Although the Western Mountain region of the USA has experienced substantial change, especially since 1990, there is relatively little understanding of the processes and impacts of restructuring in this largely rural region. In addition to the widely understood shift to service and high technology employment experienced in urban, suburban, and rural places, restructuring in the Western Mountain states has also significantly challenged existing political and social relationships. The authors examine the outcomes of restructuring by exploring economic, social, and political change in Idaho—a state in the Western USA. Idaho has witnessed a drastic decline in agriculture, ranching, and mining, and a rapid growth in the tourism, recreation, and high-technology sectors. Such changes have contributed to escalating tensions across the state concerning the appropriate use of public lands. The authors illustrate these tensions by exploring an ongoing controversy over the use of Idaho's school-endowment lands. The conflict over how these lands should be used highlights the central role that restructuring has played in political and social conflict over environmental protection and land use in largely rural areas.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BlakelyE J, 1991, “The emerging global economy and rural communities: A new perspective”, in The Future of Rural America: Anticipating Policies for Constructive Change Ed. PiggK E (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 57–71
2.
BlankR H, 1988Individualism in Idaho: The Territorial Foundations (Washington State University Press, Pullman, WA)
3.
BrickP, 1995, “Determined opposition: The Wise Use movement challenges environmentalism”Environment37(8) 16–27
4.
CappsG, 1997, “Letter”Times News 5 January
5.
ClarkG L, 1989Unions and Communities Under Siege: American Communities and the Crisis of Organized Labor (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
6.
ClokePLittleJ, 1990The Rural State?: Limits to Planning in Rural Society (Clarendon Press, Oxford)
7.
CogginsG CEvansP BLindberg-JohnsonM, 1982, “The law of public rangeland management I: The extent and distribution of federal power”Environmental Law12535–621
8.
DeaversK, 1992, “What is rural?”Policy Studies Journal20(2) 183–189
9.
DeSilverD, 1994a, “Noh on outs with environmentalists”Times NewsTwin Falls, ID, 6 January, page B1
10.
DeSilverD, 1994b, “Cattle foe Marvel no steward of his own land, Noh charges”Times News 6 January, page B1
11.
DubbinkD, 1984, “I'll have my town medium-rural please”Journal of the American Planning Association50406–418
12.
EdlesL D, 1994, “Cultural frameworks and growth in Idaho”Idaho IssuesSpecial Edition: Growth, College of Social Sciences and Public Affairs, Boise State University, Boise, ID
13.
ElliottMMcGuireSMurrAGlickD, 1995, “The West at war”Newsweek 17 July, pages 24–28
14.
FainsteinS S, 1987, “Local mobilization and economic discontent”, in The Capitalist City: Global Restructuring and Community Politics Eds SmithM PFeaginJ R (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 323–324
15.
FeaginJ RSmithM P, 1987, “Cities and the new international division of labor: An overview”, in The Capitalist City: Global Restructuring and Community Politics Eds SmithM PFeaginJ R (Basil Blackwell, Oxford) pp 2–34
16.
FitchenJ M, 1991Endangered Spaces, Enduring Places: Change, Identity, and Survival in Rural America (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
17.
FlynnAMarsdenT K, 1995, “Rural change, regulation, and sustainability”Environment and Planning A271180–1192
18.
GallagherM L, 1996, “Wise Use or wise marketing?”Planning62(1) 4–9
19.
GlasmeierA K, 1993, “High-tech manufacturing: Problems and prospects”, in Economic Adaptation: Alternatives for Nonmetropolitan Areas Eds BarkleyD L (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 165–184
20.
GoberPMcHuchK ELeclercD, 1993, “Job-rich but housing-poor: The dilemma of a Western amenity town”The Professional Geographer4512–20
21.
GoodwinMClokePMilbourneP, 1995, “Regulation theory and rural research: Theorising contemporary rural change”Environment and Planning A271245–1260
22.
HalfacreeK, 1995, “Talking about rurality: Social representations of the rural as expressed by residents of six English parishes”Journal of Rural Studies111–20
23.
HalsethG, 1996, “‘Community’ and land-use planning debate: An example from rural British Columbia”Environment and Planning A281279–1298
24.
HelvargD, 1994, “Grassroots for sale: The inside scoop on (un) Wise Use (anti-environmentalist movement)”Amicus Journal16(3) 24–29
25.
HelvargD, 1996, “Open hostilities: National Park personnel are increasingly targeted by the Wise Use movements campaign of violence”National Parks70(9–10) 36–41
26.
HummonD M, 1990Commonplaces: Community Ideology and Identity in American Culture (State University of New York Press, New York)
27.
Idaho Blue Book1994Demographics: Idaho Population Growth 1870–1990Pete T Cenarrusa, Idaho Secretary of State, 700 W Jefferson Street, Room 203, PO Box 83720, Boise, ID 83720–0080
28.
Idaho Department of Agriculture, 1996Idaho Agricultural StatisticsIdaho Agricultural Statistic Service, Idaho Department of Agriculture, PO Box 790, Boise, ID 83701
29.
Idaho Department of Commerce, 700 West State Street, PO Box 83720, Boise, ID 83720–0093
30.
Idaho Department of Commerce, 1992Profile of Rural Idaho: A Look at the Economic and Social Trends Affecting Rural IdahoDivision of Economic Development
31.
Idaho Department of Commerce, 1995Idaho Facts (1995)Division of Economic Development
32.
Idaho Department of Commerce, 1997aHistorical Idaho Employment Trends—Annual Averages: High Technology
33.
Idaho Department of Commerce, 1997bTotal Estimated Travel Expenditures in Idaho
34.
Idaho Department of Labor, 317 Main Street, Boise, ID 83735–0600
35.
Idaho Department of Labor, 1995a, “Labor force and wages: Agricultural employment”, in Idaho FactsDivision of Economic Development, page 5
36.
Idaho Department of Labor, 1995b, “Labor force and wages: Covered employment”, in Idaho FactsDivision of Economic Development, page 4
37.
Idaho Department of Labor, 1995c, “Travel and tourism: Employment in tourism-related establishments”, in Idaho FactsDivision of Economic Development, page 118
38.
Idaho Department of Labor, 1997Annual Covered Employment in Idaho for 1996
39.
Idaho Department of Transportation, 1997Net Surrenders of Drivers Licenses: 1991–1996Idaho Department of Transportation, 3311 West State Street, Boise, ID 83703
40.
Idaho Division of Financial Management, 1996, “Idaho economic forecast”, Economic Analysis Bureau, Idaho Division of Financial Management, 700 West State Street, PO Box 83720, Boise, ID 83720–0093
41.
Idaho State Board of Land Commissioners, 1997, “G-8900 (Ingram) conflict auction appeal memorandum”, 25 March, Idaho State Board of Land Commissioners, Idaho Department of Lands, 954 W Jefferson Street, PO Box 83720, Boise, ID 83720–0050
42.
Idaho Watersheds Project, 1996, “Idaho Watersheds Project summary and memorandum”, Idaho Watersheds Project, Box 1602, Hailey, ID 83333
43.
JacksonT, 1997, “Cattle grazing politics: Conservationists blame GOP for grazing damage near reservoir”Gateway 16 January
44.
KittredgeW, 1993, “The last safe place”Time 6 September, page 27
45.
LakeR WRegulskaJ, 1990, “Political decentralization and capital mobility in planned and market societies: Local autonomy in Poland and the United States”Policy Studies Journal18702–720
46.
LasseyW RLappingM BCarlsonJ E, 1988, “The USA”, in Policies and Plans for Rural People: An International Perspective Ed. ClokeP (Unwin Hyman, London) p 142–165
47.
LowePMarsdenTWhatmoreS, 1994, “Changing regulatory orders: The analysis of economic governance of agriculture”, in Regulating Architecture Eds LowePMarsdenTWhatmoreS (David Fulton, London) pp 1–30
48.
Magic Valley Ag Weekly1996, “Land Board orders another auction” 11 September, page B2
49.
MarsdenTArceA, 1995, “Constructing quality: Emerging food networks in the rural transition”Environment and Planning A271261–1279
50.
MarsdenTLowePWhatmoreS, 1990, “Introduction: Questions of rurality”, in Rural Restructuring: Global Processes and Their Responses Eds MarsdenTLowePWhatmoreS (David Fulton, London) pp 1–20
51.
MarsdenTMurdochJLowePMuntonRFlynnA, 1993Constructing the Countryside (Westview Press, Boulder, CO)
52.
MarvelJ, 1996, “Idaho Watersheds projects with Supreme Court decision and Lake Creek auction”Watersheds Messenger: Idaho Watersheds Project NewsletterFall edition3(2) 1–10
53.
MillerA P, 1993, “All is not quiet on the Western front”The Urban Lawyer25827–840
54.
MorehouseB J, 1996, “Conflict, space, and resource management at Grand Canyon”Professional Geographer4846–57
55.
MurdochJMarsdenT, 1994Reconstituting Rurality: Class, Community, and Power in the Development Process (UCL Press, London)
56.
NelsonP B, 1997, “Migration, sources of income, and community change in the non-metropolitan Northwest”Professional Geographer49418–430
57.
NokkentvedN S, 1996, “Grazing critic speaks to range managers”Times News 7 December, page B1
58.
NokkentvedN S, 1997, “Critic: Grazing feels trail inflation. Marvel says public grass price should triple”Times News 8 July, page C1
59.
New York Times1996, “Idaho, plan to protect wild horses causes furor” 8 December, page N16
60.
OldsK, 1995, “Globalization and the production of new urban spaces: Pacific Rim megaprojects in the late 20th Century”Environment and Planning A271713–1743
61.
OsborneL, 1997, “Letter”Magic Valley Ag Weekly 3 May, page 4
62.
SassenS, 1994Cities in a World Economy (Pine Forge Press, Thousand Oaks, CA)
63.
ShumwayJ MDavisJ A, 1996, “Nonmetropolitan population change in the Mountain West: 1970–1995”Rural Sociology61513–529
SmutnyG, 1998, “Legislative support for growth management in the Rocky Mountains: An exploration of attitudes in Idaho”Journal of the American Planning Association forthcoming
66.
SnyderC, 1996, “Range discussion encompasses industry, environment”Magic Valley Ag Weekly 14 December, page 3
67.
StarrsP F, 1995, “Conflict and change on the landscapes of the arid American West”, in The Changing American Countryside: Rural People and Places Ed. CastleE N (University Press of Kansas, Lawrence, KA) pp 271–285
68.
State of Idaho, 1996, “Amendment to clarify state's conflict bid law on state land leases”, House Bill 793, Legislature of the State of Idaho, Legislative Services Office, State Capitol, Lower Level, East Wing, PO Box 83720, Boise, ID 83720–0054
