In this paper we present a perspective on approaches to enhancing the feeling of safety in the urban public realm. Many planning and urban design responses to concerns about a lack of safety in city centres seem often to have led to the ‘fortress’ city and/or the ‘panoptic’ city. These are repressive and oppressive, socially divisive and exclusive, and deny the city's inhabitants a richer urban experience. We suggest more positive ways of making city centres feel safer. We start by discussing the concept of the urban public realm, then briefly review crime and incivilities, and outline the spectres of the fortress city and the panoptic city. In the remainder of the paper we discuss positive strategies for safer city centres. By doing so, we seek to offer a resistance to the tendencies towards fortress and panoptic cities. The paper is aimed primarily at those concerned with the design and management of the urban public realm, such as local authorities, planners, urban designers, and city-centre managers. There is also a wider audience that includes retailers, city-centre property owners, the police, and others with interests in the city centre. Although many of the issues have universal applicability, the focus here is on English provincial cities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArendtH, 1958The Human Condition (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
2.
AtkinsS, 1989Critical Paths: Designing for Safe Travel (The Design Council, London)
3.
BianchiniF, 1994, “Night cultures, night economies”Town and Country Planning63308–310
4.
BottomsA E, 1990, “Crime prevention in the 1990s”Policing and Society13–22
5.
BoxSHaleCAndrewsG, 1988, “Explaining fear of crime”British Journal of Criminology28340–356
6.
BoyerM C, 1992, “Cities for sale: Merchandising history at South Street Seaport”, in Variations on a Theme Park: The New American City and the End of Public Space Ed. SorkinM (Hill and Wang, New York) pp 181–204
7.
BrownB, 1995, “CCTV in town centres: Three case studies”, Crime Detection and Prevention Series, paper 68, Home Office Police Research Group, 50 Queen Anne's Gate, London SW1H 9AT
8.
CampbellD, 1995, “Spy cameras become part of the landscape”The Guardian 30 January, page 6
9.
CarrSFrancisMRivlinL GStoneA M, 1992Public Space (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
10.
ClarkeR V G (Ed.), 1992Situational Crime Prevention: Successful Case Studies (Harrow and Heston, New York)
11.
ClarkeR V GMayhewP (Eds), 1980Designing Out CrimeHome Office Research and Planning Unit (The Stationery Office, London)
12.
Comedia Consultancy, 1991Out of Hours: A Study of Economic, Social, and Cultural Life in Twelve Town Centres in the UKComedia Consultancy, The Round, Bournes Green, Gloucester, England
13.
CrawfordM, 1992, “The world in a shopping mall”, in Variations on a Theme Park: The New American City and the End of Public Space Ed. SorkinM (Hill and Wang, New York) pp 3–30
14.
DaviesS, 1996Big Brother: Britain's Web of Surveillance (Macmillan, London)
15.
DavisM, 1990City of Quartz: Excavating the Future in Los Angeles (Verso, London)
16.
DavisM, 1992Beyond Blade Runner: Urban Control—The Ecology of Fear (Open Magazine, Westfield, NJ)
17.
DoE, 1994Planning Out CrimeDepartment of the Environment (The Stationery Office, London)
18.
DoE, 1997PPG1. General Policy and PrinciplesDepartment of the Environment (The Stationery Office, London)
19.
EdwardsPTilleyN, 1994Closed Circuit TV: Looking Out for You (Home Office, London)
FyfeN R, 1995, “Policing the city”Urban Studies32759–778
22.
GarofaloJ, 1981, “The fear of crime: Causes and consequences”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology72839–857
23.
GibbonsS, 1996, “Reclaiming the streets”Police Review 13 September, pp 19–21
24.
GoetzE G, 1992, “Land use and homeless policy in Los Angeles”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16540–554
25.
GrahamSBrookesJHeeryD, 1996, “Towns on the television: Closed circuit television surveillance in British towns and cities”, WP-50, Department of Town and Country Planning, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne
26.
Guessoum-BenderbouzY, 1997Planning for Women's Safety in the City Centre PhD thesis, Institute of Urban Planning, University of Nottingham, Nottingham
27.
HabermasJ, 1962The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere translated by BurgerTLawrenceF (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
28.
HeathT, 1997, “The twenty-four hour city concept—a review of initiatives in British cities”Journal of Urban Design2193–204
29.
HealK, 1992, “Changing perspectives on crime prevention: The role of information and structure”, in Crime, Policing and Place: Essays in Environmental Criminology (Routledge, London) pp 257–271
30.
Home Office, 1995, “Spotting, catching and punishing criminals with CCTV”Press Release 302/95 (Home Office, London)
31.
Home Office, 1996, “CCTV can crack crime into the next century”Press Release 007/96 (Home Office, London)
32.
HonessTCharmanE, 1992, “Closed circuit television in public places: Its acceptability and perceived effectiveness”, Home Office Police Research Group, Crime Prevention Unit Series, paper 35 (The Stationery Office, London)
33.
HoughJ MClarkR V GMayhewP, 1980, “Introduction”, in Designing Out Crime Eds ClarkeR V GMayhewP, Home Office Research and Planning Unit (The Stationery Office, London) pp 1–17
34.
JacobsJ, 1961The Death and Life of Great American Cities: The Failure of Town Planning (Peregrine Books and Jonathan Cape, London)
35.
KPMG Peat Marwick, Safe Neighbourhoods Unit, M Sims, 1991, “Counting out crime: The Nottingham crime audit”, report prepared for the Nottingham Safer Cities Project (Nottingham City Council, Nottingham)
36.
Loukaitou-SiderisA, 1996, “Cracks in the city: Addressing the constraints and potentials of urban design”Journal of Urban Design1(1) 91–104
37.
LovattA, 1994, “More hours in the day”, Manchester Institute of Popular Culture, Cavendish (North) Building, Manchester Metropolitan University, Oxford Road, Manchester M15 6BX
38.
LyonD, 1994The Electronic Eye: The Rise of Surveillance Society (Polity Press, London)
39.
MarshC, 1997, “Mixed use development and the property market”, in Reclaiming the City: Mixed Use Development Ed. CouplandA (Spon, London) pp 117–142
MontgomeryJ, 1994, “The evening economy of cities”Town and Country Planning63302–307
42.
MontgomeryJ, 1995, “Urban vitality and the culture of cities”Planning Practice and Research10101–109
43.
MuncieJ, 1996, “The construction and deconstruction of crime”, in The Problem of Crime Eds MuncieJMcLaughlinE (Sage, London) pp 5–64
44.
OcTTiesdellS (Eds), 1997Safer City Centres: Reviving the Public Realm (Paul Chapman, London)
45.
OcTTiesdellS, 1998, “City centre management and safer city centres: Approaches in Coventry and Nottingham”Cities: The International Journal of Urban Policy and Planning forthcoming
46.
OcTTrenchS, 1993, “Planning and shopper security”, in Retail Change Eds BromleyR D FThomasC J (UCL Press, London) pp 153–170
47.
O'ConnorJLovattJ, 1993, “Towards the twenty-four hour city”, in Transcript of the First National Conference on the Evening EconomyManchester Institute of Popular Culture, Cavendish (North) Building, Manchester Metropolitan University, Oxford Road, Manchester M15 6BX
48.
PainterK, 1989, “Lighting and crime prevention for community safety: The Tower Hamlets study. First report”, Centre for Criminology, Middlesex University, Queensway, Enfield, England
49.
PainterK, 1996, “It's safety first and last”Landscape Design March, page 52
50.
PunterJ, 1990, “The privatisation of the public realm”Planning Practice and Research5(3) 17–21
51.
RamseyM, 1990, “Lager land lost? An experiment in keeping drinkers off the streets in central Coventry and elsewhere”, Crime Prevention Unit, paper 22, Home Office Police Research Group, 50 Queen Anne's Gate, London SW1H 9AT
52.
RamseyM, 1994, “The effect of better street lighting on crime and fear: A review”, Crime Prevention Unit paper 29, Home Office Police Research Group, 50 Queen Anne's Gate, London SW1H 9AT
53.
ReeveA, 1996, “The private realm of the managed town centre”Urban Design International1(1) 61–80
54.
RigerSGordonM TLe BaillyR K, 1982, “Coping with crime: Women's use of precautionary behaviours”American Journal of Community Psychology10369–386
55.
ScrutonR, 1982A Dictionary of Political Thought (Pan, London)
56.
SennettR, 1977The Fall of Public Man (Faber and Faber, London)
57.
ShearingC DStenningP C, 1985, “From the Panopticon to Disney World: The development of discipline”, in Criminological Perspectives: A Reader Eds MuncieJMcLaughlinELanganM (Sage, London) pp 413–422
58.
SorkinM (Ed.), 1992Variations on a Theme Park: The New American City and the End of Public Space (Hill and Wang, New York)
59.
TrenchS, 1996, “Safer transport and parking”, in Safer City Centres: Reviving the Public Realm Eds OcTTiesdellS (Paul Chapman, London) pp 143–155
60.
TrenchSOcTTiesdellS, 1992, “Safer cities for women—perceived risks and planning measures”Town Planning Review63279–296
61.
WekerleG RWhitzmanC, 1995Safe Cities: Guidelines for Planning, Design and Management (Van No strand Reinhold, New York)
