We discuss two contrasting discourses of environmental management for the management of rivers and floodplain environments in the United Kingdom. Through the 1990s a long-established flood defence discourse gave way to a new discourse of river and floodplain restoration. We draw on qualitative interviews with river managers to set out these discourses, and consider the engagement between them. We consider particularly the way in which flood defence engineers have resisted and gradually been won over to aspects of the new restoration discourse, and the role of champions in that discourse transition.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsW M, 1992Wasting the Rain: Rivers, People and Planning in Africa (Earthscan, London)
2.
AdamsW M, 2001Green Development: Environment and Sustainability in the Third World (Routledge, London)
3.
AdamsW M, 2003Future Nature: A Vision for Conservationrevised edition (Earthscan, London)
4.
AdamsW MPerrowM R, 1999, “Scientific and institutional constraints on floodplain restoration”, in Floodplains: Interdisciplinary Approaches special publications 163, Eds MarriotSDanielanderJHeyR (Geological Society, London) pp 89–97
5.
BoonP JCalowPPettsG E (Eds), 1992River Conservation and Management (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
6.
BowersJ K, 2000, “Taken on the flood. The new project appraisal guidelines for flood defence”Ecos: A Review of Conservation20(2) 61–69
7.
BradshawA D, 1987, “The reclamation of derelict land and the ecology of ecosystems”, in Restoration Ecology: A Synthetic Approach to Ecological Research Eds JordanW RIIIGilpinM EAberJ D (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 53–74
8.
BradshawA D, 2002, “Introduction and philosophy”, in Handbook of Ecological Restoration Eds PerrowM RDayA J (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 3–9
9.
BrookesA, 1996a, “River restoration experience in northern Europe”, in River Channel Restoration: Guiding Principles for Sustainable Projects Eds BrookesAShieldsF DJr (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 233–267
10.
BrookesA, 1996b, “Floodplain restoration and rehabilitation”, in Floodplain Processes Eds AndersonM GWallingD EBatesP D (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 553–576
BuckleyG P (Ed.), 1989Biological Habitat Reconstruction (Belhaven, London)
13.
CairnsJJr, 2002, “Rationale for restoration”, in Handbook of Ecological Restoration Eds PerrowM RDayA J (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 10–23
14.
CastreeNBraunB, (Eds), 2001Social Nature: Theory, Practice and Politics (Blackwell, Oxford)
15.
CastreeNMacMillanT, 2001, “Dissolving dualisms: Actor-networks and the reimagination of nature”, in Social Nature: Theory, Practice and Politics Eds CastreeNBraunB (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 208–224
16.
ColstonA, 2003, “Beyond preservation: The challenge of ecological restoration”, in Decolonizing Nature: Strategies for Conservation in a Post-colonial Era Eds AdamsW MMulliganM (Earthscan, London), pp 247–267
17.
CowellR, 1997, “Stretching the limits: Environmental compensation, habitat creation and sustainable development”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series22292–306
18.
CrafterMde GarisYLuttNNewsomeATaggA, 2000, “River restoration: Riding a flow of consents”Ecos: A Review of Conservation21(2) 59–64
19.
CreswellJ1994Research Design: Using Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches (Sage, London)
20.
de WaalLCLargeA R GWadeP M (Eds), 1998Rehabilitation of Rivers: Principles and implementation (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
21.
DownsP WSkinnerK SKondolfCM, 2002, “Rivers and streams”, in Handbook of Ecological Restoration Eds PerrowM RDayA J (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 267–326
22.
DryzekJ, 1997The Politics of the Earth: Environmental Discourses (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
23.
EdenSTunstallS MTapsellS M, 1999, “Environmental restoration: Environmental management or environmental threat?”Area31151–159
24.
EdenSTunstallS MTapsellS M, 2000, “Translating nature: River restoration as nature–culture”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space18257–273
25.
ElliotR, 1997Faking Nature: The Ethics of Environmental Restoration (Routledge, London)
26.
English Nature, 1997Wildlife and Fresh Water: An Agenda for Sustainable Management (English Nature, Peterborough, Cambs)
27.
Environment Act1995Public General Acts—Elizabeth II chapter 25 (The Stationery Office, London)
28.
GrafW L, 2001, “Damage control: Restoring the integrity of America's rivers”Annals of the Association of American Geographers911–27
29.
GruffuddP, 1990, “Uncivil engineering: Nature, nationalism and hydro-electrics in north Wales”, in Water, Engineering and Landscape: Water Control and Landscape Transformation in the Modern Period Eds CosgroveDPettsG (Belhaven Press, London) pp 159–173
30.
GurnellAPettsG, 2000, “Causes of catchment scale hydrological changes”, in The Hydrology of the UK: A Study of Change Ed. AcremanM (Routledge, London) pp 82–98
31.
HajerM, 1995The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernisation and the Policy Process (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
32.
HeffernanM, 1990, “Bringing the desert to bloom: French ambitions: The Sahara desert during the late nineteenth century—the strange case of ‘la mer intérieure’”, in Water, Engineering and Landscape: Water Control and Landscape Transformation in the Modern Period Eds CosgroveDPettsG (Belhaven Press, London) pp 94–114
33.
HolmesN, 1997, “River rehabilitation in the UK”Ecos: A Review of Conservation18(2) 33–40
34.
HughesF M R, 1997, “Floodplain biogeomorphology”Progress in Physical Geography21501–529
35.
HughesF M RRoodS, 2001, “Floodplains”, in Habitat Conservation: Managing the Physical Environment Eds WarrenAFrenchJ R (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 105–201
36.
HughesF M RAdamsW MRichardsK S RBarsoumNMullerENilssonCDecampsHFoussadierRGirelJGuilloyHHayesAJohanssonMLambsLPautouGPeiryJ-LPerrowMVautierFWinfieldM, 2001, “Managing flows for the restoration of floodplain woodland: Local and reach scale factors in different European rivers”Regulated Rivers: Research and Management17325–345
37.
IUCN, 1980The World Conservation Strategy (International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources, United Nations Environment Programme, World Wildlife Fund, Geneva)
38.
JordanW RIIIPackardS, 1989, “Just a few oddball species: Restoration practice and ecological theory”, in Biological Habitat Reconstruction Ed. BuckelyG P (Belhaven Press, London) pp 18–28
39.
JordanW RIIIGilpinM EAberJ D, 1987a, “Restoration ecology: Restoration as a technique for basic research”, in Restoration Ecology: A Synthetic Approach to Ecological Research Eds JordanW RIIIGilpinM EAberJ D (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 3–21
40.
JordanW RIIIGilpinM EAberJ D (Eds), 1987bRestoration Ecology: A Synthetic Approach to Ecological Research (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
41.
KatzE, 2001, “Another look at restoration: Technology and artificial nature”, in Restoring Nature: Perspectives from the Social Sciences and Humanities Eds GrobsterP HHillR B (Island Press, Washington, DC) pp 37–48
42.
KeeleyJScoonesI, 2003Understanding Environmental Policy Narratives: Cases from Africa (Earthscan, London)
43.
LatourB, 1999Pandora's Hope: Essays on the Reality of Science Studies (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
44.
McCullyP, 1996Silenced Rivers: The Ecology and Politics of Large Dams (Zed Press, London)
45.
McHargI, 1969Design with Nature (Natural History Press, Garden City, NY)
46.
OwensS ECowellR, 2001Land and Limits: Interpreting Sustainability in the Planning Process (Routledge, London)
47.
PerrowM RDavyA J (Eds), 2002Handbook of Ecological Restoration2 volumes (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
48.
PeterkenG FHughesF M R, 1995, “The restoration of floodplain woodlands in Britain”Forestry63187–202
49.
PetersenR CPetersenL B-MLacoursièreJ, 1992, “A building block model for stream restoration”, in River Conservation and Management Eds BoonP JCalowPPettsG E (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 293–309
50.
PettsG E, 1996, “Sustaining the ecological integrity of large floodplain rivers,” in Floodplain Processes Eds AndersonM GWallingD EBatesP D (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) pp 535–551
51.
PettsGCalowP, 1996River Restoration: Selected Extracts from the Rivers Handbook (Blackwell, Oxford)
52.
PursegloveJ, 1988Taming the Flood (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
53.
ReisnerM1986Cadillac Desert: The American West and its Disappearing Waters (Peregrine Books, New York)
54.
RobertsonJ, 2001, “Moving the deckchairs or changing course—will DEFRA make a difference?”Ecos: A Review of Conservation22(2) 7–14
55.
RoeE, 1991, “Development narratives, or making the best of blueprint development”World Development19287–300
56.
RSPB, 1994The New Rivers and Wildlife Handbook2nd edition (Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, Sandy, Beds)
57.
SchoenbergerE, 1991, “The corporate interview as a research method in economic geography”The Professional Geographer43180–189
58.
SearDWilcockDRobinsonMFisherK2000, “River channel modification in the UK”, in The Hydrology of the UK: A Study of Change Ed. AcremanM (Routledge, London) pp 55–81
59.
SheailJ, 1981Rural Conservation in Inter-war Britain (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
60.
TapsellSTunstallSHouseMWhomsleyJMacnaghtenP, 2001, “Growing up with rivers? Rivers in London children's worlds”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series33177–189
61.
WalkerSSargentBWaterworthJ, 2000, “Responsibilities and strategies of UK organisations”, in The Hydrology of the UK: A Study of Change Ed. AcremanM (Routledge, London) pp 227–243
62.
WhatmoreS, 1999, “Hybrid geographies: Rethinking the ‘human’ in human geography”, in Human Geography Today Eds MasseyDAllenJSarreP (Polity Press, Cambridge) pp 22–39
WhatmoreSBoucherS, 1993, “Bargaining with nature: The discourse and practice of planning gain”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series18166–178
65.
WhiteR, 1995The Organic Machine (Hill and Wang, New York)
66.
Wildlife and Countryside Act1981Public General Acts—Elizabeth II chapter69 (HMSO, London)
67.
WorsterD, 1985Rivers of Empire (W W Norton, New York)
