In the 1960s and early 1970s growth center policies were included in the regional policies of countries throughout much of the world. However, by the mid-1970s, many academics and government agencies believed that growth center policies were not successful in encouraging regional development, and since that time growth center theory has remained, in general, poorly regarded. In the 1960s, the Appalachian Regional Commission (ARC) implemented a growth center policy. Though much has been written about the ARC, there is little research on the Commission's experience in implementing its growth center policy. The author uses historical documentation from the ARC to assess the Commission's growth center policy, particularly in the context of growth center theory. He then utilizes ARC expenditure data to determine the extent to which the ARC was able to implement what is best termed a ‘modified growth center strategy’. It is concluded that the ARC did not implement a policy that was particularly akin to growth center policy as presented in the theoretical literature; however, it is also concluded that the ARC did implement a modified version of a growth center strategy with some success.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ARC, Appalachian Regional Commission, 1666Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 700, Washington, DC 20009–1068; archived collection held at University of Kentucky.
2.
1968aStaff Evaluation: Appalachian Regional Development Program 1965–1968.
3.
1968bState and Regional Development Plans in Appalachia: 1968.
4.
1970aThe Appalachian Experiment 1965–1970.
5.
1970bThe Urban – Rural Growth Strategy in Appalachia.
6.
1972Internal Memo from Kenneth D Rainey to The Executive Committee, March 17, 1972.
7.
1973State Development Plan (Mississippi 1973).
8.
1977Appalachia: Goals, Objectives and Development Strategies.
9.
1981A Report to Congress from the Appalachian Governors.
10.
1985Appalachia: Twenty Years of Progress.
11.
19961996 Annual Report.
12.
BarkleyDHenryMBaoS, 1996, “Identifying ‘spread’ versus ‘backwash’ effects in regional economic areas: A Density functions approach”Land Economics72336–357.
13.
BerryB, 1972, “Hierarchical diffusion: The basis of development filtering and spread in a system of growth centers”, in Growth Centers in Regional Economic Development Ed. HansenN (The Free Press, New York) pp 108–138.
14.
BerryB, 1973Growth Centers in the American Urban System (Ballinger, Cambridge, MA).
15.
BoudevilleJ, 1957, “Contribution a l'étude des pôles de croissance brésiliennes: une industrie motrice, la sidérurgie du minas gerais” [Contribution to the study of Brazilian growth poles: a driving industry, the iron and steel industry of Minas Gerais] The Economic Institute of Applied Science, Paris, Serie L.
16.
BradshawM, 1992The Appalachian Regional Commission: Twenty-five Years of Government Policy (University of Kentucky Press, Lexington, KY).
17.
CasettiEKingLOdlandJ, 1971, “The formalization and testing of concepts of growth poles in a spatial context”Environment and Planning3377–382.
18.
DarwentD, 1969, “Growth poles and growth centers in regional planning—a review”Environment and Planning15–32.
19.
EDA, 1997Cluster Based Economic Development: A Key to Regional CompetitivenessEconomic Development Administration, http://www.doc.gov/eda/pdf/cluster.pdf.
20.
FriedmannJ, 1964, “The concept of a planning region—the evolution of an idea in the United States”, in Regional Development and Planning: A Reader Eds FriedmannJAlonsoW (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 497–518.
21.
GaileG, 1980, “The spread–backwash concept”Regional Studies1415–25.
22.
GalstonWBaehlerK, 1995Rural Development in the United States: Connecting Theory, Practice, and Possibilities (Island Press, Washington, DC).
23.
GibbsRBernatG, 1997, “Rural industry clusters raise local earnings”Rural Development Perspectives1218–25.
24.
GlasmeierAFuellhartK, 1999Building on Past Experiences: Creating a New Future for Distressed CountiesInstitute for Policy Research and Evaluation, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA.
25.
HansenN, 1971Intermediate-size Cities as Growth Centers: Applications for Kentucky, the Piedmont Crescent, the Ozarks, and Texas (Praeger, New York).
26.
HansenN, 1972, “Growth center policy in the United States”, in Growth Centers in Regional Economic Development Ed. HansenN (Free Press, New York) pp 266–281.
27.
HansenN, 1975, “An evaluation of growth-center theory and practice”Environment and Planning A7821–832.
28.
HansenNHigginsBSavoieD, 1990Regional Policy in a Changing World (Plenum, New York).
29.
HenryMBarkleyDBaoS, 1997, “The hinterland's stake in metropolitan growth: Evidence from selected southern regions”Journal of Regional Science37479–501.
30.
HirschmanA, 1958The Strategy of Economic Development (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT).
31.
HooverE, 1971An Introduction to Regional Economics (Alfred A Knopf, New York).
32.
HooverEGiarrataniF, 1984An Introduction to Regional Economics (Alfred A Knopf, New York).
33.
HughesDHollandD, 1994, “Core–periphery economic linkage: A Measure of spread and possible backwash effects for the Washington economy”Land Economics70364–377.
34.
IssermanA, 1996Appalachia Then and Now: An Update of ‘The Realities of Deprivation’ Reported to the President in 1964Appalachian Regional Commission, 1666 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 700, Washington DC 20009–1068.
35.
IssermanARephannT, 1995, “The economic effects of the Appalachian Regional Commission: An empirical assessment of 26 years of regional development planning”Journal of the American Planning Association61345–364.
36.
MairA, 1993, “New growth poles? Just-in-time manufacturing and local economic development strategy”Regional Studies27207–221.
37.
MooreT, 1994, “Core–periphery models, regional planning theory, and Appalachian development”The Professional Geographer46316–331.
38.
MorrillR, 1973, “On the size and spacing of growth centers”Growth and Change421–24.
39.
MoseleyM, 1973, “The impact of growth centres in rural regions I”Regional Studies757–75.
40.
MoseleyM, 1974Growth Centres in Spatial Planning (Pergamon Press, New York).
41.
MurrayE, 1999, “Cluster-based development strategies: Lessons from the plastics industry in North Central Massachusetts”Economic Development Quarterly13266–280.
42.
MyrdalG, 1957Rich Lands and Poor: The Road to World Prosperity (Harper and Brothers, New York).
43.
PARC, 1964Appalachia: A Report by the President's Appalachian Regional Commission President's Appalachian Regional Commission (US Government Printing Office, Washington DC).
44.
ParrJ, 1999a, “Growth-pole strategies in regional economic planning: A Retrospective view. Part 1. Origins and advocacy”Urban Studies361195–1215.
45.
ParrJ, 1999b, “Growth-pole strategies in regional economic planning: A Retrospective view. Part 2. Implementation and outcome”Urban Studies361247–1268.
46.
PerrouxF, 1950, “Economic space, theory and applications”Quarterly Journal of Economics February, pages 90–97.
47.
PrestonJ, 1971An Analysis of the Growth Center Strategy of the Appalachian Regional CommissionAppalachian Regional Commission, 1666 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 700, Washington, DC 20009–1068.
48.
RichardsonH, 1976, “Growth pole spillover: The dynamics of backwash and spread”Regional Studies101–9.
49.
RichardsonH, 1979Regional Economics (University of Illinois Press, Urbana, IL).
50.
RobinsonGSalihK, 1971, “The spread of development around Kuala Lumpur: A Methodology for an exploratory test of some assumptions of the growth-pole model”Regional Studies5303–314.
51.
RothblattD, 1971Regional Planning: The Appalachian Experience (DC Heath, Lexington, MA).
52.
ShellhammerK, 1972Growth Center Strategy as Applied to Depressed Areas in Advanced Countries: The Case of Appalachiaunpublished PhD dissertation, Department of Economics, The University of Colorado, Boulder, CO US Congress, 1965 Appalachian Regional Development Act (Public Law 94–188) (Government Printing Office, Washington, DC).
53.
WidnerR, 1968, “The role of urbanization in Appalachian regional development”, paper presented at Sixty-Fourth Annual Meeting of the Association of American Geographers, Washington, DC, 19 August; copy may be consulted at Appalachian Regional Commission archive collection, University of Kentucky.
54.
WidnerR, 1990, “Appalachian development after 25 years: An assessment”Economic Development Quarterly4291–312.
55.
WilsonT, 1964Policies for Regional Development (Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh).
56.
WoodLBischakG, 2000Progress and Challenges in Reducing Economic Distress in Appalachia: An Analysis of National and Regional Trends Since 1960Appalachian Regional Commission, 1666 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 700, Washington, DC 20009–1068.
