This paper explores the links between spatial mobility and job-related well-being for young Italian graduates. Theoretically it posits that mobility and job satisfaction can be related indirectly, as migration may provide access to new or better job opportunities, and directly, as mobility generates expectations on the outcome of the move. Methodologically it applies sample-selection ordered logit to a survey of graduates conducted by the Italian National Statistical Institute (ISTAT). The paper investigates how personal characteristics and employment features, together with migration behaviour, impact on several domains of job satisfaction, comparing the graduates from Southern regions—ie, the backward Mezzogiorno—to those of the Centre-North of Italy. Our most novel results indicate that, whilst indirect effects are qualitatively similar for both Southern and Centre–Northern graduates, direct effects are not. This highlights that geography affects satisfaction by shaping individual expectations, adding another dimension to the long-standing debate on Italian spatial inequality.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenJVan der VeldenR, 2001, “Educational mismatches versus skill mismatches: Effects on wages, job satisfaction and on-the-job search”Oxford Economic Papers53434–452.
2.
BaiciECasaloneG, 2005, “Can human capital be accounted for regional economic growth in Italy? A panel analysis of the 1980–2001 period”, paper presented at the ERSA Conference. Amsterdam, 23–27 August, http://www-sre.wu-wein.ac.at/ersa/ersaconfs/ersa05/papers/251.pdf.
3.
BarcaF, 2006Italia Frenata, Paradossi e Lezioni della Politica per lo Sviluppo (Donzelli, Rome).
4.
BattuHBelfieldC RSloaneP J, 1999, “Overeducation among graduates: A cohort view”Education Economics721–38.
5.
BiagiBFaggianAMcCannP, 2011, “Long and short distance migration in Italy: The role of economic, social and environmental characteristics”Spatial Economic Analysis6111–131.
6.
BrunelloGCappellariL, 2008, “The labour market effects of alma mater: Evidence from Italy”Economics of Education Review27564–574.
7.
VieraCabral JA, 2005, “Skill mismatches and job satisfaction”Economics Letters8939–47.
8.
ChecchiDPeragineV, 2005, “Regional disparities and inequality of opportunity: The case of Italy” IZA discussion paper 1874, Institute for the Study of Labor, Bonn.
9.
ClarkA E, 1996, “Job satisfaction in Britain”British Journal of Industrial Relations34189–217.
10.
ClarkA E, 1997, “Job satisfaction and gender: Why are women so happy at work?”Labour Economics4341–372.
11.
ClarkA EOswaldA J, 1994, “Unhappiness and unemployment”Economic Journal104 (424) 648–659.
12.
ClarkA EOswaldA J, 1996, “Satisfaction and comparison income”Journal of Public Economics61359–381.
13.
ConiglioNPeragineV, 2007, “Giovani al sud: Tra immobilità sociale e mobilità territoriale”, in Prima Rapporto Banche e Mezzogiorno Eds ConiglioNPeragineV (Banca Carime/University of Bari, Bari) pp 64–94.
14.
ConiglioNProtaF, 2008, “Human capital accumulation and migration in a peripheral EU region: The case of Basilicata”Papers in Regional Science8777–96.
15.
DantonioMScarlatoM, 2007, “I laureati del Mezzogiorno: Una risorsa sottoutilizzata o dispersa”Quaderni SvimezSvimez, Rome.
16.
De JongGChamratrithirongATranQ G, 2002, “For better, for worse: Life satisfaction consequences of migration”International Migration Review36838–863.
17.
Di LibertoA, 2007, “Education and Italian regional development”Economics of Education Review2794–107.
18.
Di PietroG, 2005, On migration and unemployment: Evidence from Italian graduates”Economic Issues10(2) 11–28.
19.
Di PietroGUrwinP, 2006, “Education and skills mismatch in the Italian graduate labour market”Applied Economics3879–93.
20.
FabraM ECamisonC, 2009, “Direct and indirect effects of education on job satisfaction: A structural equation model for the Spanish case”Economics of Education Review28600–610.
21.
FaggianAMcCannP, 2006, “Human capital flows and regional knowledge assets: A simultaneous equation approach”Oxford Economic Papers58475–500.
22.
FaggianAMcCannP, 2009, “Human capital, graduate migration and innovation in British regions”Cambridge Journal of Economics33317–333.
23.
FaggianAMcCannPSheppardS, 2006, “An analysis of ethnic differences in UK graduate migration behaviour”Annals of Regional Science40461–464.
24.
FaggianAMcCannPSheppardS, 2007a, “Human capital, higher education and graduate migration: An analysis of Scottish and Welsh students”Urban Studies442511–2528.
25.
FaggianAMcCannPSheppardS, 2007b, “Some evidence that women are more mobile than men: Gender differences in UK graduate migration behavior”Journal of Regional Science47517–539.
26.
FreemanR, 1978, “Job satisfaction as an economic variable”American Economic Review68 (2) 135–142.
27.
GaziogluSTanselA, 2006, “Job satisfaction in Britain: Individual andjob related factors”Applied Economics381163–1171.
28.
GhignoniE, 2005, “Household income, family composition and human capital in southern Italy” WP 78, Department of Public Economics, La Sapienza University, Rome.
29.
GreeneW HHensherD A, 2010Modeling Ordered Choices (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
30.
GreenwoodM J, 1972, “The geographic mobility of college graduates”The Journal of Human Resources8506–515.
31.
GreenwoodM J, 1975, “Research on internal migration in the United States: A survey”Journal of Economic Literature13397–433.
32.
GrootWvan den BrinkMaassen HM, 1999, “Job satisfaction of older workers”International Journal of Manpower20343–360.
33.
GruenbergB, 1980, “The happy worker: An analysis of educational and occupational differences in determinants of job satisfaction”American Journal of Sociology86247–271.
34.
HamermeshD, 1977, “Economic aspects of job satisfaction”, in Essays in Labor Market and Population Analysis Eds AshenfelterOOatesW (John Wiley, New York) pp 53–72.
35.
HarterJ KSchmidtF LHaydesT L, 2002, “Business-unit-level relationship between employee satisfaction, employee engagement, and business outcomes: A meta-analysis”Journal of Applied Psychology87268–279.
36.
HeckmanJ, 1979, “Sample selection bias as a specification error”Econometrica47153–161.
37.
HerschJ, 1991, “Education match and job match”Review of Economics and Statistics73140–144.
38.
HicksJ R, 1932The Theory of Wages (Macmillan, London).
39.
HoogstraG Jvan DijkJFloraxRJGM, 2011, “Determinants of variation in population—employment interaction findings: A quasi-experimental meta-analysis”Geographical Analysis4314–37.
40.
HouseR JShaneS AHeroldD M, 1996, “Rumors of the death of dispositional research are vastly exaggerated”Academy of Management Review21203–224.
41.
IammarinoS, 2005, “An evolutionary integrated view of regional systems of innovation: Concepts, measures and historical perspectives”European Planning Studies13497–519.
42.
IdsonT L, 1990, “Establishment size, job satisfaction and the structure of work”Applied Economics221007–1018.
43.
ISTAT, Rome2005aStatistiche in Breve, Inserimento Professionale dei Laureati.
44.
ISTAT, Rome2005bL'Istruzione della Popolazione al 2001. Dati Definitivi del Censimento.
45.
ISTAT, Rome2006I Laureati e il Mercato del Lavoro.
46.
ISTAT, Rome2007Indagine Campionaria sull'Inserimento Professionale dei Laureati.
47.
JansonPMartinJ K, 1982, “Job satisfaction and age: A test of two views”Social Forces601088–1102.
48.
JauhiainenS, 2011, “Overeducation in the Finnish regional labour markets”Papers in Regional Science90573–588.
49.
JudgeT AHellerDMountM K, 2002, “Five-factor model of personality and job satisfaction: A meta-analysis”Journal of Applied Psychology87530–541.
50.
LehmerFLudsteckJ, 2011, “The returns to job mobility and inter-regional migration: Evidence from Germany”Papers in Regional Science Science90549–571.
51.
LuechingerSStutzerAWinkelmannR, 2008, “Self-selection and subjective well-being: Copula models with an application to public and private sector work”, SOEP (German Socio-Economic Panel Study) paper 135, DIW Berlin.
52.
LundholmEMalmbergG, 2006, “Gains and losses, outcomes of interregional migration in the five Nordic countries”Geografiska Annaler, Series B: Human Geography8835–47.
53.
LydonRChevalierA, 2002, “Estimates of the effect of wages on job satisfaction” LSE/CEP DP 0531, London School of Economics and Political Sciences.
MartinJ KLichterD T, 1983, “Geographic mobility and satisfaction with life and work”Social Science Quarterly64524–535.
56.
MauroLPodreccaE, 1994, “The case of Italian regions: Convergence or dualism”Economics Notes3447–468.
57.
MirandaARabe-HeskethS, 2006, “Maximum likelihood estimation of endogenous switching and sample selection models for binary, ordinal, and count variables”Stata Journal6285–308.
58.
MoraJ GVilaL EGarcía-AracilA, 2005, “European higher education graduates and job satisfaction”European Journal of Education4035–44.
59.
MoraJ GGarcía-AracilAVilaL E, 2007, “Job satisfaction among young European higher education graduates”Higher Education5329–59.
60.
MoraTFerrer-I-CarbonellA, 2009, “The job satisfaction gender gap among young recent university graduates: Evidence from Catalonia”The Journal of Socio-Economics38581–589.
61.
PaciRPigliaruF, 1998, “Growth and sectoral dynamics in the Italian regions”, WP 1988/3, CRENoS—Centre for North South Economic Research, Cagliari.
62.
PirasR, 1996, “Il ruolo del capitale umano e dei flussi migratori nel processo di convergenza tra le regioni italiane”Rivista Internazionale di Scienze Sociali104367–400.
63.
PirasR, 2005, “Il contenuto di capitale umano dei flussi migratori interregionali: 1980–2002”Politica Economica21461–491.
64.
PirasR, 2006, “I movimenti migratori interregional per titolo di studio: Una stima dei tassi migratori ed un'analisi dei flussi”Studi di Emigrazione43153–170.
65.
PirasRMelisS, 2007, “Evoluzione e tendenze delle migrazioni interne”Economia Italiana2437–461.
66.
QuinnM ARubbS, 2005, “The importance of education–occupation matching in migration decisions”Demography42153–167.
67.
QuintanoCCastellanoRD'AgostinoA, 2008, “Graduates in economics and educational mismatch: The case study of the University of Naples ‘Parthenope’”Journal of Education and Work21249–271.
68.
Rodríguez-PoseAVilalta-BufiM, 2005, “Education, migration, and job satisfaction: The regional returns of human capital in the EU”Journal of Economic Geography5545–566.
69.
RossC EReskinB F, 1992, “Education, control at work, and job satisfaction”Social Science Research21134–148.
70.
RossMVan WilligenM, 1997, “Education and the subjective quality of life”Journal of Health and Social Behavior38275–297.
71.
SchomburgH, 2007, “The professional success of higher education graduates”European Journal of Education4235–57.
72.
SjaastadL A, 1962, “The costs and returns of human migration”Journal of Political Economy70 (5) 80–93.
73.
SloaneP JWilliamsH, 2000, “Job satisfaction, comparison earnings and gender”Labour14473–501.
74.
Sousa-PozaASousa-PozaA A, 2000, “Taking another look at the gender/job paradox”Kyklos53135–152.
75.
SVIMEZ, Rome2007Rapporto Svimez 2007 sull'Economia del Mezzogiorno.
76.
SVIMEZ, Rome2008Rapporto Svimez 2008 sull'Economia del Mezzogiorno.
77.
SVIMEZ, Rome2009Rapporto Svimez 2009 sull'Economia del Mezzogiorno.
VaccaroR, 1995Unità Politica e Dualismo Economico in Italia: 1861–1993 (Cedam, Padua).
80.
VenhorstV Avan DijkJvan WissenLJG, 2010, “Do the best graduates leave the peripheral areas in The Netherlands?”Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie101521–537.
81.
VenhorstV Avan DijkJvan WissenLJG, 2011, “An analysis of trends in spatial mobility of Dutch college of higher education graduates”Spatial Economic Analysis657–82.
82.
VerhaestDOmeyE, 2006, “The impact of overeducation and its measurement”Social Indicators Research77419–448.
83.
ViestiG, 2003Abolire il Mezzogiorno (Laterza, Bari).
84.
VilaEGarcía-MoraB, 2005, “Education and the determinants of job satisfaction”Education Economics13409–425.
85.
ZieglerJ ABrittonC R, 1981, “A comparative analysis of socioeconomic variations in measuring the quality of life”Social Science Quarterly62303–312.
