In this paper I report on a participatory planning project undertaken in a community engaged in a ten-year revitalization effort. Working with several youth-serving organizations, a community planning project was conducted in which local youth collected qualitative data about their neighborhood through a variety of techniques (photography, drawings, narratives). The project took place against the backdrop of an emerging neighborhood indicators geographical information system (GIS) aimed at tracking the impact of the revitalization effort. Although techniques for collecting and using qualitative data have matured during several decades of use in the field of participatory planning and development, their effective incorporation into GIS remains elusive. Although few technical barriers remain, the absence of stakeholder participation and the lack of community capacity to implement a community-based GIS are important obstacles to a fully realized qualitative GIS. Drawing on the youth-development literature, I demonstrate in this case study the potential of qualitative GIS for engaging young people in participatory planning, while also highlighting the continuing challenge to its implementation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AitkenS, 2002, “Public participation, technological discourses and the scale of GIS”, in Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 357–366
2.
AitkenSMichelS, 1995, “Who contrives the ‘real’ in GIS? Geographic information, planning and critical theory”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems22(1) 17–29
3.
BalesS, 2001, “Perceptual barriers to valuing and supporting youth”, in Trends in Youth Development: Visions, Realities and Challenges Eds BensonPPittmanK (Kluwer, Boston, MA) pp 55–75
4.
BannerjeeKDriskellD, 2002, “Tales from truth town: Children's lives in a small south Indian ‘slum’”, in Growing up in an Urbanising World Ed. ChawlaL (Earthscan, London) pp 136–160
5.
BarndtM, 1998, “Public participation GIS: Barriers to implementation”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems25(2) 105–117
6.
BarnesTDuncanJ, 1992, “Introduction: Writing worlds”, in Writing Worlds: Discourse, Text and Metaphor in the Representation of Landscape Eds BarnesTDuncanJ (Routledge, London) pp 1–17
7.
BartlettSHartRSatterthwaiteDde la BarraXMissairA, 1999Cities for Children: Children's Rights, Poverty, and Urban Management (Earthscan, London)
8.
BensonPPittmanK, 2001, “Moving the youth development message: Turning a vague idea into a moral imperative”, in Trends in Youth Development: Visions, Realities and Challenges Eds BensonPPittmanK (Kluwer, Boston, MA) pp vii–xii
9.
BosworthMDonovanJCoueyP, 2002, “Portland Metro's dream for public involvement”, in Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 125–136
10.
BreitbartM, 1997, “‘It takes a child to inspire a village’: Re-visioning and redesigning neighborhood space with urban youth”, in Growing Up in a Changing Urban Landscape Ed. CamstraR (Van Gorcum, Assen) pp 139–149
11.
BrodySGodschalkDBurbyR, 2003, “Mandating citizen participation in plan making: Six strategic planning choices”Journal of the American Planning Association69245–264
12.
CarverSEvansAKingstonRTurtonI, 2001, “Public participation, GIS, and cyberdemocracy: Evaluating on-line spatial decision support systems”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design28907–921
13.
CaseyLPedersonT, 2002, “Mapping Philadelphia's neighborhoods”, in Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 65–76
14.
CeccatoVSnickarsF, 2000, “Adapting GIS technology to the needs of local planning”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design27923–937
15.
ChawlaL, 2002, “Toward better cities for youth and children”, in Growing Up in an Urbanising World Ed. ChawlaL (Earthscan, London) pp 219–242
16.
CheckowayBRichards-SchusterK, 2004, “Youth participation in evaluation and research as a way of lifting new voices”Children, Youth and Environments14(2) 84–98
17.
ConnellJGamboneMSmithT, 2001, “Youth development in community settings: Challenges to our field and our approach”, in Trends in Youth Development: Visions, Realities and Challenges Eds BensonPPittmanK (Kluwer, Boston, MA) pp 291–307
18.
CostelloJTolesMSpielbergerJWynnJ, 2001, “How history, ideology, and structure shape the organizations that shape youth”, in Trends in Youth Development: Visions, Realities and Challenges Eds BensonPPittmanK (Kluwer, Boston, MA) pp 191–229
19.
DennisSFJr, 2003, “Planning for change: South Allison Hill neighborhood indicators”, report prepared for the Community Action Commission, Harrisburg; copy available from the author
20.
de Souza BriggsX, 1998, “Doing democracy up-close: Culture, power, and communication in community building”Journal of Planning Education and Research181–13
21.
DriskellD, 2002Creating Better Cities with Children and Youth: A Manual for Participation (Earthscan, London)
22.
ElwoodS, 2002a, “GIS use in community planning: A multidimensional analysis of empowerment”Environment and Planning A34905–922
23.
ElwoodS, 2002b, “The impact of GIS use for neighborhood revitalization in Minneapolis”, in Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 77–88
24.
ElwoodSLeitnerH, 1998, “GIS and community-based planning: Exploring the diversity of neighborhood perspectives and needs”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems25(2) 77–88
25.
ElwoodSLeitnerH, 2003, “GIS and spatial knowledge production for neighborhood revitalization: Negotiating state priorities and neighborhood vision”Journal of Urban Affairs25139–157
26.
FlanaganCVan HornB, 2003, “Youth civic engagement: A logical next step in community youth development”, in Community Youth Development: Programs, Policies and Practices Eds VillarruelFAPerkinsDFBordenLMKeithJG (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 273–296
27.
GhoseRHuxholdW, 2001, “The role of local contextual factors in building public participation GIS: The Milwaukee experience”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems28(3) 195–208
28.
GinwrightSJamesT, 2002, “From assets to agents of change: Social justice, organizing, and youth development”, in Youth Participation: Improving Institutions and Communities Eds KirshnerBO'DonoghueJMcLaughlinM (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA) pp 27–46
29.
HanSPengZ, 2003, “Public participation GIS (PPGIS) for town council management in Singapore”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design3089–111
30.
HarleyJ, 1992, “Deconstructing the map”, in Writing Worlds: Discourse, Text and Metaphor in the Representation of Landscape Eds BarnesTDuncanJ (Routledge, London) pp 231–247
31.
HarrisTWeinerD, 2002, “Implementing a community-integrated GIS: Perspectives from South African fieldwork”, in Community Participation and Geographical Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 246–258
32.
HartR, 1979Children's Experience of Place (Irvington, New York)
33.
HartR, 1997Children's Participation: The Theory and Practice of Involving Young Citizens in Community Development and Environmental Care (Earthscan, London)
34.
HellisonDCutforthN, 1997, “Extended day programs for urban children and youth: From theory to practice”, in Children and Youth: Interdisciplinary Perspectives Eds WalbergHReyesOWeissbergR (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 223–249
35.
HollowaySLValentineG, 2000, “Children's geographies and the new social studies of childhood”, in Children's Geographies: Playing, Living, Learning Eds HollowaySAValentineG (Routledge, London) pp 1–26
36.
HorelliL, 1997, “Challenges of children's participation in urban planning”, in Growing up in a Changing Urban Landscape Ed. CamstraR (Van Gorcum, Assen) pp 131–138
37.
HuberMFrommeyerJWeisenbachASazamaJ, 2003, “Giving youth a voice in their own community and personal development: Strategies and impacts of bringing youth to the table”, in Community Youth Development: Programs, Policies and Practices Eds VillarruelFAPerkinsDFBordenLMKeithJG (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 297–323
38.
HuebnerA, 2003, “Positive youth development: The role of competence”, in Community Youth Development: Programs, Policies and Practices Eds VillarruelFAPerkinsDFBordenLMKeithJG (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 341–357
39.
JonesP, 2003, “Urban regeneration's poisoned chalice: Is there as impasse in (community) participation-based policy?”Urban Studies40581–601
40.
KwanM, 2002a, “Introduction: Feminist geography and GIS”Gender, Place and Culture9261–262
41.
KwanM, 2002b, “Feminist visualization: Re-envisioning GIS as a method in feminist geographic research”Annals of the Association of American Geographers92645–661
42.
KyemPAK, 2004, “Of intractable conflicts and participatory GIS applications: The search for consensus amidst competing claims and institutional demands”Annals of the Association of American Geographers9437–57
43.
LeitnerHMcMasterRElwoodSMcMasterSSheppardE, 2002, “Models for making GIS available to community organizations: Dimensions of difference and appropriateness”, in Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 37–54
44.
Loukaitou-SiderisA, 2003, “Children's common grounds: A study of intergroup relations among children in public settings”Journal of the American Planning Association69130–143
45.
LynchK, 1977Growing Up in Cities (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
46.
MacDonaldGValdiviesoR, 2001, “Measuring deficits and assets: How we track youth development now, and how we should track it”, in Trends in Youth Development: Visions, Realities and Challenges Eds BensonPPittmanK (Kluwer, Boston, MA) pp 155–186
47.
McLaffertyS, 2002, “Mapping women's worlds: Knowledge, power, and the bounds of GIS”Gender, Place and Culture9263–269
48.
MatthewsHLimbMTaylorM, 1999, “Young people's participation and representation in society”Geoforum30135–144
49.
MatthewsSADetwilerJEBurtonLM, 2005, “Geo-ethnography: Coupling geographic information analysis with ethnographic methods in urban research”, in “Critical GIS”, Eds HarveyFKwanMPavlovskayaM, special issue of Cartographica40(4) 75–90
50.
MullaheyRSusskindYCheckowayB, 1999Youth Participation in Community Planning (American Planning Association, Chicago, IL)
51.
ObermeyerN, 1998, “The evolution of public participation GIS”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems25(2) 65–66
52.
O'DonoghueJKirshnerBMcLaughlinM, 2002, “Moving youth participation forward”, in Youth Participation: Improving Institutions and Communities Eds KirshnerBO'DonoghueJMcLaughlinM (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA) pp 15–26
53.
ParkerCPascualA, 2002, “A voice that could not be ignored: Community GIS and gentrification battles in San Francisco”, in Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 55–64
54.
PerkinsDBordenL, 2003, “Key elements of community youth development programs”, in Community Youth Development: Programs, Policies and Practices Eds VillarruelFAPerkinsDFBordenLMKeithJG (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 327–340
55.
PerkinsDBordenLKeithJHoppe-RooneyTVillarruelF, 2003, “Community youth development: Partnership creating a positive world”, in Community Youth Development: Programs, Policies and Practices Eds VillarruelFAPerkinsDFBordenLMKeithJG (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 1–24
56.
PittmanKIrbyMFerberT, 2001, “Unfinished business: Further reflections of a decade of promoting youth development”, in Trends in Youth Development: Visions, Realities and Challenges Eds BensonPPittmanK (Kluwer, Boston, MA) pp 3–50
57.
RaceBTormaC, 1998Youth Planning Charrettes: A Manual for Planners, Teachers, and Youth Advocates (American Planning Association, Chicago, IL)
58.
RamasubramanianL, 1995, “Building communities: GIS and participatory decision making”Journal of Urban Technology3(1) 67–79
59.
SanoffH, 2000Community Participation in Design and Planning (John Wiley, New York)
60.
SawickiDBurkeP, 2002, “The Atlanta project: Reflections of PPGIS practice”, in Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 89–100
61.
ScalesPLeffertN, 1999Developmental Assets: A Synthesis of the Scientific Research on Adolescent DevelopmentSearch Institute, The Bank Building, 615 First Avenue NE, Suite 125, Minneapolis, MN 55413
62.
SchuurmanNKwanM-P, 2004, “Guest editorial: Taking a walk on the social side of GIS”Cartographica39(1) 1–3
63.
SheppardE, 1995, “GIS and society: Towards a research agenda”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems22(1) 5–16
64.
SheppardE, 2001, “Quantitative geography: Representations, practices, and possibilities”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space19535–554
65.
SieberR, 2000, “GIS implementation in the grassroots”URISA Journal12(1) 15–29
SieberR, 2003, “Public participation geographic information systems across borders”The Canadian Geographer4750–61
68.
SkeltonNBoyteHSordeletL, 2002Youth Civic Engagement: Reflections of an Emerging Public IdeaCenter for Democracy and Citizenship, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN
69.
SkeltonTValentineG, 1998Cool Places: Geographies of Youth Cultures (Routledge, London)
70.
StraussACorbinJ, 1998Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory2nd edition (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA)
71.
TalenE, 2000, “Bottom-up GIS: A new tool for individual and group expression in participatory planning”Journal of the American Planning Association66279–294
72.
TalenECoffindafferM, 1999, “The utopianism of children: An empirical study of children's neighborhood design preferences”Journal of Planning Education and Research18321–331
73.
ValentineG, 1996a, “Children should be seen and not heard: The production and transgression of adults' public space”Urban Geography17205–220
74.
ValentineG, 1996b, “Angels and devils: Moral landscapes of childhood”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14581–599
75.
WeinerDHarrisTCraigW, 2002, “Community participation and geographic information systems”, in Community Participation and Geographic Information Systems Eds CraigWHarrisTWeinerD (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 3–16
76.
WoodD, 1992The Power of Maps (Guilford Press, New York)
77.
WoolleyHSpencerCDunnJRowleyG, 1999, “The child as citizen: Experiences of British town and city centers”Journal of Urban Design4255–282
