The concept of heterotopia was introduced and immediately abandoned by Michel Foucault in 1966–67, but it quickly diffused across human geography, urban theory, and cultural studies during the 1990s. Notwithstanding the deserved impact of Foucault's overall work on these fields, there are some conceptual problems with the heterotopia concept. While the desire for a single term to probe spatial difference is understandable, the author takes issue with the kind of space envisioned in heterotopology. From a close reading of Foucault's notes, and with the help of Deleuze, Derrida, and Althusser, it is suggested that the spatiality of Foucault's heterotopology repeats certain flaws of the structuralism in vogue in 1960s France. In order for heterotopias to be ‘absolutely different’ from ‘all the rest’ of space, Foucault needs to posit a totality to society and to perform a ‘slice of time‘. The author ends by briefly examining how the structuralist tendency of heterotopology has pervaded some recent Anglophone adoptions of Foucault. As both geography and postcolonial theory have shown, slicing time often conceals particularist suppositions and is therefore inadequate to account for the multiplicity and unevenness of geographical change.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AhlbäckP M, 2001Energy, Heterotopia, Dystopia: George Orwell, Michel Foucault and the Twentieth Century Environmental Imagination (Åbo Akademis Förlag, Åbo)
2.
AllenJ, 2003Lost Geographies of Power (Blackwell, Oxford)
3.
AlthusserL, 1970 [1968], “The object of Capital”, in Reading Capital translated by BrewsterB (New Left Books, London) pp 71–324
4.
BarnesT J, 2004, “Placing ideas: Genius loci, heterotopia and geography's quantitative revolution”Progress in Human Geography28565–595
5.
BarreraE, 2003, “Aliens in heterotopia: An intertextual reading of the Border Control Museum”, in Ethnography at the Border Ed. VilaP (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN) pp 166–181
6.
BernauerJ W, 1992 [1990] Michel Foucault's Force of Flight: Toward an Ethics for Thought (Humanities Press, Atlantic Highlands, NJ)
7.
BogumilS, 2001, “Comparative literature, globalization and heterotopia”Neohelicon: Acta Comparationis Litterarum Universarum2843–54
8.
BonazziA, 2002, “Heterotopology and geography: A reflection”Space and Culture542–48
9.
BoydR, 1990Foucault and Derrida: The Other Side of Reason (Routledge, London)
10.
CarterP, 1987The Road to Botany Bay: An Essay in Spatial History (Faber and Faber, London)
11.
CasarinoC, 2002Modernity at Sea: Melville, Marx, Conrad in Crisis (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
12.
ChaplinS, 2000, “Heterotopia deserta: Las Vegas and other spaces”, in Intersections: Architectural Histories and Critical Theories Eds BordenIRendellJ (Routledge, London) pp 203–220
13.
ChengM, 2001, “Highways, L.A.: Multiple communities in a heterolocus”Theater Journal53429–454
14.
D'AmicoR, 1984, “Text and context: Derrida and Foucault on Descartes”, in The Structural Allegory: Reconstructive Encounters with the New French Thought Ed. FeketeJ (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN) pp 164–182
15.
DefertD, 2004, “L'espace s'écoute”, essay with the audio CD of M Foucault Utopies et Hétérotopies
16.
DeleuzeG, 1988 [1986] Foucault translated by HandS (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
17.
DeleuzeG, 2004 [1967], “How do we recognize structuralism?”, in Desert Islands and Other Texts, 1953–1974, Ed. LapoujadeD, translated by TaorminaM (Semiotext(e), Los Angeles, CA) pp 170–192
18.
DerridaJ, 1978Writing and Difference translated by BassA (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
19.
De SaussureF, 1966 [1916] Course in General Linguistics translated by BaskinW (McGraw-Hill, New York)
20.
DuncanJ S, 1994, “After the civil war: Reconstructing cultural geography as heterotopia”, in Re-reading Cultural Geography Eds FooteK EHugillP JMathewsonKSmithJ M (University of Texas Press, Austin, TX) pp 401–408
21.
EldenS, 2001Mapping the Present: Heidegger, Foucault and the Project of a Spatial History (Continuum, London)
22.
FeketeJ, 1995, “Postmodernism and cultural studies: On the utopianization of heterotopia”, in Constitutive Criticism: The Human Sciences in the Age of Theory Eds KreiswirthMCarmichaelT (University of Toronto Press, Toronto) pp 201–220
23.
FoucaultM, 1965 [1961] Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason translated by HowardR (Random House, New York)
24.
FoucaultM, 1970 [1966] The Order of Things: An Archeology of the Human Sciences translated by Sheridan SmithA M (Random House, New York)
25.
FoucaultM, 1973The Birth of the Clinic: An Archaeology of Medical Perception translated by Sheridan SmithA M (Tavistock Publications, London)
26.
FoucaultM, 1979 [1972], “My body, this paper, this fire”, translated by BenningtonG POxford Literary Review49–28
27.
FoucaultM, 1980 [1976], “Questions on geography”, in Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972–1977 edited and translated by GordonC (Pantheon Books, New York) pp 63–77
FoucaultM, 1998, “Different spaces”, in Aesthetics, Method, and Epistemology: Essential Works of Michel Foucault, 1954–1984volume 2, Ed. FaubionJ D, translated by HurleyR (Allen Lane, London) pp 175–186
32.
FoucaultM, 2001 [1982], “Space, knowledge, and power”, in Power: The Essential Works of Michel Foucault, 1954–1984volume 3, Ed. FaubionJ D, translated by HurleyR (Penguin, London) pp 349–363
33.
FoucaultM, 2004Utopies et Hétérotopies audio CD of radio broadcasts on France Culture radio, 7 and 21 December 1966 (INA Mémoire Vive, IMV056)
34.
GenocchioB, 1995“Discourse, discontinuity, difference: The question of other spaces”, in Postmodern Cities and Spaces Eds WatsonSGibsonK (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 35–46
35.
GuarassiV, 2001, “Paradoxes of modern and postmodern geography: Heterotopia of landscape and cartographic logic”, in Postmodern Geography: Theory and Praxis Ed. MinaC (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 226–237
36.
HannahM G, 2000Governmentality and the Mastery of Territory in Nineteenth-century America (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
37.
HarknessJ, 1983, “Translator's introduction”, in This Is Not a Pipe M Foucault (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 1–12
38.
HarveyD, 2000, “Cosmopolitanism and the banality of geographical evils”Public Culture12529–564
39.
HetheringtonK, 1997The Badlands of Modernity: Heterotopia and Social Ordering (Routledge, London)
40.
HookDVrdoljakM, 2002, “Gated communities, heterotopia and a ‘rights’ of privilege: A ‘heterotopology’ of the South African security-park”Geoforum33195–219
41.
JacobsK, 2004, “Pornography in small places and other spaces”Cultural Studies1867–83
KahnM, 1995, “Heterotopic dissonance in the museum representation of Pacific Island cultures”American Anthropologist97324–338
44.
KalogerasY, 1998, “The ‘other space’ of Greek America”American Literary History10702–724
45.
KezerZ, 2004, “If walls could talk: Exploring the dimensions of heterotopia at the Four Seasons Istanbul Hotel”, in Architecture as Experience: Radical Change in Spatial Practice Eds ArnoldDBallantyneA (Routledge, London) pp 210–332
46.
LeesL, 1997, “Ageographia, heterotopia, and Vancouver's new public library”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space15321–347
47.
LefebvreH, 1972Espace et politique published with Le droit à la ville (Anthropos, Paris)
48.
LefebvreH, 1991 [1974] The Production of Space translated by Nicholson-SmithD (Blackwell, Oxford)
49.
LefebvreH, 2003 [1970] The Urban Revolution translated by BononnoR (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
50.
MasseyD, 2005For Space (Sage, London)
51.
NorthP, 1999, “Explorations in heterotopia: Local Exchange Trading Schemes (LETS) and the micropolitics of money and livelihood”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1769–86
52.
OgbornM, 1998Spaces of Modernity: London's Geographies, 1680–1780 (Guilford Press, New York)
53.
OwensB M, 2002,“Monumentally, identity, and the state: Local practice, world heritage, and heterotopia at Swayambhu, Nepal”Anthropological Quarterly75269–316
54.
PhilipsD, 2002, “Consuming the West: Main Street, USA”Space and Culture529–41
55.
PhiloC, 1992, “Foucault's geography”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space10137–161
56.
PiagetJ, 1970 [1968] Structuralism edited and translated by MaschlerC (Harper and Row, New York)
57.
Reid-PharrR F, 1994, “Disseminating heterotopia”African American Review28347–357
58.
RelphE, 1991, “Post-modern geography”The Canadian Geographer/Le Géographe Canadien3598–105
59.
SaidE W, 1978, “The problem of textuality: Two exemplary positions”Critical Inquiry4673–714
60.
SchmidtA, 1981 [1971] History and Structure: An Essay on Hegelian – Marxist and Structuralist Theories of History translated by HerfJ (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
61.
SchubertA, 1985Der Strukturgedanke in Hegels ‘Wissenschaft der Logik” (Anton Hain, Köningstein)
62.
SharpJ PRoutledgePPhiloPPaddisonR, (Eds) 2000Entanglement of Power: Geographies of Domination/Resistance (Routledge, London)
63.
SiebersT (Ed.) 1994Heterotopia: Postmodern Utopia and the Body Politic (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI)
64.
SojaE W, 1989Postmodern Geographies: The Reassertion of Space in Critical Social Theory (Verso, London)
65.
SojaE W, 1995, “Heterotopologies: A remembrance of other spaces in the Citadel-LA”, in Postmodern Cities and Spaces Eds WatsonSGibsonK (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 125–137
66.
SojaE W, 1996Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-imagined Places (Blackwell, Oxford)
67.
SojaE W, 2000Postmetropolis: Critical Studies of Cities and Regions (Blackwell, Malden, MA)
68.
TamboukouM, 2000, “Of other spaces: Women's colleges at the turn of the century”Gender, Place and Culture7247–263
69.
TurnerV, 1966The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-structure (Aldine, Chicago, IL)
70.
VattimoG, 1992 [1989], “From Utopia to heterotopia”, in The Transparent Society translated by WebbD (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 62–75
71.
WilkeH, 2003Heterotopia: Studien zur Krisis der Ordnung moderner Gesellschaften (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main)
