The author examines the determinants of migration intentions in Hubei province in central China. The analysis suggests that temporary migrants are more likely to migrate than are comparable permanent migrants or nonmigrants. The results also indicate that males are more likely to migrate as individuals than are females. Although age has a great deterrent impact on family migration, being married shows a much greater negative effect on planning an individual migration. Also, family network proves to be more important for determining individual migration than family migration. The results lend support to the notion that temporary migrants in cities do consider themselves as temporary residents and are therefore more likely to migrate again in the near future. They also confirm the argument that different factors play significant roles in individual versus family migration, and highlight the importance in distinguishing the two in empirical studies in developing countries.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BanisterJ, 1987China's Changing Population (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
2.
BielbyR TBielbyD D, 1992, “I will follow him: gender role beliefs, and reluctance to relocate to a better job”American Journal of Sociology971241–1267
3.
BilsborrowR E, 1984, “Survey design”, in Migration Surveys in Low-income Countries: Guidelines for Survey and Questionnaire Design, Eds BilsborrowEOberaiA SStandingG (Croom Helm, London) pp 60–87
4.
BilsborrowRMcDevittTKossoudjiSFullerR, 1987, “The impact of origin community characteristics on rural–urban out-migration in a developing country”Demography24191–210
5.
BilsborrowR EHugoGOberaiAZlotnikH, 1997International Migration Statistics: Guidelines for the Improvement of Data Collection Systems (International Labor Office, Geneva)
6.
Bravo-UretaB EQuirogaR EBreaJ A, 1996, “Migration decisions, agrarian structure, and gender: the case of Ecuador”The Journal of Developing Areas30463–476
7.
BrownL A, 1991Place, Migration and Developing in the Third World (Routledge, New York)
8.
BrownL ASierraR, 1994, “Frontier migration as a multi-stage phenomenon reflecting the interplay of macroforces and local conditions: the Ecuador Amazon”Papers in Regional Science73267–288
9.
BrownL ABreaAGoetzA R, 1988, “Policy aspects of development and individual mobility: migration and circulation from Ecuador's rural sierra”Economic Geography64147–170
10.
ChanK W, 1996, “Post-Mao China: a two-class urban society in the making”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research20134–150
11.
ChoiJ H, 1984, “Urban to rural migration in Korea”, in Rural Migration in Developing Countries Ed. GoldscheiderC (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 21–108
12.
ChristiansenF, 1992, “Market transition in China: the case of the Jiangsu labor market, 1978–1990”Modern China18(1) 72–93
CND1998, “Face or money, that's the question for laidoff Beijing workers”China News Digest 20 March, news item 5
15.
DaVanzoJ, 1981, “Repeat migration, information cost, and location-specific capital”Population and Environment445–73
16.
De JongG FFawcettJ T, 1981, “Motivations for migration: an assessment and a value-expectancy research model”, in Migration Decision Making: Multidisciplinary Approaches to Microlevel Studies in Developed and Developing Countries Eds De JongG FGardnerR W (Pergamon Press, New York) pp 13–58
17.
De JongG FJohnsonA G, 1996, “Determinants of migration values and expectations in rural Thailand”Asian and Pacific Migration Journal5399–416
18.
De JongG FRootB DGardnerR WFawcettJ TAbadR G, 1986, “Migration intentions and behavior: decision making in a rural Philippine province”Population and Environment8(1, 2) 41–62
19.
De JongG FRichterKIsarabhakdiP, 1996, “Gender, values, and intentions to move in rural Thailand”International Migration Review30748–770
20.
FanC, 1996, “Economic opportunities and internal migration: a case study of Guangdong province, China”Professional Geographer48(1) 28–45
21.
FangX, 1992, “Hubei ‘QiWu’ Shiqi Renkou yu Jingji FaZhan Wenti YanJiu” [A study of population and economic development issues during the 7th five-year plan period in Hubei], in Contemporary Chinese Population, volume 2 Ed. SunJ (State Statistical Bureau, Beijing) pp 1143–1150
22.
FindleyS E, 1982, “Migration survey methodologies: a review of design issues”, no 20, IUSSP papers, International Union for the Scientific Study of Population, rue des Augustins 34, 4000 Liege, Belgium
23.
FindleyS E, 1987Rural Development and Migration (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
24.
GardnerR WDe JongG FArnoldFCarinoB V, 1986, “The best-laid schemes: an analysis of discrepancies between migration intentions and behavior”Population and Environment8(1, 2)63–77
25.
GoldsteinSGoldsteinA, 1985Population Mobility in the People's Republic of China (East–West Center, Honolulu, HI)
26.
GoldsteinAGoldsteinS, 1996, “Migration motivations and outcomes: permanent and temporary migrants compared”, in China: The Many Facets of Demographic Change Eds GoldsteinAFengW (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 187–212
27.
GoldsteinAWhiteM JGoldsteinS, 1997, “Migration and fertility in Hubei province, China”Demography34481–492
28.
GuSZhongSYeB, 1992, “Renkou Liuqian yu Chengzhenghua—yi Hubei Sheng wei Gean” [Population mobility and urbanization—the case of Hubei province], in Contemporary Chinese Population, volume 2 Ed SunJ (State Statistical Bureau, Beijing) pp 881–904
29.
GuestM, 1989Labor Allocation and Rural Development (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
30.
GuilkeyD K, 1992, “Correcting for community effects in demographic and health survey data”, IRD Macro, Columbia, MD
31.
HarbisonS F, 1981, “Family structure and family strategy in migration decision making”, in Migration Decision Making Eds De JongG FGardnerR W (Pergamon Press, New York) pp 225–251
32.
HugoG J, 1981, “Village-community ties, village norms, and ethnic and social networks: a review of evidence from the Third World”, in Migration Decision Making Eds De JongG FGardnerR W (Pergamon Press, New York) pp 186–224
33.
LawsonV A, 1998, “Hierarchical households and gendered migration in Latin America: feminst extensions to migration research”Progress in Human Geography2239–53
34.
LeClereF BMcLaughlinD K, 1997, “Family migration and changes in women's earnings: a decomposition analysis”Population Research and Policy Review16315–335
35.
LeeE S, 1966, “A theory of migration”Demography347–57
36.
LiangZWhiteM, 1997, “Market transition, government policies, and interprovincial migration in China: 1983–1988”Economic Development and Cultural Change45(2) 19–37
37.
MaL J CXiangB, 1998, “Native place, migration and the emergence of peasant enclaves in Beijing”China Quarterly155546–581
38.
McDevittT MHawleyA HUdryJ RGadallaS MLeoprapaiBGutierrezR C, 1986, “Migration plans of the rural population of Third World countries: a probit analysis of micro-level data from Asia, Africa, and Latin America”Journal of Developing Areas20473–490
39.
MasseyD S, 1990, “Social structure, household strategies and the cumulative causation of migration”Population Index563–26
40.
MasseyD SEspinosaK E, 1997, “What's driving Mexico US migration? A theoretical, empirical, and policy analysis”American Journal of Sociology102939–999
41.
NormanD, 1970Models of Human Memory (Academic Press, New York)
42.
ProtheroR MChapmanM, 1985Circulation in Third World Countries (Routledge and Kegan Paul, New York)
43.
RitchyP N, 1976, “Explanation of migration”Annual Review of Sociology2363–404
44.
RobertsK D, 1997, “China's ‘tidal wave’ of migrant labor: what can we learn from Mexican undocumented migration to the United States?”International Migration Review31249–293
45.
RodriguezGGoldmanN, 1995, “An assessment of estimation procedures for multilevel models with binary responses”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society15873–89
46.
RootB DDe JongG F, 1991, “Family migration in a developing country”Population Studies45221–233
47.
SeltzerW, 1973Demographic Data Collection: A Summary of Experience (The Population Council, New York)
48.
ShieldsG MShieldsM P, 1989, “Family migration and nonmarket activities in Costa Rica”Economic Development and Cultural Change3873–88
49.
SimmonsA B, 1986, “Recent studies on place-utility and intention to migrate: an international comparison”Population and Environment8(1, 2) 120–140
50.
SlyD FWrigleyJ M, 1986, “Migration decision making and migration behavior in rural Kenya”Population and Environment8(1, 2) 78–97
51.
SolingerD J, 1999Contesting Citizenship in Urban China: Peasant Migrants, the State, and the Logic of the Market (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
52.
SomR K, 1973Recall Lapse in Demographic Enquiries (Asia Publishing House, New York)
53.
StarkO, 1991The Migration of Labor (Blackwell, Oxford)
54.
StarkOLevhariD, 1982, “On migration and risk in LDCs”Economic Development and Cultural Change31191–196
State Statistical Bureau, 1993China Statistics Yearbook (China Statistics Publisher, Beijing)
57.
StinnerW FXuWWeiJ, 1993, “Migrant status and labor market outcomes in urban and rural Hebei province, China”Rural Sociology58366–386
58.
TaylorJ R, 1988, “Rural employment trends and the legacy of surplus labour, 1978–86”China Quarterly116736–766
59.
United Nations, 1984National Migration Surveys Survey Manuals, X: Guidelines for Analysis (United Nations, New York)
60.
WilsonJ L, 1990, “Labor policy in China: reform and retrogression”Problems of Communism September–October, pages 44–65
61.
WoonY F, 1993, “Circulatory mobility in post-Mao China: temporary migrants in Kaiping county, Pearl River Delta region”International Migration Review27578–604
62.
YangL, 1992, “The current status and the trend of change of the employed labor force in China”, Dangdai Zhongguo Renkou (Contemporary Chinese Population) Eds SunJSunHZhangW (China Census Bureau and State Statistics Bureau, Beijing) pp 602–612
63.
YangQGuoF, 1996, “Occupational attainments of rural to urban temporary economic migrants in China, 1985–1990”International Migration Review30(3) 771–787
64.
YangX, 1993, “Household registration, economic reform and migration”International Migration Review27796–818
65.
YangX, 1994a, “A sensitivity analysis of migration attrition in the study of migrant adjustment: the case of Bangkok”Demography31585–592
66.
YangX, 1994b, “Urban temporary out-migration under economic reforms: who moves and for what reasons?Population Research and Policy Review1383–100
67.
YangX, 1996, “Patterns of economic development and patterns of rural–urban migration in China”European Journal of Population12195–218
68.
YangXGuoF, 1999, “Gender differences in determinants of temporary labor migration in China: a multilevel analysis”International Migration Review33929–953
69.
ZhouD, 1993, “An approach to the problems of population movement and cultural adaptation in the urbanizing Pearl River Delta”, in Urban Anthropology in China Eds GuldinGSouthallA (E J Brill, Leiden) pp 205–215
