The author considers patterns of population growth and density occurring in Canadian metropolitan areas (CMAs) over the 25-year period 1971–96. Two different sets of data, population and household, are examined with the aid of distance-decay density gradients and enumeration of intrazonal change in census tracts defined as core area (census tracts immediately adjacent to the central business district), inner city, and suburban. Important differences are found when household data are used in lieu of population data. In the core and inner city, household change points towards an overall pattern of recentralization and, in the suburbs, to intensification of development—albeit muted. This contrasts with an accentuated trend to decentralization witnessed in the population-based analyses. The author concludes that centralization is an active force in most CMAs, although it is not as strong a force as decentralization. It is also suggested that there is great diversity between the twenty-two CMAs that make up the dataset. Most important is the demonstration that evidence based on population trends alone is not sufficient to gauge changing patterns of intrametropolitan population distribution.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbbottC, 1993, “Five downtown strategies: policy, discourse and downtown planning since 1945”Journal of Policy History55–27
2.
AnasA, 1978, “Dynamics of urban residential growth”Journal of Urban Economics566–87
3.
BeauregardR A, 1990, “Trajectories of neighborhood change: the case of gentrification”Environment and Planning A22855–874
4.
BellW, 1968, “The city, suburb and a theory of social choice”, in The New Urbanization Ed. GreerS (St Martin's Press, New York) pp 132–168
5.
BerryB J LKimH M, 1993, “Challenges to the monocentric model”Geographical Analysis251–4
6.
BirchE, 2002, “Having a longer view on downtown living”Journal of the American Planning Association685–21
7.
BorchertJ R, 1991, “Futures of American cities”, in Our Changing Cities Ed. HartJ F (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 218–250
8.
BourneL S, 1989, “Are new urban forms emerging? Empirical tests for Canadian urban areas”Canadian Geographer33312–328
9.
BourneL S, 1992, “Population turnaround in the Canadian inner city”Canadian Journal of Urban Research166–89
10.
BourneL S, 1993a, “The myth and reality of gentrification: a commentary on emerging urban forms”Urban Studies30183–189
11.
BourneL S, 1993b, “Close together and worlds apart: an analysis of change in the ecology of income in Canadian cities”Urban Studies301293–1317
12.
BourneL S, 1996, “Social polarization and spatial segregation: changing income inequalities in Canadian cities”, in Contemporary City Structuring: International Geographical Insights Ed. DaviesR J (Society of South African Geographers, Wits, South Africa) pp 134–147
13.
BourneL S, 2001, “The urban sprawl debate: myths, realities and hidden agendas”Plan Canada41(4) 26–30
14.
BourneL SFlowersM, 1996The Canadian Urban System Revisited: A Statistical AnalysisCentre for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto, Toronto
15.
BourneL SRoseD, 2001, “The changing face of Canada: the uneven geographies of population and social change”Canadian Geographer45105–119
16.
BourneL SSimmonsJ W, 2003, “New fault lines? Recent trends in the Canadian urban system and their implications for planning and public policy”Canadian Journal of Urban Research1222–48
17.
BroadwayM, 1992, “Differences in inner-city deprivation: an analysis of seven Canadian cities”Canadian Geographer36189–196
18.
BroadwayM, 1995, “The Canadian inner city 1971–1991: regeneration and decline”Canadian Journal of Urban Research41–20
19.
BroadwayMJestyG, 1998, “Are Canadian inner cities becoming more dissimilar?”Urban Studies351423–1438
20.
BruecknerJ, 1980, “A vintage model of urban growth”Journal of Urban Economics8389–402
21.
BuntingTFilionP, (Eds), 1988The Changing Canadian Inner City publication 31, Department of Geography, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario
BuntingTMillwardH, 1998, “A tale of two CBDs: the decline and revival of downtown in Halifax and Kitchener”Canadian Journal of Urban Research7139–166
24.
BuntingTFilionPPristonH, 2000, “Centralization, decentralization and recentralization”Cahiers de Geographie du Quebec44341–361
25.
BuntingTFilionPPristonH, 2002, “Density gradients in Canadian metropolitan regions, 1971–96: different patterns of central area and suburban growth and change”Urban Studies392531–2552
26.
CaulfieldJ, 1994City Form and Everyday Life: Toronto's Gentrification and Critical Social Practices (University of Toronto Press, Toronto)
27.
ClarkWDielemanF, 1996Households and Housing: Choice and Outcomes in the Housing Market (Centre for Urban and Policy Research, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ)
28.
DaviesW K DMurdieR M, 1993, “Measuring the social ecology of cities”, in The Changing Social Geography of Canadian Cities Eds BourneL SLeyD F (McGill–Queen's University Press, Montreal) pp 552–575
29.
DearM JDrakeJ JReedsL G, (Eds), 1987Steel City: Hamilton and Region (University of Toronto Press, Toronto)
30.
EricksonR A, 1983, “The evolution of the suburban space economy”Urban Geography495–121
31.
EwingR, 1997, “Is Los Angeles-style sprawl desirable?”Journal of the American Planning Association63107–126
32.
FilionP, 1987, “Concepts of the inner city and recent trends in Canada”Canadian Geographer31223–232
33.
FootDStoffmanD, 1996Boom, Bust, and Echo: How to Profit from the Coming Demographic Shift (Macfarlane and Ross, Toronto)
34.
FordL, 1991, “A metatheory of urban structure”, in Our Changing Cities Ed. HartJ F (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 12–30
35.
FreemanB, 1976, “Hamilton's Civic Square: the first 11 years”City Magazine1(8) 26–41
36.
GadGMatthewM, 2000, “Central and suburban downtowns”, in Canadian Cities in Transition: The Twenty-first Century Eds BuntingTFilionP (Oxford University Press, Toronto) pp 248–272
37.
GarreauJ, 1991Edge City: Life on the New Frontier (Doubleday, New York)
38.
GoldbergM AMercerJ, 1986The Myth of the North American City: Continentalism Challenged (University of British Columbia Press, Vancouver)
39.
GordonPRichardsonH, 1997, “Are compact cities a desirable planning goal?”Journal of the American Planning Association6395–106
40.
GottdienerMKlephartG, 1991, “The multinucleated metropolitan region”, in Postsuburban America: The Transformation of Orange County Since World War II Eds KlingROlinSPosterM (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 31–54
41.
HendersonVSladeE, 1993, “Development games in non-monocentric cities”Journal of Urban Economics34207–229
42.
KlassenL, 1987, “The future of larger European towns”Urban Studies24251–257
43.
KlassenL, 1981Transportation and Reurbanization (Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
44.
KlingROlinSPosterM, (Eds), 1991Postsuburban America (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
45.
LeyD, 1988, “Social upgrading in six Canadian inner cities”Canadian Geographer76521–535
46.
LeyD, 1996The New Middle Class and the Remaking of the Central City (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
47.
LeyD, 2000, “The inner city”, in Canadian Cities in Transition: The Twenty-first Century Eds BuntingTFilionP (Oxford University Press, Toronto) pp 274–301
48.
McDonaldJ F, 1989, “Econometric studies of urban population density: a survey”Journal of Urban Economics26361–385
49.
McLemoreRAassCKeilhoferP, 1975The Changing Canadian Inner City (Ministry of State for Urban Affairs, Ottawa)
50.
MercerJ, 1999, “North American cities: the micro-geography”, in North America: A Geographical Mosaic Eds BoalF WRoyleS A (Arnold, London) pp 191–206
51.
MercerJEnglandK, 2000, “Canadian cities in continental context: global and continental perspectives on Canadian urban development”, in Canadian Cities in Transition: The Twenty-first Century Eds BuntingTFilionP (Oxford University Press, Toronto) pp 55–75
52.
MilesSPaddisonR, 1998, “Urban consumption: an historiographical note”Urban Studies35815–824
53.
MillwardHBuntingT, 1999, “A tale of two CBDs II”Canadian Journal of Urban Research81–27
54.
MironJ, 1988Demographic Change, Household Formation and Housing Demand: Canada's Postwar Experience (McGill–Queen's University Press, Montreal)
55.
MironJ, 1993, “Demography, living arrangements and residential geography”, in The Changing Social Geography of Canadian Cities Eds BourneL SLeyD (McGill–Queen's University Press, Montreal)
56.
MurdieR WTeixeiraC, 2000, “The city as social space”, in Canadian Cities in Transition: The Twenty-first Century Eds BuntingTFilionP (Oxford University Press, Toronto) pp 198–223
57.
MurphyP, 1973, “Apartment location: the balance between developer and community”, in Residential and Neighbourhood Studies in Victoria Ed. ForwardC Western Geographical Series 5, University of Victoria, Victoria, pp 149–177
58.
NewlingB, 1969, “The spatial variation of urban population densities”Geographical Review59242–252
59.
NewmanPKenworthyJ, 1989Cities and Automobile Dependency (Gower, Aldershot, Hants)
60.
NixeyD, 1991The Future Greenbelt: Economic Analysis OttawaLong Range Planning Division, National Capital Commission, 202–240Elgin Street, Ottawa K1P 1C7
61.
PalumboGSacksSWasylenkoM, 1990, “Population decentralization within metropolitan areas: 1970–80”Journal of Urban Economics27151–167
62.
PapageorgiouY, 1989, “The exponential density function: first principles, comparative statistics, and empirical evidence”Journal of Urban Economics26264–268
63.
PierceJSeguinJ, 1993, “Exclusive agricultural zoning in British Columbia and Quebec”, in Progress in Rural Policy and Planning, Volume 3 Ed. GilgA W (Belhaven Press, London)
64.
QuayleM, 1997Stakes in the Ground: Provincial Interest in the Agricultural Land Commission ActMinistry of Agriculture and Food, Vancouver, BC
65.
RamBNorrisM JSkofK J, 1989The Inner City in Transition (Statistics Canada, Ottawa)
66.
RichardsonH, 1988, “Monocentric vs. polycentric models: the future of urban economics in regional science”Annals of Regional Science221–12
67.
RobertsonK, 1995, “Downtown redevelopment strategies in the United States: an end-of-the-century assessment”Journal of the American Planning Association61429–437
68.
RoweP G, 1991Making a Middle Landscape (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
69.
SassenS, 1991The Global City (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
70.
SkaburskisA, 1989, “Inversions in urban density gradients: a brief look at the Vancouver metropolitan area density profile”Urban Studies26397–401
71.
SmallK ASongS, 1994, “Population and employment densities: structure and change”Journal of Urban Economics36292–313
72.
SmithB E, 1997, “A review of monocentric urban density analysis”Journal of Planning Literature12115–135
73.
SojaE, 1989Postmodern Geographies (Verso, London)
74.
Statistics Canada, 1997a1996 Census Dictionary 92-351-XPE, Ministry of Industry, Ottawa
75.
Statistics Canada, 1997bPopulation and Dwelling Counts 93-357-XPB, Ministry of Industry, Ottawa
76.
TomaltyR, 1997The Compact Metropolis: Growth Management and Intensification in Vancouver, Toronto, and Montreal (ICURR Publications, Toronto)
77.
VanceJ E, 1990The Continuing City (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
78.
VanceJ E, 1991, “Human mobility and the shaping of cities”, in Our Changing Cities Ed. HartJ F (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 67–86
79.
Van den BergL, 1981Urban Europe: A Study of Growth and Decline (Pergamon Press, Oxford)
80.
WalksA, 2001, “Social ecology of the post-Fordist/global city? Economic restructuring and socio-spatial polarisation in the greater Toronto region”Urban Studies38407–447
81.
ZukinS, 1995The Culture of Cities (Blackwell, Oxford)
82.
ZukinS, 1998, “Urban lifestyles: diversity and standardisation in spaces of consumption”Urban Studies35825–840
