This paper examines the Australasian breakfast cereal commodity chain and the processes of value creation in the industry. The paper has two points of entry to the commodity chain; first, a productionist perspective aimed at revealing how the material commodity is constituted, and, second, a consumptionist viewpoint, intended to show the construction of symbolic elements of the commodity. The value of the breakfast cereal commodity includes both its utility (food) value, and the semiotic and moral narratives associated with it—its symbolic value. To maintain these value dimensions the breakfast cereal companies have fashioned relationships with other organisations to legitimise prod-ucts in the eyes of the consumers. Both governmental and nongovernmental organisations are drawn into the commodity chain, and along with consumers, they actively participate in the recreation and redescription of the commodity's value. Through adhering to the analytical strategy of delineating both production and consumption dimensions the case study was able to establish the multiple layering of meanings that are associated with breakfast cereals—meanings that continue to be aligned with the industry's founding principles.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABS, 1996, “Detailed expenditure items, 1993–94 household expenditure survey, Australia”,Australian Bureau of Statistics (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra).
ANZFA, 1997Annual Report of the Australia New Zealand Food Authority, 1996–97 (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra).
4.
ANZFA, 2000, “Health ministers make historic decision on food regulation”, 24 November, Media Advisory of the Australia New Zealand Food Standards Council; now Food Standards Australia New Zealand, 55 Blackall Street, Barton, ACT 2600.
5.
ANZFA, 2001, “Australia New Zealand Food Authority”, www.anzfa.gov.au.
6.
ArceAMarsdenT K, 1993, “The social construction of international food: A New research agenda”Economic Geography69293–311.
7.
BIE, 1995Impact of the CER Trade AgreementBureau of Industry Economics (Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra).
8.
BrittonSLe HeronR BPawsonE (Eds), 1992Changing Places: A Geography of Restructuring (New Zealand Geographical Society, Christchurch).
9.
BruceSCrawfordB, 1995Cerealizing America: The Unsweetened Story of American Breakfast Cereal (Faber and Faber,Winchester, MA).
10.
ChandlerM, 2002, “Aldi has shoppers swooning in the aisles”The Australian Financial Review 18 January, page 64.
11.
CookI, 1994, “New fruits and vanity: Symbolic production in the global food economy”, in From Columbus to ConAgra: The globalization of Agriculture and Food Eds BonannoABuschLFriedlandW HGouveiaLMingioneE (University of Kansas Press, Lawrence, KS) pp 232–248.
12.
CookICrangP, 1996, “Amos Gitai's ananas: Commodity systems, documentary filmmaking and the new geographies of food”, paper presented to the Annual Conference of the Royal Geographical Society and the Institute of British Geographers, Strathclyde University, Glasgow, January; copy available from Dr Cook, School of Geography, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham.
13.
DawsonM F, 1987, “Letter to the editor”New Zealand Listener 30 October.
14.
De BoniD, 1999, “Prophets before profits in the cereal trade”New Zealand Herald 13 October, page E9.
15.
DickenP, 1986Global Shift: Industrial Change in a Turbulent World (Harper and Row, London).
16.
DickenP, 19994 “Global–local tensions: Firms and states in the global-space economy”Economic Geography70101–128.
17.
DickenP, 1998Global Shift: Transforming the World Economy3rd edition (Paul Chapman, London).
18.
DixonJ, 1999, “Reflexive accumulation and global restructuring: Retailers and cultural processes in the Australian poultry industry”Rural Sociology64320–333.
19.
DoelC, 1999, “Towards a supply-chain community? Insights from governance processes in the food industry”Environment and Planning A3169–85.
20.
EllerG, 1993, “Rural report” (radio broadcast), Radio New Zealand, 5 February.
21.
FaganRWebberM, 1994: Global Restructuring: The Australian Experience (Oxford University Press, Melbourne).
FineBHeasmanMWrightJ, 1996Consumption in the Age of Affluence: The World of Food (Routledge, London).
24.
Food and Liquor Week1997a, “Health attributes avert low price cereal push”, number 1422, 13 (Australia).
25.
Food and Liquor Week1997b, “Cereal slump”, number 1433, 15 (Australia).
26.
Food Industry Week1996, “Woolworths boosts First Choice label”, 18 October, pages 1–2 (New Zealand).
27.
FriedlandW H, 1994, “The new globalization: The case of fresh produce”, in From Columbus to ConAgra: The Globalization of Agricultureand Food Eds BonannoABuschLFriedlandW HGouveiaLMingioneE (University of Kansas Press, Lawrence, KS) pp 210–231.
28.
FriedlandW H, 2001, “Reprise on commodity systems methodology”International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food9(1) 82–103.
29.
GereffiG, 1994, “The organization of buyer-driven commodity chains: How US retailers shape overseas production networks”, in Commodity Chains and Global Capitalism Eds GereffiGKorzeniewiczM (Praeger Press, Westport, CT) pp 95–122.
30.
GereffiGKorzeniewiczM (Eds), 1994Commodity Chains and Global Capitalism (Praeger Press, Westport, CT).
31.
GlennieP DThriftN, 1993, “Modern consumption: Theorising commodities and consumers”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space11603–606.
32.
GoodmanGSorjBWilkinsonJ, 1987From Farming to Biotechnology (Basil Blackwell, Oxford).
33.
HannenM, 2001, “A hard sell for Franklins”Business Review Weekly 13 December, pp 36–37.
34.
HardymentC, 1995Slice of Life: The British Way of Eating Since 1945 (BBC Books, London).
35.
HartwickE, 1998, “Geographies of consumption: A Commodity-chain approach”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space16423–437.
36.
HaywardD JLe HeronR BPerryMCooperI, 1998, “Networking, technology, and governance: Lessons from New Zealand horticulture”Environment and Planning A302025–2040.
37.
HeadW, 1999, “Retail rivalry grows in grocery industry”MG Business 13 September, pages 4–5 (New Zealand).
38.
HoadleyS, 1995New Zealand and Australia: Negotiating Closer Economic Relations (New Zealand Institute for International Affairs, Wellington).
39.
HopkinsT KWallersteinI, 1986, “Commodity chains in the world-economy prior to 1800”Review10157–170.
40.
HopkinsT KWallersteinI, 1994, “Commodity chains in the world-economy prior to 1800”, in Commodity Chains and Global Capitalism Eds GereffiGKorzeniewiczM (Greenwood Press, Westport, CT) pp 17–20.
41.
HorneryA, 1998, “Survey takes shine off sports stars”Sydney Morning Herald 8 March Hubbard Foods Ltd, 2000, “Businesses for social responsibility”, Auckland, http://www.hubbards.co.nz/bsr/bsr.htm.
42.
JohnstonRLawrenceP R, 1988, “Beyond vertical integration—the rise of the value-adding partnership”Harvard Business Review66(4) 94–101.
Kellogg Foundation, 20012000 Annual Report of the W. K. Kellogg FoundationKellogg Foundation,One Michigan Avenue East, Battle Creek, MI 49017–4058.
45.
Le HeronK L, 1998“The hidden world of breakfast cereals: governance in the Australasian breakfast cereal industry”, unpublished MA thesis, University of Auckland, Auckland.
46.
Le HeronR B, 1988, “State, economy and crisis in New Zealand in the 1980s: Implications for land-based production of a new mode of regulation”Applied Geography8273–290.
47.
Le HeronR B, 1993Globalised Agriculture: Political Choice (Pergamon, Oxford).
48.
Le HeronR BPawsonE (Eds), 1996Changing Places: New Zealand in the Nineties (Longman Paul, Auckland).
49.
Le HeronR BRocheM, 1996, “Globalization, sustainability, and apple orcharding, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand”Economic Geography72416–432.
50.
Le HeronR BCooperIHaywardD JPerryM, 1997, “Commodity system governance by quality management: A New Zealand discourse”, in Independent and Uneven Development Eds TaylorM JContiS (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 81–100.
51.
LempertP, 1997, “Hot cereals get boost from health claims”Chicago Tribune 10 December, page 6.
52.
LeslieDReimerS, 1999, “Spatializing commodity chains”Progress in Human Geography23401–420.
53.
McMichaelP, 1996Development and Social Change (Pine Forge Press, Thousand Oaks, CA).
54.
MoneyJ, 1995The Destroying Angel: Sex, Fitness and Food in the Legacy of Degeneracy Theory: Graham Crackers, Kellogg's Corn Flakes and American Health History (Prometheus Books, Buffalo, NY).
55.
National Business Review1998, “Progs' management door revolves again”, 13 March, page 75.
56.
National Food Authority, 1995Code of Practice: Nutrient Claims in Foods Labels and in AdvertisementsNational Food Authority; now Food Standards Australia New Zealand, 55 Blackall Street, Barton, ACT 2600.
57.
NHF, National Heart Foundation of Australia; now Heart Foundation of Australia, Cnr. Denison Street and Geils Court, Deakin, ACT 2600..
58.
1997a, “The Tick: symbol of success”, unpublished.
59.
1997b, “Guidelines for acceptability”, unpublished.
NZ Ministry of Health1994, “Background paper—Harmonization of the New Zealand and Australian standards for vitamin and mineral additions to food”, unpublished, October, New Zealand Ministry of Health, 133 Molesworth Street, Wellington.
62.
ParrRListerG, 1995, “What hath God wraught! The Sanitarium Health Food Company story ”, Sanitarium, Locked Bag 7, Central Coast Mail Centre, NSW 2252, Australia.
63.
PorterM E, 1985Competitive Advantage: Creatingand Sustaining Superior Performance (Free Press, New York).
64.
PorterM E, 1986, “Competition in global industries: A Conceptual framework”, in Competition in Global Industries Ed. PorterM E (Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA) pp 15–60.
65.
PowellH B, 1956The Original Has This Signature (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ).
66.
PrattleyC, 1995Australian Food: The Complete Reference to the Australian Food IndustryAgri Food Media Pty Ltd, 52 George Street, East Melbourne 3002.
67.
PritchardW, 2000a, “The transnational corporate networks of breakfast cereals in Asia”Environment and Planning A32789–804.
68.
PritchardW, 2000b, “Beyond the modern supermarket: Geographical approaches to the analysis of contemporary Australian retail rsestructuring”Australian Geographical Studies38204–218.
69.
ReevesE, 1998, “One palatable path to improved health”The Mercury 8 July, page 43 (Australia) Retail Today 1997“Pick the Tick merger harmonized” 3(4) 9 (New Zealand).
70.
Retail World1996, “Packaged groceries: chains climb to 75.8 percent”49(23) 15.
71.
Retail World, 1999Australian Grocery Industry GuideRetail World, Paramatta, Australia.
72.
SandersonG, 1994, “Breakfast cereals—additions of vitamins and minerals: draft reply to Senator McMullan”, unpublished, New Zealand Ministry of Commerce, Wellington, October.
73.
SchererF M, 1986, “The breakfast cereal industry”, in The Structure of American Industry7th edition, Ed. AdamsW (Macmillan, New York) pp 172–202.
74.
ShoebridgeN, 1994, “The health factor has been a key generator of growth in the breakfast cereal industry”Business Review Weekly 21 March, page 83 (Australia).
75.
ShoebridgeN, 1997, “Uncle Toby's succeeds because all of its lines fit the core brand values”Business Review Weekly 8 September, pages 81–82 (Australia).
76.
ShoebridgeN, 1998, “Crunch time for Kellogg”Business Review Weekly 30 March, pages 50–54 (Australia).
77.
Statistics New Zealand, 1999, “Household Economic Survey, Information for Official Statistics”, INFOS—an on-line data source, Statistics New Zealand, Wellington.
78.
StopfordJ MStrangeS, 1991Rival States, Rival Firms: Competition for World Market Shares (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
79.
Supermarketing1995, “Weet-Bix campaign crosses the Tasman”, 31 July, pages 5–6 (New Zealand).
80.
The Australian2000, “Minister in a crackle and pop row”, 22 November, page6.
81.
TorranceF, 1986, “Selling by the good book” Marketing 52 (April) 78.
82.
UnsworthM, 1996, “History of the fortification issue and the legislative process in New Zealand”, paper presented to the Fortification and Nutritional Claims Seminar, Wellington, 22 August; copy available from the author, Saunders Unsworth, PO Box 10–200, Wellington.
83.
WalkerR, 1988, “The geographical organization of production-systems”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space6377–408.
84.
WilliamsR, 1998, “Job to do on breakfast skippers”Retail Today August, pages 44–48 (New Zealand).
85.
WTO, 1999Trading into the Future (World Trade Organization, Geneva).
86.
YeungH W C, 1998, “Capital, state and space: Contesting the borderless world”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series23291–309.
