Since each of the modern sciences—physical, biological, and human—broke their traditional ties with philosophy they have reflected less upon foundational problems of their methodologies. The essay constitutes an invitation to reflect upon Q-analysis in an historical perspective, raising the question of the meaning of mathematization in the human sciences. Functional description implies a mechanical framework for the human world. By enlarging the descriptive possibilities to the mapping and relation, Q-analysis raises the question of allowing and forbidding, but not requiring, geometries. It also opens up difficult questions of language in the human sciences, the constrained nature of current methodologies, the effects of aggregation, and a concern for proper definitions—including the notion of structure itself.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenPSanglierM, 1979, “A dynamic model of growth in a central place system”Geographical Analysis11256–272
2.
AtkinR, 1956Mathematics and Wave Mechanics (Heinemann Educational Books, London)
AtkinR, 1965, “Abstract physics”Il Nuevo Cimento38496–517
5.
AtkinR, 1971, “Cohomology of observations” in Quantum Theory and Beyond Ed. BastinT, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 191–211
6.
AtkinR, 1972, “Multidimensional structure in the game of chess”International Journal of Man-Machine Studies4341–362
7.
AtkinR, 1974Mathematical Structure in Human Affairs (Heinemann Educational Books, London)
8.
AtkinR, 1976, “Positional play in chess by computer” in Advances in Computer Chess Ed. ClarkeM, (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh)
9.
AtkinR, 1977aCombinatorial Connectivities in Social Systems (Birkhäuser, Basle)
10.
AtkinR, 1977b, “Q-analysis: Theory and practice” research report X, Department of Mathematics, University of Essex, Colchester, Essex
11.
AtkinR, 1978, “Q-analysis: A hard language for the soft sciences”Futures10492–499
12.
AtkinR, 1981Multidimensional Man (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
13.
AtkinRHartstonWWittenI, 1976, “FRED CHAMP, positional game analyst”International Journal of Man-Machine Studies8517–529
14.
AtkinRWittenI, 1975. “A multidimensional approach to positional chess”International Journal of Man-Machine Studies7727–750
15.
BeaumontJGatrellA, 1982CATMOG 34: An Introduction to Q-analysis (Geo-Abstracts, Norwich)
16.
ChristensenK, 1982, “Geography as a human science: A philosophic critique of the positivist-humanist split” in A Search for Common Ground Eds GouldPOlssonG, (Pion, London) pp 37–57
17.
CouclelisH, 1977Urban Development Models: Towards a General Theory PhD thesis, University of Cambridge, Cambridge
18.
CouclelisH, 1982, “Philosophy in the construction of geographic reality” in A Search for Common Ground Eds GouldPOlssonG, (Pion, London) pp 105–138
19.
EarlCJohnsonJ, 1981, “Graph theory and Q-analysis”Environment and Planning B8367–391
20.
GarrisonWMarbleD, 1960, “Connectivity of the interstate highway system”Regional Science Association, Papers and Proceedings6121–137
21.
GasparJGouldP, 1981, “The Cova da Beira: An applied structural analysis of agriculture and communication” in Space and Time in Geography Ed. PredA, (Gleerup, Lund) pp 183–214
22.
GouldP, 1980, “Q-analysis, or a language of structure: An introduction for social scientists, geographers and planners”International Journal of Man-Machine Studies13169–199
23.
GouldP, 1981a, “A structural language of relations” in Future Trends in Geomathematics Eds CraigRLabovitzM, (Pion, London) pp 281–313
24.
GouldP, 1981b, “Electrical power failure: Reflections on compatible descriptions of human and physical systems”Environment and Planning B8405–417
25.
GouldP, 1981c, “Letting the data speak for themselves”Annals of the Association of American Geographers71166–176
26.
GouldP, 1982, “Is it necessary to choose? Some technical, hermeneutic, and emancipatory thoughts on inquiry” in A Search for Common Ground (Pion, London) pp 71–104
27.
GouldP, 1983, “Destructive retrieval in the realm of three-mode thinking” in Research Methods for Multimode Data Analysis in the Behavioral Sciences Eds LawHHattieJMacDonaldRSnyderW, (Praeger, New York) pp 15.1–15.34
28.
GouldPJohnsonJChapmanG, 1984Television, the World of Structure: Structure, the World of Television (Pion, London)
29.
GriffithsB, 1983, “Using mathematics to simplify Q-analysis”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design10403–422
30.
GriffithsHEvansP, 1981, “Atkin's Q-analysis: A critique and reformulation” SSRC report; available as a mimeo from the author, Faculty of Mathematical Studies, University of Southampton, Southampton S09 5NH
31.
HabermasJ, 1971Knowledge and Human Interests (Beacon Press, Boston, MA)
32.
HeideggerM, 1977, “The age of the world picture” in The Question Concerning Technology and Other Essays translated by LovittW, (Harper and Row, New York) pp 115–154
33.
HoY-S, 1982a, “The planning process: A formal model”Environment and Planning B9377–386
34.
HoY-S, 1982b, “The planning process: Fundamental issues”Environment and Planning B9387–395
35.
HoY-S, 1982c, “The planning process: Structure of verbal descriptions”Environment and Planning B9397–420
36.
IliopoulouPGouldP, 1984, “Appropriate mathematical structures for geographic description”Technica Chronica: Scientific Journal of the Technical Chamber of Greece, Section A (forthcoming)
37.
JohnsonJ H, 1979, “Can science improve industrial relations?” mimeo, Department of Geography, University of Cambridge, Cambridge
38.
JohnsonJ H, 1982, “The logic of speculative discourse: Guidelines for decisionmakers”Environment and Planning B915–32
39.
JohnsonJ, 1983, “The logic of speculative discourse: Time, prediction, and strategic planning”Environment and Planning B9269–294
40.
KanskyK, 1963Structure of Transport Networks: Relationships between Network Geometry and Regional Characteristics RM-84, Department of Geography, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL
41.
KellyG, 1955The Psychology of Personal Constructs (W W Norton, New York)
42.
KolakowskiL, 1975Husserl and the Search for Certitude (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
43.
KuhnT, 1970The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
44.
LewinK, 1936Principles of Psychological Topology (McGraw-Hill, New York)
45.
MarchLHoY-S, 1982, “The planning process: A category-theoretic approach”Sistemi Urbani4453–483
46.
MedawarP B, 1963, “Is the scientific paper a fraud”The Listener12 September, page 377
47.
OlssonG, 1980Birds in Egg/Eggs in Bird (Pion, London)
48.
PerelmanC, 1982The Realm of Rhetoric (University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, IN)
49.
RichardsonW, 1974Heidegger: Through Phenomenology to Thought (Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague)
50.
SeidmanS, 1981, “Structures induced by collections of subsets: A hypergraph approach”Mathematical Social Sciences1381–396
51.
SugiuraN, 1983Rhetoric and Geographers Worlds: The Case of Spatial Analysis PhD dissertation, Department of Geography, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA
