, Herts SG13 8DN
