Local complementary currency systems (LCCSs), like the Local Exchange Trading System scheme in the English-speaking world, are one of the alternative economies organised to overcome the exclusionary aspects of the regular market economy and support those short of money. I analyse the benefits for the poor and unemployed of the Argentine variant, called Clubes de Trueque. I conclude that the Clubes de Trueque were a meeting point of social strata and gender groups. They became a market space “for us, women”, rather than a second-class market “for us, the poor”. In economic terms they facilitated the access to goods and services for the disenfranchised middle class and the unemployed, but did not correct the exclusionary mechanisms that affect the poorest of the poor. These findings suggest that LCCSs can help some low-income groups to protect and improve their lifestyles but are not a general tool for poverty reduction.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AldridgeTPattersonA, 2002, “LETS get real: Constraints on the development of Local Exchange Trading Schemes”Area34370–381.
2.
AldridgeTLeyshonAWilliamsC, 2001, “Recasting work: The example of Local Exchange Trading Schemes”Work, Employment and Society15565–579.
3.
AnglinPBayeM, 1987, “Information, multiprice search, and cost-of-living index theory”Journal of Political Economy951179–1195.
4.
BanerjeeADufloE, 2007, “The economic lives of the poor”Journal of Economic Perspectives21141–167.
5.
BeccariaLLópezN, 1996Sin Trabajo: Las Características del Desempleo y sus Efectos en la Sociedad Argentina (Losada, Buenos Aires).
6.
BernerEGómezGKnorringaP, 2008, “‘Helping a large number of people become a little less poor’: The logic of survival entrepreneurs”, in UNU-WIDER Project Workshop on Entrepreneurship and Economic Development: Concepts, Measurements, and Impacts 21–22 August, Helsinki; copy available from E Berner, Institute of Social Studies, The Hague.
7.
BlancJ, 2006, “Les monnaies sociales: Un outil et ses limites”, in Exclusions et Liens Financiers: Monnaies Sociales Ed. BlancJ (Economica, Paris) pp 11–24.
8.
BowlesSGintisH, 1993, “The revenge of Homo economicus: contested exchange and the revival of political economy”The Journal of Economic Perspectives783–102.
9.
ChangH-J, 2002, “Breaking the mould: An institutionalist political economy alternative to the neo-liberal theory of the market and the state”Cambridge Journal of Economics26539–559.
10.
CollomE, 2005, “Community currency in the United States: The social environments in which it emerges and survives”Environment and Planning A371565–1587.
11.
CreweL, 2000, “Geographies of retailing and consumption”Progress in Human Geography24275–290.
12.
DinersteinA, 2003, “Que se vayan todos! Popular insurrection and the asambleas barriales in Argentina”Bulletin of Latin American Research22187–200.
13.
EkinsPMax-NeefM, 1986The Living Economy (Routledge, London).
14.
FanelliJ MFrenkelR, 1994Estabilidad y Estructura: Interacciones en el Crecimiento Económico (Cedes, Buenos Aires).
15.
Garcia-ParpetM F, 2007, “The social construction of a perfect market: The strawberry auction at Fontaines-en-Sologne”, in Do Economists Make Markets? On the Performativity of Economics Eds MacKenzieDMuniesaFSiuL (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 21–53.
16.
GerchunoffGLlachL, 2005El Ciclo de la Ilusión y el Desencanto: Un Siglo de Políticas Económicas Argentinas (Ariel, Buenos Aires).
17.
Gibson-GrahamJ K, 2008, “Diverse economies: Performative practices for ‘other worlds’”Progress in Human Geography32613–632.
18.
GómezG M, 2009Argentina's Parallel Currency: The Economy of the Poor (Pickering and Chatto, London).
19.
GómezG MHelmsingAHJ, 2008, “Selective spatial closure and local economic development: What do we learn from the Argentine local currency systems?”World Development362489–2511.
20.
Gonzalez BombalI, 2003Respuestas de la Sociedad Civil a la Emergencia Social (Cedes, Buenos Aires).
21.
González de la RochaM, 2001, “Are poor households coping? Assets, vulnerability and decreasing opportunities”Development and Society301–40.
22.
GrecoT, 2001Money: Understanding and Creating Alternatives to Legal Tender (Chelsea Green, White River Junction, VT).
23.
GrugelJRiggirozziM P, 2007, “The return of the state in Argentina”International Affairs8387–107.
24.
HarmanC, 2002, “Argentina: Rebellion at the sharp end of the world crisis”International Socialism943–48.
25.
HayC, 2007, “Globalisation and the institutional re-embedding of markets: The political economy of price formation in the Bordeaux en primeur market”New Political Economy12185–209.
26.
HodgsonG, 2006, “What are institutions?”Journal of Economic Issues401–25.
27.
KarnaniA, 2007, “The mirage of marketing to the bottom of the pyramid: How the private sector can help alleviate poverty”California Management Review4990–111.
28.
KosacoffBHeymannD, 2000La Argentina de los Noventa. Desempeño Económico en un Contexto de Reformas (EUDEBA CEPAL, Buenos Aires).
29.
LeeR, 1996, “Moral money? LETS and the social construction of local economic geographies in Southeast England”Environment and Planning A281377–1394.
30.
LeeRLeyshonAAldridgeTTookeJWilliamsCThriftN, 2004, “Making geographies and histories? Constructing local circuits of value”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space22595–617.
31.
LeoniF, 2003“Ilusión para nuchos, alternativa para oocos: la práctica del Trueque en los sectores populares”, masters dissertation, Instituto de Ciencias, Universidad Nacional de General Sarmiento, Buenos Aires.
32.
LernerA, 1972, “The economics and politics of consumer sovereignty”American Economic Review62258–266.
LvovichD, 2000, “Colgados de la soga: La experiencia del tránsito desde la clase media a la nueva pobreza en la ciudad de Buenos Aires”, in Desde Abajo: La Transformación de las Identidades Sociales Ed. SvampaM (Biblos, Buenos Aires) pp 51–80.
35.
MaddisonA, 2002The World Economy: A Millennial Perspective (OECD, Paris).
36.
MinujinA, 1993Cuesta Abajo: Los Nuevos Pobres: Efectos de la Crisis en la Sociedad Argentina (Losada and Unicef, Buenos Aires).
37.
MinujinA, 1997, “Estrujados. La clase media en América Latina”, in Empleo y Globalización: La Nueva Cuestión Social en la Argentina Ed. VillanuevaE (Universidad Nacional de Quilmes, Buenos Aires) pp 213–234.
38.
MurmisMFeldmanS, 1993, “La heterogeneidad social de las pobrezas”, in Cuesta Abajo. Los Nuevos Pobres: Efectos de la Crisis en la Sociedad Argentina Ed. MinujinA (Losada and UNICEF, Buenos Aires) pp 45–92.
39.
MusgrovePGalindoO, 1988, “Do the poor pay more? Retail food prices in northeast Brazil”Economic Development and Cultural Change3791–109.
40.
NorthP, 2006Alternative Currency Movements as a Challenge to Globalisation? A Case Study of Manchester's Local Currency Networks (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants).
41.
NorthP, 2007Money and Liberation: The Micropolitics of Alternative Currency Movements (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN).
42.
NorthPHuberU, 2004, “Alternative spaces of the Argentinazo’”Antipode36963–984.
43.
O'DohertyR KDürrschmidtJJowersPPurdueD A, 1999, “Local exchange and trading schemes: A Useful strand of community economic development policy?”Environment and Planning A311639–1653.
44.
OvallesE, 2002, “Argentina es el país del mundo en el cual el fenómeno del trueque tiene mayor dimensión social”Carta Económica1942–45, Centro de Estudios Nueva Mayoría, Buenos Aires.
45.
PacioneM, 1997, “Local Exchange Trading Systems as a response to the globalisation of capitalism”Urban Studies341179–1199.
46.
PacioneM, 1999, “The other side of the coin: Local currency as a response to the globalisation of capital”Regional Studies3363–72.
47.
PalominoHSchvarzerJ, 1996, “Entre la informalidad y el desempleo: Una perspectiva de largo plazo sobre el mercado de trabajo en la Argentina”Realidad Económica 1 April–15 May, 17–43.
48.
PearsonR, 2003, “Argentina's barter network: New currency for new times”Bulletin of Latin American Research22214–230.
49.
PowellJ, 2002, “Petty capitalism, perfecting capitalism or post-capitalism? Lessons from the Argentine Barter Network”, WP 357; copy available from the Library at the Institute of Social Studies, Kortenaerkade 12, 2518 AX The Hague.
50.
PozziP, 2000, “Popular upheaval and capitalist transformation in Argentina”Latin American Perspectives2763–87.
51.
RaoV, 2000, “Price heterogeneity and ‘real’ inequality: A Case-study of prices and poverty in rural South India”Review of Income and Wealth42201–211.
52.
SchuldtJ, 1997Dineros Alternativos: Para el Desarrollo Local (Universidad del Pacífico, Lima).
53.
SeyfangG, 2001a, “Community currencies: A Small change for a green economy”Environment and Planning A33975–996.
54.
SeyfangG, 2001b, “The euro, the pound and the shell in our pockets: Rationales for complementary currencies in a global economy”New Political Economy5227–246.
55.
SeyfangG, 2001c, “Money that makes a change: Community currencies, North and South”Gender and Development960–69.
56.
SeyfangG, 2001d, “Working for the Fenland dollar: An evaluation of Local Exchange Trading Schemes (LETS) as an informal employment strategy to tackle social exclusion”Work, Employment and Society15581–593.
57.
SlaterDTonkissF, 2001Market Society: Markets and Modern Social Theory (Polity Press, Cambridge).
58.
ThorneL, 1996, “Local exchange trading systems in the United Kingdom: A Case of re-embedding?”Environment and Planning A281361–1376.
59.
ThriftNLeyshonA, 1999, “Moral geographies of money”, in Nation-states and Money: The Past, Present and Future of National Currencies Eds GilbertEHelleinerG (Routledge, London) pp 159–181.
60.
Van PraagBMSBayeM R, 1990, “The poverty concept when prices are income-dependent”Journal of Econometrics43153–166.
61.
WilliamsC C, 1996, “An appraisal of Local Exchange and Trading Systems (LETS) in the United Kingdom”Local Economy11275–282.
62.
WilliamsCPaddockC, 2003, “Reconciling economic and cultural explanations for participation in alternative consumption spaces”Geografiska Annaler, Series B: Human Geography85137–148.
63.
WilliamsCWindebankJ, 2000, “Modes of goods acquisition in deprived neighbourhoods”International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research1073–94.
64.
WilliamsCWindebankJ, 2002, “The ‘excluded consumer’: A Neglected aspect of social exclusion?”Policy and Politics30501–513.
65.
WilliamsCAldridgeTLeeRLeyshonAThriftNTookeJ, 2001, “Bridges into work? An evaluation of Local Exchange Trading Schemes (LETS)”Policy Studies22119–132.
