This paper shows the main limitations and difficulties in the efficiency argument of ecological modernization. Eight limitations in the concept of eco-efficiency are revealed. Recommendations to improve the use of eco-efficiency in ecological modernization policy and management are derived from the critique. Eco-efficiency serves as an important technical tool, practical instrument, or indicator in environmental policy and management, but is not suitable as the overall goal and strategic vision.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenbyBCooperW E, 1994, “Understanding industrial ecology from a biological systems perspective”Total Quality Environmental Management (Spring) 343–354
2.
BerkhoutP H GMuskensCVelthuijsenJ W, 2000, “Defining the rebound effect”Energy Policy28425–432
3.
BluhdornI, 2000, “Ecological modernisation and post-ecologist politics”, in Environment and Global Modernity Eds SpaargarenGMolAButtelF (Sage, London) pp 209–228
4.
BratteboH, 2005, “Towards a methods framework for eco-efficiency analysis?”Journal of Industrial Ecology9(4) 9–11
5.
ButtelF, 2000, “Ecological modernization as social theory”Geoforum3157–65
6.
CEC, 2001, “Proposal for a decision of the European Parliament and of the Council laying down the community environment action programme 2001–2010”, Commission Proposals, Document 501PC0031, Commission of the European Communities, Brussels, http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/en/com/dat/2001/en_501PC0031.html
7.
CherfasJ, 1991, “Skeptics and visionaries examine energy saving”Science251154–156
8.
ChertowM R, 2000, “Industrial symbiosis: Literature and taxonomy”Annual Review of Energy and the Environment25313–337
9.
ChristoffP, 2000, “Ecological modernization, ecological modernities”, in The Emergence of Ecological Modernisation: Integrating the Environment and the Economy? Ed. YoungS (Routledge, London) pp 209–232
10.
ClevelandC JRuthM R, 1997, “When, where, and by how much do biophysical limits constrain the economic process? A survey of Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen's contribution to ecological economics”Ecological Economics22203–223
11.
CohenM, 1997, “Risk society and ecological modernization: Alternative visions for post-industrial nations”Futures29105–119
12.
CostanzaRDalyH, 1992, “Natural capital and sustainable development”Conservation Biology6(1) 37–46
DalyH, 1990, “Toward some operational principles of sustainable development”Ecological Economics21–6
15.
DalyH, 1996Beyond Growth: The Economics of Sustainable Development (Beacon Press, Boston, MA)
16.
DimaggioP JPowellW W, 1983, “The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organisational fields”American Sociological Review48 (April) 147–160
17.
EhrenfeldJ, 1997, “Industrial ecology: A framework for product and process design”Journal of Cleaner Production587–96
18.
EhrenfeldJ, 2000, “Industrial ecology: Paradigm shift or normal science?”American Behavioral Scientist44(2) 229–244
19.
EhrenfeldJ, 2003, “Putting the spotlight on metaphors and analogies in industrial ecology”Journal of Industrial Ecology7(1) 1–4
20.
EhrenfeldJGertlerN, 1997, “The evolution of interdependence at Kalundborg”Industrial Ecology1(1) 67–80
21.
FiggeFHahnT, 2004, “Sustainable value added-measuring corporate contributions to sustainability beyond eco-efficiency”Ecological Economics48173–187
22.
GaleF P, 2000, “Economic specialisation versus ecological diversification: The trade policy implications of taking the ecosystem approach seriously”Ecological Economics34285–292
23.
GiampietroM, 1994, “Sustainability and technological development in agriculture: A critical appraisal of genetic engineering”Bioscience44677–689
24.
GibbsD, 2000, “Ecological modernization, regional economic development and regional development agencies”Geoforum319–19
25.
GouldsonAMurphyJ, 1997, “Ecological modernization: Restructuring industrial economies”, in Greening the Millennium? The New Politics of the Environment Ed. JacobsM (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 74–86
26.
HajerM, 1995The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernization and the Policy Process (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
27.
HalmeMAnttonenMHraudaGKortmanJ, 2006, “Sustainability evaluation of European household services”Journal of Cleaner Production141529–1540
28.
HeijungsRGuineeJ B, 1992, “Environmental life cycle assessment of products”, Centrum voor Milieukunde, Leiden
29.
HillsPWelfordR, 2002, “Ecological modernization as a weak form of sustainable development in Hong Kong”International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology9315–331
30.
HinterbergerFLuksFSchmidt-BleekF, 1997, “Material flows vs. natural capital: What makes an economy sustainable”Ecological Economics231–14
31.
HuesemanM, 2001, “Can pollution problems be effectively solved by environmental science and technology? An analysis of critical limitations”Ecological Economics37271–287
32.
HukkinenJ, 2003a, “From groundless universalism to grounded generalism: Improving ecological economic indicators of human – environmental interaction”Ecological Economics4411–27
33.
HukkinenJ, 2003b, “Sustainability indicators for anticipating the fickleness of human–environmental interaction”Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy5200–208
JänickeMMönchHBinderM, 2000, “Structural change and environmental policy”, in The Emergence of Ecological Modernisation: Integrating the Environment and the Economy? Ed. YoungS (Routledge, London) pp 133–152
36.
JevonsF, 1990, “Greenhouse: A paradox”Search21171–172
37.
JohanssonAKischPMirataM, 2005, “Distributed economies: A new engine for innovation”Journal of Cleaner Production13971–979
38.
KorhonenJ, 2002, “The dominant economics paradigm and corporate social responsibility”Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management9(1) 67–80
39.
KorhonenJSnäkinJ-P, 2003, “Industrial ecosystem evolution of North Karelia heating energy system”Regional Environmental Change3128–139
40.
KorhonenJSnäkinJ-P, 2005, “Analysing the evolution of industrial ecosystems: Concepts and application”Ecological Economics52169–186
41.
KorhonenJvon MalmborgFStrachanP AEhrenfeldJ E, 2004, “Management and policy aspects of industrial ecology: An emerging research agenda”Business Strategy and the Environment13289–305
42.
LazearE, 2000, “Economic imperialism”The Quarterly Journal of Economics (February) 99–146
43.
MacA, 2002, “When firms make sense of environmental agendas of society”Journal of Cleaner Production10259–270
44.
MatutinovicI, 2001, “The aspects and the role of diversity in socioeconomic systems: An evolutionary perspective”Ecological Economics39239–256
45.
MatutinovicI, 2002, “Organizational patterns of economies: An ecological perspective”Ecological Economics40421–440
46.
MatutinovicI, 2003, “Human carrying capacity and socioeconomic diversity”, in Advances in Energy Studies: Reconsidering the Importance of Energy Eds UlgiatiSBrownM TGiampietroMHerendeenR AMayumiK (SGE Publishers, Padua)
MurphyJGouldsonA, 2000, “Environmental policy and industrial innovation: Integrating environment and economy through ecological modernization”Geoforum3133–44
54.
NewmanP, 1991, “Greenhouse, oil and cities”Futures (May) 335–348
55.
NiutanenVKorhonenJ, 2003, “Industrial ecology flows of agriculture and food industry: Utilizing by-products and wastes”The International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology10133–147
56.
NortonBCostanzaRBishopR C, 1998, “The evolution of preferences: Why ‘sovereign’ preferences may not lead to sustainable policies and what to do about it”Ecological Economics24193–211
PongraczE, 2002, “Re-defining the concepts of waste and waste management: Evolving the theory of waste management”Acta University of Oulu C 173
59.
PorterMvan der LindeC, 1996, “Green and competitive: Ending the stalemate”, in Business and the Environment Eds WelfordRStarkeyR (Earthscan, London) pp 61–77
60.
RenningsKWiggeringH, 1997, “Steps towards indicators of sustainable development: Linking economic and ecological concepts”Ecological Economics2025–36
61.
RingI, 1997, “Evolutionary strategies in environmental policy”Ecological Economics23237–250
62.
RobertK-H, 2000, “Tools and concepts for sustainable development, how do they relate to a general framework for sustainable development, and to each other?”Journal of Cleaner Production8243–254
63.
RobèrtK-HSchmidt-BleekBde LarderelAloise JBasileGJansenJ LKuehrRRhomasPrice PSuzukiMHawkenPWackernagelM, 2002, “Strategic sustainable development: Selection, design and synergies of applied tools”Journal of Cleaner Production10197–214
64.
RobèrtK-HBasileGBromanGByggethSCookDHaraldssonHJohanssonLMacDonaldJNyHOldmarkJWaldronD, 2004Strategic Leadership Towards Sustainability (Blekinge Institute of Technology, Kalskrona, Sweden)
65.
SalmiO, 2003, “Development and path dependence in the industrial system of the Kola Peninsula”, in Technology Society Environment, Ed. HukkinenJ (Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo, Otamedeia Oy, Finland) pp 29–46
SpaargarenGMolAButtelF, 2000, “Introduction: Globalization, modernity and the environment”, in Environment and Global Modernity Eds SpaargarenGMolAButtelF (Sage, London) pp 1–16
68.
StahelW R, 1989The Limits to Certainty: Facing Risks in the New Service Economy (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht)
69.
StevensonREvansJ W, 2004, “Cutting across interests: Cleaner production, the unified force of sustainable development”Journal of Cleaner Production12185–187
70.
TempletP H, 2004a, “Diversity and other emergent properties of industrial economies”Progress in Industrial Ecology1 (1–3) 24–38
71.
TempletP H, 2004b, “Partitioning of resources in production: An empirical analysis”Journal of Cleaner Production12 (8–10) 855–864
72.
WackernagelMReesW, 1997, “Perceptual and structural barriers to investing in natural capital: Economics from an ecological footprint perspective”Ecological Economics202–24
WealeA, 1992The New Politics of Pollution (Manchester University Press, Manchester)
75.
WeitzmanM L, 2000, “Economic profitability versus ecological entropy”The Quarterly Journal of Economics115 (February) 237–264
76.
WelfordR, 1998, “Corporate environmental management, technology and sustainable development: Postmodern perspectives and the need for a critical research agenda”Business Strategy and the Environment7(1) 1–12
77.
WelfordR, 2002, “Globalisation, corporate social responsibility and human rights”Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management9(1) 1–7
