Against the backdrop of a perceived ‘crisis’ within the field of Anglo-American regional science, in this paper we offer a brief overview of the early engagement of regional science with the regional concept, while placing its theoretical formulations within the wider sociohistorical context of the Cold War period and the rise of positivist social science. With regard to the development of regional science as a field of enquiry with its own theoretical and empirical postulates, attention focuses on what David Harvey has referred to as a “utopianism of spatial form”, defined by the idea that spatial constructs can serve to control social processes in positive ways, thus using space to evade historical change. In building bridges from the Isardian promise of the past of regional science to its multiple futures, we suggest that the field today may break out of its current ‘isolated state’ by entering into creative dialogue with the metaphors animating three research streams: (1) an ‘analytical turn’ in Marxist economic geography; (2) a Marshallian ‘New Regionalism’; and (3) a ‘cultural turn’ perceived to be occurring within the field of radical political economy. Each stream, addressed here as a successive and broader departure from the more orthodox “utopianism of spatial form” in spatial and regional science, is briefly surveyed in turn. Drawing on the metaphor of borders and border-lands, we conclude by arguing that rather than view each research strand as an ‘improvement’ on its predecessor they should be viewed as the grounds for a potentially rich cross-fertilization between spatial science and various fields of nonorthodox economics.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlonsoWBramhallD FIsardWStevensB H, 1958, “The core and boundaries of regional science”Papers and Proceedings of the Regional Science Association43–13
2.
AminA, 1999, “An institutionalist perspective on regional development”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research23365–378
3.
AminA, 2000, “Industrial districts”, in A Companion to Economic Geography Eds SheppardEBarnesT JBlackwell, Oxford) pp 149–168
4.
AminARobinsK, 1990, “Industrial districts and regional development”, in Industrial Districts and Inter-firm Cooperation in Italy Eds PykeFBecattiniGSengenbergerWILO, Geneva) pp 185–213
5.
AminAThriftN, 1992, “Marshallian nodes in global networks”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research16571–587
6.
AminAThriftN, 2000, “What kind of economic theory for what kind of economic geography?”Antipode324–9
7.
AppaduraiA, 1990, “Disjuncture and difference in the global cultural economy”, in Global Culture Ed. FeatherstoneMSage, London) pp 295–310
8.
AppaduraiA, 1996Modernity at Large: Cultural Dimensions of Globalization (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
9.
ArthurW B, 1994Increasing Returns and Path Dependence in the Economy (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI)
10.
AsheimB T, 1997, “‘Learning regions’ in a globalized world economy: towards a new competitive advantage of industrial districts?”, in Interdependent and Uneven Development: Global – Local Perspectives Eds ContiSTaylorMAvebury, Aldershot, Hants) pp 143–176
11.
AsheimB T, 2000, “Industrial districts: the contributions of Marshall and beyond”, in The Oxford Handbook of Economic Geography Eds ClarkG LFeldmanM PGertlerM SOxford University Press, Oxford) pp 413–431
12.
BagnascoA, 1977Tre Italie: La Problematica Territoriale dello Sviluppo Italiano [Third Italy: the territorial problematic of Italian development] (Il Mulino, Bologna)
13.
BarnesT J, 1985, “Theories of interregional trade and theories of value”Environment and Planning A17729–746
14.
BarnesT J, 1993, “Whatever happened to the philosophy of science?”Environment and Planning A25301–304
15.
BarnesT J, 1995, “Political economy I: ‘the culture, stupid’”Progress in Human Geography19423–431
16.
BarnesT J, 1996Logics of Dislocation: Models, Metaphors, and Meanings of Economic Space (Guilford Press, New York)
17.
BecattiniG, 1989, “Sectors and/or districts: some remarks on the conceptual foundations of industrial economics”, in Small Firms and Industrial Districts in Italy Eds GoodmanEBamfordJSaynorPRoutledge, London) pp 123–135
18.
BecattiniG, 1991, “Italian industrial districts: problems and perspectives”International Studies of Management and Organization2183–89
19.
BecattiniG, 1992, “Le district marshallien: une notion socio-économique” [The Marshallian district: a socioeconomic concept], in Les Regions qui Gagnent: Districts et Reseaux: Les Nouveaux Paradigmes de la Geographie Economique Eds BenkoGLipietzA (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris)
20.
BeckULashSGiddensA, 1994Reflexive Modernization: Politics, Tradition and Aesthetics in the Modern Social Order (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
21.
BenderTShorskeC, 1997American Academic Culture in Transformation: Fifty Years, Four Disciplines (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
22.
BermanM J L, 1982All That is Solid Melts into Air: The Experience of Modernity (Simon and Schuster, New York)
23.
BerryB, 1995, “Whither regional science”Regional International Science Review17297–305
24.
BurmeisterE, 1980Capital Theory and Dynamics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
CastellsM, 1983The City and the Grassroots: A Cross-cultural Theory of Urban Social Movements (Edward Arnold, London)
27.
ChatterjiM, 1990, “Postscript: the future of regional science”, in New Frontiers in Regional Science: Essays in Honor of Walter Isard, Volume 1 Eds ChatterjiMKuenneRMacmillan, London) pp 351–364
28.
ChinitzB, 1961, “Contrasts in agglomeration: New York and Pittsburgh”American Economics Association Paper Proceedings 73rd Meeting51279–289
29.
ChisholmM, 1975Human Geography: Evolution or Revolution? (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
30.
ClarkG LFeldmanM PGertlerM S (Eds), 2000The Oxford Handbook of Economic Geography (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
31.
CoaseR H, 1937, “The nature of the firm”Economica4386–405
32.
CookeP (Ed.), 1989Localities: The Changing Face of Urban Britain (Unwin Hyman, London)
33.
CorbridgeSMartinR LThriftN J (Eds), 1994Money, Power and Space (Blackwell, Oxford)
34.
CrangP, 1997, “Cultural turns and the (re)constitution of economic geography”, in Geographies of Economies Eds LeeRWillsJEdward Arnold, London) pp 3–15
35.
DavidP, 1975Technical Choice, Innovation and Economic Growth: Essays on American and British Experiences in the 19th Century (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
36.
DearM, 1995, “Reinventing regional science”Regional International Science Review17355–360
37.
DiMaggioP, 1994, “Culture and economy”, in The Handbook of Economic Sociology Eds SmelserN JSwedbergRPrinceton University Press, Princeton, NJ) pp 27–57
38.
DosiGFreemanCNelsonRSilverbergGSoeteL, 1988Technical Change and Economic Theory (Pinter, London)
39.
DosiGPavittKSoeteL, 1990The Economics of Technical Change and International Trade (New York University Press, New York)
40.
DostoyevksyF, 1880The Brothers Karamazov: A Novel in Four Parts and an Epilogue (Penguin, London)
41.
DouglasMWildavskyA, 1983Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
42.
FukuyamaF, 1992The End of History and the Last Man (Hamilton, London)
43.
GarofoliG, 1992, “Les systemes de petites entreprises: un cas paradigmatique de developpement endogene” [Small enterprise systems: a paradigmatic case of endogenous development], in Les Regions qui Gagnent: Districts et Reseaux: Les Nouveaux Paradigmes de la Geographie Economique Eds BenkoGLipietzA (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris) pp 147–163
44.
GiddensA, 1991Modernity and Self-identity: Self and Society in the Late-modern Age (Polity Press, Cambridge, MA)
45.
GranovetterM, 1985, “Economic action and social structure: the problems of embeddedness”American Journal of Sociology91481–510
46.
GregoryD, 1978Ideology, Science and Human Geography (Hutchinson, London)
47.
GregsonN, 2000, “Family, work, and consumption: mapping the borderlands of economic geography”, in A Companion to Economic Geography Eds SheppardEBarnesT JBlackwell, Oxford) pp 312–324
48.
GregsonNSimonsenKVaiouD, 1999a, “Thinking further about economy and culture: problems, foreclosures and possibilities”, paper presented at Seminar of the Aegean, Towards a Radical Cultural Agenda for European Cities and Regions, Paros, Greece; copy available from KramschO, Department of Human Geography, Nijmegen School of Management, Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, Nijmegen
49.
GregsonNSimonsenKVaiouD, 1999b, “The meaning of work: some arguments for the importance of culture within formulations of work in Europe”European Urban and Regional Studies6(3) 197–214
50.
Gunder FrankA, 1978Dependent Accumulation and Underdevelopment (Macmillan, London)
51.
HakliJ, 1998, “Cross-border regionalisation in the ‘new Europe’: theoretical reflection with two illustrative examples”Geopolitics3(3) 83–103
52.
HardtMNegriA, 2000Empire (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
53.
HarrisonB, 1992, “Industrial districts: old wine in new bottles?”Regional Studies26469–483
54.
HarrisonB, 1994, “The Italian districts and the crisis of the cooperative firm: part I”European Planning Studies23–22
55.
HarveyD, 1982The Limits to Capital (Blackwell, Oxford)
56.
HarveyD, 1985Consciousness and the Urban Experience (Blackwell, Oxford)
57.
HarveyD, 1989The Condition of Postmodernity (Blackwell, Oxford)
58.
HarveyD, 2000Spaces of Hope (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh)
HirschmannA O, 1977The Passions and the Interests: Political Arguments for Capitalism Before its Triumph (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
61.
HodgsonG, 1993Economics and Evolution: Bringing Life Back into Economics (Polity Press, Cambridge)
62.
HooverE M, 1971An Introduction to Regional Economics (Knopf, New York)
63.
IsardW, 1956Location and Space Economy: A General Theory Relating to Industrial Location, Market Areas, Land Use, Trade, and Urban Structure (Technology Press of Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA)
64.
IsardWOstroffD, 1958, “The existence of a competitive interregional equilibrium”Papers and Proceedings of the Regional Science Association449–76
65.
IsraelJ, 2001Radical Enlightenment: Philosophy and the Making of Modernity, 1650 – 1750 (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
66.
IssermanA M, 1984, “Projection, forecast, and plan: on the future of population forecasting”Journal of the American Planning Association50208–221
67.
IssermanA M, 1995, “The history, status, and future of regional science: an American perspective”International Regional Science Review17249–296
68.
JacksonP, 1996, “Consumption and identity: the cultural politics of shopping”, paper presented at the Seminar of the Aegean, Space, Inequality and Difference: from ‘Radical’ to ‘Cultural’ Formulations? Milos, Greece; copy available from KramschO, Department of Human Geography, Nijmegen School of Management, Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, Nijmegen
69.
JamesonF, 1998The Cultural Turn: Selected Writings on the Postmodern, 1983 – 1998 (Verso, London)
70.
JensenR C, 1991, “Quo vadis, regional science?”Papers in Regional Science7097–111
71.
JessopB, 1994, “Post-Fordism and the state”, in Post-Fordism: A Reader Ed. AminABlackwell, Oxford) pp 251–279
72.
JessopB, 1995, “The regulation approach, governance and post-Fordism: alternative perspectives on economic and political change?”Economy and Society24307–333
73.
JohnstonR J, 1991Geography and Geographers: Anglo-American Geography Since 19454th edition (Edward Arnold, London)
74.
KeatingMLoughlinJ (Eds), 1997The Political Economy of Regionalism (Frank Cass, London)
75.
KramschO, 1998, “Tropics of planning discourse: stalking the ‘constructive imaginary’ of selected urban planning histories”, in Making the Invisible Visible: A Multicultural Planning History Ed. SandercockLUniversity of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 163–183
76.
KramschO, 2002, “Navigating the spaces of Kantian reason: notes on cosmopolitical governance within the cross-border Euregios of the European Union”Geopolitics6(2) 27–50
77.
KramschCKramschO, 2000, “The avatars of literature in language study”The Modern Language Journal84553–573
78.
LashSUrryJ, 1994Economies of Signs and Space (Sage, London)
79.
LightIRosensteinC (Eds), 1995Race, Ethnicity, and Entrepreneurship in Urban America (Aldine de Gruyter, Hawthorne, NY)
80.
LoveringJ, 1999, “Theory led by policy: the inadequacies of the ‘New Regionalism’ (illustrated from the case of Wales)”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research23379–395
81.
LundvallB A (Ed.), 1992National Systems of Innovation (Pinter, London)
82.
MarkusenA, 1995, “Growing pains: thoughts on theory, method, and politics for a regional science of the future”International Regional Science Review17319–326
83.
MarshallA, 1919Industry and Trade (Macmillan, London)
84.
MartinR, 1999a, “The new ‘geographical turn’ in economics: some critical reflections”Cambridge Journal of Economics23(1) 65–91
85.
MartinR, 1999b, “Editorial: the ‘new economic geography’: challenge or irrelevance?”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series24387–396
86.
MenandL, 2001, “College: the end of the golden age”New York Review of Books48(16) 44–47
MitchellK, 1997, “Transnational subjects: constituting the cultural citizen in the era of Pacific Rimcapital”, in Ungrounded Empires: The Cultural Politics of Modern Chinese Transnationalism Eds OngADoniniD MRoutledge, New York)
89.
MorishimaM, 1973Marx's Economics: A Dual Theory of Value and Growth (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
90.
MyrdalG, 1957Economic Theory and Underdeveloped Regions (Harper and Row, New York)
91.
NelsonR RWinterS G, 1982An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
92.
NorthD, 1981Structure and Change in Economic History (Norton, New York)
93.
O'BrienR, 1992Global Financial Integration: The End of Geography (Pinter, London)
94.
OngPBonacichEChengL (Eds), 1994The New Asian Immigration in Los Angeles and Global Restructuring (Temple University Press, Philadelphia, PA)
95.
PavlikC E, 1995, “Gotterdammerung or brave new world?”International Regional Science Review17361–366
96.
PeetR, 2000, “Culture, imaginary, and rationality in regional economic development”Environment and Planning A321215–1234
97.
PioreM JSabelC F, 1984The Second Industrial Divide (Basic Books, New York)
98.
PolèseM, 1995, “On the cultural origins and future directions of regional science: a voice from the periphery”International Regional Science Review17311–318
99.
PorterM, 1990The Competitive Advantage of Nations (Macmillan, London)
100.
PrattM L, 1992Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation (Routledge, London)
101.
PudupM B, 1992, “Industrialization after (de)industrialization: a review essay”Urban Geography13187–200
102.
PutnamR, 1993Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ)
103.
ReesJ, 1999, “Regional science: from crisis to opportunity”Papers in Regional Science78101–110
104.
RichardsonH W, 1995, “Not a funeral but a wake: regional science in perspective”International Regional Science Review17333–336
105.
RoemerJ, 1981Analytical Foundations of Marxian Economic Theory (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
106.
RothschildE, 2001Economic Sentiments: Adam Smith, Condorcet, and the Enlightenment (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
107.
RyanA, 2001, “A new vision of liberty”New York Review of Books48(11) 42–45
108.
SabelC, 1989, “Flexible specialization and the re-emergence of regional economies”, in Reversing Industrial Decline? Eds HirstPZeitlinJBerg, Oxford) pp 17–70
109.
SamuelsonP A, 1952, “Spatial price equilibrium and linear programming”American Economic Review42283–303
110.
SayerA, 1988, “The ‘new’ regional geography and problems of narrative”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space7253–276
111.
SayerARayL, 1999Culture and Economy After the Cultural Turn (Sage, London)
112.
ScottA J, 1988New Industrial Spaces: Flexible Production Organization and Regional Development in North America and Western Europe (Pion, London)
113.
ScottA J, 1997, “The cultural economy of cities”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research21323–339
114.
ScottA JStorperM, 1990, “Regional development reconsidered”, UCLA Lewis Center for Regional Policy Studies, Los Angeles, CA
115.
ScottW, 2000, “Euroregions, governance, and transborder cooperation within the EU”, in European Research in Regional Science 10. Borders, Regions and People Eds van der VeldeMvan HoutumHPion, London) pp 104–115
116.
SheppardE, 1984, “Value and exploitation in a capitalist space economy”International Regional Science Review997–108
117.
SheppardE, 1990, “Modeling the capitalist space economy: bringing society and space back”Economic Geography66201–228
118.
SheppardE, 1995, “Dissenting from spatial analysis”Urban Geography16283–303
119.
SheppardE, 2001, “Quantitative geography: representations, practices, and possibilities”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space19535–554
120.
SheppardEBarnesT J, 1986, “Instabilities in the geography of capitalist production: collective vs. individual profit maximization”Annals of the Association of American Geographers76493–507
121.
SheppardEBarnesT J (Eds), 2000A Companion to Economic Geography (Blackwell, Oxford)
122.
SojaE W, 1989Postmodern Geographies: The Reassertion of Space in Critical Social Theory (Verso, London)
123.
SojaE W, 1999, “In difference spaces: the cultural turn in urban and regional political economy”European Planning Studies7(1) 65–75
124.
SojaE W, 2000Postmetropolis: Critical Studies of Cities and Regions (Blackwell, Oxford)
125.
SparkeM, forthcoming Hyphen-nation-states: Critical Geographies of Displacement and Disjuncture (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
126.
SraffaP, 1960Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities: Prelude to a Critique of Economic Theory (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
127.
StorperM, 1997The Regional World: Territorial Development in a Global Economy (Guilford Press, New York)
128.
StorperMSalaisR, 1997Worlds of Production: The Action Frameworks of the Economy (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
SunleyP, 1992, “Marshallian industrial districts: the case of Lancashire cotton industry in the inter-war years”Transactions Institute of British Geographers, New Series17306–320
131.
ThriftN, 1997, “The rise of soft capitalism”Cultural Values1(1) 29–57
132.
ThriftNOldsK, 1996, “Refiguring the economic in economic geography”Progress in Human Geography20311–337
133.
VaiouDMantouvalouM, 1999, “Guest editorial: spatial disciplines in the cultural turn”European Planning Studies7(1) 5–7
134.
VaiouDGregsonNSimonsenK, 1999, “The meaning of work: some arguments for the importance of culture within formulations of work in Europe”European Urban and Regional Studies6(3) 197–214
135.
WarfB, 1995, “Separated at birth? Regional science and social theory”International Regional Science Review18185–194
136.
WebberM J, 1987, “Quantitative measurement of some Marxist categories”Environment and Planning A191303–1321
137.
WebberM J, 1991, “The contemporary transition”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space9165–182
138.
WebberM JSheppardERigbyD, 1992, “Forms of technical change”Environment and Planning A241679–1709
139.
WhiteH, 1987The Content of the Form: Narrative Discourse and Historical Representation (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
140.
WilliamsonO, 1975Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications (Free Press, New York)
141.
ZukinS, 1995The Cultures of Cities (Blackwell, Cambridge, MA)
