Pastor's discovery of a historical example of a noninferior fractional solution to the location set-covering problem is not unexpected. We argue here that a method or observation that is generally good (or true) has merit and should not be dismissed as lacking in utility because of occasional counterexamples. A further report concerning fractions/integers in set-covering problems is made and the specific example cited by Pastor is analyzed.
RosingK E, 1992, “An optimal method for solving the (generalized) multi-Weber problem”European Journal of Operations Research58414–426
6.
RosingK EHarrisB, 1992, “Algorithmic and technical improvements: Optimal solutions to the (generalized) multi-Weber problem”Papers in Regional Science71331–352
7.
RosingK EReVelleC SRosing-VogelaarH, 1992, “Fractions in the location set-covering problem”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design19125–130
8.
ToregasCSwainRReVelleC SBergmanL, 1971, “The locations of emergency service facilities”Operations Research191363–1373
