By using the example of the reintroduction of wolves to the southern French Alps, this paper explores the competing ‘philosophies of nature’ that are revealed when agendas of biodiversity enhancement and protection conflict with notions of biosecurity. Tracing the shifting status of wolves as threat and hazard to emblems of reconstituted naturality, I argue that the reintroduction of wolves disturbs notions of both biodiversity and biosecurity, making unified strategies of management increasingly difficult and problematic. More significantly, the reintroduction of these classically ‘wild’ predators into seminatural and domesticated spaces challenges otherwise simplistic classifications not only of wild and domestic but also of human and nonhuman.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsW, 2003, “When nature won't stand still: conservation, equilibrium and control”, in Decolonizing Nature: Strategies for Conservation in a Postcolonial Era Eds AdamsWMulliganM (Earthscan, London) pp 220–246
2.
AgambenG, 2004The Open: Man and Animal (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
3.
BangsE EFrittsS H, 1996, “Reintroducing the gray wolf to central Idaho and Yellowstone National Park”Wildlife Society Bulletin24402–413
4.
BeckU, 1992Risk Society (Sage, London)
5.
BennettJ, 2001The Enchantment of Modern Life (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
6.
BinghamNHinchliffeS, 2008, “Reconstituting natures: articulating other modes of living together”Geoforum3983–87
7.
BobbéS, 2002a, “Idéologie, mythe et science: le loup, objet de toutes nos passions”, in Le Fait du Loup: De la Peur à la Passion—Le Renversement d'une Image Eds Campion-VincentVDuclosJ-CAbryC (Centre Alpin et Rhodanien d'Ethnologie, Grenoble) pp 53–71
8.
BobbéS, 2002b, “L'ours et le loup: essai d'anthropologie symbolique”, MSH/INRA, Paris
9.
BobbéS, 2003Le Loup (Le Cavalier Bleu, Paris)
10.
BraunB, 2004, “Nature and culture: on the career of a false problem”, in A Companion to Cultural Geography Eds DuncanJJohnsonCScheinR (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 151–179
11.
BrownlowA, 2000, “A wolf in the garden: ideology and change in the Adirondack landscape”, in Animal Spaces, Beastly Places Eds PhiloCWibertC (Routledge, London) pp 141–158
12.
BuffièreC F, 1987La Bête du Gévaudan: Une Grande Enigmes de l'Histoireprivate publication, Toulouse
13.
BullerH, 2004, “Where the wild things are”Journal of Rural Studies20131–141
14.
CailléAChanialPVandenbergheF, 2001, “Présentation”Revue du Mauss175–21
15.
Campion-VincentVDuclosJ-CAbryC (Eds), 2002Le Fait du Loup: De la Peur à la Passion: Le Renversement d'une Image (Centre Alpin et Rhodanien d'Ethnologie, Grenoble)
16.
ClarkS, 1999The Political Animal (Routledge, London)
17.
ColemanJ T, 2004Vicious: Wolves and Men in America (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
18.
CollierSLakoffARabinowP, 2004, “Biosecurity: proposal for an anthropology of the contemporary”Anthropology Today20(5) 3–7
19.
Council for Europe, 2003, “Plan d'action pour la conservation du loup en Europe”, Sauvegarde de la Nature, number 113, Council for Europe, Strasbourg
EmelJ, 1998, “Are you man enough, big and bad enough? Wolf eradication in the US”, in Animal Geographies Eds WolchJEmelJ (Verso, London) pp 91–116
24.
EspunoN, 2004Impact du Loup sur les Ongulés Sauvages et Domestiques dans le Massif du Mercantour unpublished PhD thesis in biology, University of Montpellier, Montpellier
25.
FAO, 2003, “Biosecurity in food and agriculture”, discussion paper, Committee on Agriculture, 17th Session, Food and Agriculture Organization
26.
Federal Endangered Species Act, 1973United States Senate, Document Q /COMP/WILDLIFE/ESA73
27.
FoucaultM, 2004Sécurite, Territoire, Population: Cours au Collège de France 1977–1978 (Seuil, Paris)
28.
FranklinA, 2006Animal Nation (University of New South Wales Press, Sydney)
29.
FreudS, 1995 [1918], “From the history of an infantile neurosis”, in The Freud Reader Ed. GayP (Vintage, London) pp 400–426
Singh ReverendJ A LZinggR M, 1942WolfChildren and Feral Man (Harper, London)
56.
SpagnouD, 2003a, “Rapport au nom de la Commission d'enquête sur les conditions de la présence du loup en France et l'exercice du pastoralisme dans les zones de montagne”, volume 1, Rapport. Report of the Commission of the Assemblée Nationale, number 825, 2 May
57.
SpagnouD, 2003b, “Rapport au nom de la Commission d'enquête sur les conditions de la présence du loup en France et l'exercice du pastoralisme dans les zones de montagne”, volume 2, Auditions, Report of the Commission of the Assemblée Nationale, number 825, 2 May
58.
ThomasK, 1991Man and the Natural World (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
59.
ThompsonC, 2002, “When elephants stand for competing philosophies of nature”, in Complexities: Social Studies of Knowledge Practice Eds LawJMolA (Duke University Press, Durham, NC) pp 166–190
60.
ThriftN, 2005, “From born to made: technology, biology and space”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series30463–476
61.
WarnerM, 1995Six Myths of Our Time (Vintage, London)
62.
WhatmoreS, 2002Hybrid Geographies (Sage, London)
63.
WhiteheadA N, 1925The Concept of Nature (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
64.
WhiteheadA, 1964The Concept of Nature The Tanner Lectures delivered in Trinity College, 1919 (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
