The core values of the ethical foodscape—ecological integrity and social justice—can assume very different political forms unless they are fashioned into a coherent and progressive narrative of sustainability. This paper explores the politics of sustainability through the prism of three major issues. First, the carbon-labelling controversy is used to highlight the potential conflict between green campaigners (who extol the benefits of local food) and social justice campaigners (who support fairly traded food from afar). Second, school-food reform is used to demonstrate that local and global food, far from being mutually exclusive options, can both be part of the constitution of a sustainable food system if global food is framed in cosmopolitan terms. Third, the paper engages with the politics of care literature to explore a question that underlies the above issues, namely, how and why we care for others. It is argued that ethical consumerism, a key part of a progressive narrative of care, is not sufficient to counter the challenge of climate change—the greatest threat to ecological integrity and social justice.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
APA, 2007, “Policy guide on community and regional food planning”, 11 May, American Planning Association, Chicago, IL.
2.
ArcherM, 2000Being Human: The Problem of Agency (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
3.
BarryJ, 2002, “Vulnerability and virtue: Democracy, dependency and ecological stewardship”, in Democracy and the Claims of Nature Eds MinteerBTaylorB (Rowman and Littlefield) pp 133–152.
BecchetiLCostantinoM, 2008, “The effects of Fair Trade on affiliated producers: An impact analysis on Kenyan farmers”World Development36823–842.
6.
BornBPurcellM, 2006, “Avoiding the local trap: Scale and food systems in planning research”Journal of Planning Education and Research26195–207.
7.
Desmarais, 2007La Via Campesina: Globalization and the Power of Peasants (Pluto Press, London).
8.
DobsonA, 2004, “Ecological citizenship”, paper presented to the Annual Meeting of the Western Political Science Association, Portland, Oregon, 11 March; copy available from the author.
Edwards-JonesGeta l, 2008, “Testing the assertion that ‘local food is best’: The challenges of an evidence-based approach”Trends in Food Science and Technology19265–274.
11.
Fairtrade Foundation, 2008, “Tipping the balance: the Fairtrade Foundation's vision for transforming trade, 2008–2012”, The Fairtrade Foundation, London.
12.
FAO, 2006The State of Food Insecurity in the World (Food and Agriculture Organization, Rome).
GarsideBMacGregorJVarleyB, 2007, “Miles better? How ‘fair miles’ stack up in the sustainable supermarket”, International Institute for Environment and Development, London.
15.
GoodmanD, 2004, “Rural Europe redux? Reflections on alternative agro-food networks and paradigm change”Sociologia Ruralis443–16.
16.
GoodmanM K, 2004, “Reading fair trade: Political ecological imaginary and moral economy of fair trade foods”Political Geography23891–915.
17.
GuthmanJ, 2004Agrarian Dreams: The Paradox of Organic Farming in California (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
18.
HeldV, 2005The Ethics of Care: Personal, Political, and Global (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
19.
HinrichsC, 2003, “The practice and politics of food system localization”Journal of Rural Studies1933–45.
20.
HumeD, 1978A Treatise of Human Nature (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
21.
IGD, 2003Local Food Comes From Our County, Says ConsumersIGD, London.
22.
IGD, 2005Patriotism Alone Will Not Sell British Food, Says New ResearchIGD, London.
23.
IlberyBKneafseyM, 2000, “Registering regional speciality food and drink products in the UK: The case of PDOs and PGIs”Area32317–325.
24.
LangTHeasmanM, 2004Food Wars: The Global Battle for Minds, Mouths and Markets (Earthscan, London).
25.
LeahyT, 2007, “Green grocer? Tesco, carbon and the consumer”, speech to Forum for the Future, London, 18 January; copy available from Forum for the Future.
26.
MacGregorJVorleyB, 2006, “Fair miles? The concept of ‘food miles’ through a sustainable development lens”, International Institute for Environment and Development, London.
27.
Marks & Spencer, 2007, “M&S launches Plan A”, Marks & Spencer, London.
28.
MarsdenT, 2004, “Theorising food quality: Some key issues in understanding its competitive production and regulation”, in Qualities of Food Eds HarveyMMcMeekinMWardeA (Manchester University Press, Manchester) pp 129–155.
29.
MasseyD, 2007World City (Polity Press, Cambridge).
30.
MayeDHollowayLKneafseyM (Eds), 2007Alternative Food Geographies: Representation and Practice (Elsevier, Oxford).
31.
Mayor of London, 2006, “Healthy and sustainable food for London: the Mayor's food strategy”, May, Mayor of London, City Hall, London.
32.
MorganKSonninoR, 2008The School Food Revolution: Public Food and the Challenge of Sustainable Development (Earthscan, London).
33.
MorganKMarsdenTMurdochJ, 2006Worlds of Food: Place, Power and Provenance in the Food Chain (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
34.
MorganKBastiaTKanemasuY, 2007Home Grown: The New Era of School FeedingWorld Food Programme, Rome.
35.
PotterC, 1998Against the Grain: Agri-environmental Reform in the US and the EU (CABI, Wallingford, Oxon).
36.
SayerA, 2010Why Things Matter: Social Science, Normativity and Values (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
37.
SeyfangG, 2006, “Ecological citizenship and sustainable consumption: Examining local organic food networks”Journal of Rural Studies22383–395.
38.
SmithA, 1976The Theory of Moral Sentiments (Oxford University Press, New York).
39.
SmithD, 1998, “How far should we care? On the spatial scope of beneficence”Progress in Human Geography2215–38.
40.
SmithD, 2000Moral Geographies: Ethics in a World of Difference (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh).
41.
SA, Soil Association, Bristol BS1 3NX2007, “Should the Soil Association tackle the environmental impact of air freight in its organic standards?”, May.
42.
SA, Soil Association, Bristol BS1 3NX2008, “Ensuring limited organic air freight is fair and ethical”, Press Release, 6 March.
43.
SA, Soil Association, Bristol BS1 3NX2009, “Five reasons to choose organic”, May.
44.
SonninoR, 2009, “Quality food, public procurement, and sustainable development: The school meal revolution in Rome”Environment and Planning A41425–440.
45.
SternN, 2009The Global Deal (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
46.
Sustain, 2008Ethical Hijack: Why the Terms ‘Local’, ‘Seasonal’ and ‘Farmers' Market’ should be Defended from Abuse by the Food IndustrySustain, London.
47.
TrontoJ, 1994Moral Boundaries: A Political Argument for an Ethic of Care (Routledge, New York).
48.
Twin, 2007, “Twin and Twin Trading annual report 2006/2007”, Twin and Twin Trading Ltd, London EC2A 3LT.
49.
UNDP, 2007Fighting Climate Change: Human Solidarity in a Divided WorldUnited Nations Development Programme, United Nations, New York.
50.
Via Campesina, 1996Food Sovereignty: A Future Without HungerVia Campesina, Rome.
51.
WatkinsK, 2003, “Reducing poverty starts with fairer farm trade”Financial Times 2 June.
52.
WhatmoreSThorneL, 1997, “Nourishing networks: Alternative geographies of food”, in Globalising Food Eds GoodmanDWattsM (Routledge, London) pp 287–304.
53.
WindfuhrMJonsenJ, 2005Food Sovereignty: Towards Democracy in Localized Food Systems (FIAN-International, Heidelberg).
54.
World Bank, 2007World Development Report 2008: Agriculture for Development (World Bank, Washington, DC).
