Forecasting is essential in all planning activity; yet there are serious conceptual and methodological issues to be faced, particularly where public policymaking is involved. Forecasting methods in planning have varied widely from unsystematic and highly subjective scenario writing to the unimaginative extrapolation of trends. In practice, some blend of these methodologies is often employed. In this paper, it is argued that an effective approach may lie in the development of explicitly hybrid methodology which can blend perspectives on futures and provide a proper integration of policy expectations into policy planning forecasts. In the paper a framework is described which offers the possibility of overcoming some limitations of existing approaches.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmaraR, 1972, “A note on cross-impact analysis: A calculus for sequence dependent events”Futures4267–291
2.
AscherW, 1978Forecasting: An Appraisal for Policy-makers and Planners (The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
3.
BerryB J L, 1973, “A paradigm for modern geography” in Directions in Geography Ed. ChorleyR J (Methuen, Andover, Hants) pp 3–21
4.
BlincoeW, 1979, “Analytical models for planning housing provision: a critical assessment of current practice” WP-9, Department of Civic Design, University of Liverpool, Liverpool
5.
BoyntonJ, 1979, “Planning policy: Its formation and implementation”Report of Proceedings of the Town and Country Planning Summer School University of York, 8–19 September (Royal Town Planning Institute, London) pp 68–71
6.
BrackenI, 1978, “Simulation: Methodology for urban study”Progress in Human Geography249–75
7.
BrackenI, 1981Urban Planning Methods: Research and Policy Analysis (Methuen, Andover, Hants)
8.
BrackenI, 1982a, “Flexibility in strategic land-use planning: case studies of planning practice and policies” Papers in Planning Research 53, Department of Town Planning, UWIST, Cardiff
9.
BrackenI, 1982b, “New directions in key activity forecasting”Town Planning Review5215–31
10.
BrackenI, 1982c, “Towards an analytic framework for land-use planning policies”Urban Studies19351–360
11.
BrackenIHumeD, 1981, “Key activity forecasting in structure planning” Papers in Planning Research 26, Department of Town Planning, UWIST, Cardiff
12.
BrehenyM JRobertsA J, 1978, “An integrated forecasting system for structure planning”Town Planning Review49306–318
13.
CropperS A, 1982, “Theory and strategy in the study of planning processes—the uses of the case study”Environment and Planning B9341–357
14.
CrossD T, 1975, “Planning forecasting” in Progress and Problems in Social Forecasting Eds FreemanCJahodaMMilesI (Social Science Research Council, London) pp 55–66
15.
DalkeyN, 1972, “An elementary cross-impact model”Technological Forecasting and Social Change3341–351
16.
DuvalAFontelaEGabusA, 1974Cross-impact: A Handbook on Concepts and Applications (Battelle, Geneva)
17.
EnzerS, 1970, “A case-study using forecasting as a decision making aid”Futures2341–362
18.
EnzerSAlterS, 1978, “Cross-impact analysis and classical probability”Futures10227–239
19.
GordonT JHaywardH, 1968, “Initial experiments with the cross impact matrix method of forecasting”Futures1100–116
20.
GordonPLedentJ, 1980, “Modelling the dynamics of a system of metropolitan areas: A demo-economic approach”Environment and Planning A12125–133
21.
HecloH H, 1972, “Review article: Policy analysis”British Journal of Political Science283–108
22.
HicklingAFriendJLuckmanJ, 1979, “The development plan system and investment programmes” Report 2T235, Centre for Organisational and Operational Research, Tavistock Institute for Human Relations, London
23.
HolmPSnickarsFGustafssonJ RHarsmanB, 1978, “Policy-oriented housing models: Some tentative applications” in London Papers in Regional Science 8. Theory and Method in Urban and Regional Analysis Ed. BateyP W J (Pion, London) pp 150–167
24.
JacksonJ ELawtonW, 1976, “Some probability problems with cross-impact analysis”Technological Forecasting and Social Change8263–273
25.
JenkinsW I, 1978Policy Analysis: A Political and Organizational Perspective (Martin Robertson, Oxford)
26.
JohnsonH E, 1970, “Some computational aspects of cross-impact forecasting”Futures2123–131
27.
JowellJ, 1977, “Bargaining in development control”Journal of Planning and Environment Law1414–433
28.
KleijnenJ P C, 1974Statistical Techniques in Simulation. Part 1 (Marcel Dekker, New York)
29.
LonsdaleA J, 1978, “Judgement research in policy analysis”Futures10213–226
30.
LowiT J, 1972, “Four systems of policy, politics and choice”Public Administration Review4298–310
31.
MaddenMBateyP W J, 1980, “Achieving consistency in demographic-economic forecasting”Papers of the Regional Science Association4491–106
32.
MilesIIrvineJ, 1979, “Social forecasting: Predicting the future or making history?” in Demystifying Social Statistics Eds IrvineJMilesIEvansJ (Pluto Press, London) pp 305–324
33.
NAG, 1978Fortran Library: Mark 7Numerical Algorithms Group, Oxford
34.
PollittCLewisLNegroJPattenJ, 1979Public Policy in Theory and Practice (Hodder and Stoughton, Sevenoaks, Kent)
35.
PopperK, 1972Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge4th edition (Routledge and Kegan Paul, Henley-on-Thames, Oxon)
36.
RochbergR, 1970, “Methodology, convergence and variability because of random numbers in cross impact analysis”Futures2276–278
37.
RoosL L, 1975, “Quasi-experiments and environmental policy”Policy Sciences6249–266
38.
SarinR K, 1978, “A sequential approach to cross-impact analysis”Futures1053–62
39.
SmithT B, 1973, “The policy implementation process”Policy Sciences4197–209
40.
TinbergenJ, 1963On the Theory of Economic Policy (North-Holland, Amsterdam)
41.
TuroffM, 1972, “An alternative approach to cross-impact analysis”Technological Forecasting and Social Change3309–339
42.
WildavskyA, 1979Speaking Truth unto Power: The Art and Craft of Policy Analysis (Little, Brown, Boston, MA)
43.
WillekensF, 1979, “Optimal migration policies: An analytical approach”Regional Science and Urban Economics9345–367
44.
YoungM, 1968Forecasting and the Social Sciences (Heinemann Educational Books, London)
