This paper examines the development of environmental governance in Russia, using the concept of ecological modernization as an analytical framework for an empirical study. From an investigation into both the relationship between economic growth and environmental stress on the basis of the revised model of decoupling and the development of institutional capacity for environmental policy in recent years, this paper reveals that Russia's pathway to ecological modernization is now ‘closed’ in most spheres owing to the economic crisis that followed the collapse of the Soviet Union; this is in contrast to China's experience, wherein ecological modernization has been ‘forced’ as a national policy. Russia is considered to be a typical case of failure of realization of industrial restructuring leading to a relative reduction in environmental stress in a centrally planned economy. Moreover, the country's hyperdepression since the introduction of a market economy has hindered the search for a pathway to medium-term and long-term ecological modernization, which has been exchanged for short-term ‘ecological improvement without environmental policy’.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersenM, 2002, “Ecological modernization or subversion? The effect of Europeanization on Eastern Europe”American Behavioral Scientist451394–1416.
2.
ÅslundA, 2006, “Russia's energy policy: A Framing comment”Eurasian Geography and Economics47321–328.
3.
AvdoninAKamaevRRyzhevskayaD, 1997, “Ekologicheskoe soznanie: Sostoyanie i prichiny passivnosti” [Ecological consciousness: the existing situation and reasons for passivism] Sotsiologicheskie Issledovaniya [Sociological Research] 888–92.
4.
BlühdornI, 2000, “Ecological modernization and post-ecologist politics”, in Environment and Global Modernity Eds SpaargarenGMolAButtelF (Sage, London) pp 209–228.
5.
BridgesOBridgesJ, 1996Losing Hope: The Environment and Health in Russia (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants).
6.
ButtelF, 2000, “Ecological modernization as social theory”Geoforum3157–65.
7.
CarterNMolA (Eds), 2007Environmental Governance in China (Routledge, London).
8.
DeBardelebenJ, 1985The Environment and Marxism–Leninism: The Soviet and East German Experience (Westview Press, Boulder, CO).
9.
EricsonR, 2002, “The Russian economy: Market in form but ‘feudal’ in content?”, in Institutional Change in Transition Economies Eds CuddyMGekkerR (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 3–34.
10.
Eydel'manM, 1992, “Peresmotr dinamicheskikh ryadov osnovnykh makroekonomicheskikh pokazateley” [Reexamination of the dynamic series of basic macroeconomic indicators] Vestnik Statistiki [Bulletin of Statistics] 419–26.
11.
FeshbachMFriendlyAJr, 1992Ecocide in the USSR: Health and Nature under Siege (Basic Books, New York).
JancarB, 1987Environmental Management in the Soviet Union and Yugoslavia: Structure and Regulation in Federal Communist States (Duke University Press, Durham, NC).
18.
JänickeM, 1992, “Conditions for environmental policy success: An international comparison”The Environmentalist1247–58.
19.
JänickeM, 1997, “The political system's capacity for environmental policy”, in National Environmental Policies: A Comparative Study of Capacity-building Eds JänickeMWeidnerH (Springer, Berlin) pp 1–14.
20.
JänickeMWeidnerH (Eds), 1995Successful Environmental Policy: A Critical Evaluation of 24 Cases (Edition Sigma, Berlin).
JänickeMMönchHBinderM, 1992Umweltentlastung durch industriellen Strukturwandel?: Eine Explorative Studie über 32 Industrieländer (1970 bis 1990) [Environmental relief by industrial restructuring?: an exploratory study of 32 industrialized countries (from 1970 to 1990)] (Edition Sigma, Berlin).
23.
JänickeMBinderMMönchH, 1997, “‘Dirty industries’: Patterns of change in industrial countries”Environmental and Resource Economics9467–491.
24.
JänickeMMönchHBinderM, 2000, “Structural change and environmental policy”, in The Emergence of Ecological Modernisation: Integrating the Environment and the Economy? Ed. YoungS (Routledge, London) pp 133–152.
25.
KatayamaH, 2008, “Ecological modernization in Northeast Asia”, in Energy and Environment in Slavic Eurasia: Towards the Establishment of the Network of Environmental Studies in the Pan-Okhotsk Region Ed. TabataS (Slavic Research Center, Hokkaido University, Sapporo) pp 185–201.
26.
KhaninG, 1988, “Ekonomicheskiy rost: Al'ternativnaya otsenka” [Economic growth: an alternative evaluation] Kommunist [Communist] 1783–90.
27.
KortelainenJKotilainenJ, 2006Contested Environments and Investments in Russian Woodland Communities (Kikimora Publications, Helsinki).
28.
KotilainenJTysiachnioukMKuliasovaAKuliasovIPchelkinaS, 2008, “The potential for ecological modernisation in Russia: Scenarios from the forest industry”Environmental Politics1758–77.
29.
Kto Est'Kto v Ekonomike Prirodopol'zobaniya: Entsiklopediya [Who's who in resource economics: encyclopaedia] (Ekonmika, Moscow).
30.
KuboniwaM, 1997, “Economic growth in postwar Russia: Estimating GDP”Hitotsubashi Journal of Economics3821–32.
31.
KuboniwaM, 2008, “Profit and capital of the oil and gas industry”, in Oil and Gas in the Russian Economy Ed. TabataS (Hokkaido University Press, Sapporo) pp 101–124 (in Japanese).
32.
KuboniwaM, 2009, “Growth and diversification of the Russian economy in light of input–output tables”, RRC Working Paper 18, Russian Research Center, The Institute of Economic Research, Hitotsubashi University, Kunitachi, Tokyo.
33.
KuboniwaMTabataSUstinovaN, 2005, “How large is the oil and gas sector of Russia? A research report”Eurasian Geography and Economics4668–76.
34.
McIntyreRThorntonJ, 1978, “On the environmental efficiency of economic systems”Soviet Studies30173–192.
MilanezBBührsT, 2008, “Ecological modernisation beyond Western Europe: The case of Brazil”Environmental Politics17784–803.
37.
MolA, 1996, “Ecological modernisation and institutional reflexivity: Environmental reform in the late modern age”Environmental Politics5302–323.
38.
MolA, 2000, “Globalization and environment: Between apocalypse-blindness and ecological modernisation”, in Environment and Global Modernity Eds SpaargarenGMolAButtelF (Sage, London) pp 121–149.
39.
MolA, 2006, “Environment and modernity in transitional China: Frontiers of ecological modernization”Development and Change3729–56.
40.
MolA, 2009, “Environmental deinstitutionalization in Russia”Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning11223–241.
41.
MolASpaargarenG, 1993, “Environment, modernity and the risk-society: The apocalyptic horizon of environmental reform”International Sociology8431–459.
42.
MoritaTMatsuokaY, 1997, “Asian environmental problems and their future trends”Environmental Information Science262–7 (in Japanese).
43.
OECD, 1999Environment in the Transition to a Market Economy: Progress in Central and Eastern Europe and the New Independent States (OECD, Paris).
44.
OECD, 2001The Investment Environment in the Russian Federation: Laws, Policies and Institutions (OECD, Paris).
45.
OECD/IEA (a) Energy Balances of Non-OECD Countries various issues (OECD, Paris).
46.
OECD/IEA (b) Energy Balances of OECD Countries various issues (OECD, Paris).
47.
OldfieldJ, 2005Russian Nature: Exploring the Environmental Consequences of Societal Change (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants).
48.
PetersonD, 1993Troubled Lands: The Legacy of Soviet Environmental Destruction (Westview Press, Boulder, CO).
49.
PrydeP (Ed.), 1995Environmental Resources and Constraints in the Former Soviet Republics (Westview Press, Boulder, CO).
50.
RosefieldeS, 2005, “Russia: An abnormal country”The European Journal of Comparative Economics23–16.
51.
Sätre ÅhlanderA, 1994Environmental Problems in the Shortage Economy: The Legacy of Soviet Environmental Policy (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos).
52.
ShiobaraT, 2006, “Oversights in Russia's corporate governance: The case of the oil and gas industry”, in Dependent on Oil and Gas: Russia's Integration into the World Economy Ed. TabataS (Slavic Research Center, Hokkaido University, Sapporo) pp 85–114.
53.
SosunovaI, 2005, “Sotsial'no-ekologicheskaya napryazhennost’: Metodologiya i metodika otsenki” [Socio-ecological tension: Methodology and methods of evaluation]Sotsiologischeskie Issledovaniya [Sociological Research] 794–104.
54.
SpaargarenG, 2000, “Ecological modernization theory and the changing discourse on environment and modernity”, in Environment and Global Modernity Eds SpaargarenGMolAButtelF (Sage, London) pp 41–71.
55.
SunY, 2005, “The transformation of the industrial structure and the environmental burden”The Review of Welfare Society4/569–96 (in Japanese).
56.
TikhomirovaN, 2005, “Ekologicheskaya obstanovka glazami Rossiyan” [The state of the ecology: A Russian viewpoint]Monitoring Obshchestvennogo Mneniya [Monitoring for social awareness] 4102–107.
57.
TokunagaM, 2009, “Ecological modernization in the emerging markets: A Preliminary analysis”, in Shanghai Economic Area and Japanese Companies in China Ed. MizunoI (Kansai University Press, Osaka) pp 168–186 (in Japanese).
58.
TsSU RSFSRNarodnoe Khozyaystvo RSFSR [National Economy of the Republic of Russia], various issues (TsSU RSFSR, Moscow).
59.
United Nations, 2008National Accounts Statistics: Main Aggregates and Detailed Tables, 2006, Part III (United Nations, New York).
60.
WeidnerH, 2002, “Capacity building for ecological modernization: Lessons from cross-national research”American Behavioral Scientist451340–1368.
61.
WhitefieldS, 2003, “Russian mass attitudes towards the environment, 1993–2001”Post-Soviet Affairs1995–113.
62.
YanitskyO, 2001Russian Greens in a Risk Society: A Structural Analysis (Kikimora Publications, Helsinki).
63.
YatsukiS, 2000, “The transformation of industrial structure and environmental impact”The Research and Study1950–69 (in Japanese).
64.
YoungS, 2000, “Introduction: The origins and evolving nature of ecological modernisation”, in The Emergence of Ecological Modernisation: Integrating the Environment and the Economy? Ed. YoungS (Routledge, London) pp 1–39.
65.
ZhangLMolASonnenfeldD, 2007, “The interpretation of ecological modernisation in China”Environmental Politics16659–668.
66.
ZieglerC, 1980, “Soviet environmental policy and Soviet central planning: A Reply to McIntyre and Thornton”Soviet Studies32124–134.
67.
ZieglerC, 1990Environmental Policy in the USSR (University of Massachusetts Press, Amherst, MA).
